Symphysiotomy controversy in Ireland

Last updated

From approximately 2000, there was a controversy over the use of symphysiotomies during childbirth in the Republic of Ireland between 1944 and 1987. In 2002 an advocacy group called Survivors of Symphysiotomy (SoS) was set up in Ireland alleging religiously motivated symphysiotomies were performed without consent and against best medical practice in Republic of Ireland between 1944 and 1987. [1] [2] In 2014 Ireland agreed to pay women who received the procedure compensation without admitting liability. [3] Some media reported that pubiotomy was also practised, [4] but only one payout was given in 2014 for an "accidental" pubiotomy that occurred in the 1950s. [5]

History

It is estimated that 1,500 women unknowingly and without consent underwent symphysiotomies during childbirth in the Republic of Ireland between 1944 and 1987. [6] A 2012 report found that many of the victims say the Catholic Church "encouraged, if not insisted upon, symphysiotomies." [7] It has been suggested that during that period, non-Catholic doctors recommended sterilisation of women after three caesarean section operations, while Catholic doctors usually recommended "compassionate hysterectomies" as a solution to the prohibition on sterilisations. [8] Despite legal restrictions being placed on the use of artificial contraceptives, the average size of families in Ireland declined from the 1930s. [9] [10] [11]

Dr. Alex Spain was master of the National Maternity Hospital during the mid-20th century, and performed 43 symphysiotomies during his tenure. Spain's successor, Arthur Barry, was also a strong supporter of Catholicism and the practice of symphysiotomy. [12]

In 2002, survivor Matilda Behan and her daughter, Bernadette, set up an advocacy group for the victims called Survivors of Symphysiotomy (SoS). [13] Matilda was operated upon at NMH 17 days before her baby was born. She thought she was being brought to theatre for a caesarean section. No one told her the plan was to do the 'new procedure,' a pubiotomy. [14] In 2008, the Irish Human Rights Commission recommended that the Government should reconsider its decision not to set up an independent inquiry into symphysiotomy. The Minister for Health refused. [15]

On 18 February 2010, an RTÉ Prime Time documentary revealed that, over half a century, some 1,500 women had symphysiotomies performed on them during childbirth by doctors in order to train medical personnel and perfect the surgery for Africa. Following the programme, victims of the procedure called on the Minister for Health, Mary Harney, to initiate an independent inquiry. Instead, she commissioned the IOG, a training body, to inquire into itself by reviewing operations carried out by some of its own members for teaching purposes. [16] [17]

A Dáil debate on the issue was heard on 15 March 2012, which was organised by Deputy Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin. Leading the debate in the Dáil, Ó Caoláin compared symphysiotomy to clerical abuse: "The infliction of symphysiotomy on women in Ireland is one of the greatest medical scandals not only here but on an international scale. Symphysiotomy is a clinical scandal on a par with the clerical scandals we have seen exposed in the past two decades." [18] Gerry Adams described the procedure as "institutional abuse involving acts of butchery against women." [19] While Clare Daly declared that "it is an important acknowledgment by the State of the crimes committed against many of the women present today, crimes which led to the suffering endured by them and their families for decades". [18]

Eight days later, on 23 March 2012, a County Louth woman, Olivia Kearney, who was subjected to a post caesarean-section symphysiotomy, which was performed by Dr. Gerard Connolly, was awarded €450,000 by the High Court. [20] The Kearney case was appealed to the Irish Supreme Court, which found in favour of Ms. Kearney and declared that symphysiotomy was not a generally approved obstetric practice in 1969. While the Supreme Court reduced the award of damages from €450,000 to €325,000, the decision represented the first court condemnation of the practice of symphysiotomy by an institution of the Irish state. [21]

In June 2012 details of Professor Oonagh Walsh's draft report on the use of this procedure in Ireland were released. The report by Prof. Walsh (UCC) found that although symphysiostomies were phased out in most medical institutions across the country, Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital was practising the procedure until the 1980s, a fact linked to the "unswervingly Catholic ethos" of the hospital. [22] The draft Walsh report nevertheless found that symphysiotomy was justifiable and sought to consult with survivors on its findings. [23]

The draft Walsh report was criticised by victims' advocate group Survivors of Symphysiotomy, and by a number of opposition TDs and journalists, for failing to adequately address issues such as patient consent, and for perceivably justifying the performance of the operation. Survivors of Symphysiotomy members subsequently decided to boycott the second stage of the Walsh report. [24] [25]

