Talbot v Laroche

Last updated

Talbot V. Laroche
CourtGuildhall,London
Full case name William Fox Talbot and Martin Laroche
Decided1854
Case history
Related actions Intellectual Property and Photographic Society
Court membership
Judge sittingSir John Jervis
Case opinions
Decision by Chief Justice of the Common Pleas
Keywords
Patent law

Talbot v Laroche (unreported) was an 1854 legal action, pivotal to the history of photography, by which William Fox Talbot sought to assert that Martin Laroche's use of the unpatented, collodion process infringed his calotype patent.

Contents

Background

Fox Talbot had developed the calotype process and patented it in 1841 [1] to run until 1855. By 1852, many in the photographic community felt that Fox Talbot's insistence on the economic rights in his intellectual property were hampering the development of photography in England and had called upon him to relinquish his patent. He had made a concession by allowing a free licence to amateur photographers [2] but he still insisted that professionals pay an annual licence fee. The situation was exacerbated by Fox Talbot's insistence that Frederick Scott Archer's collodion process was covered by his patent. The collodion process was widely used and there was disquiet among the professional photographic community at the payment of a licence to Fox Talbot, rather than Archer, for its use. [3]

In 1854, Fox Talbot applied to the Privy Council for an extension of his patent and Laroche was instrumental in fomenting opposition. Laroche was a professional photographer who has been claimed as a collaborator of Archer. He orchestrated the Photographic Society's public opposition to an extension and entered his own formal objection with the Privy Council. As a deliberate casus belli , he advertised his photographic services in The Times , stating that he used "the new process on paper", the collodion process. Laroche's solicitor was Peter Fry, an amateur photographer who had been active against the original patent. [3]

Fox Talbot had won actions against other photographers [4] and sued Laroche for £5,000 damages (£350,000 at 2003 prices [5] ) for infringement of his patent. [3]

Fox Talbot claimed that his patent covered "the making visible photographic images upon paper ... by washing them with liquid" and argued that Laroche's use of pyrogallic acid rather than his own mixture of silver nitrate, acetic acid, and gallic acid was immaterial. [3]

Laroche argued:

  1. There was prior art in the calotype patent rendering it invalid. In particular, the method had been developed by Joseph Bancroft Reade and described in an 1839 lecture. [3]
  2. The technique used by Laroche differed in that:
    1. It used pyrogallic, rather than gallic, acid; [3] and
    2. It used collodion rather than paper. [3]

Case

The case was heard 18–20 December 1854 in the Guildhall, London before Chief Justice of the Common Pleas Sir John Jervis. [3]

Fox Talbot's leading counsel was Sir Frederick Thesiger, later to become Attorney-General, assisted by William Robert Grove, a barrister and distinguished scientist who was to go on to become a judge. The first witness was Fox Talbot and Grove performed the examination-in-chief. There were then ten witnesses for Fox Talbot: [3]

Laroche did not give evidence but the witnesses called by his counsel included: [3]

Thesinger gave the closing speech for Fox Talbot and Jervis gave a lengthy summing up for the jury. [6]

Verdict

The jury found that Fox Talbot was "the first and true inventor of the calotype process ... the first person who disclosed it to the public" but that Laroche had not infringed his patent. [3]

Notes

  1. Patent No. 8842
  2. The Times , 13 August 1852
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Wood (1975)
  4. Wood (1971b, 1971c)
  5. O‘Donoghue, J.; et al. (2004). "Consumer Price Inflation since 1750". Economic Trends. 604: 38–46, March.
  6. Juries were used in civil trials in England until the 1930s.

Bibliography

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Calotype</span> Early photographic process

Calotype or talbotype is an early photographic process introduced in 1841 by William Henry Fox Talbot, using paper coated with silver iodide. Paper texture effects in calotype photography limit the ability of this early process to record low contrast details and textures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Fox Talbot</span> English photography pioneer (1800–1877)

William Henry Fox Talbot was an English scientist, inventor, and photography pioneer who invented the salted paper and calotype processes, precursors to photographic processes of the later 19th and 20th centuries. His work in the 1840s on photomechanical reproduction led to the creation of the photoglyphic engraving process, the precursor to photogravure. He was the holder of a controversial patent that affected the early development of commercial photography in Britain. He was also a noted photographer who contributed to the development of photography as an artistic medium. He published The Pencil of Nature (1844–1846), which was illustrated with original salted paper prints from his calotype negatives and made some important early photographs of Oxford, Paris, Reading, and York.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Collodion process</span> Early photographic technique

The collodion process is an early photographic process. The collodion process, mostly synonymous with the "collodion wet plate process", requires the photographic material to be coated, sensitized, exposed, and developed within the span of about fifteen minutes, necessitating a portable darkroom for use in the field. Collodion is normally used in its wet form, but it can also be used in its dry form, at the cost of greatly increased exposure time. The increased exposure time made the dry form unsuitable for the usual portraiture work of most professional photographers of the 19th century. The use of the dry form was mostly confined to landscape photography and other special applications where minutes-long exposure times were tolerable.

