Richard Puller von Hohenburg

Last updated
Manuscript depiction of the burning of Puller and his servant Anton Matzler outside the walls of Zurich for sodomy, in 1482. Illustration from the Grosse Burgunderchronik of Diebold Schilling. The depiction of the execution in front of the city walls is inaccurate, as Puller was actually burned in Zurich's market square, inside the walls. Burning of Sodomites.jpg
Manuscript depiction of the burning of Puller and his servant Anton Mätzler outside the walls of Zürich for sodomy, in 1482. Illustration from the Grosse Burgunderchronik of Diebold Schilling. The depiction of the execution in front of the city walls is inaccurate, as Puller was actually burned in Zürich's market square, inside the walls.

Richard Puller von Hohenburg (died 24 September 1482) was a 15th-century Alsatian and Swiss nobleman and knight. He is notable for his homosexual liaisons, his strategic avoidance of prosecution, and later execution for his homosexuality.

Contents

Biography

Richard Puller von Hohenburg was born, perhaps towards the end of the 1420s, second son to the wealthy noble Wirich II Puller von Hohenburg. A descendant of Konrad Hohenburg  [ de ], Wirich had inherited much, but his political shrewdness and local reputation as an advisor ensured that the family's status only grew. [2] It is a testament to his shrewdness that he and his son became citizens of Strasbourg in Alsace (in 1453 and 1454 respectively) in spite of Wirich's former allegiance to Bishop Wilhelm von Diest  [ de ], despised within the city. [3] Wirich probably arranged the younger Puller's marriage to one Sophie Bock, daughter of the wealthy Strasbourg magistrate Hans Konrad Bock, which took place in 1455. [4]

Wirich died sometime after 1454 [5] and Richard's elder brother, Wirich III, was slain in battle in 1455, leaving Richard the only surviving male heir of the family. As head of the family, he first married off his sisters, but soon found himself embroiled in local feuds and trials. The details of these disputes are murky but they apparently reached such a pitch that he was stripped of the Löwenstein castle  [ de ] in 1457, an estate the family had held for generations in fealty to the Electorate of the Palatinate. [6]

In 1463, the Swiss noble Wirich von Berstett captured one of Puller's servants, a man named Ludwig Fischer, after he had been seen dressed in lavish clothes and in possession of more money than his occupation would afford him. [7] In early modern Europe, gifts of clothing were often used as evidence of offering improper sexual services, presented as either a token of love or a bribe from the paying participant. [8] Under torture, Fischer revealed that Puller had romantically pursued him, an act he used to his advantage by blackmailing Puller for money and status. [9] Puller was consequently stripped of his fiefs, which were transferred to the bishop of Strasbourg, Rupert of Palatinate-Simmern, but he was not put on trial. Shortly after, he was released from arrest. [10]

Though he had managed to evade prosecution this time, in 1474 Puller was again accused of sodomy. Puller's enemies even claimed that, in the interval between these charges, Puller had been so wary of discovery he had a servant who witnessed a sexual act drowned. Even against such a severe charge, Puller managed to evade negative consequences through the strategic manipulation of his social status. He procured, or else forged, letters of recommendation from far-off authorities, playing the local Alsatian nobles off against the imperial powers of the Holy Roman Empire. By 1476, Puller was released upon a set of conditions: confessing his misdeeds, giving up his properties, and monastic imprisonment. Puller was quickly stripped of his Alsatian possessions, but fled from Alsace before beginning a monastic life, intent on recovering these possessions. [11]

In 1476, Puller had turned to the Old Swiss Confederacy, then a popular refuge for European criminals, in search of aid in reclaiming his lost properties. His petitions of entry not only cited (genuine) letters he had obtained from imperial and papal authorities, but outright forgeries, such as one which claimed Bishop Rupert had found him entirely innocent. He turned to city authorities at Bern for assistance, who rejected his pleas after much deliberation, and after that the authorities of Zürich, who were more obliging and accepted him. Zürich hoped for a lucrative feud with the rich Strasbourg, but Puller's property claims generated conflict between the Confederacy and Strasbourg, which had historically been a close ally to the Swiss. [12]

By 1480, Puller was now demanding an entire inheritance from Strasbourg (his father-in-law Hans Konrad Bock was dead by 1479). Zürich could find no allies in the Confederacy for its feud against Strasbourg and Puller's residency in Zürich was becoming a political nuisance. [13] In 1482, city officials discovered a homosexual relationship between Puller and his servant, Anton Mätzler. [14] The convenient détente this trial provided to relations between Strasbourg and the Confederacy did not go uncommented on by contemporaries. Indeed, one source (apparently from an underling of the councillors) alleges Strasbourg made a payment of eight thousand florins to the councillors for the trial and execution of Puller, although the source was definite about Puller's guilt of the charges. [15]

