Sugar house prisons in New York City

Last updated
The Livingston sugar house (left) on Liberty Street in Manhattan once detained 400 to 500 American prisoners of the Revolutionary War. The old Sugar House & Middle Dutch Church, Liberty St. N.Y. in 1830 by George Hayward in 1858..jpg
The Livingston sugar house (left) on Liberty Street in Manhattan once detained 400 to 500 American prisoners of the Revolutionary War.

Sugar houses in New York City were used as prisons by occupying British forces during the American Revolutionary War. Out of 2,600 prisoners of war captured during the Battle of Fort Washington in November 1776, 1,900 would die in the following months at makeshift prisons throughout the city. [1] At least 17,500 are estimated to have perished under substandard conditions of such sugar houses and British prison ships over the course of the war, more than double the number of killed from battle. [2]

Contents

Background

During the 18th century, a large part of commerce in New York City was trade with the British West Indies. Destined for refineries, sugar and molasses imported from Jamaica and Sint Eustatius were stored in warehouses built by merchant families, such as the Bayards, Cuylers, Livingstons, Rhinelanders, Roosevelts, and the Van Cortlands. [3] [4] Three of these large structures were known for being used by the British Army to house prisoners of war during their occupation of New York City in the midst of the American Revolution. [1] [4]

Prisons

Livingston's sugar house

USA New York City location map.svg
Red pog.svg
Van Cortlandt
Red pog.svg
Livingston
Red pog.svg
Rhinelander
Red pog.svg
Van Cortlandt Park (Sugar house window)
Sugar house locations in New York City.

The sugar house on Crown (now Liberty) Street in Manhattan was a six-story stone building which had been built in 1754 by the Livingston family as a refinery with very low floors. [3] [5] According to Revolutionary War veteran Levi Hanford, who was captured in March 1777, the cramped conditions initially housed about 40 to 50 prisoners. The population soon swelled to between 400 and 500, though attrition was constant due to those succumbing to illness. Rations consisted of pork and sea biscuits, which were often moldy from sea water and infested with worms. Nevertheless, the starving prisoners seldom refused the food, which was made consumable by placing it in a kettle of water and skimming off the parasites. Supplies for sick prisoners were provided by the fledgling American government, as Hanford stated that "the British furnished nothing." [5] Deceased prisoners were sewn up into their blankets and placed in a corner of the yard for pickup by a dead cart in the morning; as many as fifteen bodies once accumulated in the period of one day. Prisoner exchanges were organized with the prisoners held longest having priority. [5] The structure was later demolished in 1846. [4]

In the northeast corner of Trinity Churchyard in Lower Manhattan stands the Soldiers' Monument, with an inscription reading: "At a meeting of Citizens held at the City Hall of the City of New York June 8, 1852: It was resolved That the Erection of a becoming Monument with appropriate inscriptions by Trinity Church to the Memory of those great and good Men who died whilst in Captivity in the old [Livingston] Sugar House and were interred in Trinity Church Yard in this City will be an act gratifying not only to the attendants of this Meeting but to Every American Citizen." [6] The claim those prisoners are buried in Trinity Churchyard is disputed by Charles I. Bushnell, who argued in 1863 that Trinity Church would not have accepted the burials because it was a Church of England parish, the state church headed by the British monarch they rebelled against. [7] Historian Edwin G. Burrows explains how the controversy related to a proposal to build a public street through the churchyard. [8] :228–30

Rhinelander's sugar house

Rhinelander's sugar house & residence, between William & Rose Streets. The last of the sugar house prisons of the Revolution Manual of the corporation of the city of New York (1857) (14763739955).jpg
Rhinelander's sugar house & residence, between William & Rose Streets. The last of the sugar house prisons of the Revolution

The sugar house on the corner of Rose (now William) Street and Duane Street in Lower Manhattan was a five-story brick warehouse. Built in 1763 by William Rhinelander, the structure originally stored molasses and sugar next to his own residence. [9] During the Revolutionary War it is believed to have been used by the British army as a prison. [10] In 1852 Benson J. Lossing wrote:

Van Cortlandt's sugar house, which stood at the northwest corner of Trinity Churchyard, corner of Thames and Lumber [now Trinity Place] Streets; Rhinelander's, on the corner of William and Duane Streets, now (1852) Lightbody's Printing-ink Manufactory; and the more emininently historical one on Liberty Street (numbers 34 and 36), a few feet eastward of the Middle Dutch Church, now the Post-office, were the most spacious buildings in the city and answered the purposes of prisons very well. Rhinelander's is the only one remaining, the one on Liberty Street having been demolished in June, 1840, and Van Cortlandt's during the summer of 1852. [11]

But Brooklyn history professor Edwin G. Burrows disagrees, writing in 2008: "Demolition of the Rhinelander Sugar House in 1892 gave rise to stories—completely unsubstantiated—that it had served as a prison during the Revolution." [8] :323#42 When the building fell into disrepair during the early 19th century, locals believed it to be haunted by ghosts of prisoners from the war. The old warehouse was replaced by the Rhinelander Building, which retained part of the original wall from 1892 to 1968, and continued to receive reports of ghostly sightings in a window. The site is now occupied by the headquarters of the New York City Police Department, near which one of the original barred windows was retained. A section of wall with another window was moved to Van Cortlandt Park in the Bronx. [9]

