Schwartzbard trial

Last updated
Schwartzbard trial
Sholom Schwartzbard Henry Torres Oct 1928.jpg
Sholem Schwartzbard's speech the court. Below him, Henri Torrès, his attorney. Oct. 1927
Native name Процес Шварцбарда
DateOctober 18–26, 1927 (1927-10-18 1927-10-26)
Location Paris, France
Type Trial
Cause Assassination of Symon Petliura
Motive Revenge for antisemitic pogroms in Ukraine
Casualties
Symon Petliura
Accused Sholem Schwarzbard
Charges Murder
Verdict Acquittal

The Schwartzbard trial was a sensational 1927 French murder trial in which Samuel "Sholem" Schwartzbard was accused of murdering the Ukrainian immigrant and head of the Ukrainian government-in-exile Symon Petliura. The trial quickly began to revolve around Petliura's responsibility for the 1919-1920 pogroms in Ukraine, during which Schwartzbard had lost all 15 members of his family. During the trial, prosecution alleged that Schwartzbard was a Soviet agent and assassinated Petliura on Soviet orders. This view is still widely held, especially in Ukraine, but is far from universal. [1] Schwartzbard was acquitted of all charges.

Contents

Assassination

In 1919, fighting in southern Ukraine as part of the Bolshevik Revolutionary Insurgent Army of Ukraine (RIAU), led by Grigori Kotovsky, [2] Schwartzbard was told that he had lost 15 members of his family in pogroms that had taken place in Odesa, Ukraine that year. He held Symon Petliura, who was the head of the Directorate of the Ukrainian National Republic, responsible for their deaths.

According to his autobiography, after hearing the news that Petliura had relocated to Paris in 1924, Schwartzbard became distraught and started plotting Petliura's assassination. A picture of Petliura with Józef Piłsudski was published in Encyclopédie Larousse and enabled Schwartzbard to recognize him. [3]

On 25 May 1926, at 14:12, by the Gibert bookstore, he approached Petliura, who was walking on the Rue Racine near boulevard Saint-Michel in the Latin Quarter, Paris, and asked him in Ukrainian, "Are you Mr. Petliura?" Petliura did not answer but raised his cane. Schwartzbard pulled out a gun and shot him five times and, after Petliura fell to the pavement, shot him twice more. When the police came and asked if he had done the deed, he reportedly said, "I have killed a great assassin." [4]

It is reported [5] that he had planned to assassinate Petliura at a gathering of Ukrainian emigrants marking Petliura's birthday, but the attempt was foiled by the anarchist Nestor Makhno, who was also at the function. Schwartzbard had told Makhno that he was terminally sick, was about to die and would take Petliura with him. [5] (Schwartzbard died eleven years after the trial.)

The French secret service had been monitoring Schwartzbard since his arrival in Paris, and noted his meetings with known Bolsheviks. During the trial, the German special services also alleged to their French counterparts that Schwartzbard had assassinated Petliura on the orders of Galip[ who? ], an emissary of the Union of Ukrainian Citizens. Galip had received orders from Christian Rakovsky, an ethnic Bulgarian and a Soviet ambassador to France (1925–27), a former revolutionary leader from Romania and a former prime minister of the Ukrainian SSR. The act was according to the prosecution consolidated by Mikhail Volodin, who arrived in France on 8 August 1925 and who had been in close contact with Schwartzbard. [5] [6]

The trial

Schwartzbard turned himself in to a nearby gendarme and was arrested at the site of the assassination. Lawyers César Campinchi and Henri Torres led the prosecution and the defense, respectively. After only 35 minutes of deliberation, the jury acquitted Schwartzbard. [4]

The lawyers

For the defense, Henri Torres, grandson of Isaiah Levaillant, the man who founded the "League for the Defense of Human and Civil Rights" during the Dreyfus Affair. Torres was a renowned French left-wing jurist who had previously defended anarchists such as Buenaventura Durruti and Ernesto Bonomini and also represented the Soviet consulate in France.

