Plumbylene

Last updated
Plumbylenes, R2Pb Plumbylene structure.svg
Plumbylenes, R2Pb

Plumbylenes (or plumbylidenes) are divalent organolead(II) analogues of carbenes, with the general chemical formula, R2Pb, where R denotes a substituent. Plumbylenes possess 6 electrons in their valence shell, and are considered open shell species.

Contents

The first plumbylene reported was the dialkylplumbylene, [(Me3Si)2CH]2Pb, which was synthesized by Michael F. Lappert et al in 1973. [1]

Plumbylenes may be further classified into carbon-substituted plumbylenes, plumbylenes stabilized by a group 15 or 16 element, and monohalogenated plumbylenes (RPbX). [2]

Synthesis

Plumbylenes can generally be synthesized via the transmetallation of PbX2 (where X denotes halogen) with an organolithium (RLi) or Grignard reagent (RMgX). [2] The first reported plumbylene, [((CH3)3Si)2CH]2Pb, was synthesized by Michael F. Lappert et al by transmetallation of PbCl2 with [((CH3)3Si)2CH]Li. [1] The addition of equimolar RLi to PbX2 produces the monohalogenated plumbylene (RPbX); addition of 2 equivalents leads to disubstituted plumbylene (R2Pb). [3] Adding an organolithium or Grignard reagent with a different organic substituent (i.e. R’Li/R’MgX) from RPbX leads to the synthesis of heteroleptic plumbylenes (RR’Pb). [3] Dialkyl-, [1] diaryl-, [4] diamido-, [5] dithioplumbylenes, [3] and monohalogenated plumbyelenes [3] have been successfully synthesized this way.

General synthesis of plumbylenes via transmetallation General synthesis of plumbylenes.png
General synthesis of plumbylenes via transmetallation

Transmetallation with [((CH3)3Si)2N]2Pb as the Pb(II) precursor has also been used to synthesize diarylplumbylenes, [6] disilylplumbylenes, [7] and saturated N-heterocyclic plumbylenes. [8]

Synthesis of various plumbylenes via transmetallation from [((CH3)3Si)2N]2Pb Plumbylene Synthesis transmetallation.png
Synthesis of various plumbylenes via transmetallation from [((CH3)3Si)2N]2Pb

Alternatively, plumbylenes may be synthesized from the reductive dehalogenation of tetravalent organolead compounds (R2PbX2). [6]

Synthesis of plumbylenes via reductive dehalogenation of tetravalent organolead compounds Plumbylene Synthesis reductive dehalogenation.png
Synthesis of plumbylenes via reductive dehalogenation of tetravalent organolead compounds

Structure and bonding

Key valence orbitals of Pb in plumbylenes: the 6s lone pair and vacant 6p Key valence orbitals of Pb in plumbylenes the 6s lone pair and vacant 6p.svg
Key valence orbitals of Pb in plumbylenes: the 6s lone pair and vacant 6p

The bonding and reactivity in plumbylenes are dictated by the inert pair effect, whereby the combination of a widening s–p orbital energy gap as a trend down the group 14 elements and a strong relativistic contraction of the 6s orbital limits sp hybridization. The 6s orbital is deep in energy and inert. [9] Consequently, plumbylenes exclusively have a singlet spin state. They tend to exist in an equilibrium between monomeric and dimeric forms in solution. [9] In contrast carbenes sometimes have a triplet ground state and in all cases readily dimerize.

In dimethyllead, (CH3)2Pb, the Pb–C bond length is 2.267 Å and the C–Pb–C bond angle is 93.02°; the singlet–triplet gap is 36.99 kcal mol−1. [10] [ verification needed ]

Dimethyllead, (CH3)2Pb, and diphenyllead, (C6H5)2Pb Dimethyllead diphenyllead.png
Dimethyllead, (CH3)2Pb, and diphenyllead, (C6H5)2Pb

The PbC bond distance was found to be 2.303 Å and the CPbC angle 105.7°. Notwithstanding the different levels of theory, the larger bond angle for (C6H5)2Pb compared to (CH3)2Pb can be rationalized by steric effects.

