Selection limits

Last updated
Results of a hypothetical replicated artificial selection experiment with three treatments. At generation 0, the base population of organisms had been randomly sampled to create six lines, two of which would be selectively bred for high values of the trait, two for low values of the trait, and two of which would not experience any intentional selection. The control lines diverged somewhat by random genetic drift and possibly unique mutations, but, overall, did not change in their average phenotype from the beginning of the experiment. Both of the high-selected lines reached apparent selection limits around generation 20. Both of the low-selected reached absolute limits near zero around generation 25. Selection Limits 1.svg
Results of a hypothetical replicated artificial selection experiment with three treatments. At generation 0, the base population of organisms had been randomly sampled to create six lines, two of which would be selectively bred for high values of the trait, two for low values of the trait, and two of which would not experience any intentional selection. The control lines diverged somewhat by random genetic drift and possibly unique mutations, but, overall, did not change in their average phenotype from the beginning of the experiment. Both of the high-selected lines reached apparent selection limits around generation 20. Both of the low-selected reached absolute limits near zero around generation 25.

A selection limit is a term from animal breeding and quantitative genetics that refers to a cessation of progress even when continued directional selection is being applied to a trait, such as body size. In other words, a breeder or scientist is using selective breeding (artificial selection) and choosing individuals as breeders within a population based on some phenotypic trait or traits. If this is done, then the average value of the population typically evolves across generations in the direction being favored by selection (i.e., for higher or lower values of the trait), but then at some point the population stops evolving. The trait under selection is then said to have reached a limit or plateau at that value.

Contents

Details

The existence of limits in artificial selection experiments was discussed in the scientific literature in the 1940s or earlier. [1] The most obvious possible cause of reaching a limit (or plateau) when a population is under continued directional selection is that all of the additive-genetic variation (see additive genetic effects) related to that trait gets "used up" or fixed. [2] For example, if a trait, such as body mass, is under selection to increase, then, over time (i.e., across generations), the alleles (genetic variants) at all loci (most simply, positions on chromosomes) that tend to make individuals larger than average will increase in frequency, while those that tend to make an individual smaller than average will decrease in frequency. Eventually, in principle, the favored alleles at all relevant loci will become the only ones remaining at those loci. In reality, mutation, random genetic drift (especially in small populations), and gene flow from immigrants may stop some loci from becoming fixed for the "good" alleles.

However, other factors may interfere with the realization of genetic gains before loss of genetic variation causes a selection limit. As noted by Lerner and Dempster, [1] these factors are generally one of two types: 1) negative relations with Darwinian fitness; 2) non-additive gene action and/or genotype-environment interaction (although others are possible [3] [4] [2] [5] ).

A negative relation with Darwinian fitness is a situation in which an allele that is "good" for the trait under directional selection is "bad" with respect to lifetime reproductive success. For example, an allele that tends to confer larger body size might also lead to infertility, thus reducing the ability of individuals with that allele to produce offspring, limiting further response to selection, and sometimes even leading to extinction of the selected line. [6]

Non-additive gene action refers to such situations as heterozygote advantage, where heterozygous individuals have higher (or lower) values for a trait (such as body size) than do either of the two homozygotes. In such a case, selection will tend to maintain more than one allele in the population, and a selection limit may be reached while additive-genetic variation (narrow-sense heritability) remains for the trait under directional selection.

Genotype-environment interaction occurs when the phenotype produced by a particular set of alleles (at one or more loci) confers relatively higher or lower values of a trait depending on the environmental circumstances in which an individual is born or raised, or under which the trait is measured. For instance, somewhat different genes (a term that can refer to alleles or loci) tend to give the highest value of a trait depending on the season. If this occurs, then directional selection will act to favor some genes in winter and others in summer, for example. Again, the result may be that a selection plateau is attained while the population retains some additive-genetic variance for the trait under directional selection.[ citation needed ]

Some traits have a natural physical limit beyond which a trait cannot possibly go. [2] For example, replicated selection for the building of small thermoregulatory nests in mice reached a limit at or near zero (i.e., none of the provided cotton was being used to make nests). [7] Similarly, lines of corn selected for low oil or protein content in the kernels reached limits near to zero percent. [4]

