Teina Pora

Last updated

Teina Pora (born 1975) [1] is a New Zealander with foetal alcohol syndrome disorder, who made a false confession to the police, and was wrongfully convicted of murdering a woman he had never met, named Susan Burdett, when he was aged 17; he served 20 years in Paremoremo prison from 1994, until he was paroled in 2014. [2]

Contents

In 1992, 39-year-old Burdett was raped and murdered in her home in Papatoetoe, Auckland. She was repeatedly struck in the head with a softball bat. About a year later, Pora who was a Mongrel Mob prospect at the time, [3] was arrested on other charges and, when he learned there was $20,000 reward for information, claimed he was there when the murder happened. He was interviewed for 14 hours without a lawyer present, and was later said to have a mental age of nine or 10 at the time of the crime. The police and jury were unaware of this, and in 1994, he was convicted of rape and murder. [4] [5]

In 1999, Malcoholm Rewa was found guilty of raping Susan Burdett on the night she died. Pora appealed his conviction, but in 2000, was found guilty for the crime a second time. After spending 20 years in prison, Pora was released on parole in April 2014. [6]

However, he continued to maintain his innocence, and the convictions were quashed by the Privy Council in March 2015, notably being the last ruling rendered by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council with respect to an appeal from the courts of New Zealand. He was awarded NZ$3,509,048 million compensation and received a government apology for being wrongfully convicted of rape and murder. [7]

In 2019, Malcolm Rewa was subsequently found guilty of Burdett's murder. [8]

Early history

Teina Pora was born with foetal alcohol spectrum disorder, caused by his mother's drinking during pregnancy. [9] [10] He grew up in Ōtara. His father was never around and his teenage mother died of cancer when he was four.

After his mother's death, Pora lived with grandparents and other family members, including an aunt who tried to raise him as her own son. [11] As a teenager he spent time in boys' homes but often ran away. [12] His brother told TV3's 3rd Degree programme that by the time he was a teenager, Pora was already doing "heaps of crime" but that "he was never a violent person". [13]

The murder of Susan Burdett

Susan Burdett was a 39-year-old accounts clerk who lived alone in Papatoetoe and enjoyed ten pin bowling. On 23 March 1992, she went bowling at the Manukau Superstrike. After she got home, she had a shower and was then raped and battered to death with a softball bat. When she was found, the softball bat, which she kept for her own protection, was found lying on the bed beside her. [14]

Background to Pora's involvement

Pora and some friends were walking through a park in Manukau a few days after the murder when they found an old softball bat in a drain. It was not the weapon used in the Burdett murder as this was found beside her body at the scene of the crime. [12] Unaware of this, when Pora's aunt found out about the bat in the drain, she suggested to police that Pora may have committed the murder. Police responded by interviewing Pora in April 1992 and again in May 1992. On both occasions he denied any involvement and provided hair and DNA samples to police, which excluded him as a suspect. However, his aunt continued to put forward the view that Pora was involved but the police concluded her information was unreliable. [15]

Pora's 'confession'

Pora was a prolific car thief [14] and almost a year later, he was arrested for failing to attend court. In the course of a "general conversation" with a police officer, Pora "told him of his troubled life, told the officer he wanted to go straight, that he felt unwanted by his family and that he knew he was being sought by the Mongrel Mob and police". [15] After police told him there was a reward of $20,000 for assistance in capturing Susan Burdett's murderer, Pora claimed he knew who committed the crime. He said he drove two Mongrel Mob members to the house and acted as lookout while they went inside. [16]

Pora did not give the names of the Mongrel Mob members, but when police put two names to him, he went along with these suggestions. [14] Later on, police determined the two Mongrel Mob members both had alibis and their DNA did not match that found in the body. The DNA came from Malcolm Rewa but police did not learn that until four years later. [16]

After claiming he was at the scene, Pora was held for the next four days during which he was questioned about the case for 14 hours without a lawyer. [12] During the course of this drawn out interview, much of which was recorded on video, he frequently changed his story about what happened. After initially claiming he acted as a lookout for the two "Mongrel Mob members", he later said he went into the house after "hearing noises and seeing the crimes being carried out". Still later, he said he held Burdett down by the arms while the others raped her. [5] Pora was subsequently charged with Burdett's rape and murder. In 1995, once Pora was in prison, he provided three more names to police after they offered him another $50,000 and said they would help when he came up for parole. [17]