Plumbylenes occur as reactive intermediates in the formation of tetravalent plumbanes (R4Pb). [11] Although the inert pair effect suggests the divalent state should be thermodynamically more stable than the tetravalent state, in the absence of stabilizing substituents, plumbylenes are sensitive to heat and light, [12] and tend to undergo polymerization and disproportionation, forming elemental lead in the process. [11] [12]

Plumbylenes can be stabilized as monomers by the use of sterically bulky ligands (kinetic stabilization) or heteroatom-containing substituents that can donate electron density into the vacant 6p orbital (thermodynamic stabilization). [2]

Dimerization

Equilibrium between plumbylenes (monomer) and diplumbenes (dimer) in solution Plumbylene dimerization.png
Equilibrium between plumbylenes (monomer) and diplumbenes (dimer) in solution

Organoplumbylenes tend to exist in an equilibrium between the monomeric and dimeric form in solution, and, due to the low dimerization energy, as either monomers or dimers in the solid state, depending on the steric bulk of substituents. [2] [9] [13] [14] Bulky substituents allow the plumbylene to exist exclusively as monomers. [15] [3] [14] In the dimerization, a Lewis acidic vacant 6p orbital interacts with a weakly Lewis basic 6s lone pair. [7] [16]

Valence bonding diagram showing donation of 6s lone pairs of Pb into vacant 6p orbital of adjacent Pb in diplumbene Valence bonding diagram showing donation of 6s lone pairs of Pb into vacant 6p orbital of adjacent Pb in diplumbene.png
Valence bonding diagram showing donation of 6s lone pairs of Pb into vacant 6p orbital of adjacent Pb in diplumbene

These diplumbenes possess a trans-bent structure similar to that in lighter, non-carbon congeners (disilenes, digermylenes, distannylenes). [9] The observed PbPb bond lengths in diplumbenes (2.90  3.53 Å) have been found to typically be longer than those in tetravalent diplumbanes R3PbPbR3 (2.84  2.97 Å). [14] This, together with the low computed dimerization energy (energy released from the formation of dimers from monomers) of 24 kJ mol1 for Pb2H4, [17] indicates weak multiple bonding. This counterintuitive result is due to the pair of 6s-6p donor-acceptor interactions representing the Pb=Pb double bond in diplumbenes being less energetically favourable compared to the overlap of spn orbitals (with a higher degree of hybridization than in diplumbenes) in the PbPb single bond in diplumbanes. [14]

Monohalogenated plumbylenes dimerize by formation of bridging halide. The halogen donate a lone pair into the vacant 6p orbital of a second lead atom. Again, sufficiently bulky substituents on lead can sterically block this dimerization mode. [2]

Due to decreasing dimerization energy down Group 14, while monohalogenated stannylenes and plumbylenes dimerize via the halogen-bridging mode, monohalogenated silylenes and germylenes tend to dimerize via the abovementioned multiply-bonded mode instead. [2]

Equilibrium between monomers and halogen-bridged dimers in monohalogenated plumbylenes Equilibrium between monomers and halogen-bridged dimers in monohalogenated plumbylenes.png
Equilibrium between monomers and halogen-bridged dimers in monohalogenated plumbylenes

N-heterocyclic plumbylene also dimerize leading to CH activation, existing in solution in an equilibrium between the monomer and a dimer resulting from cleavage of an aryl CH bond and formation of PbC and NH bonds. [18]

Stabilizing intramolecular interactions with substituents bearing lone pairs

Plumbylenes may be stabilized by electron donation into the vacant orbital of the lead atom. The two common intramolecular modes are resonance from a lone pair on the atom directly attached to the lead or by coordination from a Lewis base elsewhere in the molecule. [19]

For example, Group 15 or 16 elements directly adjacent to Pb donate a lone pair in manner similar to their stabilizing effect on Fisher carbenes. [2] [4] [20] [21] Common examples of more remote electron-donors include nitrogen atoms that can lead to a six-memberd ring by bonding to the lead. [19] Even a fluorine atom on a remote trifluoromethyl group has been seen forming a coordination to lead in [2,4,6-(CF3)3C6H2]2Pb. [22]

(a) Valence orbital diagram showing the donation of a lone pair on heteroatom E to the vacant 6p orbital of adjacent Pb. (b) Examples of heteroatom-stabilized plumbylenes (a) Valence orbital diagram showing the donation of a lone pair on heteroatom E to the vacant 6p orbital of adjacent Pb.png
(a) Valence orbital diagram showing the donation of a lone pair on heteroatom E to the vacant 6p orbital of adjacent Pb. (b) Examples of heteroatom-stabilized plumbylenes
Example of plumbylene stabilized by lone pair donation from heteratom in side-arm of substituent (2).png
(2,4,6-(CF3)3C6H2)2Pb skeletal.png
(2,4,6-(CF3)3C6H2)2Pb X-ray.png
(From left) Example of plumbylene stabilized by lone pair donation from heteratom in side-arm of substituent; [2,4,6-(CF3)3C6H2]2Pb and its X-ray structure showing donation of lone pairs on F atoms in substituents to Pb atom (highlighted with red dashed lines)