Also in June 2012, Survivors of Symphysiotomy testified publicly before the Joint Oireachtas (Select) Committee on Justice. Catherine McKeever, a private patient at the Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda in 1969, told the Committee that she did not realise what had happened: 'I saw him [the doctor] with an instrument which I thought was a bit brace because my father was a wood turner. I felt a crack ... Nobody answered me or said anything'. Margaret Conlan, who was operated upon in 1962 in St Finbarr's Hospital, Cork, testified that she had never been told anything about it: 'My baby's head was perforated and the baby died... I did not find out [about the symphysiotomy] until I read it in the newspaper'. [26]

Ó Caoláin introduced the Statute of Limitations (Amendment) Bill, which was unanimously supported by Dáil on 17 April 2013. [27] The proposed legislation sought to lift the statute of limitations for a period of one year, to enable all survivors of symphysiotomy to bring their cases through the Irish courts. By July 2013, the Bill had stalled before the Joint Oireachtas (Select) Committee on Justice, leading SoS to protest outside the Parliament on 26 June. [28]

In November 2013, Minister for Health James Reilly announced that Judge Yvonne Murphy had been appointed to review the findings of the Walsh report, to meet with survivors of symphysiotomy, hospital authorities, and insurers with a view to deciding on whether an ex gratia redress scheme would be preferred to allowing legal actions to proceed. The terms of reference for the Murphy inquiry were criticised by Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin, who stated that the "type of scheme outlined in the terms of reference offers the women no prospect of adequate compensation for what was so barbarically done to them nor the choice to pursue their rights in the courts". [29] It also emerged that the Government would no longer support the statute of limitations bill, which had been unanimously adopted by the Dáil in April 2013. [30] SoS rejected the Government's statement and described their plans as 'paternalistic'. [31]

In March 2014, Survivors of Symphysiotomy made a complaint to the United Nations Committee Against Torture about the Irish State's failure to properly, thoroughly or impartially investigate the practice of symphysiotomy in Ireland. [32] [33] [34] In July, the United Nations committee on human rights called for the Irish government to hold an investigation into the issue. [4] [35] In 2014 an investigation was established under Judge Harding Clark to allow the Ex-gratia Payment. In October 2016, this body published their report establishing that this procedure was used only rarely, and in very difficult labours. She found no evidence to support the claim that a symphysiotomy caused lifelong disability or suffering. Nevertheless, women who had the procedure were awarded compensation. The report found that at least one third of women claiming to have suffered from having the procedure never had symphysiotomies. Although these claimants were denied compensation, others with weak evidence received pay-outs. Judge Harding Clark stated 'I believe that early uncritical reliance on medical reports led me to make awards where it is highly probable that no symphysiotomy was performed.' [36] Commenting on the Harding Clark report, Nil Muižnieks on behalf of the Council for Europe stated that he was ‘particularly struck by the patronising tone’ of the report and that it did not ‘give acknowledgement to women’s suffering and seems to perpetuate some gender stereotypes against (elderly) women.’ [37]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin</span> Irish former Sinn Féin politician (b. 1953)

Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin is an Irish former Sinn Féin politician who served as a Teachta Dála (TD) for the Cavan–Monaghan constituency from 1997 to 2020. Ó Caoláin's victory in 1997 made him the first member of Sinn Féin to be elected to the Dáil since 1957, and the first to actually take their seat since 1922. His election, which paralleled the signing of the Good Friday Agreement in 1998, is cited as the beginning of Sinn Féin's involvement in the formal national politics of the Republic of Ireland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Denis O'Brien</span> Irish billionaire businessman

Denis O'Brien is an Irish billionaire businessman, and the founder and owner of Digicel. He was listed among the World's Top 200 Billionaires in 2015 and was Ireland's richest native-born citizen for several years. His business interests have also extended to aircraft leasing, utilities support (Actavo), petroleum, football, and healthcare. As former chairman of the Esat Digifone consortium, O'Brien was questioned by the Moriarty Tribunal, which investigated the awarding of a mobile phone licence to Esat, among other things.

