 | This article needs additional citations for verification .(June 2023) |
The syncretistic controversy was the theological debate focusing on efforts to unite Protestant churches in 17th century Germany. It was started mainly by the efforts of Georg Calixt and his supporters to secure a basis on which Lutherans could have a good relationship with both the Reformed Church and the Roman Catholic Church. It lasted from 1640 to 1686.
Calixt, a professor at Helmstedt, had travelled through England, the Netherlands, Italy, and France. His acquaintance with the different churches and their representatives there, and his extensive study, had given him a more friendly attitude towards the different religious bodies than the majority of his contemporary Lutheran theologians. [1]
While the latter firmly adhered to the "pure doctrine", Calixt tended not to regard doctrine as the one thing necessary for a Christian and did not regard everything in doctrine as equally certain and important. Consequently, he advocated unity between those who agreed on the fundamental minimum, and liberty with regard to the less fundamental points. In regard to Catholicism, he would have (as Melanchthon once would have) conceded to the pope a primacy by human right, rather than divine right; he also stated that one might call the Mass a sacrifice.
Abraham Calov in particular opposed Calixt. In 1645, he prevented Calixt from attending the Colloquy of Thorn as a representative of Dantzic. Calixt eventually attended with the Konigsberg group and publicly renounced the Reformed Confession of Thorn. [2]
The theological faculties of universities in Helmstedt, Rinteln, and Königsberg stood with Calixt; the theologians of the universities of the Leipzig, Jena, Strasburg, Giessen, Marburg, and Greifswald stood in opposition to his views.
The Elector of Saxony, for political reasons, opposed the Reformed Church, as the other two secular electors (Palatine and Brandenburg) were Reformed, and were gaining an advantage on him. In 1649, he sent a communication to the three dukes of Brunswick, who maintained Helmstedt as their common university, in which he voiced all the objections of his Lutheran professors, and complained that Calixt wanted to extract the elements of truth from all religions, fuse them into an entirely new religion, and so provoke a violent schism.
In 1650, Calov became a professor at Wittenberg, marking his entrance into office with a vehement attack on the syncretists in Helmstedt. A stream of polemical writings followed. In 1650, the dukes of Brunswick responded to the Elector of Saxony, urging that the discord not be allowed to continue and proposing a meeting of the political councillors. Saxony, however, did not favour this suggestion. An attempt to convene a meeting of theologians was not successful. The theologians of Wittenberg and Leipzig then elaborated a new formula, condemning 98 heresies of the Helmstedt theologians. This formula (consensus) was to be signed by everyone who wanted to remain in the Lutheran Church. Outside Wittenberg and Leipzig, however, it was not accepted, and Calixt's death in 1656 ushered in five years of almost undisturbed peace.
The disagreement arose again in Hesse-Kassel, where Landgrave William VI sought to unite his Lutheran and Reformed subjects, or at least to lessen their mutual hatred. In 1661, he held a colloquy in Cassel between two Lutheran theologians of the University of Rinteln and two from the Reformed theologians of the University of Marburg. They drew up a statement which recognised differences of opinion between the parties, but at the same-time showed an agreement between them on all essential matters. It urged the exercise of brotherly love and the recognition that both parties belonged to one Church, shared in a common faith, and looked forward to a shared heaven. [2]
The Wittenberg theologians were angered at this revival of syncretism and called on all Lutherans to reject the colloquy. They also called on the Rinteln professors to make their submission, whereupon the latter answered with a detailed defence. Another long series of polemical treatises followed.
In 1663 in Brandenburg-Prussia, the "Great Elector" Frederick William I forbade preachers to speak of the disputes between the Evangelical bodies.
A long colloquy in Berlin (September 1662 to May 1663) led only to fresh discord and the conferences ended in 1664 with the publication of another "syncretistic" edict. Since the edict disallowed the Formula of Concord (one of the Lutheran Confessions as contained in the 1580 Book of Concord), many Lutheran clergy refused to comply with the edict.
Any person refusing to sign the form declaring his intention to observe this regulation was deprived of his position, including Paul Gerhardt, a pastor and noted hymnwriter. The citizens of Berlin petitioned to have him restored and, owing to their repeated requests, an exception was made for him, although his conscience did not allow him to retain a post which, as it appeared to him, could be held only on condition of a tacit repudiation of the Formula of Concord. He continued to live in Berlin for over a year without a secure job. During this time his wife died, leaving him with one surviving child. The edict was withdrawn a few months later, although by this time his patroness, Electress Louisa Henrietta had died and so he was still without a position.
Many Lutherans choose to move abroad rather than sign the form.
The attempts of the Wittenberg theologians to declare Calixt and his school un-Lutheran and heretical were now met by Calixt's son, Friedrich Ulrich Calixt. The latter defended the theology of his father, but also tried to show that his doctrine did not differ much from that of his opponents. Wittenberg found its new champion in Aegidius Strauch, who attacked Calixt with all the resources of learning: polemics, sophistry, wit, cynicism, and abuse. The Helmstedt side was defended by the scholar and statesman Hermann Conring. The Saxon princes now recognized the danger that the attempt to carry through the "Consensus" as a formula of belief might lead to a fresh schism in the Lutheran Church, and might thus render its position difficult in the face of the Catholics.
The proposals of Calov and his party to continue the refutation and to compel the Brunswick theologians to bind themselves under obligation to the old Lutheran confession therefore remained unimplemented. The Saxon theologians were forbidden to continue the controversy in writing.