Van Cortlandt's sugar house

Van Cortlandt's sugar house Van Cortlandt's sugar house (NYPL Hades-255900-430920).jpg
Van Cortlandt's sugar house

The sugar house on the northwest corner of the yard of Trinity Church in Manhattan was built by John Van Cortlandt and partner George Petterson around 1755; Van Cortlandt took sole proprietorship after their partnership was dissolved two years later. [12] Used as a prison during the Revolutionary War, the building was torn down in 1852. [4]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clement Clarke Moore</span> American writer and professor (1779–1863)

Clement Clarke Moore was an American writer, scholar and real estate developer. He is best known as author of the Christmas poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas", which first named each of Santa Claus's reindeer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stephanus Van Cortlandt</span> American politician

Stephanus van Cortlandt was the first native-born mayor of New York City, a position which he held from 1677 to 1678 and from 1686 to 1688. He was the patroon of Van Cortlandt Manor and was on the governor's executive council from 1691 to 1700. He was the first resident of Sagtikos Manor in West Bay Shore on Long Island, which was built around 1697. A number of his descendants married English military leaders and Loyalists active in the American Revolution, and their descendants became prominent members of English society.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prisoners of war in the American Revolutionary War</span>

During the American Revolutionary War (1775–1783), management and treatment of prisoners of war (POWs) were very different from the standards of modern warfare. Modern standards, as outlined in the Geneva Conventions of later centuries, assume that captives will be held and cared for by their captors. One primary difference in the 18th century was that care and supplies for captives were expected to be provided by their own combatants or private resources.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Watts (New York politician)</span> American politician

John Watts Jr. was an American lawyer and politician from New York City who represented New York in the U.S. House of Representatives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trinity Church Cemetery</span> Cemeteries in Manhattan, New York

The parish of Trinity Church has three separate burial grounds associated with it in the New York City borough of Manhattan. The first, Trinity Churchyard, is located in Lower Manhattan at 74 Trinity Place, near Wall Street and Broadway. Alexander Hamilton and his wife Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton, Albert Gallatin, and Robert Fulton are buried in the downtown Trinity Churchyard.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Duane</span> American Founding Father and judge

James Duane was an American Founding Father, attorney, jurist, and American Revolutionary leader from New York. He served as a delegate to the First Continental Congress, the Second Continental Congress and the Congress of the Confederation, a New York state senator, the 44th Mayor of New York City, the 1st post-colonial Mayor of New York City and a United States district judge of the United States District Court for the District of New York. Duane was a signatory of the Continental Association and the Articles of Confederation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Van Cortlandt House</span> Historic house in the Bronx, New York

The Van Cortlandt House, also known as the Van Cortlandt Mansion, is the oldest known surviving house in the Bronx in New York City. It is located in the southwestern portion of Van Cortlandt Park. The house is operated as a historic house museum known as the Van Cortlandt House Museum. Built by Frederick Van Cortlandt and completed in 1749, the house is a 2+12-story Georgian building with a rubblestone facade and Georgian-style interiors. It served as a residence of one branch of the Van Cortlandt family for 140 years before it reopened as a museum in 1897.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre Van Cortlandt</span> American politician

Pierre Van Cortlandt was an American politician who served as the first lieutenant governor of New York.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philip Van Cortlandt</span> American politician 1749–1831

Philip Van Cortlandt was an American surveyor, landowner, and politician from Westchester County, New York. Van Cortlandt was the son of Pierre Van Cortlandt and brother of Pierre Van Cortlandt, Jr. He was a Continental Army officer during the American Revolution, and later served several terms in the United States House of Representatives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prison Ship Martyrs' Monument</span> Monument in Brooklyn, New York, U.S.

The Prison Ship Martyrs' Monument is a war memorial at Fort Greene Park, in the New York City borough of Brooklyn. It commemorates more than 11,500 American prisoners of war who died in captivity aboard sixteen British prison ships during the American Revolutionary War. The remains of a small fraction of those who died on the ships are interred in a crypt beneath its base. The ships included HMS Jersey, Scorpion, Hope, Falmouth, Stromboli, Hunter, and others.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">St. Paul's Chapel</span> United States historic place

St. Paul's Chapel is a chapel building of Trinity Church, an episcopal parish, located at 209 Broadway, between Fulton Street and Vesey Street, in Lower Manhattan, New York City. Built in 1766, it is the oldest surviving church building in Manhattan, and one of the nation's finest examples of Late Georgian church architecture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Schuyler family</span> Dutch-American family

The Schuyler family was a prominent Dutch family in New York and New Jersey in the 18th and 19th centuries, whose descendants played a critical role in the formation of the United States, in leading government and business in North America and served as leaders in business, military, politics, and society. The other two most influential New York dynasties of the 18th and 19th centuries were the Livingston family and the Clinton family.