Aside from absolute physical limits, and whatever their cause, limits or plateaus have often been observed in artificial selection experiments with animals, including: bristle number in fruit flies ( Drosophila ); [8] avoidance behavior in laboratory rats; [9] and large body size, [4] large litter size, [10] large nest size, [7] and high voluntary wheel-running behavior in laboratory house mice. [11]

Experiments to identify causes of selection limits

Experimental approaches to probe the causes of selection are of two general types, quantitative genetic and functional. The former asks general questions about the genetic architecture of the trait when a limit has been attained (e.g., has narrow-sense heritability gone to zero?), whereas the latter attempts to determine what aspect of physiological or other function might have reached a limit or constraint. Experimental studies may involve attempts to break an apparent selection limit. As an example of a genetic approach, two replicate lines of mice at a limit for large nest size were crossed and selection was continued on this new population, resulting in further increase in nest size. [12] From a functional perspective, in lines of mice at a selection limit for high wheel running, administration of an erythropoietin analog increased the maximal rate of oxygen consumption during forced exercise, but did not increase wheel running, a result suggesting that motivation for exercise may be limiting the behavior, rather than inherent ability to run on wheels. [13]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heredity</span> Passing of traits to offspring from the species parents or ancestor

Heredity, also called inheritance or biological inheritance, is the passing on of traits from parents to their offspring; either through asexual reproduction or sexual reproduction, the offspring cells or organisms acquire the genetic information of their parents. Through heredity, variations between individuals can accumulate and cause species to evolve by natural selection. The study of heredity in biology is genetics.

Small populations can behave differently from larger populations. They are often the result of population bottlenecks from larger populations, leading to loss of heterozygosity and reduced genetic diversity and loss or fixation of alleles and shifts in allele frequencies. A small population is then more susceptible to demographic and genetic stochastic events, which can impact the long-term survival of the population. Therefore, small populations are often considered at risk of endangerment or extinction, and are often of conservation concern.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heritability</span> Estimation of effect of genetic variation on phenotypic variation of a trait

Heritability is a statistic used in the fields of breeding and genetics that estimates the degree of variation in a phenotypic trait in a population that is due to genetic variation between individuals in that population. The concept of heritability can be expressed in the form of the following question: "What is the proportion of the variation in a given trait within a population that is not explained by the environment or random chance?"

Population genetics is a subfield of genetics that deals with genetic differences within and among populations, and is a part of evolutionary biology. Studies in this branch of biology examine such phenomena as adaptation, speciation, and population structure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Directional selection</span> Type of genetic selection favoring one extreme phenotype

In population genetics, directional selection is a type of natural selection in which one extreme phenotype is favored over both the other extreme and moderate phenotypes. This genetic selection causes the allele frequency to shift toward the chosen extreme over time as allele ratios change from generation to generation. The advantageous extreme allele will increase as a consequence of survival and reproduction differences among the different present phenotypes in the population. The allele fluctuations as a result of directional selection can be independent of the dominance of the allele, and in some cases if the allele is recessive, it can eventually become fixed in the population.

A quantitative trait locus (QTL) is a locus that correlates with variation of a quantitative trait in the phenotype of a population of organisms. QTLs are mapped by identifying which molecular markers correlate with an observed trait. This is often an early step in identifying the actual genes that cause the trait variation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pleiotropy</span> Influence of a single gene on multiple phenotypic traits

Pleiotropy occurs when one gene influences two or more seemingly unrelated phenotypic traits. Such a gene that exhibits multiple phenotypic expression is called a pleiotropic gene. Mutation in a pleiotropic gene may have an effect on several traits simultaneously, due to the gene coding for a product used by a myriad of cells or different targets that have the same signaling function.