The year 1854 in science and technology involved some significant events, listed below.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frederick Scott Archer</span> English photographer and sculptor

Frederick Scott Archer was an English photographer and sculptor who is best known for having invented the photographic collodion process which preceded the modern gelatin emulsion. He was born in either Bishop's Stortford or Hertford, within the county of Hertfordshire, England and is remembered mainly for this single achievement which greatly increased the accessibility of photography for the general public.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Dillwyn Llewelyn</span> Welsh botanist and photographer

John Dillwyn Llewelyn was a Welsh botanist and pioneer photographer.

Rev. Joseph Bancroft Reade FRS FRMS was an English clergyman, amateur scientist and pioneer of photography. A gentleman scientist, Reade co-founded the Royal Microscopical Society and the Royal Meteorological Society.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Beard (photographer)</span> British photographer and businessman

Richard Beard was an English entrepreneur and photographer who vigorously protected his photographic business by litigation over his photographic patents and helped to establish professional photography in the UK.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Wedgwood (photographer)</span> English photographer and inventor

Thomas Wedgwood was an English photographer and inventor. He is most widely known as an early experimenter in the field of photography.

Events from the year 1854 in the United Kingdom.

Martin Laroche, born William Henry Silvester, was an early English professional photographer who successfully challenged William Fox Talbot's patent on the calotype and effected a liberalisation in professional practice, research and development that catalysed the development of photography in the nineteenth century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Ambrose Cutting</span> American photographer and inventor

James Ambrose Cutting (1814–1867) was an American photographer and inventor, sometimes called the inventor of the Ambrotype photographic process.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Collen</span> English painter

Henry Collen was an English miniature portrait painter to Queen Victoria of the United Kingdom and the Duchess of Kent. Later in life he turned to photography and was the first professional calotypist in London.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edinburgh Calotype Club</span>

The Edinburgh Calotype Club of Scotland was the first photographic club in the world. Its members consisted of pioneering photographers primarily from Edinburgh and St Andrews. The efforts of the Club's members resulted in the production of two of the world's earliest assembled photographic albums, consisting of more than 300 images.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Farnham Maxwell-Lyte</span> English chemist and photographer

Farnham Maxwell-Lyte FRSC was an English chemist and the pioneer of a number of techniques in photographic processing. As a photographer he is known for his views of the French Pyrenees.

Paper texture effects in calotype photography limit the ability of this early process to record low contrast details and textures. A calotype is a photographic negative produced on uncoated paper. An important feature is that a relatively short exposure in a camera produces a latent image that is subsequently made visible by development. Then positive images for viewing are obtained by contact printing. This technique was in use principally from 1840 into the 1850s, when it was displaced by photography on glass. Skilled photographers were able to achieve dramatic results with the calotype process, and the reason for its eclipse may not be evident from viewing reproductions of early work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peter Wickens Fry</span> English photographer

Peter Wickens Fry was a pioneering English amateur photographer, although professionally he was a London solicitor. In the early 1850s, Fry worked with Frederick Scott Archer, assisting him in the early experiments of the wet collodion process. He was also active in helping Roger Fenton to set up the Royal Photographic Society in 1853. Several of his photographs are in the Victoria and Albert Museum in London.

Photo-crayotypes were an artistic process used for the hand-colouring of photographs by the application of crayons and pigments over a photographic impression.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hugh Owen (photographer)</span> Early British photographer (1808–1897)

Hugh Owen was one of the first generation of amateur photographers in the United Kingdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wothlytype</span> Short-lived nineteenth-century positive photographic printing process using uranium

The Wothlytype was an alternative photographic printing process, the eponymous 1864 invention of the German Jacob Wothly, in which a mixture of uranium ammonio-nitrate and silver nitrate in collodion formed a light-sensitive layer.