Concerns about the confession

According to The New Zealand Herald investigative reporter, Phil Taylor, who wrote extensively about the case, Pora's 'confession' was flawed. He "couldn't find the street Burdett lived in, couldn't point out her house when police stood him in front of it, described Burdett as fair and fat when she was dark and slim, didn't know the (victim's) bed was a waterbed...couldn't describe the house layout... didn't know the position her body was left in, (and) said she screamed and yelled when her closest neighbour heard only a series of dull thuds. And those he claimed had raped her were all cleared by DNA." [5] [12]

Gisli Gudjonsson, professor of forensic psychology at the Institute of Psychiatry, King's College, London, was asked to review the nine hours of videotaped interviews and talked with Pora in prison. Gudjonsson is an authority on how people can be induced to make false "confessions". He said Pora's confessions were the result of intellectual impairment and his desire to claim the $20,000 reward – Pora was told there was an "indemnity against prosecution for non-principal offenders". [12] Gudjonsson believed the convictions were "fundamentally flawed and unsafe". [18]

Trials and hearings

First trial 1994

No finger prints, DNA, or any other direct evidence linking Pora to the murder scene were produced in court. [19] Nevertheless, despite the contradictory nature of Pora's 'confessions', the Crown successfully argued at his trial that no one would confess to being involved in such a brutal rape and murder if they were not actually involved. His aunt, Terry McLaughlin, [20] was a key Crown witness at the trial. [11] Court documents showed she was paid $5000 to testify against him at the trial. [12] Police have refused Official Information Act requests about payments made to other witnesses against Pora but the NZ Herald reports that a minimum of three witnesses were paid and received a total of $15,000. [21]

Conviction of Malcolm Rewa for rape

In 1999, Malcolm Rewa was convicted of raping Susan Burdett after semen at the crime scene was found to be his. He was also found guilty of raping numerous other women and currently serves preventive detention for these attacks. [22]

Rewa's offending went on for some years before the police finally brought him to justice. In 2014, TV3's 3rd Degree programme suggested police had overlooked Rewa's involvement in six different sexual assaults. The IPCA was then asked to investigate the failure of the police to investigate Rewa's previous rapes including one particular sexual attack which occurred in 1987, [23] five years before he raped Susan Burdett. Police eventually apologised to Malcolm Rewa's victims over the length of time it took to catch him and prevent any further offending. [24]

Rewa was also charged with the murder of Susan Burdett. Detective sergeant David Henwood thought the reason the jury failed to convict Rewa of the murder was that they could not reconcile this possibility with the knowledge that Pora had already been convicted for it. So although Rewa was found guilty for sexually assaulting Ms Burdett on the night she died, the jury at the time was unable to decide whether he was involved in her murder. [25] However, in 2015 Pora's conviction was overturned, and in 2019, Rewa was tried again and found guilty of the murder.

Malcolm Rewa's offending profile

When prosecuting Rewa, the police argued that Rewa and Pora committed the crime together. The difficulty with this view is that Rewa had a track record as a lone offender – a serial stalker and rapist who was convicted of attacks on 24 other women. Rewa and Pora also came from rival gangs and were significantly different in age; Rewa was 40 and a senior member of the Highway 61 gang while Pora was a 16-year-old Mongrel Mob associate. [26] Evidence put to the Privy Council also suggested that Rewa suffered from erectile dysfunction and would have been unlikely to have had an accomplice because of his embarrassment about this. [27]

Professor Laurence Alison, chair of forensic psychology at Liverpool University, concluded that it is "highly unlikely" Malcolm Rewa would have worked with any co-offender, let alone with Pora. He said: "These conclusions would have been much harder to arrive at at the time of Teina Pora's appeal since far less was known about behavioural profiling and specific co-offending patterns in rape. [28]

