Pleasant Hill bus tragedy

Last updated

Pleasant Hill bus tragedy
Details
DateMarch 26, 1931
LocationNear Towner, Colorado
Coordinates 38°17′30.7″N102°05′06.0″W / 38.291861°N 102.085000°W / 38.291861; -102.085000
Country United States [1]
ServiceSchool Bus
Incident typeExposure to weather
Causeschool bus stalled in blizzard
Statistics
Bus1
Passengers20
Crew1
Deaths6
Injured15

The Pleasant Hill bus tragedy happened on March 26, 1931, near Towner, Colorado, United States, when a spring blizzard caused the death of five school children and their bus driver, while the rest of the students had to wait 33 hours for rescue.

Contents

Build-up to tragedy

Towner, Colorado, was served by the two one-room school houses, one for grades 1-6 and the other for grades 7–8. Two school buses, one for the east side and one for the west side, took the students to and from school. The east-side bus was a 1929 Chevrolet truck modified and driven by farmer and bus driver Carl Miller. [1] [2] On the day of the tragedy, some of the back windows were broken and cardboard was used to block the wind. [1]

March 23, 1931, started out warm, at 60 °F (16 °C), though dark clouds were forming. The east-side bus ran the route and picked up 20 students, ranging in age from 7 to 14 years old. Due to the warmth, some students, such as Mary Louise Stonebraker, did not bring winter clothes. [3] When the students got to school around 9 a.m., the weather had turned for the worse; temperatures dropped below freezing, and snow started to fall. [1] At the school, the two school teachers, Maude Mosier and Franz Freiday, came to the decision that the children should be taken home because the school had no water or food, and only a small stove for heat. Miller disagreed, but the teachers overruled him. All the students returned to the two school buses. The west bus made it to a local farmhouse. [4]

Tragedy

As the east bus left the school, driven by 30-year-old Carl Miller and loaded with 20 students, the full force of the blizzard hit, with strong winds. Miller was trying to take a shortcut to get to the Untiedt farm, but he almost immediately got lost, unable to see past the radiator of the bus. Around 9:30 a.m., as they were driving around looking for a landmark, the school bus slid into a ditch on Holly–Towner Road and the engine stalled out. [2] Miller tried to restart the engine, but packed snow and ice prevented it from starting up again.

Stuck on a bus with no heater, and with high wind that blew out the cardboard covering the missing windows (which caused snow to start to pile up inside), the situation became dire. The occupants tried to get warm by making a fire with school books, but this mostly filled the bus with smoke. Plus, their lunches had become frozen, and so they were also hungry. To stay warm, the bus driver ordered the kids to jump around.

In the afternoon, as the storm continued to rage, Miller asked two of the older students, Bryan Untiedt and Clara Smith, to go for help. [4] They walked some distance, but they were too cold and had to turn around. [3] The occupants continued to jump around and dance to stay warm, even through the night.

The next morning, the blizzard continued. Miller made the decision then to go find help. He told the older kids to continue to exercise and then left. Soon after he left, 13-year-old Mary Louise Stonebraker was the first child to die. [3]

Later that second day (March 27), some of the fathers, Bud Untiedt, Ernie Johnson, and Dave Stonebraker, left their homes to find the students. Finding the school empty, they then searched the nearby area. By the evening, the storm was breaking, and Untiedt and Stonebraker found the stranded school bus. Temperatures dropped as low as −20 °F (−29 °C), with 70 miles per hour (110 km/h) winds. [5] Upon entering the bus, they found the 17 living students; two more, 7-year-old Kenneth Johnson and 11-year-old Robert "Bobbie" Brown, had died on the bus. Loading the kids onto a wagon, they took them to Andy and Fern Reinert's farmhouse, reaching the house around 5 p.m. [3] That night, two more students died, Mary Louise Miller, the bus driver's daughter, and Arlo Untiedt, both 8 years old. The students had been on the bus over 30 hours.

The Pleasant Hill Memorial Pleasant Hill Memorial-3.JPG
The Pleasant Hill Memorial

Miller's body was found on Saturday, March 28, 1931, frozen, 3.5 miles (5.6 km) away from the school bus. [1] [3] His hands were bloody from using a barbed wire fence to find help.

Aftermath

The students all went to Maxwell Hospital in Lamar, and recovered, though none of them made it to the funeral, which was on March 31, 1931. [1] The tragedy became national news, and Bryan Untiedt was invited to the White House. [3] The survivors suffered psychologically, and some never talked about it.

