Payne v. City of Charlottesville

Last updated
Payne v. City of Charlottesville
CourtCharlottesville Circuit Court - Civil Division

Payne v. City of Charlottesville is a 2017 lawsuit opposing the removal of Confederate monuments and memorials in Charlottesville, Virginia.

Contents

The plaintiffs filed the original complaint on March 20, 2017. [1] [2]

In May 2017 the judge stated that the statues would not be moved before November 2017 at the soonest. [3]

In June 2018 the judge ruled that the city counselors would not have personal legal immunity for certain errors they could have made in their response to the lawsuit. [4]

Proposed removal

In an open-air press conference beside the Robert E. Lee statue in March 2016, Charlottesville's vice mayor Wes Bellamy called on Charlottesville City Council to remove the statue and rename Lee Park. He said that the statue's presence "disrespected" parts of the community, and that he had "spoken with several different people who have said they have refused to step foot[ sic ] in to that park because of what that statue and the name of that park represents. And we can't have that in the city of Charlottesville" [5]

Local NAACP head Rick Turner spoke in support of removal, calling Lee a "terrorist". Others accused the city council and Bellamy of disregarding Lee's historical significance and how important he was to Virginia, of sowing division, and of trying to rewrite history. A petition to remove the statue was initiated, with wording saying the statue represented "hate" and was a "subliminal message of racism". [6] [7]

In April 2016, the city council decided to appoint a special commission, named the Blue Ribbon Commission on Race, Monuments and Public Spaces, to recommend to city officials how to best handle issues surrounding statues of Stonewall Jackson (Thomas Jonathan Jackson) in Court Square and Lee in Lee Park, as well as other landmarks and monuments. Early in November 2016, the Blue Ribbon Commission voted 6–3 to let both statues remain in place. [8] On November 28, 2016, it voted 7–2 to remove the Lee statue to McIntire Park in Charlottesville and 8–1 to keep the Jackson statue in place, [9] delivering a final report with that recommendation to Charlottesville City Council in December. [10]

On February 6, 2017, Charlottesville's five-member city council voted three votes to two to remove the Lee statue and, unanimously, to rename Lee Park. [11]

In response, a lawsuit was filed on March 20 by numerous plaintiffs, including the Monument Fund Inc, the Sons of Confederate Veterans, and descendants of the statue's donor and sculptor, to block the removal of the Lee and Jackson statues. The lawsuit sought a temporary injunction to halt the removal, arguing that Charlottesville City Council's decision violated a state law designed to protect American Civil War monuments and memorials, and that the council had additionally violated the terms of McIntire's gift to Charlottesville of the statue and the land for Lee Park. [12] The city responded by asking that the temporary injunction be denied, arguing that the two statues were not erected to commemorate the Civil War and therefore the Virginia statute protecting war monuments does not apply. [13]

In April 2017, the city council voted three to two (exactly along the lines of the February vote) that the statue be removed completely from Charlottesville and sold to whoever the Council chooses. [14]

On May 2, 2017, Judge Richard Moore issued a temporary injunction blocking the removal of the Robert E. Lee statue for six months, in the public's interest, pending a court decision in the suit. [13]

Sometime overnight between Friday July 7 and Saturday July 8, the statue was vandalized by being daubed in red paint. [15] It had been vandalized before; in June 2016 the pedestal was spray painted with the words "Black Lives Matter". [7]

Shrouding

On August 20, 2017, the city council unanimously voted to shroud the statue, and that of Stonewall Jackson, in black. The Council "also decided to direct the city manager to take an administrative step that would make it easier to eventually remove the Jackson statue." [16] The statues were covered in black shrouds on August 23, 2017. [17] The tarp was removed in February 2018 by order of a judge. [18]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Monument Avenue</span> United States historic place

Monument Avenue is a tree-lined grassy mall dividing the eastbound and westbound traffic in Richmond, Virginia, originally named for its emblematic complex of structures honoring those who fought for the Confederacy during the American Civil War. Between 1900 and 1925, Monument Avenue greatly expanded with architecturally significant houses, churches, and apartment buildings. Four of the bronze statues representing J. E. B. Stuart, Stonewall Jackson, Jefferson Davis and Matthew Fontaine Maury were removed from their memorial pedestals amidst civil unrest in July 2020. The Robert E. Lee monument was handled differently as it was owned by the Commonwealth, in contrast with the other monuments which were owned by the city. Dedicated in 1890, it was removed on September 8, 2021. All these monuments, including their pedestals, have now been removed completely from the Avenue. The last remaining statue on Monument Avenue is the Arthur Ashe Monument, memorializing the African-American tennis champion, dedicated in 1996.