Agostic interactions

Agostic interactions have also been shown to stabilize plumbylenes. DFT computations on the compounds [(R(CH3)2Si){(CH3)2P(BH3)}CH]2Pb (R = Me or Ph) found that agostic interactions between bonding BH orbitals and the vacant 6p orbital lowered the energy of the molecule by ca. 38 kcal mol1; this was supported by X-ray crystal structures showing the favourable positioning of said BH bonds in proximity of Pb. [23]

Agostic interactions between B-H bonds and vacant 6p orbital of Pb (2).png
Plumbylene agostic front view2.png
Plumbylene agostic top view2.png
(From left) Examples of plumbylenes exhibiting agostic bonding between BH bonds and vacant 6p orbital of Pb; front and top views of X-ray crystal structure of [((CH3)3Si){(CH3)3P(BH3)}CH]2Pb. Agostic interactions are highlighted with red dashed lines in the front view; the axis of interactions is indicated with a red dot in the top view.

Reactivity

As previously mentioned, unstabilized plumbylenes are prone to polymerization and disproportionation, and plumbylenes without bulky substituents tend to dimerize in one of two modes. Below, the reactions of stabilized plumbylenes (at least at the temperatures at which they were studied) are listed.

Lewis acid-base adduct formation

Plumbylenes are Lewis acidic via the vacant 6p orbital and tend to form adducts with Lewis bases, such as trimethylamine N-oxide (Me3NO), [24] 1-azidoadamantane (AdN3), [25] and mesityl azide (MesN3). [24] In contrast, the reaction between stannylenes and Me3NO produces the corresponding distannoxane (from oxidation of Sn(II) to Sn(IV)) instead of the Lewis adduct, which can be attributed to tin being a period above Pb, experiencing the inert pair effect to a lesser degree and hence having a higher susceptibility to oxidation. [26]

In reactions with azides, the precise nature of adducts depends on the moieties near the lead(II) center. A nearby phosphorus atom also acts as a Lewis base, and in the known instance forms a bridging ring; [25] absent such an atom, the azide evolves N2 to form a nitrene, which then inserts into a C-H bond of an arene substituent and coordinates to Pb as an amine base. [24]

Reaction of plumbylenes with various Lewis bases Reaction of plumbylenes with various Lewis bases.png
Reaction of plumbylenes with various Lewis bases

Insertion

Similar to carbenes [27] and other Group 14 congeners, [2] plumbylenes have been shown to undergo insertion reactions, specifically into CX (X = Br, I) and Group 16 EE (E = S, Se) bonds. [6]

Insertion reactions of R2Pb with R'-X (X = Br, I), R'-E-E-R' (E = S, Se) and S8 Insertion reactions of plumbylenes.png
Insertion reactions of R2Pb with R'X (X = Br, I), R'EER' (E = S, Se) and S8

Insertions into lead-substituent bonds can also occur.27 In the examples below, insertion is accompanied by intramolecular rearrangement to place more electron-donating heteroatoms next to the electron-deficient lead.27

Insertion of an alkylazide and an isocyanate into [(Si(CH3)3)3Si]2Pb Insertion of an alkylazide and an isocyanate into ((Si(CH3)3)3Si)2Pb.png
Insertion of an alkylazide and an isocyanate into [(Si(CH3)3)3Si]2Pb

Transmetallation

Plumbylenes are known to undergo nucleophilic substitution with organometallic reagents to form transmetallated products.28 In an unusual example, the use of TlPF6, bearing the weakly coordinating anion PF6, led to the formation of crystals of an oligonuclear lead compound with a chain structure upon work-up, highlighting the interesting reactivity of plumbylenes.28

Transmetallation between a plumbylene and various organometallic reagents (top) and the formation of an unusual oligomeric chain compound (bottom) Transmetallation between a plumbylene and various organometallic reagents (top) and the formation of an unusual oligomeric chain compound.png
Transmetallation between a plumbylene and various organometallic reagents (top) and the formation of an unusual oligomeric chain compound (bottom)

In addition, plumbylenes can also undergo metathesis with group 13 E(CH3)3 (E = Al, Ga) compounds. [15]