A polygene is a member of a group of non-epistatic genes that interact additively to influence a phenotypic trait, thus contributing to multiple-gene inheritance, a type of non-Mendelian inheritance, as opposed to single-gene inheritance, which is the core notion of Mendelian inheritance. The term "monozygous" is usually used to refer to a hypothetical gene as it is often difficult to distinguish the effect of an individual gene from the effects of other genes and the environment on a particular phenotype. Advances in statistical methodology and high throughput sequencing are, however, allowing researchers to locate candidate genes for the trait. In the case that such a gene is identified, it is referred to as a quantitative trait locus (QTL). These genes are generally pleiotropic as well. The genes that contribute to type 2 diabetes are thought to be mostly polygenes. In July 2016, scientists reported identifying a set of 355 genes from the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) of all organisms living on Earth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Threshold model</span> Type of mathematical model

In mathematical or statistical modeling a threshold model is any model where a threshold value, or set of threshold values, is used to distinguish ranges of values where the behaviour predicted by the model varies in some important way. A particularly important instance arises in toxicology, where the model for the effect of a drug may be that there is zero effect for a dose below a critical or threshold value, while an effect of some significance exists above that value. Certain types of regression model may include threshold effects.

Marker assisted selection or marker aided selection (MAS) is an indirect selection process where a trait of interest is selected based on a marker linked to a trait of interest, rather than on the trait itself. This process has been extensively researched and proposed for plant- and animal- breeding.

Sex-limited genes are genes that are present in both sexes of sexually reproducing species but are expressed in only one sex and have no penetrance, or are simply 'turned off' in the other. In other words, sex-limited genes cause the two sexes to show different traits or phenotypes, despite having the same genotype. This term is restricted to autosomal traits, and should not be confused with sex-linked characteristics, which have to do with genetic differences on the sex chromosomes. Sex-limited genes are also distinguished from sex-influenced genes, where the same gene will show differential expression in each sex. Sex-influenced genes commonly show a dominant/recessive relationship, where the same gene will have a dominant effect in one sex and a recessive effect in the other. However, the resulting phenotypes caused by sex-limited genes are present in only one sex and can be seen prominently in various species that typically show high sexual dimorphism.

In multivariate quantitative genetics, a genetic correlation is the proportion of variance that two traits share due to genetic causes, the correlation between the genetic influences on a trait and the genetic influences on a different trait estimating the degree of pleiotropy or causal overlap. A genetic correlation of 0 implies that the genetic effects on one trait are independent of the other, while a correlation of 1 implies that all of the genetic influences on the two traits are identical. The bivariate genetic correlation can be generalized to inferring genetic latent variable factors across > 2 traits using factor analysis. Genetic correlation models were introduced into behavioral genetics in the 1970s–1980s.

Behavioural genetics, also referred to as behaviour genetics, is a field of scientific research that uses genetic methods to investigate the nature and origins of individual differences in behaviour. While the name "behavioural genetics" connotes a focus on genetic influences, the field broadly investigates the extent to which genetic and environmental factors influence individual differences, and the development of research designs that can remove the confounding of genes and environment. Behavioural genetics was founded as a scientific discipline by Francis Galton in the late 19th century, only to be discredited through association with eugenics movements before and during World War II. In the latter half of the 20th century, the field saw renewed prominence with research on inheritance of behaviour and mental illness in humans, as well as research on genetically informative model organisms through selective breeding and crosses. In the late 20th and early 21st centuries, technological advances in molecular genetics made it possible to measure and modify the genome directly. This led to major advances in model organism research and in human studies, leading to new scientific discoveries.

In genetics, association mapping, also known as "linkage disequilibrium mapping", is a method of mapping quantitative trait loci (QTLs) that takes advantage of historic linkage disequilibrium to link phenotypes to genotypes, uncovering genetic associations.

Quantitative trait loci mapping or QTL mapping is the process of identifying genomic regions that potentially contain genes responsible for important economic, health or environmental characters. Mapping QTLs is an important activity that plant breeders and geneticists routinely use to associate potential causal genes with phenotypes of interest. Family-based QTL mapping is a variant of QTL mapping where multiple-families are used.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Genetic variance</span> Biological concept

Genetic variance is a concept outlined by the English biologist and statistician Ronald Fisher in his fundamental theorem of natural selection. In his 1930 book The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection, Fisher postulates that the rate of change of biological fitness can be calculated by the genetic variance of the fitness itself. Fisher tried to give a statistical formula about how the change of fitness in a population can be attributed to changes in the allele frequency. Fisher made no restrictive assumptions in his formula concerning fitness parameters, mate choices or the number of alleles and loci involved.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Epistasis</span> Dependence of a gene mutations phenotype on mutations in other genes

Epistasis is a phenomenon in genetics in which the effect of a gene mutation is dependent on the presence or absence of mutations in one or more other genes, respectively termed modifier genes. In other words, the effect of the mutation is dependent on the genetic background in which it appears. Epistatic mutations therefore have different effects on their own than when they occur together. Originally, the term epistasis specifically meant that the effect of a gene variant is masked by that of different gene.