The tragedy did cause reform in school buses and schools, such as adding two-way radios to all buses, and Colorado mandated all schools have a telephone. [4] A marker is located in the Holly Cemetery in Holly, Colorado. In addition, a memorial, called the Pleasant Hill Memorial, is located alongside Kiowa County Road 78. The north-south road connects Towner and Holly, and the memorial is on the road's west side about ten miles north of Holly. [6]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Winter storm</span> Low-temperature extreme weather events of high winds and freezing precipitation forms

A winter storm is an event in which wind coincides with varieties of precipitation that only occur at freezing temperatures, such as snow, mixed snow and rain, or freezing rain. In temperate continental and subarctic climates, these storms are not necessarily restricted to the winter season, but may occur in the late autumn and early spring as well. A snowstorm with strong winds and other conditions meeting certain criteria is called a blizzard.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nor'easter</span> Type of cyclone occurring in the northern Atlantic coast of North America

A nor'easter, is a large-scale extratropical cyclone in the western North Atlantic Ocean. The name derives from the direction of the winds that blow from the northeast. Typically, such storms originate as a low-pressure area that forms within 100 miles (160 km) of the shore between North Carolina and Massachusetts. The precipitation pattern is similar to that of other extratropical storms, although nor'easters are usually accompanied by heavy rain or snow, and can cause severe coastal flooding, coastal erosion, hurricane-force winds, or blizzard conditions. They tend to develop most often and most powerfully between the months of November and March, because of the difference in temperature between the cold polar air mass coming down from central Canada and the warm ocean waters off the upper East Coast. The susceptible regions—the upper north Atlantic coast of the United States and the Atlantic Provinces of Canada—are generally impacted by nor'easters a few times each winter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Blizzard of 1977</span> Deadly blizzard in New York, United States, and Ontario, Canada

The blizzard of 1977 hit Western New York and Southern Ontario from January 28 to February 1 of that year. Daily peak wind gusts ranging from 46 to 69 mph were recorded by the National Weather Service in Buffalo, with snowfall as high as 100 in (254 cm) recorded in areas, and the high winds blew this into drifts of 30 to 40 ft. There were 23 total storm-related deaths in Western New York, with five more in northern New York.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Schoolhouse Blizzard</span> January 1888 blizzard in the USA

The Schoolhouse Blizzard, also known as the Schoolchildren's Blizzard, School Children's Blizzard, or Children's Blizzard, hit the U.S. Great Plains on January 12, 1888. With an estimated 235 deaths, it is the world's 10th deadliest winter storm on record.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">North American blizzard of 1996</span> Severe noreaster in January 1996

The North American blizzard of 1996 was a severe nor'easter that paralyzed the United States East Coast with up to 4 feet (1.2 m) of wind-driven snow from January 6 to January 8, 1996. The City University of New York reported that the storm "dropped 20 inches of snow, had wind gusts of 50 mph and snow drifts up to 8 feet high." This storm was a classic example of a nor'easter, but the storm would not have been as historically significant without the presence of the arctic high pressure system located to the north of New York. It was followed by another storm, an Alberta Clipper, on January 12, then unusually warm weather and torrential rain which caused rapid melting and river flooding in the Northeast Floods later that month. Along with the March Superstorm of 1993 and the January 2016 United States blizzard, it is one of only three snowstorms to receive the top rating of 5, or "Extreme", on the Northeast Snowfall Impact Scale (NESIS).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">North American blizzard of 2006</span> Winter storm in North America in 2006

The North American blizzard of 2006 was a nor'easter that began on the evening of February 11, 2006 and impacted much of eastern North America. It dumped heavy snow across the Mid-Atlantic and New England states, from Virginia to Maine through the early evening of February 12, and ended in Atlantic Canada on February 13. The major cities from Baltimore to Boston received at least a foot of snow, with a second-highest amount of 26.9 inches (68 cm) in New York City, the most since at least 1869, the start of record keeping, only broken by the January 2016 United States blizzard nearly 10 years later.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2006 Colorado Holiday Blizzards</span> Weather event in Colorado, United States

The Holiday Blizzards were major storms occurring in two segments during the last two weeks of December 2006 in the Denver, Colorado area. The blizzards occurred within a week of each other. A subsequent storm, smaller in scope, struck the area less than a week after the second blizzard, further hampering removal efforts and travel in the region. The blizzard covered homes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Towner, Colorado</span> Census-designated place in Kiowa County, Colorado, United States

Towner is a census-designated place (CDP) in and governed by Kiowa County, Colorado, United States. The population of the Towner CDP was 18 at the United States Census 2020. The Sheridan Lake post office serves Towner postal addresses. Towner's post office closed down in 1992.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hazel Miner</span>

Hazel Dulcie Miner was a student at a rural Great Plains one-room school, who died while protecting her 10-year-old brother, Emmet, and 8-year-old sister, Myrdith, from the spring blizzard of 1920 in Center, North Dakota.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wilmington, Vermont</span> Town in Windham County, Vermont, US