<i>Confederate War Memorial</i> (Dallas) Confederate monument previously displayed in Dallas, Texas, United States

The Confederate War Memorial was a 65 foot (20 m)-high monument that pays tribute to soldiers and sailors from Texas who served with the Confederate States of America (CSA) during the American Civil War. The monument was dedicated in 1897, following the laying of its cornerstone the previous year. Originally located in Sullivan Park near downtown Dallas, Texas, United States, the monument was relocated in 1961 to the nearby Pioneer Park Cemetery in the Convention Center District, next to the Dallas Convention Center and Pioneer Plaza.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert E. Lee Monument (New Orleans)</span> United States historic place

The Robert E. Lee Monument, formerly in New Orleans, Louisiana, is a historic statue dedicated to Confederate General Robert E. Lee by American sculptor Alexander Doyle. It was removed (intact) by official order and moved to an unknown location on May 19, 2017. Any future display is uncertain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Confederate Monument (Portsmouth, Virginia)</span> United States historic place

The Confederate Monument in Portsmouth, Virginia, was built between 1876 and 1881. It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) in 1997.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Equestrian statue of Stonewall Jackson (Charlottesville, Virginia)</span> United States historic place

Thomas Jonathan Jackson is a historic bronze equestrian statue of Confederate general Stonewall Jackson which was formerly located at Courthouse Historic District of Charlottesville, Virginia and installed in 1921. The statue was sculpted by Charles Keck and was the third of four works commissioned from members of the National Sculpture Society by philanthropist Paul Goodloe McIntire. It was the second of three statues McIntire donated to the city of Charlottesville, which he did over a period of five years from 1919 to 1924. The statue was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1997.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert E. Lee Monument (Charlottesville, Virginia)</span> Destroyed equestrian statue

The Robert E. Lee Monument was an outdoor bronze equestrian statue of Confederate general Robert E. Lee and his horse Traveller located in Charlottesville, Virginia's Market Street Park in the Charlottesville and Albemarle County Courthouse Historic District. The statue was commissioned in 1917 and dedicated in 1924, and in 1997 was listed on the National Register of Historic Places. It was removed on July 10, 2021, and melted down in 2023.

<i>Meriwether Lewis and William Clark</i> (sculpture) United States historic place

Meriwether Lewis and William Clark is a historic bronze sculpture of Meriwether Lewis, William Clark, and Sacagawea located at Charlottesville, Virginia. Known as Their First View of the Pacific, it was sculpted by noted artist Charles Keck (1875-1951), and was the first of four commemorative sculptures commissioned from members of the National Sculpture Society by philanthropist Paul Goodloe McIntire. The sculpture was erected in 1919.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert E. Lee Monument (Richmond, Virginia)</span> Former public sculpture in Richmond, Virginia, United States

The Robert E. Lee Monument in Richmond, Virginia, was the first installation on Monument Avenue in 1890, and would ultimately be the last Confederate monument removed from the site. Before its removal on September 8, 2021, the monument honored Confederate Civil War General Robert E. Lee, depicted on a horse atop a large marble base that stood over 60 feet (18 m) tall. Constructed in France and shipped to Virginia, it remained the largest installation on Monument Avenue for over a century; it was first listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2007 and the Virginia Landmarks Register in 2006.

<i>Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee Monument</i> Double equestrian statue formerly installed in Baltimore, Maryland, U.S.

The Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee Monument, often referred to simply as the Jackson and Lee Monument or Lee and Jackson Monument, was a double equestrian statue of Confederate generals Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee, formerly located on the west side of the Wyman Park Dell in Charles Village in Baltimore, Maryland, alongside a forested hill, similar to the topography of Chancellorsville, Virginia, where Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee met before the Battle of Chancellorsville in 1863. The statue was removed on August 16, 2017, on the order of Baltimore City Council, but the base still remains. The monument is in storage and some city council members have called for all Confederate monuments in the state to be destroyed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Market Street Park</span> Park in Charlottesville, Virginia, United States

Market Street Park, known as Lee Park until 2017, and as Emancipation Park from June 2017 to July 2018, is a public park in Charlottesville, Virginia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jason Kessler</span> American white supremacist and far-right political activist

Jason Eric Kessler is an American neo-Nazi, white supremacist, and antisemitic conspiracy theorist. Kessler organized the Unite the Right rally held in Charlottesville, Virginia, on August 11–12, 2017, and the Unite the Right 2 rally held on August 12, 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials</span> Ongoing development in the United States

There are more than 160 monuments and memorials to the Confederate States of America and associated figures that have been removed from public spaces in the United States, all but five of which have been since 2015. Some have been removed by state and local governments; others have been torn down by protestors.