David Mathews was an American born British lawyer and politician from New York City. He was a Loyalist during the American Revolutionary War and was the 43rd and last Colonial Mayor of New York City from 1776 until 1783. As New York City was the center of British control of the Colonies during the war, he was one of the highest ranking civilian authorities in the Colonies during this period. He was accused of supporting a plan led by Thomas Hickey to kill the Revolutionary General George Washington. He resettled in Nova Scotia after the war, and became a leading political figure in the Cape Breton colony that was created in 1786.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cortlandt Street (Manhattan)</span> Street in Manhattan, New York

Cortlandt Street is a west-east street in the Financial District of Lower Manhattan, New York City. It runs one block from Broadway to Church Street, then continues an additional block as the non-vehicular Cortlandt Way from Church to Greenwich Street. At its eastern end, the street continues as Maiden Lane.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">T. J. Oakley Rhinelander</span>

Thomas Jackson Oakley Rhinelander was an American heir and real estate magnate who was prominent in New York Society during the Gilded Age.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trinity and United States Realty Buildings</span> Buildings in Manhattan, New York

The Trinity Building, designed by Francis H. Kimball and built in 1905, with an addition of 1907, and Kimball's United States Realty Building of 1907, located respectively at 111 and 115 Broadway in Manhattan's Financial District, are among the first Gothic-inspired skyscrapers in New York, and both are New York City designated landmarks. The Trinity Building, adjacent to the churchyard of Richard Upjohn's neo-Gothic Trinity Church, replaced an 1853 Upjohn structure of the same name. Earlier, the Van Cortlandt sugar house stood on the west end of the plot – a notorious British prison where American soldiers were held during the Revolutionary War.

Henry Beekman was a prominent colonial American politician and landowner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peter Stuyvesant (merchant)</span> New York landowner and merchant (1727–1805)

Petrus "Peter" Stuyvesant was a New York landowner and merchant who was a great-grandson of his namesake, Peter Stuyvesant, the last Dutch Director-General of New Amsterdam.

Lt.-Col. Hubertus "Gilbert" Livingston was a younger son of Robert Livingston the Elder who was a lawyer and politician in colonial New York.

References

  1. 1 2 Dandridge, Danske (1911). "The Prisons of New York—Jonathan Gillett". American Prisoners of the Revolution. Charlottesville, VA: The Michie Company, Printers. p. 25f.
  2. Reese, Jimmie (September 17, 2009). "The Sugar House As A Prison During The Revolutionary War". Knickerbocker Village. Retrieved February 12, 2011.
  3. 1 2 Wilson, James Grant (1892). "The Memorial History of the City of New-York: From Its First Settlement to the Year 1892". Vol. 2. New York History Company. p. 454. Retrieved February 11, 2011.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Wilson, James Grant (1893). "The Memorial History of the City of New-York: From Its First Settlement to the Year 1892". Vol. 3. New York History Company. p. 301. Retrieved February 11, 2011.
  5. 1 2 3 Hanford, William H. (January 15, 1852). "Incidents of the Revolution: Recollections of the Old Sugar House Prison" (PDF). The New York Times . Retrieved February 11, 2011.
  6. Chi, Sheena (December 15, 2008). "Trinity Church—Soldiers' Monument—Memorial for Unknown Revolutionary War Heroes". Archived from the original on December 16, 2019. Retrieved December 16, 2019. This inscription is on the south side. An inscription on the north side is more general: "Sacred to the memory of those brave and good Men who died whilst imprisoned in this City for their devotion to the cause of American independence." (Burrows, cited elsewhere, p. 230 (caption); photos at "Revolutionary War Soldiers Monument". Find A Grave. Retrieved January 12, 2020.)
  7. Bushnell, Charles I. (1863). A Narrative of the Life and Adventures of Levi Hanford, a Soldier of the Revolution. New York: [privately printed]. pp. 66–70 (note 27). This note was also published separately as a pamphlet with its own title: Bushnell, Charles Ira (1863). The Claim of Trinity Church to Having Furnished Burial Places For Some of the American Prisoners, Who Died in the Old Sugar House Prison, in Liberty Street, During the Revolution, Examined and Refuted. New York: [privately published].
  8. 1 2 Burrows, Edwin G. (2008). Forgotten Patriots. New York: Basic Books. ISBN   978-0-465-00835-3. OCLC   191926052.
  9. 1 2 Lidian (March 19, 2010). "The Rhinelander Sugar House". The Virtual Dime Museum: Adventures in Old New York. Archived from the original on July 5, 2012. Retrieved January 6, 2020.
  10. Black, Mary (24 July 2013). Old New York in Early Photographs. Dover Publications. p. 56. ISBN   978-0-486-31743-4.
  11. Lossing, Benson J. (1852). The Pictorial Field-book of the Revolution. Vol. II. New York: Harper & Brothers. p.  865.
  12. De Forest, Louis Effingham (1930). "The New Jersey Branch". The Van Cortlandt family. The Historical Pub. Society. Retrieved February 11, 2011.

Further reading