Contemporary chronicler Diebold Schilling the Elder reported that, as before, this act had been discovered because of his servant's boasts of the "precious clothing, beautiful shirts, and other treasures" in his possession, which the officials had suspected to be sexual gifts from his master. [16] Puller and his servant were charged by the officials with "heresy". Under torture by the city officials, Puller confessed to having had same-sex relationships with Mätzler and several other men. Consequently, he was sentenced to be burned at the stake alongside his servant Mätzler in the market square of Zürich. On 24 September 1482, a large crowd had gathered to see Puller executed. Puller was asked to repeat his confession, but he refused, instead claiming that the accusation of sodomy was only a cover for the Zürich officials who wished to seize his land and fortune. One of the officials mentioned by name was Hans Waldmann, then mayor of Zürich, who was later executed for several charges (among them, sodomy) after a spectacular but brief and unpopular political career in Zürich. [17] With the execution of its last scion, the noble family of the von Hohenburgs perished, with their ancestral castle passing on to the Sickinger family. [18]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Codex Manesse</span> 14th-century German illuminated manuscript

The Codex Manesse is a Liederhandschrift, the single most comprehensive source of Middle High German Minnesang poetry, written and illustrated between c. 1304 when the main part was completed, and c. 1340 with the addenda.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Morgarten</span> 1315 battle during the creation of the Swiss Confederacy

The Battle of Morgarten took place on 15 November 1315, when troops of Schwyz, supported by their allies of Uri and Unterwalden, ambushed an Austrian army under the command of Leopold I, Duke of Austria on the shores of Lake Ägeri, in the territory of Schwyz.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Tell</span> Folk hero of Switzerland

William Tell is a folk hero of Switzerland. According to the legend, Tell was an expert mountain climber and marksman with a crossbow who assassinated Albrecht Gessler, a tyrannical reeve of the Austrian dukes of the House of Habsburg positioned in Altdorf, in the canton of Uri. Tell's defiance and tyrannicide encouraged the population to open rebellion and a pact against the foreign rulers with neighbouring Schwyz and Unterwalden, marking the foundation of the Swiss Confederacy. Tell was considered the father of the Swiss Confederacy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alemannic German</span> Group of dialects of the Upper German branch of the Germanic language family

Alemannic, or rarely Alemannish, is a group of High German dialects. The name derives from the ancient Germanic tribal confederation known as the Alemanni.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Early modern Switzerland</span>

The early modern history of the Old Swiss Confederacy and its constituent Thirteen Cantons encompasses the time of the Thirty Years' War (1618–1648) until the French invasion of 1798.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Switzerland in the Napoleonic era</span>

During the French Revolutionary Wars, the revolutionary armies marched eastward, enveloping Switzerland in their battles against Austria. In 1798, Switzerland was completely overrun by the French and was renamed the Helvetic Republic. The Helvetic Republic encountered severe economic and political problems. In 1798 the country became a battlefield of the Revolutionary Wars, culminating in the Battles of Zürich in 1799.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leo Jud</span> Swiss reformer

Leo Jud, known to his contemporaries as Meister Leu, was a Swiss reformer who worked with Huldrych Zwingli in Zürich.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Swabian War</span> Swiss conflict against the Habsburgs

The Swabian War of 1499 (Alemannic German: Schwoobechrieg, called Schwabenkrieg or Schweizerkrieg in Germany and Engadiner Krieg was the last major armed conflict between the Old Swiss Confederacy and the House of Habsburg. What had begun as a local conflict over the control of the Val Müstair and the Umbrail Pass in the Grisons soon got out of hand when both parties called upon their allies for help; the Habsburgs demanding the support of the Swabian League, while the Federation of the Three Leagues of the Grisons turning to the Swiss Eidgenossenschaft. Hostilities quickly spread from the Grisons through the Rhine valley to Lake Constance and even to the Sundgau in southern Alsace, the westernmost part of the Habsburg region of Further Austria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Konrad Pellikan</span> German Protestant theologian, humanist, Protestant reformer and Christian Hebraist

Konrad Pellikan was a German Protestant theologian, humanist, Protestant reformer and Christian Hebraist who worked chiefly in Switzerland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Grandson</span> Part of the Burgundian Wars (1476)

The Battle of Grandson was fought on 2 March 1476, during the Burgundian Wars, and resulted in a major defeat for Charles the Bold, Duke of Burgundy, at the hands of the Old Swiss Confederacy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rütli Oath</span> Legendary oath taken at the foundation of the Old Swiss Confederacy

The Rütli Oath is the legendary oath taken at the foundation of the Old Swiss Confederacy by the representatives of the three founding cantons, Uri, Schwyz and Unterwalden. It is named after the site of the oath taking, the Rütli, a meadow above Lake Uri near Seelisberg. Recorded in Swiss historiography from the 15th century, the oath is notably featured in the 19th century play William Tell by Friedrich Schiller.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Herrad of Landsberg</span> 12th-century abbess, author and illustrator from Alsace

Herrad of Landsberg was a 12th-century Alsatian nun and abbess of Hohenburg Abbey in the Vosges mountains. She was known as the author of the pictorial encyclopedia Hortus deliciarum.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hans Waldmann (mayor)</span> Swiss politician (1435–1489)

Hans Waldmann was mayor of Zurich and a Swiss military leader. Born in Blickensdorf near Zug, he married well and became Squire of Dubelstein. He served as Mayor of Zurich between 1483–1489 and was beheaded on the 6 April 1489 following a peasant revolt.

