The Bertrand Russell Case

Last updated

Kay v. Board of Higher Education
Court Supreme Court of New York, New York County
Full case nameIn the Matter of the Application of Jean Kay, Petitioner, v. Board of Higher Education of the City of New York
DecidedMarch 30, 1940
Citation(s)1193 Misc. 943 18 N.Y.S. (2d) 821 (1940)
Court membership
Judge(s) sitting John E. McGeehan
Bertrand Russell Bertrand Russell 1954.jpg
Bertrand Russell

The Bertrand Russell Case, known officially as Kay v. Board of Higher Education, was a case concerning the appointment of Bertrand Russell as Professor of Philosophy of the College of the City of New York, as well as a collection of articles on the aforementioned case, edited by John Dewey and Horace M. Kallen.

Contents

Background

In 1940, Bertrand Russell was hired by the City College of New York to teach classes on logic, mathematics, and metaphysics of science. This appointment was made controversial by Dr. William Thomas Manning, the Episcopal Bishop of New York City, who argued that due to Bertrand Russell's writings against religion and approval of sexual acts disapproved of by traditional Christian teachings, he should not be instated as a professor. [1] Following Manning's denunciation, a group of religious individuals lobbied New York City government institutions to reject Bertrand Russell's position as professor. However, despite that pressure, Russell was confirmed by the New York Board of Higher Education. [1] Following that decision, the matter was taken to the New York Supreme Court by Jean Kay, who argued that her daughter would be morally compromised should she study under Russell even though her daughter could not have been a student at CCNY, which at that time exclusively enrolled male students. [1] [2]

Court case

The judge hearing the case was the Irish Catholic John E. McGeehan, who ruled against Russell's appointment on three criteria. First, McGeehan argued that Russell should not be allowed to teach due to his status as a non-citizen of the United States, whom New York law prohibited from teaching in public schools. [3] Second, McGeehan wrote that Russell was not given a competitive examination of his merit for the position to which he was appointed. [3] Thirdly, McGeehan concluded that Russell held immoral views regarding sexuality on the basis of four of his popular and non-philosophic books ( On Education , What I Believe, Education and the Modern World , and Marriage and Morals ), and that his opinions regarding sexual relations between college-aged students amounted to an endorsement of abduction, rendering him morally unfit to teach philosophy and an advocate of lawlessness. [3] [4] In the books, Russell advocated for sex before marriage, homosexuality, temporary marriages, and the privatization of marriage, among other things. [3] [5]

Russell was prevented from appearing in court and an appeal by the American Civil Liberties Union was denied in several courts. The City of New York's lawyers told the Board of Higher Education that the verdict would not be appealed. A few days later Mayor La Guardia removed the funds for the position from the budget. [6]

Judge McGeehan's ruling was published as Kay v. Board of Higher Ed. of City of New York, 193 Misc. 943 18 N.Y.S. (2d) 821 (1940). [7]

Aftermath

When Russell published An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth , the lectures he gave at Harvard that fall, he added "Judicially pronounced unworthy to be Professor of Philosophy at the College of the City of New York" to the listing of distinctions and academic honors on the title page in the British version. [8] Russell commented on Judge McGeehan, writing, "As an Irish Catholic, his views were perhaps prejudiced," and compared his case to the case against Socrates saying that "precisely the same accusations were brought — atheism and corrupting the young." [9]

Following his dismissal, Russell was hired by Albert C. Barnes, who wrote the foreword for The Bertrand Russell Case, to teach for the Barnes Foundation. However, Barnes dismissed Russell in December 1942 due to his distaste for lecturing and his impolite attitude towards students, which violated Barnes's ideas of democracy and education. [10]

Book by Dewey and Kallen

John Dewey John Dewey cph.3a51565.jpg
John Dewey

In 1941, John Dewey and Horace M. Kallen published The Bertrand Russell Case, a collection of articles defending Russell's appointment and criticizing McGeehan's ruling, characterizing it as unjust, punitive, and libelous. [3]

Themes

A major theme treated by the book is the necessity of academic freedom in American universities. [3] Many of the essayists featured in the Bertrand Russell Case see Russell's dismissal as a microcosm of American democracy, in which freedom of expression is stifled by religious individuals. [3] Additionally, many of the book's authors discuss at length the necessity for academic disciplines to feature counter-cultural thinkers, as they are skeptical of a framework of thought enforced by religious or political individuals. [3]