Metathesis reaction between R2Pb and E(CH3)3 (E = Al, Ga). In this example, the plumbylene formed dimerizes into a diplumbene Metathesis reactions of plumbylenes.png
Metathesis reaction between R2Pb and E(CH3)3 (E = Al, Ga). In this example, the plumbylene formed dimerizes into a diplumbene

Plumbylenes bearing different substituents can also undergo transmetallation and exchange substituents, with the driving force being the relief of steric strain and the low Pb-C bond dissociation energy. [28]

Transmetallation reaction between R2Pb and R'2Pb Transmetallation reactions of plumbylenes.png
Transmetallation reaction between R2Pb and R’2Pb

Applications

Synergic s-donor-s-acceptor interactions of PbCl2 with Pt(PCy3)2 Synergic s-donor-s-acceptor interactions of plumbylene with Pt(PCy3)2.png
Synergic σ-donor-σ-acceptor interactions of PbCl2 with Pt(PCy3)2

Plumbylenes can be used as concurrent σ-donor-σ-acceptor ligands to metal complexes, functioning as σ-donor via its filled 6s orbital and σ-acceptor via its empty 6p orbital.[ citation needed ]

Room temperature-stable plumbylenes have also been suggested as precursors in chemical vapour deposition (CVD) and atomic layer deposition (ALD) of lead-containing materials. [29] Dithioplumbylenes and dialkoxyplumbylenes may be useful as precursors for preparing the semiconductor material lead sulphide and piezoelectric PZT respectively. [30]

