Perdition (play)

Last updated

Perdition is a 1987 stage play by Jim Allen. Its premiere at London's Royal Court Theatre Upstairs, in a production directed by Ken Loach, was abandoned because of protests, and criticism by two historians, over its controversial and tendentious claims. [1]

Contents

Outline

The play makes use of a libel trial in Israel in 1954–55 concerning allegations of collaboration during the Second World War in 1944 between the leadership of the Zionist movement in Hungary and the Nazis.

Its starting point was the trial of Rudolf Kastner, a leading member of the Budapest Aid and Rescue Committee, whose job was to help Jews escape from Nazi-ruled Hungary. His libel trial in Israel concerned an accusation that he had collaborated with Adolf Eichmann, one of the main SS officers in charge of carrying out the Holocaust. Although the initial trial found that he had indeed "sold his soul to the devil" by saving certain Jews whilst failing to warn others that their "resettlement" was in fact deportation to the gas chambers, there was a subsequent trial at the Supreme Court of Israel in 1958 at which the findings were overturned. The claim he had collaborated with Eichmann was false. [2] By the time of the appeal, Kastner had been assassinated. [3] A 2017 account by Paul Bogdanor concerning Kastner's activities in Hungary concluded that he did collaborate with Eichmann and his associates. "During the Holocaust in Hungary the acting head of the country's Jewish rescue operations betrayed his duty to rescue the victims and placed himself at the service of the murderers". [4]

The play itself, paralleling the 1954 case, uses the device of another (this time, fictional) libel trial in London in 1967 involving a man called Dr. Yaron who is suing Ruth Kaplan, an Israeli Jew who has claimed Yaron collaborated with Eichmann. [3] Allen queries whether the saving of certain Jews in a purported act of collaboration in line with Zionist philosophies about populating Israel at the expense of those Jews who remained.[ clarification needed ] The play’s text includes such analogies as “the Zionist knife in the Nazi fist” (which was cut in the pre-production period) [5] and accuses Jewish leaders: “To save your hides, you practically led them to the gas chambers of Auschwitz”. [6] Characters assert that “Israel was founded on the pillars of Western guilt and American dollars” and “Israel was coined in the blood of Hungarian Jewry”. [2]

Allen was influenced by activist Lenni Brenner’s book Zionism in the Age of the Dictators (1983), [7] which he described as "a goldmine source". [8] In an interview with Time Out at the time of the intended original production, Allen described his play as "the most lethal attack on Zionism ever written, because it touches the heart of the most abiding myth of modern history, the Holocaust. Because it says quite plainly that privileged Jewish leaders collaborated in the extermination of their own kind in order to help bring about a Zionist state, Israel, a state which is itself racist". [5] [9] According to Allen, during the Holocaust, "the lower you went down on the social scale, the more you found resistance; but the higher you went up the social scale, the more you found cooperation and collaboration [with the Nazis]”. [2] In an interview in The Guardian , Allen claimed Zionists' interests overlapped with Hitler's "on the basis of opportunism." Allen said: "Hitler was fond of the Zionists, they were good Jews, prepared to fight for land." [10]

Chaim Bermant wrote in The Jewish Chronicle that Allen "suggests that the entire leadership of the Zionist movement ... people who strained every ounce of their being to do all that could be done to save European Jews – were involved in a dark conspiracy to betray them." [11] David Cesarani wrote that, like Brenner in his book, Allen drew on anti-Zionist stereotypes originating in the Soviet Union which have a "Jewish conspiracy theory" at their centre. [8]

Cancellation and controversy

In January 1987, the Ken Loach-directed production of Perdition for London's Royal Court Theatre, intended for its Upstairs studio theatre, [1] was cancelled on the day before the first preview performance. At the time, the historian Martin Gilbert said the play was "a complete travesty of the facts" [2] and "deeply anti-Semitic". [12] Gilbert identified 60 errors in the script. He told The Sunday Times :

"In reality there are inaccuracies on almost every page of the script; not only errors of fact, but innuendoes and allegations against thousands of Jews unable to defend themselves because they were murdered ... by the very people with whom, the script insists they were in deliberate and sinister collusion." [13]

Another specialist in the field, David Cesarani, agreed. [14] Max Stafford-Clark, then the artistic director of the Royal Court, rejected assertions the play was antisemitic or contained errors, but said that continuing with the production would cause "great distress to sections of the community". [12] Stafford-Clark recalled in 2021 that Stephen Roth, chairman of the Institute of Jewish Affairs, told him that in Allen's text "the Zionist resistance wasn’t mentioned, the confused situation in Budapest wasn’t mentioned and the number saved wasn’t touched on." [3]