Pora's second trial 2000

Pora appealed his conviction after the semen in Ms Burdett's body was found to belong to Malcolm Rewa. [24] The Court of Appeal ordered a retrial and in 2000, Pora was found guilty a second time. [18] Pora then applied for the royal prerogative of mercy, under which the Governor-General can order a new trial. [18] In May 2013, his legal team prepared an appeal to the Privy Council to have his convictions quashed which put his application for mercy on hold. [29]

Police concerns about Pora's conviction

Two police officers expressed concerns that Pora was wrongly convicted. Detective Sergeant Dave Henwood, a criminal profiler, believed Rewa raped and murdered Mrs Burdett and acted alone, based on his knowledge of Rewa's criminal signature. [5] In 2012 a second senior officer, who also worked on the case, wrote to Police Commissioner Peter Marshall expressing his concern that the wrong man had been convicted. [30] Susan's brother, Jim Burdett, also believed that Rewa was the one who raped and killed his sister. He believed Susan stood up for herself, that Rewa took the bat off her that she kept for self-defence and "struck the blows that killed her". [31]

Calls for inquiry

In 2013, the Police Association officially called for a review of Pora's conviction, citing "sufficient concern among some senior detectives to warrant an inquiry". [32]

The Māori Party also backed an inquiry in the case. [33] A documentary about his case titled The Confessions of Prisoner T was aired on Māori Television on 5 May 2013. It featured defence lawyer, Marie Dyhrberg, who said that out of all the criminals she has ever been involved with, she believed in Pora's innocence more than any other. [29]

In response to the documentary, the Green Party also called for a review. Green Party spokesman David Clendon wrote to Police Commissioner Peter Marshall asking him to reopen the case. He said "serious misconduct by police was rare in New Zealand", but "it was important to maintain the public's faith in the justice system by holding a review". [34]

Parole hearings

Over his 20 years in prison, Pora made numerous appearances before the parole board. At those hearings he repeatedly denied he had any part in Burdett's murder, which made it difficult for the board to grant him parole. [14] His 12th attempt to be released on parole was declined in October 2013 after he admitted visiting a prostitute with a former inmate while on temporary leave. [35] He was finally released in April 2014. [6] At a monitoring hearing five months later, the board noted he was doing well but added: "Given his lengthy time in prison, and limited education before (being) imprisoned, (reintegration) will be a difficult and necessarily slow process of which he is aware." [36]

Privy Council hearing 2014

On 31 January 2014 the Judicial Committee announced that Pora had been granted permission to take his case to the Privy Council in London later in 2014. The hearing was held in November. Pora's lawyer Jonathan Krebs told the Privy Council his client had recently been diagnosed with foetal alcohol spectrum disorder and had a mental age of nine or 10 at the time of the crime. He said this disability meant Pora was easily confused, had a drive to please others, and that his confession in 1993 should therefore be seen as unreliable. [37]

Questions were also asked about the people named by Pora as having committed the murder. One of the Privy Council judges, Lord Toulson asked New Zealand's Solicitor-General "Why didn't Pora name [Malcolm] Rewa?" The explanation given by Pora's lawyers was that "Pora couldn't name Rewa because Pora didn't know him and because Pora wasn't there". [17] The Privy Council quashed Pora's convictions on 3 March 2015. [38]

Compensation and apology

On 15 June 2016, Teina Pora was awarded NZ$2.52 million compensation and received a government apology for being wrongfully convicted of rape and murder. Retired High Court judge Rodney Hansen, QC, who was appointed by the government to review the case after the Privy Council quashed Pora's convictions, said he could have found Pora innocent on a higher standard than the balance of probabilities. [7]

In July 2017, Pora appealed the amount awarded, submitting that it had been calculated on 1998 guidelines that awarded $100,000 per year, and had not been adjusted for inflation as recommended by Judge Hansen. [39] The court upheld the appeal in August 2017. [40]

In September 2017, the general election resulted in a change of government, and incoming Justice Minister Andrew Little announced that the outgoing government's intention to appeal the decision would not go ahead and Pora's compensation would be increased to match inflation. [41] A few days later Little announced Pora would receive an extra $988,099 bringing his total compensation to $3,509,048. [42]