Michael Neary is a former Irish consultant obstetrician/gynaecologist who carried out unnecessary surgical removal of the wombs of 129 women, many immediately following delivery of a baby. This happened while he worked at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda, County Louth. He was placed on administrative leave in 1998 and suspended by the Irish Medical Council in 1999 pending investigation. In 2003 he was found guilty of professional misconduct by the Irish Medical Council and struck off the Irish Register of Medical Practitioners.

The Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (CICA) was one of a range of measures introduced by the Irish Government to investigate the extent and effects of abuse on children from 1936 onwards. Commencing its work in 1999, it was commonly known in Ireland as the Laffoy Commission after its chair, Justice Mary Laffoy. Laffoy resigned as chair in 2003 and was succeeded by Justice Sean Ryan, with the commission becoming known as the Ryan Commission. It published its final public report, commonly referred to as the Ryan report, in 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Iona Institute</span> Irish conservative Catholic organisation

Lolek CLG, operating under the business name the Iona Institute, is an Irish, socially conservative organisation that advocates the advancement and promotion of the Christian religion and its social and moral values. It has been frequently described as a Catholic pressure group. Founded by columnist David Quinn, it was launched publicly in 2007.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rónán Mullen</span> Irish politician (born 1970)

Rónán Thomas Mullen is an Irish senator and former delegate to the Council of Europe. He is the leader of the Human Dignity Alliance, an anti-abortion political party formed in 2018. He was elected by the National University Seanad constituency in July 2007 and re-elected in 2011, 2016 and 2020. He has topped the poll in every NUI Seanad election since 2011. Mullen is a frequent media commentator on social and political topics. The first National University of Ireland senator appointed to the Council of Europe, he received international coverage for his role in defeating the controversial McCafferty Report which sought to limit the right to conscientious objection for medical staff in the case of abortions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Symphysiotomy</span> Surgical procedure to widen the pelvis

Symphysiotomy is a surgical procedure in which the cartilage of the pubic symphysis is divided to widen the pelvis allowing childbirth when there is a mechanical problem. It is also known as pelviotomy and synchondrotomy. It has largely been supplanted by C-sections, with the exception of certain rare obstetric emergencies or in resource poor settings. It is different than pubiotomy, where the pelvic bone itself is cut in two places, rather than cutting though the symphysis pubis joint.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Reilly (Irish politician)</span> Irish former politician (born 1955)

James Reilly is an Irish former Fine Gael politician, businessman and medical doctor who served as a Senator from May 2016 to March 2020. He previously served as Acting Minister for Children and Youth Affairs from February to May 2016, Minister for Health from March 2011 to July 2014 and deputy leader of Fine Gael from 2010 to 2017. He was a Teachta Dála (TD) for the Dublin North constituency from 2007 to 2016. He subsequently announced his retirement from politics after he lost his bid for election for his old seat at the 2020 general election.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda</span> Hospital in County Louth, Ireland

Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital is a public hospital located in Drogheda, County Louth, Ireland. It is managed by RCSI Hospitals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2016 Irish general election</span> Election to the 32nd Dáil

The 2016 Irish general election to the 32nd Dáil was held on Friday 26 February, following the dissolution of the 31st Dáil by President Michael D. Higgins on 3 February, at the request of Taoiseach Enda Kenny. The general election took place in 40 Dáil constituencies throughout Ireland to elect to elect 158 Teachtaí Dála to Dáil Éireann, the house of representatives of the Oireachtas. There was a reduction of eight seats under the Electoral (Amendment) Act 2013.

The 31st Dáil was elected at the 2011 general election on 25 February 2011 and first met at midday on 9 March 2011 in Leinster House. The members of Dáil Éireann, the house of representatives of the Oireachtas (legislature) of Ireland, are known as TDs. It sat with the 24th Seanad as the two Houses of the Oireachtas.

The Convention on the Constitution was established in Ireland in 2012 to discuss proposed amendments to the Constitution of Ireland. More commonly called simply the Constitutional Convention, it met for the first time 1 December 2012 and sat until 31 March 2014. It had 100 members: a chairman; 29 members of the Oireachtas (parliament); four representatives of Northern Ireland political parties; and 66 randomly selected citizens of Ireland.