For the prosecution there was the Public Court Commission that was preparing the claim. It was consisting of several Ukrainian statesmen such as Oleksander Shulhyn (former Minister of Foreign Affairs, at that time professor at the Ukrainian Free University), M. Shulhina, Vyacheslav Prokopovych, М. Shumytsky, І. Tokarzhevsky, and L. Chykalenko. The Commission gathered around 70 witness reports including L. Martyniuk, Lieutenant Colonel Butakov, M. Shadrin, Colonels Dekhtiarov and Zorenko, and many others. Explanation letters were sent by Generals Mykhailo Omelianovych-Pavlenko, Vsevolod Petrov and A. Cherniavsky.

The French people were represented by public prosecutor Reynaud. In the civil suit Madame Olga Petliura (nee Bilska) and her brother-in-law Oskar were represented by Albert Wilm and Cesare Campinchi (who was the chief prosecution lawyer). Assisting them was Czeslaw Poznansky, an attorney from Poland.

Schwartzbard

Schwartzbard was charged with violations of Articles 295, 296, 297, 298 and 302 of the French Penal Code (all of which pertained to premeditated murder and provided for the death penalty). The defendant pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Questioned by the prosecutor, Schwartzbard started his testimony poorly. He lied and gave confusing answers to why he had been previously imprisoned in Russia (1906), Vienna (1908) and Budapest (1909). He lied about his age, place of birth and the fact that he had been charged with burglary in Austria twice. He also lied about his service in the Red Army, stating that he fought on the side of Alexander Kerensky [7] rather than have led a battalion under Kotovsky.

Witness for the prosecution

Several former Ukrainian officers testified for the prosecution, including Pavlo Shandruk, General Mykola Shapoval, and Oleksandr Shulhin. Over 200 documents were produced that asserted Petliura and his government attempted to stop antisemitic aggression. A 20-page testimony was read by E. Dobkovsky that Mikhail Volodin was an agent of the State Political Directorate (GPU) with access to large sums of money and that he had approached Dobkovsky and told him that he had helped in the assassination.[ citation needed ]

Witnesses for the defense

A notable witness for the defense was Haia Greenberg (aged 29) who survived the Proskuriv pogroms where she had worked as a nurse for the Danish Red Cross. She never said Petliura personally participated in the event, but named other soldiers, who said they were directed by Petliura. Torres, however, decided not to call on most of the other 80 witnesses he had prepared for Schwartzbard's defense. Instead, he took a calculated risk and delivered only a short speech, invoking the French Revolution. [8]

I demand a full acquittal for my client. I demand it in the name of the French Revolution, in the name of our nation who died in the World War; in the name of humanity and of the prestige of France, at whom the whole world is looking. The French Revolution first gave emancipation to the Jewish people. The Jews have always been grateful to France. Don't darken those feelings. Not only the fate of Schwartzbard, but the prestige of France rests with you, gentlemen of the jury." [9] [10]

Torres later remarked that had Schwartzbard been found guilty, France would have lost all meaning:

"If I had not been heard, France would have been no longer France and Paris would have been no longer Paris." [11]

Outcome

The jury deliberated for only 35 minutes before acquitting Schwartzbard, whom they viewed as innocent "before God and their conscience." Following the verdict, someone in the courtroom chanted "Vive la France," and the entire courtroom started chanting the same. [12] Not only was Schwartzbard acquitted, but Petliura's family was ordered to pay for the costs of the trial. The jury rewarded one franc in compensation to Petliura's widow and brother. Schwartzbard became seen by fellow Jews as a heroic avenger of the victims of the pogroms. [13]

Time reported that the outcome of the trial gripped all Europe and was regarded by the Jews as establishing proof of the horrors perpetrated against their co-religionists in Ukraine under the dictatorship of Simon Petliura; radical opinion rejoiced, but the conservatives saw justice flouted and the decorum of the French courts immeasurably impaired. [4]