Impact on justice system

This case has been one of a number of high profile miscarriages of justice in New Zealand in recent years. It was a factor in the Labour Government's decision to establish a Criminal Cases Review Commission in 2020. [43]

Related Research Articles

David Milgaard was a Canadian man who was wrongfully convicted for the 1969 rape and murder of nursing student Gail Miller in Saskatoon and imprisoned for 23 years. He was eventually released and exonerated. Up until his death, he lived in Alberta and was employed as a community support worker. Milgaard was also a public speaker who advocated for the wrongfully convicted and for all prisoners' rights.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Miscarriage of justice</span> Conviction of a person for a crime that they did not commit

A miscarriage of justice occurs when an unfair outcome occurs in a criminal or civil proceeding, such as the conviction and punishment of a person for a crime they did not commit. Miscarriages are also known as wrongful convictions. Innocent people have sometimes ended up in prison for years before their conviction has eventually been overturned. They may be exonerated if new evidence comes to light or it is determined that the police or prosecutor committed some kind of misconduct at the original trial. In some jurisdictions this leads to the payment of compensation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bain family murders</span> 1994 multiple homicide in New Zealand

On 20 June 1994, Robin and Margaret Bain and three of their four children – Arawa, Laniet, and Stephen – were shot to death in Dunedin, New Zealand. The only suspects were David Cullen Bain, the eldest son and only survivor, and Robin Bain, the father. David Bain, aged 22, was charged with five counts of murder. In May 1995, he was convicted on each of the five counts and sentenced to mandatory life in prison with a minimum non-parole period of sixteen years.

William Dwane Bell is a New Zealand triple murderer. He committed a triple murder on 8 December 2001 at the Panmure RSA, after they fired him. He committed the murders while out on parole for a previous aggravated robbery in which he almost killed a service station attendant. He had more than 100 prior criminal convictions, including theft, fraud, unlawful taking of motor vehicles, aggravated robbery, presenting a firearm, impersonating police, and assault. He was given a 30-year minimum non-parole life sentence, at the time the longest minimum non-parole period ever given out by New Zealand.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joe Karam</span> New Zealand rugby player and businessman

Joseph Francis Karam, also known by the nickname of "Clock", is a New Zealand former representative rugby footballer who played for the All Blacks. After retiring from rugby, he became a businessman. However, he is most notable for waging a successful 15-year campaign to have David Bain's convictions for murder overturned, and a subsequent campaign seeking compensation for him.

Arthur Allan Thomas is a New Zealand man who was granted a Royal Pardon and compensation after being wrongfully convicted of the murders of Harvey and Jeannette Crewe in June 1970. Thomas was married and farming a property in the Pukekawa district, south of Auckland before the case. Following the revelation that the crucial evidence against him had been faked, Thomas was pardoned in 1979 and awarded NZ$950,000 in compensation for his 9 years in prison and loss of earnings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Urban Höglin and Heidi Paakkonen</span> 1989 New Zealand murder case

Swedish tourists Sven Urban Höglin, aged 23, and his fiancée Heidi Birgitta Paakkonen, aged 21, disappeared while tramping on the Coromandel Peninsula of New Zealand in 1989. Police, residents, and military personnel conducted the largest land-based search undertaken in New Zealand, attempting to find the couple. In December 1990, David Wayne Tamihere was convicted of murdering Höglin and Paakkonen, and sentenced to life imprisonment based largely on the testimony of three prison inmates.

In 2001, Bailey Junior Kurariki was involved in the robbery, assault and murder of pizza delivery man Michael Richard Choy in Papakura, a suburb of Auckland, New Zealand. Kurariki was later convicted of manslaughter. He was 12 years and 252 days old the day Choy was killed, making him the youngest person convicted of killing in New Zealand history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Mellory Manning</span> New Zealand murder

Ngatai Lynette Manning was murdered in Christchurch, New Zealand, on 18 December 2008. Manning was picked up from Manchester Street and presumably taken to a property in Avonside and brutally killed by stabbing, strangling and assault with a metal pole. Her body was then dumped in the nearby Avon River and found the next morning by a kayaker. In March 2012 a 24-year-old man was arrested and charged with the murder and abduction of Manning. He was later convicted of her murder, but this conviction was overturned on appeal and the charge was later dismissed.