References

  1. 1 2 3 Davidson, Peter J.; Lappert, Michael F. (1973). "Stabilisation of metals in a low co-ordinative environment using the bis(trimethylsilyl)methyl ligand; coloured SnII and PbII alkyls, M[CH(SiMe3)2]2". Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications . 1973 (9): 317a. doi:10.1039/C3973000317A. ISSN   0022-4936.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Mizuhata, Yoshiyuki; Sasamori, Takahiro; Tokitoh, Norihiro (2009). "Stable Heavier Carbene Analogues". Chemical Reviews . 109 (8): 3479–3511. doi:10.1021/cr900093s. ISSN   0009-2665. PMID   19630390.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Pu, Lihung; Twamley, Brendan; Power, Philip P. (2000). "Terphenyl Ligand Stabilized Lead(II) Derivatives of Simple Organic Groups: Characterization of Pb(R)C6H3-2,6-Trip2 (R = Me, t-Bu, or Ph; Trip = C6H2-2,4,6-i-Pr3),{Pb(μ-Br)C6H3-2,6-Trip2}2, py·Pb(Br)C6H3-2,6-Trip2 (py = Pyridine), and the Bridged Plumbylyne Complex [{W(CO)4}2(μ-Br)(μ-PbC6H3-2,6-Trip2)]". Organometallics . 19 (15): 2874–2881. doi:10.1021/om0001624. ISSN   0276-7333.
  4. 1 2 Harris, David H.; Lappert, Michael F. (1974). "Monomeric, volatile bivalent amides of group IVB elements, M(NR12)2and M(NR1R2)2 (M = Ge, Sn, or Pb; R1 = Me3Si, R2 = Me3C)". Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications . 1974 (21): 895–896. doi:10.1039/C39740000895. ISSN   0022-4936.
  5. Hitchcock, Peter B.; Lappert, Michael F.; Samways, Barry J.; Weinberg, Erica L. (1983). "Metal (Li, GeII, GeIII, SnII, and PbII) 2,6-dialkylbenzenethiolates; X-ray crystal structures of Sn(SAr)2 (Ar = C6H2But3-2,4,6) and [M(SAr')2]3 (M = Sn or Pb, Ar' = C6H3Pri2-2,6)". Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications . 1983 (24): 1492–1494. doi:10.1039/C39830001492. ISSN   0022-4936.
  6. 1 2 3 Kano, Naokazu; Shibata, Kazusato; Tokitoh, Norihiro; Okazaki, Renji (1999). "Synthesis, Structure, and Reactivity of Kinetically Stabilized Divalent Organolead Compounds (Plumbylenes)". Organometallics . 18 (16): 2999–3007. doi:10.1021/om990188z. ISSN   0276-7333.
  7. 1 2 Klinkhammer, Karl Wihelm; Schwarz, Wolfgang (1995). "Bis(hypersilyl)tin and Bis(hypersilyl)lead, Two Electron-Rich Carbene Homologs". Angewandte Chemie International Edition in English . 34 (12): 1334–1336. doi:10.1002/anie.199513341. ISSN   0570-0833.
  8. Charmant, Jonathan P. H.; Haddow, Mairi F.; Hahn, F. Ekkehardt; Heitmann, Dennis; Fröhlich, Roland; Mansell, Stephen M.; Russell, Christopher A.; Wass, Duncan F. (2008). "Syntheses and molecular structures of some saturated N-heterocyclic plumbylenes". Dalton Transactions . 2008 (43): 6055–6059. doi:10.1039/B808717B. ISSN   1477-9226. PMID   19082063.
  9. 1 2 3 4 Fischer, Roland C.; Power, Philip P. (2010). "π-Bonding and the Lone Pair Effect in Multiple Bonds Involving Heavier Main Group Elements: Developments in the New Millennium". Chemical Reviews . 110 (7): 3877–3923. doi:10.1021/cr100133q. ISSN   0009-2665. PMID   20672858.
  10. Su, Ming-Der (2004). "Theoretical Study on the Reactivities of Stannylene and Plumbylene and the Origin of their Activation Barriers". Chemistry: A European Journal . 10 (23): 6073–6084. doi:10.1002/chem.200400413. ISSN   1521-3765. PMID   15515104.
  11. 1 2 Tokitoh, Norihiro; Ando, Wataru (2003). "Silylenes (and Germylenes, Stannylenes, Plumbylenes)". In Moss, Robert A.; Platz, Matthew S.; Jones, Maitland (eds.). Reactive Intermediate Chemistry. John Wiley & Sons. pp. 651–715. doi:10.1002/0471721492.ch14. ISBN   9780471233244.
  12. 1 2 Weidenbruch, Manfred (2003). "From a Cyclotrisilane to a Cyclotriplumbane: Low Coordination and Multiple Bonding in Group 14 Chemistry". Organometallics . 22 (22): 4348–4360. doi:10.1021/om034085z. ISSN   0276-7333.
  13. Stürmann, Martin; Saak, Wolfgang; Marsmann, Heinrich; Weidenbruch, Manfred (1999). "Tetrakis(2,4,6-triisopropylphenyl)diplumbene: A Molecule with a Lead–Lead Double Bond". Angewandte Chemie International Edition . 38 (1–2): 187–189. doi:10.1002/(sici)1521-3773(19990115)38:1/2<187::aid-anie187>3.0.co;2-2. ISSN   1521-3773.
  14. 1 2 3 4 Hino, Shirley; Olmstead, Marilyn; Phillips, Andrew D.; Wright, Robert J.; Power, Philip P. (2004). "Terphenyl Ligand Stabilized Lead(II) Derivatives: Steric Effects and Lead−Lead Bonding in Diplumbenes". Inorganic Chemistry . 43 (23): 7346–7352. doi:10.1021/ic049174y. ISSN   0020-1669. PMID   15530084.