In an interview for the book Loach on Loach, Ken said that he "had a shouting match" with Stafford-Clark and refused to tell the cast that the play was being cancelled. Loach says that Stafford-Clark was reprimanded for the decision and for not allowing any compromises, such as performances restricted to agents and friends, before he ordered all the cast off the site of the theatre. [15]

Loach claimed that the Royal Court had given in to pressure from members of the British Jewish community, including Roth, the publisher Lord Weidenfeld, and the political adviser Lord Goodman. [3] [6] Loach told a newspaper of the Workers Revolutionary Party that he "hadn't tangled with the Zionist lobby before" and "what is amazing is the strength and organisation and power of their lobby." The "Zionists", he said "want to leave intact ... the generalised sense of guilt everyone has about the Jews so that it remains an area that you can't discuss". He was also angry with the dramatist Caryl Churchill, who defended Stafford-Clark's decision. [5] Jim Allen himself blamed "the Zionist machine". [2] Cesarani in Jewish Socialist wrote in response to such comments that "the protagonists of the play are willing to manipulate anti-Jewish stereotypes outside of the theatre as well as within it." [16] The Directors Guild of Great Britain protested at the cancellation. [17]

In a letter to The Guardian in 2004, in connection with the premature end of another controversial play's production, Loach wrote that "the charge of antisemitism" against Allen's play "is the time-honoured way to deflect anti-Zionist arguments". [18]

Glenda Abramson wrote in Drama and Ideology in Modern Israel (1998) that, in his play, Allen "uses Zionism rather than Nazism as his exemplar of fascism and the analogy of Israel rather than Nazi Germany in his warning about the future revival of global fascism". [1] In an article for The Jewish Chronicle in 2017, Dave Rich described the play as a "Stalinist lie". He wrote that Loach is one individual who uses the Perdition episode "to try to claim that the entire Zionist movement collaborated in the murder of their fellow Jews; either from cold, cynical calculation – they only cared about getting Jews to Mandate Palestine – or through ideological affinity". [19]

Later developments

In 1999, the play was performed at the Gate Theatre in London in a production by Elliot Levey, Loach's son-in-law, in what David Jay, writing for the New Statesman , described as "a significantly rewritten version". [20] Levey defended the play in 1999: "It is not historically inaccurate. It's very much a pro-Jewish play. My hope is that it won't be sat on, as it was in the 1980s." [21]

Perfidy , by Ben Hecht, is a non-fiction work about the Kastner trial. The title of the play appears to echo Hecht's book. [22]

Related Research Articles

Soviet anti-Zionism is an anti-Zionist and pro-Arab doctrine promulgated in the Soviet Union during the Cold War. While the Soviet Union initially pursued a pro-Zionist policy after World War II due to its perception that the Jewish state would be socialist and pro-Soviet, its outlook on the Arab–Israeli conflict changed as Israel began to develop a close relationship with the United States and aligned itself with the Western Bloc.

David Ian Cesarani was a British historian who specialised in Jewish history, especially the Holocaust. He also wrote several biographies, including Arthur Koestler: The Homeless Mind (1998).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rezső Kasztner</span> Hungarian-Jewish lawyer and journalist (1906–1957)

Rezső Kasztner, also known as Rudolf Israel Kastner, was a Hungarian-Israeli journalist and lawyer who became known for having helped a group of Jews escape from occupied Europe during the Holocaust on the Kastner train. After World War II, he was accused of having failed to inform the majority of Hungarian Jews about the reality of what awaited them in Auschwitz. He was assassinated in 1957 after an Israeli court accused him of having "sold his soul to the devil," a charge that was overturned by the Supreme Court of Israel in 1958.

<i>Eichmann in Jerusalem</i> 1963 book by Hannah Arendt

Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil is a 1963 book by the philosopher and political thinker Hannah Arendt. Arendt, a Jew who fled Germany during Adolf Hitler's rise to power, reported on the trial of Adolf Eichmann, one of the major organizers of the Holocaust, for The New Yorker. A revised and enlarged edition was published in 1964.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kastner train</span> Holocaust rescue activity

The Kastner train is the name usually given to a rescue operation which saved the lives of over 1,600 Jews from Hungary during World War II. It consisted of 35 cattle wagons that left Budapest on 30 June 1944, during the German occupation of Hungary, ultimately arriving safely in Switzerland after a large ransom was paid to the Nazis. The train was named after Rudolf Kastner, a Hungarian-Jewish lawyer and journalist, who was a founding member of the Budapest Aid and Rescue Committee, a group that smuggled Jews out of occupied Europe during the Holocaust. Kastner negotiated with Adolf Eichmann, the German SS officer in charge of deporting Hungary's Jews to Auschwitz in German-occupied Poland, to allow over 1,600 Jews to escape in exchange for gold, diamonds, and cash. The deal was controversial and has been the subject of much debate and criticism, with some accusing Kastner of collaborating with the Nazis, while others argue that he made difficult choices to save lives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Theodor Dannecker</span> SS Officer and Holocaust perpetrator