Court Square Park is a public park in Charlottesville, Virginia.

The Charlottesville historic monument controversy is the public discussion on how Charlottesville should respond to protesters who complain that various local monuments are racist. The controversy began before 2016 when protest groups in the community asked the city council for the local removal of Confederate monuments and memorials. Other monuments became part of the controversy, including those of Thomas Jefferson because of his ownership of slaves and those of Lewis and Clark for their advocacy of white colonists over Native Americans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Floyd protests in Richmond, Virginia</span> 2020 civil unrest after the murder of George Floyd

Richmond, Virginia, experienced a series of riots in the wake of the murder of George Floyd. Richmond was the first city in the Southeastern United States to see rioting following Floyd's murder. Richmond, formerly the capital of the short-lived Confederate States of America, saw much arson and vandalism to monuments connected with that polity, particularly along Monument Avenue.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stonewall Jackson Monument</span>

The Stonewall Jackson Monument in Richmond, Virginia, was erected in honor of Thomas Jonathon "Stonewall" Jackson, a Confederate general. The monument was located at the centre of the crossing of Monument Avenue and North Arthur Ashe Boulevard, in Richmond, Virginia. The bronze equestrian statue was unveiled in 1919. Along this avenue were other statues including Robert E. Lee, J. E. B. Stewart, Jefferson Davis, Matthew Maury and more recently Arthur Ashe. Thomas Jackson is best known as one of Robert E. Lee's most trusted commanders throughout the early period of the American Civil War between Southern Confederate states and Northern Union states. He rose to prominence after his vital role in the Confederate victory at the First Battle of Bull Run in July 1861, continuing to command troops until his untimely death on May 10, 1863, after falling fatally ill following the amputation of his wounded arm.

References

  1. ↑ "Complaint Charlottesville Statues". statues.law.virginia.edu. 20 March 2017.
  2. ↑ SUAREZ, CHRIS (20 March 2017). "Suit filed to prevent Lee statue removal". The Daily Progress .
  3. ↑ Provence, Lisa (3 May 2017). "General Lee wins first court skirmish". C-VILLE Weekly.
  4. ↑ Freedman, Emmy (14 June 2018). "Judge Issues Ruling Saying City Councilors Not Entitled to Immunity". WVIR-TV .
  5. ↑ "Vice Mayor Wes Bellamy: Take Down Robert E. Lee Statue". Archived from the original on 2017-08-16. Retrieved 2018-08-11.
  6. ↑ "People Show Support for, Opposition to Lee Statue in Charlottesville". Archived from the original on 2017-08-15. Retrieved 2018-08-11.
  7. 1 2 The Statue at the Center of Charlottesville’s Storm
  8. ↑ "Commission Votes 6-3 to Keep Confederate Statues in Charlottesville". Archived from the original on 2017-08-15. Retrieved 2018-08-11.
  9. ↑ "Blue Ribbon Commission Votes on Plans for Statues at Final Meeting". Archived from the original on 2017-08-15. Retrieved 2018-08-11.
  10. ↑ "Blue Ribbon Commission Delivers Final Report to City Council". Archived from the original on 2017-08-15. Retrieved 2018-08-11.
  11. ↑ Laughland, Oliver (May 14, 2017). "White nationalist Richard Spencer at rally over Confederate statue's removal". The Guardian. Retrieved May 15, 2017.
  12. ↑ "Groups File Lawsuit to Stop Removal of Confederate Statues". Archived from the original on 2017-08-15. Retrieved 2018-08-11.
  13. 1 2 "Judge halts removal of Lee statue for 6 months". Wdbj7.com. 4 May 2017. Retrieved 12 August 2017.
  14. ↑ Charlottesville City Council Votes to Sell Statue by Bid, Rename Lee Park Archived 2017-08-24 at the Wayback Machine
  15. ↑ "Lee Statue Vandalized Ahead of KKK Rally in Charlottesville". Archived from the original on 2017-08-19. Retrieved 2018-08-11.
  16. ↑ Brown, Emma (August 22, 2017). "Charlottesville City Council votes to shroud Confederate statues in black". The Washington Post . Retrieved August 23, 2017.
  17. ↑ FOX. "Charlottesville's Confederate statues shrouded in black". fox5ny.com. Archived from the original on August 24, 2017. Retrieved August 24, 2017.
  18. ↑ Brown, Emma (February 7, 2018). "Tarps once again removed from Charlottesville statues". Richmond.com . Retrieved February 21, 2018.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.