Dublin Bay North is a parliamentary constituency that has been represented in Dáil Éireann, the lower house of the Irish parliament or Oireachtas, since the 2016 general election. The constituency elects 5 deputies. The method of election is proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote (PR-STV).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Death of Savita Halappanavar</span> Woman who died from sepsis from being denied an abortion in Ireland

Savita Halappanavar was a dentist of Indian origin, living in Ireland, who died from sepsis after her request for an abortion after a prolonged miscarriage was denied on legal grounds. In the wake of a nationwide outcry over her death, Irish voters passed in a landslide the Thirty-Sixth Amendment of the Constitution, which repealed the Eighth Amendment and empowered the Oireachtas parliament to make abortion legal. It did so through the Health Act of 20 December 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Maternity Hospital, Dublin</span> Hospital in Dublin, Ireland

The National Maternity Hospital, popularly known as Holles Street Hospital, is a large maternity hospital in Ireland. It is at the eastern corner of Merrion Square, at its junction with Holles Street and Lower Mount Street in Dublin. It is managed by Ireland East Hospital Group.

The Protection of Life During Pregnancy Act 2013 was an Act of the Oireachtas which, until 2018, defined the circumstances and processes within which abortion in Ireland could be legally performed. The act gave effect in statutory law to the terms of the Constitution as interpreted by the Supreme Court in the 1992 judgment in the X Case. That judgment allowed for abortion where pregnancy endangers a woman's life, including through a risk of suicide. The provisions relating to suicide had been the most contentious part of the bill. Having passed both Houses of the Oireachtas in July 2013, it was signed into law on 30 July by Michael D. Higgins, the President of Ireland, and commenced on 1 January 2014. The 2013 Act was repealed by the Health Act 2018, which commenced on 1 January 2019.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mother and Baby Homes Commission of Investigation</span> 2021 Irish government investigation

The Mother and Baby Homes Commission of Investigation was a judicial commission of investigation, established in 2015 by the Irish government to investigate deaths and misconduct during the 20th century in mother and baby homes—institutions, most run by Catholic religious nuns, where unwed women were sent to deliver their babies. It was set up following statements that the bodies of up to 800 babies and children may have been interred in an unmarked mass grave in the Bon Secours Mother and Baby Home, located in Tuam, County Galway. Its remit additionally covered investigation into the records of and the practices at an additional thirteen Mother and Baby Homes. The members of the three-person Commission were Judge Yvonne Murphy (chairperson), Dr William Duncan and Professor Mary E. Daly.

Events during the year 2018 in Ireland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thirty-sixth Amendment of the Constitution of Ireland</span> 2018 amendment liberalising abortion laws

The Thirty-sixth Amendment of the Constitution of Ireland is an amendment to the Constitution of Ireland which permits the Oireachtas to legislate for abortion. The constitution had previously prohibited abortion, unless there was a serious risk to the life of the mother.

In 1994, the Irish Blood Transfusion Service Board (BTSB) informed the Minister for Health that a blood product they had distributed in 1977 for the treatment of pregnant mothers had been contaminated with the hepatitis C virus. Following a report by an expert group, it was discovered that the BTSB had produced and distributed a second infected batch in 1991. The Government established a Tribunal of Inquiry to establish the facts of the case and also agreed to establish a tribunal for the compensation of victims but seemed to frustrate and delay the applications of these, in some cases terminally, ill women.