  15. 1 2 Erickson, Jeremy D.; Fettinger, James C.; Power, Philip P. (2015). "Reaction of a Germylene, Stannylene, or Plumbylene with Trimethylaluminum and Trimethylgallium: Insertion into AlC or GaC Bonds, a Reversible MetalCarbon Insertion Equilibrium, and a New Route to Diplumbenes". Inorganic Chemistry . 54 (4): 1940–1948. doi:10.1021/ic502824w. ISSN   0020-1669. PMID   25629212.
  16. Olaru, Marian; Duvinage, Daniel; Lork, Enno; Mebs, Stefan; Beckmann, Jens (2018). "Heavy Carbene Analogues: Donor-Free Bismuthenium and Stibenium Ions". Angewandte Chemie International Edition . 57 (32): 10080–10084. doi:10.1002/anie.201803160. ISSN   1433-7851. PMID   29644767.
  17. Klinkhammer, Karl W.; Fässler, Thomas F.; Grützmacher, Hansjörg (1998). "The Formation of Heteroleptic Carbene Homologues by Ligand Exchange— Synthesis of the First Plumbanediyl Dimer". Angewandte Chemie International Edition . 37 (1–2): 124–126. doi:10.1002/(sici)1521-3773(19980202)37:1/2<124::aid-anie124>3.0.co;2-c. ISSN   1521-3773.
  18. Guthardt, Robin; Oetzel, Jan; Schweizer, Julia I.; Bruhn, Clemens; Langer, Robert; Maurer, Martin; Vícha, Jan; Shestakova, Pavletta; Holthausen, Max C.; Siemeling, Ulrich (2019). "Reactive Dimerization of an N-heterocyclic Plumbylene: CH Activation with PbII". Angewandte Chemie . 131 (5): 1401–1405. doi:10.1002/ange.201811559. ISSN   0044-8249.
  19. 1 2 Barrau, Jacques; Rima, Ghassoub; El-Amraoui, Tajani (1998). "Stable divalent heteroleptic species ArO(X)M [Ar = 2,4,6-Tris(dimethylaminomethyl)phenyl-, M = Ge, Sn, Pb]". Journal of Organometallic Chemistry . 561 (1–2): 167–174. doi:10.1016/S0022-328X(98)00552-X. ISSN   0022-328X.
  20. Hahn, F. Ekkehardt; Heitmann, Dennis; Pape, Tania (2008). "Synthesis and Characterization of Stable N-Heterocyclic Plumbylenes". European Journal of Inorganic Chemistry . 2008 (7): 1039–1041. doi:10.1002/ejic.200701260. ISSN   1434-1948.
  21. Yao, Shenglai; Block, Stefan; Brym, Markus; Driess, Matthias (2007). "A new type of heteroleptic complex of divalent lead and synthesis of the P-plumbyleniophosphasilene, R2Si=PPb(L): (L = β-diketiminate)". Chemical Communications . 2007 (37): 3844–3846. doi:10.1039/B710888E. ISSN   1359-7345. PMID   18217666.
  22. Brooker, Sally; Buijink, Jan-Karel; Edelmann, Frank T. (1991). "Synthesis, structure, and reactivity of the first stable diaryllead(II) compound". Organometallics . 10: 25–26. doi:10.1021/om00047a014.
  23. Izod, Keith; Wills, Corinne; Clegg, William; Harrington, Ross W. (2009). "Acyclic Dialkylstannylene and -Plumbylene Compounds That Are Monomeric in the Solid State". Organometallics . 28 (19): 5661–5668. doi:10.1021/om900614q. ISSN   0276-7333.
  24. 1 2 3 Janes, Trevor; Zatsepin, Pavel; Song, Datong (2017). "Reactivity of heavy carbene analogues towards oxidants: A redox active ligand-enabled isolation of a paramagnetic stannylene". Chemical Communications . 53 (21): 3090–3093. doi:10.1039/C7CC00837F. ISSN   1359-7345. PMID   28243651.
  25. 1 2 Schneider, Julia; Krebs, Kilian M.; Freitag, Sarah; Eichele, Klaus; Schubert, Hartmut; Wesemann, Lars (2016). "Intramolecular Tetrylene Lewis Adducts: Synthesis and Reactivity". Chemistry: A European Journal . 22 (28): 9812–9826. doi:10.1002/chem.201601224. ISSN   0947-6539. PMID   27273819.
  26. Johnson, Brian P.; Almstätter, Stefan; Dielmann, Fabian; Bodensteiner, Michael; Scheer, Manfred (2010). "Synthesis and Reactivity of Low-Valent Group 14 Element Compounds". Zeitschrift für Anorganische und Allgemeine Chemie . 636 (7): 1275–1285. doi:10.1002/zaac.201000029. ISSN   0044-2313.
  27. Dötz, Karl Heinz (1984). "Carbene Complexes in Organic Synthesis [New Synthetic Methods (47)]". Angewandte Chemie International Edition in English . 23 (8): 587–608. doi:10.1002/anie.198405871. ISSN   0570-0833.
  28. Stürmann, Martin; Weidenbruch, Manfred; Klinkhammer, Karl W.; Lissner, Falk; Marsmann, Heinrich (1998). "New Plumbylenes and a Plumbylene Dimer with a Short Lead−Lead Separation". Organometallics . 17 (20): 4425–4428. doi:10.1021/om9804475. ISSN   0276-7333.
  29. Bačić, Goran; Zanders, David; Mallick, Bert; Devi, Anjana; Barry, Seán T. (2018). "Designing Stability into Thermally Reactive Plumbylenes". Inorganic Chemistry . 57 (14): 8218–8226. doi:10.1021/acs.inorgchem.8b00719. ISSN   0020-1669. PMID   29943579. S2CID   49410374.
  30. Rekken, Brian D.; Brown, Thomas M.; Olmstead, Marilyn M.; Fettinger, James C.; Power, Philip P. (2013). "Stable Plumbylene Dichalcogenolate Monomers with Large Differences in Their Interligand Angles and the Synthesis and Characterization of a Monothiolato Pb(II) Bromide and Lithium Trithiolato Plumbate". Inorganic Chemistry . 52 (6): 3054–3062. doi:10.1021/ic302513c. ISSN   0020-1669. PMID   23441916.