Wilmington is a town in Windham County, Vermont, United States. The population was 2,255 at the 2020 census.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">February 9–10, 2010 North American blizzard</span> Severe weather event

The February 9–10, 2010 North American blizzard was a winter and severe weather event that afflicted the Midwest, Mid-Atlantic and New England regions of the United States between February 9–11, 2010, affecting some of the same regions that had experienced a historic Nor'easter just three days earlier. The storm brought 10 to 20 inches of snow across a wide swath from Washington, D.C., to New York City, with parts of the Baltimore metro area receiving more than 20 inches (51 cm). This storm began as a classic "Alberta clipper", starting out in Canada and then moving southeast, and finally curving northeast while rapidly intensifying off the New Jersey coast, forming an eye. The National Weather Service likened this storm to a Category 1 hurricane: "Winds topped 58 mph over part of the Chesapeake Bay, and 40 mph gusts were common across the region as the storm's center deepened and drifted slowly along the mid-Atlantic coast". The storm system, in conjunction with the earlier storm, has been nicknamed "Snoverkill."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Weather of 2008</span>

Global storm activity of 2008 profiles the major worldwide storms, including blizzards, ice storms, and other winter events, from January 1, 2008 to December 31, 2008. A winter storm is an event in which the dominant varieties of precipitation are forms that only occur at cold temperatures, such as snow or sleet, or a rainstorm where ground temperatures are cold enough to allow ice to form. It may be marked by strong wind, thunder and lightning, heavy precipitation, such as ice, or wind transporting some substance through the atmosphere. Major dust storms, Hurricanes, cyclones, tornados, gales, flooding and rainstorms are also caused by such phenomena to a lesser or greater existent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">December 2010 North American blizzard</span> Blizzard

The December 2010 North American blizzard was a major nor'easter and historic blizzard affecting the Contiguous United States and portions of Canada from December 22–29, 2010. From January 4–15, the system was known as Windstorm Benjamin in Europe. It was the first significant winter storm of the 2010–11 North American winter storm season and the fifth North American blizzard of 2010. The storm system affected the northeast megalopolis, which includes major cities such as Norfolk, Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Newark, New York City, Hartford, Providence, and Boston. It brought between 12 and 32 inches of snow in many of these areas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2011 Groundhog Day blizzard</span> 2011 blizzard affecting the U.S. and Canada

The 2011 Groundhog Day blizzard was a powerful and historic winter storm that affected large swaths of the United States and Canada from January 31 to February 2, 2011, especially on Groundhog Day. During the initial stages of the storm, some meteorologists predicted that the system would affect over 100 million people in the United States. The storm brought cold air, heavy snowfall, blowing snow, and mixed precipitation on a path from New Mexico and northern Texas to New England and Eastern Canada. The Chicago area saw 21.2 inches (54 cm) of snow and blizzard conditions, with winds of over 60 mph (100 km/h). With such continuous winds, the blizzard continued to the north and affected Eastern and Atlantic Canada. Blizzard conditions affected many other large cities along the storm's path, including Tulsa, Oklahoma City, Kansas City, St. Louis, Springfield, El Paso, Las Cruces, Des Moines, Milwaukee, Detroit, Indianapolis, Dayton, Cleveland, New York City, New York's Capital District, and Boston. Many other areas not normally used to extreme winter conditions, including Albuquerque, Dallas and Houston, experienced significant snowfall or ice accumulation. The central Illinois National Weather Service in Lincoln, Illinois, issued only their fourth blizzard warning in the forecast office's 16-year history. Snowfall amounts of 20 to 28 inches were forecast for much of Northern and Western Illinois.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">January 31 – February 2, 2015 North American blizzard</span>

The January 31 – February 2, 2015 North American blizzard was a major winter storm that plowed through the majority of the United States, dumping as much as 2 feet (24 in) of new snowfall across a path from Iowa to New England, as well as blizzard conditions in early February 2015. It came less than a week after another crippling blizzard which impacted the Northeast with 2–3 feet of snow. It was the first of many intense winter storms to occur in the nation during the month of February, partly in due to an ongoing cold wave that was beginning to take shape shortly after the storm subsided.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">January 4–8, 2017 North American winter storm</span> North American winter storm

The January 4–8, 2017 North American winter storm was a major snow and ice storm that affected the Lower 48 of the United States with winter weather. Moving ashore on the West Coast on January 3, the system produced heavy snowfall in the Sierra Mountains, with nearly 4 feet of snowfall falling in the highest elevations. After impacting the Northwest and Southwest, the winter storm went on to strike the Southeast on January 5–6 with snow and ice, with snowfall accumulations up to 4 inches (10 cm). Afterwards, it began to morph into a nor'easter as it moved off the Southeast coast late on January 6, while producing blizzard conditions in the Carolinas. It then began to affect the Northeastern United States as it tracked northwards early on January 7. It produced a swath of moderate snowfall accumulations up the East Coast, with easternmost areas such as parts of Massachusetts receiving up to 1.5 feet (18 in) of snow.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2018–19 North American winter</span> North American winter of 2018–19