Theodor Dannecker was a German SS-captain, a key aide to Adolf Eichmann in the deportation of Jews during World War II.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malchiel Gruenwald</span> Israeli businessman and citizen journalist

Malchiel Gruenwald (1882–1968) was an Israeli hotelier, amateur journalist, and stamp collector, who came to public attention in 1953, when he accused an Israeli government employee, Rudolf Kastner, of having collaborated with the Nazis during the Holocaust.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert S. Wistrich</span> Professor at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (1945–2015)

Robert Solomon Wistrich was a scholar of antisemitism, considered one of the world's foremost authorities on antisemitism.

James Allen was an English socialist playwright, best known for his collaborations with Ken Loach.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adolf Eichmann</span> German Nazi official and war criminal (1906–1962)

Otto Adolf Eichmann was a German-Austrian official of the Nazi Party, an officer of the Schutzstaffel (SS), and one of the major organisers of the Holocaust. He participated in the January 1942 Wannsee Conference, at which the implementation of the genocidal Final Solution to the Jewish Question was planned. Following this, he was tasked by SS-Obergruppenführer Reinhard Heydrich with facilitating and managing the logistics involved in the mass deportation of millions of Jews to Nazi ghettos and Nazi extermination camps across German-occupied Europe. He was captured and detained by the Allies in 1945, but escaped and eventually settled in Argentina. In May 1960, he was tracked down and apprehended by Israel's Mossad intelligence agency, and put on trial before the Supreme Court of Israel. The highly publicised Eichmann trial resulted in his conviction in Jerusalem, following which he was executed by hanging in 1962.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anti-Zionism</span> Opposition to Zionism

Anti-Zionism is opposition to Zionism. Although anti-Zionism is a heterogeneous phenomenon, all its proponents agree that the creation of the modern State of Israel, and the movement to create a sovereign Jewish state in the region of Palestine—a region partly coinciding with the biblical Land of Israel—was flawed or unjust in some way.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eichmann trial</span> 1961 trial of Adolf Eichmann

The Eichmann trial was the 1961 trial in Israel of major Holocaust perpetrator Adolf Eichmann who was kidnapped in Argentina by Israeli agents and brought to Israel to stand trial. The kidnapping of Eichmann was criticized by the United Nations, calling it a "violation of the sovereignty of a Member State". Israel and Argentina issued a joint statement on 3 August, after further negotiations, admitting the violation of Argentine sovereignty but agreeing to end the dispute. The Israeli court ruled that the circumstances of Eichmann's capture had no bearing on the legality of his trial. His trial, which opened on 11 April 1961, was televised and broadcast internationally, intended to educate about the crimes committed against Jews by Nazi Germany, which had been secondary to the Nuremberg trials which addressed other war crimes of the Nazi regime. Prosecutor and Attorney General Gideon Hausner also tried to challenge the portrayal of Jewish functionaries that had emerged in the earlier trials, showing them at worst as victims forced to carry out Nazi decrees while minimizing the "gray zone" of morally questionable behavior. Hausner later wrote that available archival documents "would have sufficed to get Eichmann sentenced ten times over"; nevertheless, he summoned more than 100 witnesses, most of whom had never met the defendant, for didactic purposes. Defense attorney Robert Servatius refused the offers of twelve survivors who agreed to testify for the defense, exposing what they considered immoral behavior by other Jews. Political philosopher Hannah Arendt reported on the trial in her book Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil. The book had enormous impact in popular culture, but its ideas have become increasingly controversial.

The Other Side: the Secret Relationship Between Nazism and Zionism is a book by Mahmoud Abbas, published in 1984 in Arabic. It was re-published in 2011. It is based on his CandSc thesis, completed in 1982 at Patrice Lumumba University under the title The Connection between the Nazis and the Leaders of the Zionist Movement, and defended at the Institute of Oriental Studies of the Soviet Academy of Sciences. The central thesis of the book is that the Zionist movement and its leaders were "fundamental partners" of the Nazis and equally responsible for the Holocaust.

Leopold Itz, Edler von Mildenstein was an SS officer who is remembered as a lead supporter in the Nazi Party of some of the aims of Zionism during the 1930s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kastner trial</span>

The Attorney-General of the Government of Israel v. Malchiel Gruenwald, commonly known as the Kastner trial, was a libel case in Jerusalem, Israel. Hearings were held from 1 January to October 1954 in the District Court of Jerusalem before Judge Benjamin Halevi (1910–1996), who published his decision on 22 June 1955.