Negotiations for peace were established, with Duke Ernst the Pious of Saxe-Gotha especially active. The work of establishing a permanent college of theologians to decide theological disputes was considered. The negotiations with the courts of Brunswick, Mecklenburg, Denmark, and Sweden were fruitless; the only benefit was that peace was maintained until 1675. Calov then renewed hostilities, attacking not only Calixt, but also and particularly the moderate John Musæus of Jena. By 1679, Calov had succeeded in having the University of Jena (and after a long resistance, Musæus himself) compelled to renounce syncretism. The elector renewed his prohibition against polemical writings. This was Calov's last victory. In 1680, Johann Georg II of Saxony passed away and Calov lost his strongest supporter in his campaign.
Calov seemed to give way in 1683 when he asked whether, in the view of the danger that France constituted for Germany, a Calixtinic Syncretism with "Papists" and the Reformed was still condemnable, and in deference to the Elector of Brandenburg and the dukes of Brunswick, the strife should be buried by an amnesty, or whether, on the contrary, the war against syncretism should be continued.
Calov later returned to his attack on the syncretists, but died in 1686. The syncrestic controversary ended with his death.
The Syncretistic Controversy had the result of lessening religious hatred and of promoting mutual forbearance. Catholicism thus benefited, as Protestants came to better understand and appreciate it. In Protestant theology it prepared the way for the sentimental theology of Pietism to become more popular than orthodoxy.
Paul Gerhardt was a German theologian, Lutheran minister and hymnodist.
Crypto-Calvinism is a pejorative term describing a segment of those members of the Lutheran Church in Germany who were accused of secretly subscribing to Calvinist doctrine of the Eucharist in the decades immediately after the death of Martin Luther in 1546. It denotes what was seen as a hidden Calvinist belief, i.e., the doctrines of John Calvin, by members of the Lutheran Church. The term crypto-Calvinist in Lutheranism was preceded by terms Zwinglian and Sacramentarian. Also, Jansenism has been accused of crypto-Calvinism by Roman Catholics.
Abraham Calovius was a Lutheran theologian, and was one of the champions of Lutheran orthodoxy in the 17th century.
Martin Chemnitz was an eminent second-generation German, Evangelical Lutheran, Christian theologian, and a Protestant reformer, churchman, and confessor. In the Evangelical Lutheran tradition he is known as Alter Martinus, the "Second Martin": Si Martinus non fuisset, Martinus vix stetisset goes a common saying concerning him. He is listed and remembered in the Calendar of Saints and Commemorations in the Liturgical Church Year as a pastor and confessor by both the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America and Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod.
Georg Calixtus, Kallisøn/Kallisön, or Callisen was a German Lutheran theologian who looked to reconcile all Christendom by removing all differences that he deemed "unimportant".
Frederick III of Simmern, the Pious, Elector Palatine of the Rhine was a ruler from the house of Wittelsbach, branch Palatinate-Simmern-Sponheim. He was a son of John II of Simmern and inherited the Palatinate from the childless Elector Otto-Henry, Elector Palatine (Ottheinrich) in 1559. He was a devout convert to Calvinism, and made the Reformed confession the official religion of his domain by overseeing the composition and promulgation of the Heidelberg Catechism. His support of Calvinism gave the German Reformed movement a foothold within the Holy Roman Empire.
Nikolaus Selnecker was a German musician, theologian and Protestant reformer. He is now known mainly as a hymn writer. He is also known as one of the principal authors of the Formula of Concord along with Jakob Andreä and Martin Chemnitz.
Lutheranism as a religious movement originated in the early 16th century Holy Roman Empire as an attempt to reform the Roman Catholic Church. The movement originated with the call for a public debate regarding several issues within the Catholic Church by Martin Luther, then a professor of Bible at the young University of Wittenberg. Lutheranism soon became a wider religious and political movement within the Holy Roman Empire owing to support from key electors and the widespread adoption of the printing press. This movement soon spread throughout northern Europe and became the driving force behind the wider Protestant Reformation. Today, Lutheranism has spread from Europe to all six populated continents.
Johann Wilhelm Baier was a German theologian in the Lutheran scholastic tradition. He was born at Nuremberg, and died at Weimar.
The Philippists formed a party in early Lutheranism. Their opponents were called Gnesio-Lutherans.
Johann Hülsemann was a German Lutheran theologian. He is known as one of the most prominent Lutheran scholastic opponents of Georgius Calixtus in the Syncretistic Controversy.
Johannes Musaeus was a German Protestant theologian.
The surname of Eifert, Eiffert, Eyfert, is German in origin. It has in its modern context in the translation of zealot, the biblical form, Pinhas the zealot. There is also an early Prussian translation that means "one who protects what is dear", and symbolized in art by a wall or castle engulfed in flames.
Johann Stössel was a Lutheran Theologian and Reformer.
Tilemann Heshusius was a Gnesio-Lutheran theologian and Protestant reformer.
Gerhard Wolter Molanus was Lutheran theologian and abbot of Loccum.
Joachim Mörlin was an Evangelical Lutheran theologian and an important figure in the controversies following Martin Luther's (1483-1546) death. He was the older brother of Maximilian Mörlin, another Lutheran theologian and Reformer.
Polykarp (von) Leyser the Elder or Polykarp Leyser I was a Lutheran theologian, superintendent of Braunschweig, superintendent-general of the Saxon church-circle, professor of theology at the University of Wittenberg and chief court-preacher and consistorial-councillor of Saxony.
Maximilian Mörlin was a Lutheran theologian, court preacher, Superintendent in Coburg, and Reformer.
Aegidius Strauch was a German mathematician and theologian.
This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain : Herbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). "Syncretism". Catholic Encyclopedia . New York: Robert Appleton Company.