Polygenic adaptation describes a process in which a population adapts through small changes in allele frequencies at hundreds or thousands of loci.

This glossary of genetics and evolutionary biology is a list of definitions of terms and concepts used in the study of genetics and evolutionary biology, as well as sub-disciplines and related fields, with an emphasis on classical genetics, quantitative genetics, population biology, phylogenetics, speciation, and systematics. Overlapping and related terms can be found in Glossary of cellular and molecular biology, Glossary of ecology, and Glossary of biology.

The infinitesimal model, also known as the polygenic model, is a widely used statistical model in quantitative genetics and in genome-wide association studies. Originally developed in 1918 by Ronald Fisher, it is based on the idea that variation in a quantitative trait is influenced by an infinitely large number of genes, each of which makes an infinitely small (infinitesimal) contribution to the phenotype, as well as by environmental factors. In "The Correlation between Relatives on the Supposition of Mendelian Inheritance", the original 1918 paper introducing the model, Fisher showed that if a trait is polygenic, "then the random sampling of alleles at each gene produces a continuous, normally distributed phenotype in the population". However, the model does not necessarily imply that the trait must be normally distributed, only that its genetic component will be so around the average of that of the individual's parents. The model served to reconcile Mendelian genetics with the continuous distribution of quantitative traits documented by Francis Galton.

References

  1. 1 2 Lerner, I. M.; E. R. Dempster (1951). "Attenuation of genetic progress under continued selection in poultry". Heredity. 275 (1): 75–94.
  2. 1 2 3 Falconer, D. S.; T. F. C. Mackay (1996). Introduction to quantitative genetics. 4th edition. Harlow, Essex, England: Pearson Education Limited.
  3. ↑ Al-Murrani, W. K. (1974). "The limits to artificial selection". Animal Breeding Abstracts. 42: 587–592.
  4. 1 2 3 Falconer, D. S. (1992). "Early selection experiments". Annual Review of Genetics. 26: 1–14.
  5. ↑ Hill, W. G.; M. Kirkpatrick (2010). "What animal breeding has taught us about evolution". Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics. 41: 1–19.
  6. ↑ Mather, K.; Harrison, B. J. (1949). "The manifold effect of selection. Part I". Heredity. 3: 1–52.
  7. 1 2 Lynch, C. B. (1994). "Evolutionary inferences from genetic analyses of cold adaptation in laboratory and wild populations of the house mouse". In Boake, C. R. B. (ed.). Quantitative genetic studies of behavioral evolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. pp. 278–301.
  8. ↑ Mather, K. (1941). "Variation and selection of polygenic characters". Journal of Genetics. 41: 159–193.
  9. ↑ Brush, F. R.; J.C. Froehlich; P.C. Sakellaris (1979). "Genetic selection for avoidance behavior in the rat". Behavior Genetics. 9: 309–316.
  10. ↑ Eklund, J.; G. E. Bradford (1977). "Genetic analysis of a strain of mice plateaued for litter size". Genetics. 85: 529–542.
  11. ↑ Careau, V. C.; M. E. Wolak; P. A. Carter; T. Garland, Jr. (2013). "Limits to behavioral evolution: the quantitative genetics of a complex trait under directional selection". Evolution. 67: 3102–3119.
  12. ↑ Bult, A.; C. B. Lynch (2000). "Breaking through artificial selection limits of an adaptive behavior in mice and the consequences for correlated responses". Behavior Genetics. 30: 193–206.
  13. ↑ Kolb, E. M.; S. A. Kelly; K. M. Middleton; L. S. Sermsakdi; M. A. Chappell; and T. Garland, Jr. (2010). "Erythropoietin elevates VO2,max but not voluntary wheel running in mice". Journal of Experimental Biology. 213: 510–519.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.