French press

The French press published detailed accounts and comments relating to the court proceedings. Divergent assessments of the assassination committed by Schwartzbard coincided with the political sympathies and antipathies of the particular newspapers, which fell into three groups:

  1. Those that approved of Schwartzbard stressed the pogroms of the Jewish population and, from the very outset, treated the victim of the assassination as a defendant (the most conspicuous example being the communist newspaper L'Humanité )
  2. Papers restricted themselves to an exact observation of the court trial but refused to print commentaries or did so very cautiously ( Le Temps , L'Ere Nouvelle or Le Petit Parisien )
  3. Papers portrayed Schwartzbard's crime in an unambiguously negative light and treated the assassin predominantly as a Bolshevik agent (also centrist publications but especially the right-wing L'Intransigeant , L'Écho de Paris and L'Action Française ). The French governing circles, headed by Quai d'Orsay, were not interested in granting the case further publicity, which could cause the already-tense relations with the Soviet Union to deteriorate, which the latter threatened to sever. [14]

Aftermath

According to a defected KGB operative Peter Deriabin, the assassination of Petliura was a special operation by the GPU, and Schwartzbard was an NKVD agent and acted on the order from a former chairman of the Soviet Ukrainian government and then-Soviet Ambassador to France, Christian Rakovsky. [15] [6] [16] [17] Mykola Riabchuk wrote: "In fact, the trial turned into an ostentatious demonstration of retribution against Ukraine's demonized 'nationalism and separatism'; no Lubianka could ever have come up with anything better." [18]

After the Schwartzbard trial, Henri Torres was recognized as one of France's leading trial lawyers and remained active in political affairs.

After his acquittal in 1928, Schwartzbard decided to immigrate to the British Mandate of Palestine. The British authorities, however, refused him a visa. In 1933, he traveled the United States where he re-enacted his role in the murder on film. In 1937, Schwartzbard traveled to South Africa, where he died in Cape Town on 3 March 1938. In 1967, his remains were disinterred and transported to Israel, where he was reinterred.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anton Denikin</span> Russian military and political leader (1872–1947)

Anton Ivanovich Denikin was a Russian military leader who served as the acting supreme ruler of the Russian State and the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of South Russia during the Russian Civil War of 1917–1923. Previously, he was a general in the Imperial Russian Army during World War I.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nestor Makhno</span> Ukrainian anarchist revolutionary (1888–1934)

Nestor Ivanovych Makhno, also known as Batko Makhno, was a Ukrainian anarchist revolutionary and the commander of the Revolutionary Insurgent Army of Ukraine during the Ukrainian War of Independence. He established the Makhnovshchina, a mass movement by the Ukrainian peasantry to establish anarchist communism in the country between 1918 and 1921. Initially centered around Makhno's home province of Katerynoslav and hometown of Huliaipole, it came to exert a strong influence over large areas of southern Ukraine, specifically in what is now the Zaporizhzhia Oblast of Ukraine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Symon Petliura</span> Ukrainian military leader (1879–1926)

Symon Vasyliovych Petliura was a Ukrainian politician and journalist. He was the Supreme Commander of the Ukrainian People's Army (UNA) and led the Ukrainian People's Republic during the Ukrainian War of Independence, a part of the wider Russian Civil War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sholem Schwarzbard</span> Russo-French anarchist poet and assassin

Samuel "Sholem" Schwarzbard was a Russian-French Yiddish poet. He served in the French and Soviet military, was a communist and anarchist, and is known for organising Jewish community defense against pogroms in pre-First World War era and Russian Civil War era Ukraine, and for the assassination of Ukrainian nationalist leader Symon Petliura in 1926. He wrote poetry in Yiddish under the pen name of Baal-Khaloymes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">International League Against Racism and Anti-Semitism</span>

The International League Against Racism and Anti-Semitism—or Ligue internationale contre le racisme et l'antisémitisme (LICRA) in French—was established in 1927 and is opposed to intolerance, xenophobia, and exclusion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Maria Nikiforova</span> Ukrainian anarchist (1885–1919)