References

  1. ↑ "SOS Ireland - survivors of symphysiotomy". Survivors of Symphysiotomy ireland. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  2. ↑ "Draft Report on Symphysiotomy in Ireland 1944 - 1987, Dr Oonagh Walsh"
  3. ↑ "Symphysiotomy compensation agreed in Republic of Ireland". BBC News. 2014-07-01. Retrieved 2024-08-10.
  4. 1 2 Homa Khaleeli (13 Dec 2014). "Symphysiotomy – Ireland's brutal alternative to caesareans". The Guardian.
  5. ↑ https://assets.gov.ie/43053/b58b223e633b4123abec37475ebdbe1e.pdf
  6. ↑ "Draft Report on Symphysiotomy in Ireland 1944 - 1987, Dr Oonagh Walsh"
  7. ↑ Jillson, Irene A. "Symphysiotomy in Ireland: A Qualitative Study" (PDF). School of Nursing & Health Studies.
  8. ↑ "The Lourdes Hospital Inquiry" (PDF). January 2006. p. 236.
  9. ↑ "'The murder of infants'? Symphysiotomy in Ireland, 1944–66". HistoryIreland.com. October 2012. In Ireland at that time so-called 'artificial' contraception was illegal, and sterilisation was unobtainable.
  10. ↑ O'Carrol, Sinead (24 November 2012). "A history of symphysiotomy: the impact of Catholic ethics on Irish medicine". The Journal.ie. Symphysiotomy was thought to permanently enlarge the pelvis, and therefore, when carried out in a first pregnancy, it might remove the necessity for a woman with 'disproportion' to face repeated CS in future pregnancies. This was a particular problem for Catholic doctors. Contraception was practised in most developed countries, making repeat problem pregnancies less common, and non-Catholic doctors advised sterilisation after three CS. Irish Catholic doctors were unwilling to do this. They were aware of criticism by colleagues who believed that Catholic religious structures disadvantaged patients.
  11. ↑ Daly, Mary E. (2006). The Slow Failure Population Decline, An Independent 1920-1963. These findings confirm earlier research by Ó Gráda which established by 1911 many Irish couples, even in rural areas were practicing some form of family planning.
  12. ↑ "Symphysiotomy in the National Maternity Hospital and Coombe". History Ireland. 2013-03-06. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  13. ↑ "SOS Ireland - survivors of symphysiotomy". Survivors of Symphysiotomy ireland. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  14. ↑ O'Brien, Carl (Nov 27, 2013). "'I'll never forget the pain. It was excruciating'". The Irish Times. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  15. ↑ "Written Answers". Oireachtas Debates. 679. Dáil Éireann. 31 March 2009. Archived from the original on 2014-01-07. Retrieved 2014-01-07.
  16. ↑ "Symphysiotomy inquiry ruled out". RTÉ. 2010-02-19. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  17. ↑ "Harney requests symphysiotomy report". RTÉ. 2010-02-23. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  18. 1 2 "Symphysiotomy: Statements". Dáil Éireann Debate. 758 (6). Oireachtas. 15 March 2012. Archived from the original on 30 October 2012.
  19. ↑ "Symphysiotomy issue gets first Dáil hearing". Irish Examiner. 2012-03-15. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  20. ↑ "Woman awarded €450k over symphysiotomy". RTÉ News. Raidió Teilifís Éireann. 23 March 2012. Retrieved 23 March 2012.
  21. ↑ "Kearney v McQuillan, 2012, IESC" "
  22. ↑ "Senators debate symphysiotomy report". BBC. 13 Jun 2012.
  23. ↑ O'Brien, Carl (Jun 12, 2012). "Report shows figures for birth procedure". The Irish Times. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  24. ↑ Barry, Aoife (June 27, 2012). "Symphysiotomy survivors "repudiate" Walsh report". TheJournal.ie. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  25. ↑ O'Hanlon, Eilis (1 July 2012). "Our godlike 'butchers' must be cut down to size". Independent.ie. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  26. ↑ "Symphysiotomy Procedures: Discussion with Survivors of Symphysiotomy, Oireachtas" Wednesday, 13 June 2012
  27. ↑ "Symphysiotomy bill passed in Irish parliament". BBC News. 2013-04-17. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  28. ↑ O'Carroll, Sinead (26 June 2013). "Symphysiotomy survivors want justice for 'barbaric' acts". TheJournal.ie. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  29. ↑ O'Brien, Carl (Nov 26, 2013). "Compensation plan considered for symphysiotomy survivors". The Irish Times. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  30. ↑ O'Carroll, Sinead (26 November 2013). "U-turn on statute of limitations as closure sought for symphysiotomy survivors". TheJournal.ie. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  31. ↑ O'Doherty, Caroline (2013-12-09). "Symphysiotomy survivors reject offer". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  32. ↑ "Symphysiotomy campaign goes to UN". BBC News. 2014-03-13. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  33. ↑ "Symphysiotomy survivors take torture case against State to United Nations". The Irish Times. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  34. ↑ "Survivors of Symphysiotomy take campaign to the UN". RTE.ie. 2014-03-11. Retrieved 2018-04-16.
  35. ↑ Sinead O'Carroll (24 Jun 2014). "UN tells Ireland to open an investigation into symphysiotomy". TheJournal.ie.
  36. ↑ "The Surgical Symphysiotomy Ex Gratia Payment Scheme Report". www.gov.ie. 22 November 2016. Retrieved 2021-07-17.
  37. ↑ (Report by Nil Muižnieks, Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, Comm DH 2017 (8) 29 March 2017, p.34, § 186)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.