This timeline of anti-Zionism chronicles the history of anti-Zionism, including events in the history of anti-Zionist thought.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hansi Brand</span> Hungarian-born Zionist activist and rescue worker

Hajnalka "Hansi" Brand was a Hungarian-born Zionist activist who was involved, as a member of the Budapest Aid and Rescue Committee, in efforts to rescue Jews during the Holocaust.

<i>Zionism in the Age of the Dictators</i> 1983 book by Lenni Brenner

Zionism in the Age of the Dictators is a 1983 work by the American free-lance journalist, outspoken pro-Palestinian activist, Trotskyist and Jewish author Lenni Brenner. The book makes the argument that Zionist leaders collaborated with fascism, particularly in Nazi Germany, in order to build up a Jewish presence in Palestine.

Francis R. Nicosia was an American historian at the University of Vermont with a focus on modern history and Holocaust research.

Zionist antisemitism or antisemitic Zionism refers to a phenomenon in which antisemites express support for Zionism and the State of Israel. In some cases, this support may be promoted for explicitly antisemitic reasons. Historically, this type of antisemitism has been most notable among Christian Zionists, who may perpetrate religious antisemitism while being outspoken in their support for Jewish sovereignty in Israel due to their interpretation of Christian eschatology. Similarly, people who identify with the political far-right, particularly in Europe and the United States, may support the Zionist movement because they seek to expel Jews from their country and see Zionism as the least complicated method of achieving this goal and satisfying their racial antisemitism.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Abramson, Glenda (1998). Drama and Ideology in Modern Israel. Cambridge University Press. pp. 169–70. ISBN   9780521441599.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Joffee, Linda (23 February 1987). "A play no theater will play". Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved 27 September 2017.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Cavendish, Dominic (10 February 2021). "Ken Loach's Perdition problem: the 'anti-Semitic' play that keeps coming back to haunt him". The Telegraph. Retrieved 12 February 2021.
  4. ↑ Bogdanor, Paul (2017). Kasztner's Crime. Routledge. p. 291.
  5. 1 2 3 Rich, Dave (2016). The Left's Jewish Problem. London: Biteback. p. 147. ISBN   9781785901515.
  6. 1 2 Cohen, Ben (Fall 2004). "The Persistence of Anti-Semitism on the British Left". Jewish Political Studies Review. 16 (3–4). Retrieved 27 September 2017. (This text is also online under the title: "A Discourse of Delegitimisation: The British Left and the Jews".)
  7. ↑ Hirsh, David (2017). Contemporary Left Antisemitism. London: Routledge. p. 40. ISBN   9781315304298.
  8. 1 2 Cesarani, David (1990). "The Perdition Affair". In Wistrich, Robert S. (ed.). Anti-Zionism and Antisemitism in the Contemporary World. Basingstoke & London: Macmillan. pp. 54–55. ISBN   978-1-349-11262-3.
  9. ↑ Aaronovitch, David (12 April 2017). "Don't let the revisionists rewrite Nazi history". The Times. Retrieved 27 September 2017.(subscription required)
  10. ↑ "Leading British Theater to Present a Play Depicting Zionists As Collaborating with Nazis in Hungary". Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 16 January 1987. Retrieved 12 February 2021.
  11. ↑ Bermant, Chaim (30 January 1987). "Allen's evil example of the banality of ignorance". The Jewish Chronicle.
  12. 1 2 "London Theater Drops Disputed Play". The New York Times. Reuters. 22 January 1987. Retrieved 27 September 2017.
  13. ↑ Toomey, Christine (25 January 1987). "A Curtain Call for Courting Perdition" (PDF). The Sunday Times. London. Retrieved 12 February 2021– via paulbogdanor.com.
  14. ↑ Lion, Ed (22 January 1987). "Jewish group hails play cancellation". United Press International. Retrieved 27 September 2017.
  15. ↑ Fuller, Graham (1998). Loach on Loach. Faber & Faber. pp. 74–75. ISBN   0571179185.
  16. ↑ Cesarani, David (Spring 1987). "Perdition: Stage managed antisemitism?". Jewish Socialist. pp. 4–5.
  17. ↑ Cesarani (1990), p. 58
  18. ↑ Loach, Ken (24 December 2004). "The truth about Perdition". The Guardian. Retrieved 27 September 2017.
  19. ↑ Rich, Dave (27 September 2017). "Loach, Livingstone and the Holocaust: a study in slander". The Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved 27 September 2017.
  20. ↑ Jays, David (24 June 1999). "A damnable shame". New Statesman. Retrieved 10 October 2019.
  21. ↑ Gibbons, Fiachra (23 April 1999). "Jewish anger at revival of lost play of the 80s". The Guardian. Retrieved 27 September 2017.
  22. ↑ Pinto-Duschinsky, Michael (13 January 2017). "Book review: Kasztner's Crime, by Paul Bogdanor". The Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved 27 September 2017.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.