Maria Hryhorivna Nikiforova was a Ukrainian anarchist partisan leader that led the Black Guards during the Ukrainian War of Independence, becoming widely renowned as an atamansha. A self-described terrorist from the age of 16, she was imprisoned for her activities in Russia before managing to escape to western Europe. With the outbreak of World War I, she took up the defencist line and joined the French Foreign Legion on the Macedonian front before returning to Ukraine with the outbreak of the 1917 Revolution.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nykyfor Hryhoriv</span> Ukrainian military leader (1884–1919)

Nykyfor Oleksandrovych Hryhoriv was a Ukrainian military leader noted for repeatedly switching sides during the Ukrainian War of Independence and Soviet-Ukrainian war. He is today considered one of the most influential rebel leaders of the Otamanshchyna phenomenon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Soghomon Tehlirian</span> Armenian revolutionary and assassin (1896–1960)

Soghomon Tehlirian was an Armenian revolutionary and soldier who assassinated Talaat Pasha, the former Grand Vizier of the Ottoman Empire, in Berlin on March 15, 1921. He was entrusted to carry out the assassination after having earlier killed Harutian Mgrditichian, who had worked for the Ottoman secret police and helped compile the list of Armenian intellectuals who were deported on April 24, 1915.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the Jews in Ukraine</span> Ethnic group

The history of the Jews in Ukraine dates back over a thousand years; Jewish communities have existed in the modern territory of Ukraine from the time of the Kievan Rus'. Important Jewish religious and cultural movements, from Hasidism to Zionism, arose there. According to the World Jewish Congress, the Jewish community in Ukraine constitutes Europe's third-largest and the world's fifth-largest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anarchism in Ukraine</span> History of the anarchist movement in Ukraine

Anarchism in Ukraine has its roots in the democratic and egalitarian organization of the Zaporozhian Cossacks, who inhabited the region up until the 18th century. Philosophical anarchism first emerged from the radical movement during the Ukrainian national revival, finding a literary expression in the works of Mykhailo Drahomanov, who was himself inspired by the libertarian socialism of Pierre-Joseph Proudhon. The spread of populist ideas by the Narodniks also lay the groundwork for the adoption of anarchism by Ukraine's working classes, gaining notable circulation in the Jewish communities of the Pale of Settlement.

Elias Tcherikower, also known as Eliahu Tcherikover, Elye Tsherikover, Eliahu Tcherikower, Elias Tscherikower, and I. M. Cherikover, was a Russian-born Jewish historian of Judaism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ukrainian nationalism</span> Nationalism in support of the collective identity of Ukraine

Ukrainian nationalism is the promotion of the unity of Ukrainians as a people and the promotion of the identity of Ukraine as a nation state. The origins of modern Ukrainian nationalism emerge during the 17th-century Cossack uprising against the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth led by Bohdan Khmelnytsky. Ukrainian nationalism draws upon a single national identity of culture, ethnicity, geographic location, language, politics, religion, traditions and belief in a shared singular history that dates back to the 9th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henri Torrès</span>

Henry Torrès was a French trial lawyer and politician, and a prolific writer on political and legal matters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antisemitism in Ukraine</span>

Antisemitism in Ukraine has been a historical issue in the country, particularly in the twentieth century. The history of the Jewish community of the region dates back to the era when ancient Greek colonies existed in it. A third of the Jews of Europe previously lived in Ukraine between 1791 and 1917, within the Pale of Settlement. The large concentration of Jews in this region historically made them an easy target for anti-Jewish actions and pogroms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lviv pogroms (1941)</span> Genocidal massacres of Jews in 1941 Ukraine

The Lviv pogroms were the consecutive pogroms and massacres of Jews in June and July 1941 in the city of Lwów in German-occupied Eastern Poland/Western Ukraine. The massacres were perpetrated by Ukrainian nationalists, German death squads (Einsatzgruppen), and urban population from 30 June to 2 July, and from 25 to 29 July, during the German invasion of the Soviet Union. Thousands of Jews were killed both in the pogroms and in the Einsatzgruppen killings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jewish–Ukrainian relations in Eastern Galicia</span> Interethnic relations in western Ukraine during 1795–1944