The 2018–19 North American winter was unusually cold within the Northern United States, with frigid temperatures being recorded within the middle of the season. Several notable events occurred, such as a rare snow in the Southeast in December, a strong cold wave and several major winter storms in the Midwest, and upper Northeast and much of Canada in late January and early February, record snowstorms in the Southwest in late February, deadly tornado outbreaks in the Southeast and a historic mid-April blizzard in the Midwest, but the most notable event of the winter was a record-breaking bomb cyclone that affected much of the Central United States and Canada in mid-March. Unlike previous winters, a developing weak El Niño was expected to influence weather patterns across North America. Overall, however, winter of 2018–19 had many La Niña like conditions, being mild along the mid- and lower parts of the East Coast, the West Coast, and most of the southern Plains. Overall, the meteorological winter of 2018-19 became the wettest on record for the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">January 2022 North American blizzard</span> North American blizzard in 2022

The January 2022 North American blizzard caused widespread and disruptive impacts to the Atlantic coast of North America from northern Delaware to Nova Scotia with as much as 2.5 feet (30 in) of snowfall, blizzard conditions and coastal flooding at the end of January 2022. Forming from the energy of a strong mid- to upper-level trough, the system developed into a low-pressure area off the Southeast United States on January 28. The system then quickly intensified that night as it traveled northeast parallel to the coast on January 29, bringing heavy snowfall blown by high winds to the upper East Coast of the continent. Further north, it also moved inland in Maine and its width meant it strongly impacted all three of Canada's Maritime provinces. In some areas, mainly the coastal regions due to the wind, areas of New Jersey, Long Island and Massachusetts, it was the first blizzard since a storm in January 2018. The storm was considered a "bomb cyclone" as it rapidly intensified and barometric pressure dropped at least 24 millibars over a 24-hour period. The storm was given names such as Blizzard of 2022 and Winter Storm Kenan.

The Great Lakes Blizzard of January 1971 affected almost the entire Great Lakes region of North America, as well as the western St. Lawrence Valley and northern New England between January 25 and 28, 1971 before a second severe snowstorm hit many of the same areas between January 28 and 31, 1971. The areas that felt the fiercest effects of the dual storms, that being moderate or heavy snow, sustained high winds, and zero visibility due to blowing snow, included southern Wisconsin, most of Michigan, Southern Ontario, northeastern Ohio, northwestern Pennsylvania, most of upstate New York and Southern Quebec, while northern Wisconsin, northern Indiana, northeastern Ontario, and northern Vermont experienced blizzard conditions from the first of the storms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">December 2022 North American winter storm</span> North American winter storm in 2022

From December 21 to 26, 2022, an extratropical cyclone created crippling winter storm conditions, including blizzards, high winds, snowfall, and record cold temperatures across the majority of the United States and parts of Canada. Areas which experienced blizzard conditions included parts of Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New York and Ontario, with the Buffalo area of New York and the Fort Erie and Kingston areas of Ontario experiencing almost two full days of blizzard/zero-visibility conditions starting from December 23. The cold wave affected all U.S. states from Colorado to the Eastern Seaboard, with effects felt as far south as Miami, Florida. On December 24, 110 million people across 36 states were subject to wind chill alerts.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Taylor, Jack (May 15, 2018). "The Story of Colorado's Pleasant Hill Bus Tragedy". 99.9 KEKB. Grand Junction, CO: KEKB-FM . Retrieved September 3, 2019.
  2. 1 2 Eads High School Local History Project; Kiowa County Historical Society (2010). Kiowa County. Images of America. Charleston, SC: Arcadia Publishing. p. 117. ISBN   978-0-7385-8093-7. OCLC   610834831 . Retrieved September 3, 2019 via Google Books.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Simmons, R. Laurie; Simmons, Thomas H. (2010). Pleasant Hill (Towner) School Bus Tragedy Intensive Survey Plan (PDF). Front Range Research Associates.
  4. 1 2 3 "Pleasant Hill Bus Tragedy". Colorado Experience. Season 3. Episode 314. Rocky Mountain PBS. Retrieved September 3, 2019.
  5. Leffler, Thomas. "How a fateful 33 hours marked a critical turning point for schoolchildren". Yahoo News. Retrieved April 13, 2022.
  6. "Pleasant Hill Memorial". Atlas Obscura. n.d. Archived from the original on February 16, 2022. Retrieved March 13, 2024.