Dean Hugh Tekahu William Wickliffe is a notorious New Zealand criminal and prison escapee. He is the only person to have escaped Paremoremo maximum security prison twice, in 1976 and 1991. He was New Zealand's longest-serving prisoner.

Christine Marie Lundy, 38, and her 7-year-old daughter Amber Grace Lundy were murdered in Palmerston North, New Zealand, on 29 or 30 August 2000. In February 2001, after a six month investigation, Christine's husband and Amber's father, Mark Edward Lundy, was arrested and charged, and in 2002, he was convicted of the murders and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum non-parole period of 17 years.

This is a list of notable overturned convictions in Canada.

Antony "Tony" Shaw is a barrister of the High Court of New Zealand, and a former lecturer of law at Victoria University. He holds an LLB and BA from Auckland University. His practice covers civil and criminal matters. He is regarded as an expert on human rights law. Shaw has appeared widely in the District and High Courts of New Zealand including successful appeals to the Court of Appeal, Privy Council and the New Zealand Supreme Court. Shaw has also appeared in the Employment Court of New Zealand and regularly appears before the New Zealand Parole Board.

Ben Smart and Olivia Hope, two young New Zealanders, disappeared in the early hours of the morning on New Year's Day, 1 January 1998. The two friends had been celebrating New Year's Eve at Furneaux Lodge in the Marlborough Sounds with other partygoers. The pair accepted an offer from a stranger to stay aboard his yacht in the early hours of the morning, and it was the last time they were seen alive. The disappearance of the duo sparked one of the most publicised and controversial investigations in New Zealand's history.

Robert Brown is a Scottish man who spent 25 years in jail for a crime he did not commit, the murder of worker Annie Walsh.

Deane Fuller-Sandys and Leah Stephens disappeared in Auckland, New Zealand, five days apart in August 1989. Stephens' remains were discovered in a forest three years later. Fuller-Sandys' body has never been found. In 1999, Gail Denise Maney and Stephen Ralph Stone were convicted of Fuller-Sandys' murder, Stone was convicted of Stephens' murder, and two other men were convicted of being accessories to murder. The convictions of all four were overturned in October 2024 due to a miscarriage of justice. Maney spent a total of 16 years in prison; Stone spent 26 years behind bars and was released on bail a few days after the convictions were overturned.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Grace Millane</span> 2018 killing of a British tourist in New Zealand

Grace Emmie Rose Millane was a British tourist who was murdered in Auckland, New Zealand, in December 2018. A 26-year-old man, Jesse Shane Kempson, was charged with her murder on 8 December 2018. Millane's body was found in the Waitākere Ranges to the west of Auckland on 9 December 2018.

Paula Penfold is a New Zealand investigative journalist. She is best-known for her investigation into the wrongful conviction of Auckland man Teina Pora for murder and rape.

The New Zealand Criminal Cases Review Commission is an independent Crown entity that was set up under the Criminal Cases Review Commission Act 2019 to investigate potential miscarriages of justice. If the Commission considers a miscarriage may have occurred, it can refer the case back to the Court of Appeal to be reconsidered.

Alan Hall was convicted for the murder of Arthur Easton in 1985. The case has been described as one of New Zealand's worst miscarriages of justice. In August 2023, the Government agreed to pay him $5 million in compensation, the largest nominal payout for wrongful conviction in New Zealand history.