The Bundeslied or Tellenlied is a patriotic song of the Old Swiss Confederacy. Its original composition dates to the Burgundian Wars period (1470s). The oldest extant manuscript text was written in 1501, the first publication in print dates to 1545. It consists of stanzas of six lines each, with a rhyming scheme of A-A-B-C-C-B. It is one of the oldest existing records of the legend of Swiss national hero William Tell.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">LGBT history in Switzerland</span>

Switzerland, a country which has long held a stance of neutrality in its relations with other nations, has not been immune to the movement of equality for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender citizens. Prior to the 20th century, sodomy and other types of sexual intercourse between people of the same sex was held in various levels of legal contempt. Today, the modern LGBT rights movement in Switzerland is related to the larger international movement which developed largely after 1969.

In medieval Europe, attitudes toward homosexuality varied from region to region, determined by religious culture; the Catholic Church, which dominated the religious landscape, considered, and still considers, sodomy as a mortal sin and a "crime against nature". By the 11th century, "sodomy" was increasingly viewed as a serious moral crime and punishable by mutilation or death. Medieval records reflect this growing concern. The emergence of heretical groups, such as the Cathars and Waldensians, witnesses a rise in allegations of unnatural sexual conduct against such heretics as part of the war against heresy in Christendom. Accusations of sodomy and "unnatural acts" were levelled against the Order of the Knights Templar in 1307 as part of Philip IV of France's attempt to suppress the order. These allegations have been dismissed by some scholars.

Wirich VI, Count of Daun-Falkenstein was a German nobleman, diplomat, statesman, and politician. By descent, he was a Count of Falkenstein, and by inheritance, he was Lord of Broich and Lord of Bürgel. He belonged to the lower nobility in the Duchy of Berg and was a member of the Estates of Berg. He supported the Reformation in the Lower Rhine area.

Katherina Hetzeldorfer was recorded as the first woman to be executed for female homosexuality. She was drowned in the Rhine in Speyer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Frauenfeld</span> War of the second coalition encounter

The Battle of Frauenfeld was a military encounter during the War of the Second Coalition (1799-1802). It took place on 25 May 1799 between Austrian and French troops. The battle ended in the evening with the retreat of the Austrians, but on the following day the French withdrew.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karl von Wedel</span> Prussian general and diplomat (1842–1919)

Karl, Prince of Wedel, born Karl Leo Julius Graf von Wedel, was a Prussian general and diplomat who served as the fourth Imperial Lieutenant of the Reichsland of Alsace–Lorraine from 27 October 1907 until his resignation on 18 April 1914.

References

  1. Smalls 2015 , p. 268
  2. Franck 1880, Reinle 1997 , pp. 89–91
  3. Reinle 1997 , pp. 89–91
  4. Reinle 1997 , p. 91
  5. Reinle 1997 , p. 90
  6. Reinle 1997 , p. 92
  7. Puff 2002 , p. 258, Puff 2003 , p. 45
  8. Puff 2002 , pp. 255–256
  9. Puff 2002 , p. 258, Puff 2003 , p. 45
  10. Puff 2003 , p. 45
  11. Puff 2003 , pp. 45–46
  12. Puff 2003 , p. 46, Reinle 1997 , p. 92-93
  13. Puff 2003 , p. 48, Reinle 1997 , p. 93
  14. Puff 2003 , p. 46
  15. Puff 2003 , p. 48
  16. Puff 2002 , p. 256
  17. Puff 2003 , pp. 46–47, Smalls 2015 , p. 268
  18. Franck 1880

Sources

  • Franck, Jakob (1880). "Konrad von Hohenburg". Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie (ADB). Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie (in German). Vol. 12. Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot. pp. 669–71.
  • Puff, Helmut (2002). "The Sodomite's Clothes: Gift-Giving and Sexual Excess in Early Modern Germany and Switzerland". In McClanan, Anne; Encarnacion, Karen Rosoff (eds.). The Material Culture of Sex, Procreation, and Marriage in Premodern Europe. Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 251–73. ISBN   978-0312240011.
  • Puff, Helmut (2003). Sodomy in Reformation Germany and Switzerland, 1400–1600. University of Chicago Press. ISBN   978-0226685052.
  • Reinle, Christine (1997). "Konflikte und Konfliktstrategien eines elsässischen Adeligen: Der Fall des Richard Puller von Hohenburg († 1482)". In Andermann, Kurt (ed.). "Raubritter" oder "Rechtschaffene vom Adel"? Aspekte von Politik, Friede und Recht im späten Mittelalter. Sigmaringen: Thorbecke. pp. 89–113.
  • Smalls, James (2015). Homosexuality in Art. Parkstone International. ISBN   978-1783107278.

Further reading