Eastern Galicia was the heartland of the medieval Kingdom of Galicia–Volhynia, currently spread over the provinces of Lviv, Ivano-Frankivsk, and Ternopil in modern western Ukraine. Along with Poles and Ukrainians, Jews were one of the three largest ethnic groups in Eastern Galicia with almost 900,000 people by 1910. From the late 18th century until the early 20th century eastern Galicia had the largest concentration of Jews of any region in Europe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bernard Lecache</span> French journalist (1895–1968)

Bernard Lecache was a French journalist. In 1927, he founded the League Against Pogroms, which the following year, became the International League Against Anti-Semitism, and in 1979, became the International League against Racism and Anti-Semitism. He was the president from 1927 to 1968.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Proskurov pogrom</span> Massacre of Jews at the town of Proskurov (present-day Khmelnytskyi) in Ukraine on 15 February 1919

The Proskurov pogrom took place on 15 February 1919 in the town of Proskurov during the Ukrainian War of Independence, which was taken over from under the Bolshevik control by militants who claimed themselves to be Haidamacks. In mere three and a half hours at least 1,500 Jews were murdered, up to 1,700 by other estimates, and more than 1,000 wounded including women, children and the old. The massacre was carried out by Ukrainian People's Republic soldiers of Ivan Semesenko. They were ordered to save the ammunition in the process and use only lances and bayonets.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Olha Petliura</span> Wife of the first Ukrainian president

Olha Opanasivna Petliura was a spouse of Ukrainian political leader Symon Petliura. She graduated from the Higher Courses for Women, Kyiv.

Oleksiy Vasylovych Chubenko was a diplomat for the Revolutionary Insurgent Army of Ukraine.

References

  1. Johnson, Kelly. 2012. Sholem Schwarzbard: Biography of a Jewish Assassin. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University.
  2. Friedman (1976). p. 62.
  3. Friedman (1976). p. 65.
  4. 1 2 3 Time magazine.
  5. 1 2 3 Makhno did not allow Schwartzbard to Shoot Petliura (in Ukrainian)
  6. 1 2 Famous Assassinations in World History: An Encyclopedia, Michael Newton, two volumes, ABC-CLIO, 2014, pages 418-420
  7. Friedman (1976). p. 119.
  8. "Acquittal of Sholom Schwartzbard is Condemnation of Pogroms". Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 2015-03-20. Retrieved 2024-02-20.
  9. "Petliura". The Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle. 1927-11-04. p. 8. Retrieved 2024-02-20.
  10. "Schwartzbard trial". Times Union. 1927-10-26. p. 49. Retrieved 2024-02-20.
  11. "August 18: The Avenger". Jewish Currents. Retrieved 2024-02-20.
  12. Schur, Anna (2007). "Shades of Justice: The Trial of Sholom Schwartzbard and Dovid Bergelson's Among Refugees". Law and Literature. 19 (1): 15–43. doi:10.1525/lal.2007.19.1.15. ISSN   1535-685X. JSTOR   10.1525/lal.2007.19.1.15. S2CID   144348738.
  13. "When France Embraced a Jewish Avenger". The Forward. 2008-10-24. Retrieved 2024-02-20.
  14. The Trial of Samuel Schwartzbard at cejsh.icm.edu.pl Archived 2011-07-18 at the Wayback Machine .
  15. "Парковая СЃС'раница Imena.UA". 25 May 2006. Retrieved April 17, 2015.
  16. UNP requests Chernomyrdin to hand over archive documents about the assassination of Petliura Archived 2020-05-10 at the Wayback Machine , Newsru.ua, May 22, 2009
  17. "Convenient" assassination, "Tyzhden.ua", June 15, 2011
  18. Petlyura at ukemonde.com.

Sources

Further reading