References

  1. ↑ Taylor, Phil (30 March 2015). "Pora forgives but is still fighting fit". NZ Herald.
  2. ↑ Teina Pora granted parole, tvnz.co.nz; accessed 16 March 2019.
  3. ↑ "Bid to overturn murder conviction - National News | TVNZ". Archived from the original on 2 February 2014.
  4. ↑ 'Innocent man' in jail 20 years, www.nzherald.co.nz; accessed 16 March 2019.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Reasonable doubts
  6. 1 2 Teina Pora released from prison, New Zealand Herald, 14 April 2014
  7. 1 2 "Teina Pora compensation: Justice Minister Amy Adams confirms $2.52 million payout". The New Zealand Herald . 15 June 2016. Retrieved 15 June 2016.
  8. ↑ Police report buried for 17 years reveals serial rapist Malcolm Rewa was suspected of dozens more attacks, Stuff, 21 May 2023
  9. ↑ Teina Pora legal team: Condition linked to confession, TV3 News, 19 March 2014
  10. ↑ Pora mental age that of a child, lawyer says, New Zealand Herald, 5 November 2014
  11. 1 2 Why an innocent man would confess, New Zealand Herald, 23 March 2013
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Susan Burdett: Did the police bungle this murder case?
  13. ↑ Was Teina Pora wrongly jailed?
  14. 1 2 3 4 Susan Burdett: Did the police bungle this murder case? New Zealand Herald, 13 April 2013.
  15. 1 2 Why an innocent man would confess
  16. 1 2 Police censure profiler who spoke out about crime to Herald, New Zealand Herald, 16 March 2013
  17. 1 2 "Why didn't Pora name Malcolm Rewa?", New Zealand Herald, 8 November 2014.
  18. 1 2 3 Expert Burdett confession was utterly flawed, nzherald.co.nz; accessed 16 March 2019.
  19. ↑ Was Teina Pora wrongly jailed? , TV3, 13 March 2013
  20. ↑ Pora appeal: Error in not making rapist's impotence known, Privy Council told, New Zealand Herald, 5 November 2014
  21. ↑ Police censure profiler who spoke out about crime to Herald
  22. ↑ Teina Pora case: Police fear miscarriage of justice, New Zealand Herald, 3 August 2013
  23. ↑ Report on the Police investigations into offending by Malcolm Rewa, IPCA 24 July 2014
  24. 1 2 Police apologise for delay in catching rapist, New Zealand Herald, 24 July 2014.
  25. ↑ Report on the Police investigations into offending by Malcolm Rewa, IPCA 24 July 2014, para 1
  26. ↑ Reasonable doubts, New Zealand Herald, 19 May 2012
  27. ↑ Pora appeal: Error in not making rapist's impotence known, Privy Council told, NZ Herald, 5 November 2014
  28. ↑ British profiling expert backs Henwood on Burdett case, nzherald.co.nz; accessed 16 March 2019.
  29. 1 2 "NZ murder appeal on path to top UK court". Archived from the original on 4 May 2013. Retrieved 3 May 2013.
  30. ↑ Second cop fears wrong man jailed for Burdett murder, nzherald.co.nz; accessed 16 March 2019.
  31. ↑ Burdett's brother says Pora innocent, nzherald.co.nz; accessed 16 March 2019.
  32. ↑ "Pora's legal team must decide next step – minister". Radio New Zealand. 5 August 2013.
  33. ↑ "Maori Party pushing Pora's case". 3 News NZ. 28 March 2013.
  34. ↑ Greens call for review of Pora conviction, nzherald.co.nz, 6 May 2013.
  35. ↑ "Teina Pora declined parole again". Stuff . 21 October 2013. Retrieved 22 February 2019.
  36. ↑ PORA, Teina 26/09/2014, New Zealand Parole Board. Archived 28 January 2015 at the Wayback Machine
  37. ↑ Pora lawyer argues confession false, Radio New Zealand, 5 November 2014
  38. ↑ Taylor, Phil (4 March 2015). "Justice after 21 years in jail: Teina Pora 'set up for new life' after Privy Council quashes convictions for Susan Burdett murder". The New Zealand Herald . Retrieved 24 May 2015.
  39. ↑ "Pora heads back to court over compensation payout". Radio New Zealand – radionz.co.nz. 3 July 2017. Retrieved 25 October 2017.
  40. ↑ "Court rules for Teina Pora in compensation battle". Radio New Zealand – radionz.co.nz. 29 August 2017. Retrieved 25 October 2017.
  41. ↑ "Little confirms Pora compensation will be adjusted". Radio New Zealand – radionz.co.nz. 26 October 2017. Retrieved 25 October 2017.
  42. ↑ Teina Pora 'happy and free' after compensation adjusted for inflation by Government, New Zealand Herald, 8 November 2017.
  43. ↑ Our timeline, Criminal Cases review Commission

Source documents

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.