Contents

The Bertrand Russell Case contains an introduction by John Dewey, a foreword by Albert C. Barnes, and nine essays. [3] Kallen and Dewey each contributed a single essay to the collection. [3] While most of the articles are written by philosophers and other academics and argue in favor of Russell and academic freedom, the article "The Attitude of the Episcopal Church," which argues that Manning's assertions do not reflect the opinion of the church as a whole, was written by Guy Emery Shipler, editor of The Churchman, and "The Case as a School Administrator Sees it" was written by Carleton Washburne, an Illinois Superintendent. [3]

Reception

The Bertrand Russell Case was celebrated by many academics for its defense of academic freedom. In a review for the American Association of University Professors, Peter A. Carmichael writes, "The authors of this book deserve praise for their able defense of intellectual freedom and of a very great intellect," despite the book's lack of any religious perspective. [11] Writing for the History of Science Society's publication Isis , M. F. Ashley Montagu characterizes The Bertrand Russell Case as "an important book" and argues that all scholars should read it in order to better resist the encroachment of religious forces into science and academic study. [12]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bertrand Russell</span> British philosopher and logician (1872–1970)

Bertrand Arthur William Russell, 3rd Earl Russell, was a British mathematician, philosopher, and public intellectual. He had influence on mathematics, logic, set theory, and various areas of analytic philosophy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Dewey</span> American philosopher, psychologist, and educational reformer (1859–1952)

John Dewey was an American philosopher, psychologist, and educational reformer. He was one of the most prominent American scholars in the first half of the twentieth century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Santayana</span> Spanish-American philosopher

Jorge Agustín Nicolás Ruiz de Santayana y Borrás, known in English as George Santayana, was a Spanish-American philosopher, essayist, poet, and novelist. Born in Spain, Santayana was raised and educated in the US from the age of eight and identified himself as an American, although he always retained a valid Spanish passport. At the age of 48, Santayana left his position at Harvard and returned to Europe permanently.

Academic freedom is the right of a teacher to instruct and the right of a student to learn in an academic setting unhampered by outside interference. It may also include the right of academics to engage in social and political criticism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">American Association of University Professors</span> Nonprofit charitable organization

The American Association of University Professors (AAUP) is an organization of professors and other academics in the United States. AAUP membership includes over 500 local campus chapters and 39 state organizations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sidney Hook</span> 20th-Century American philosopher

Sidney Hook was an American philosopher of pragmatism known for his contributions to the philosophy of history, the philosophy of education, political theory, and ethics. After embracing communism in his youth, Hook was later known for his criticisms of totalitarianism, both fascism and Marxism–Leninism. A social democrat, Hook sometimes cooperated with conservatives, particularly in opposing Marxism–Leninism. After World War II, he argued that members of such groups as the Communist Party USA and Leninists like democratic centralists could ethically be barred from holding the offices of public trust because they called for the violent overthrow of democratic governments.

Cultural pluralism is a term used when smaller groups within a larger society maintain their unique cultural identities, whereby their values and practices are accepted by the dominant culture, provided such are consistent with the laws and values of the wider society. As a sociological term, the definition and description of cultural pluralism has evolved. It has been described as not only a fact but a societal goal.

John E. McGeehan (1880–1968) was a lawyer, district attorney, and judge in New York City from 1917 to 1950.

Tenure is a category of academic appointment existing in some countries. A tenured post is an indefinite academic appointment that can be terminated only for cause or under extraordinary circumstances, such as financial exigency or program discontinuation. Tenure is a means of defending the principle of academic freedom, which holds that it is beneficial for society in the long run if scholars are free to hold and examine a variety of views.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cassius Jackson Keyser</span> American mathematician

Cassius Jackson Keyser was an American mathematician of pronounced philosophical inclinations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Albert C. Barnes</span> American art collector and educator (1872–1951)

Albert Coombs Barnes was an American chemist, businessman, art collector, writer, and educator, and the founder of the Barnes Foundation in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

Ellen Wolf Schrecker is an American professor emerita of American history at Yeshiva University. She has received the Frederick Ewen Academic Freedom Fellowship at the Tamiment Library at NYU. She is known primarily for her work in the history of McCarthyism. Historian Ronald Radosh has described her as "the dean of the anti-anti-Communist historians."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">City College of New York</span> Public college in New York City

The City College of the City University of New York is a public research university within the City University of New York (CUNY) system in New York City. Founded in 1847, City College was the first free public institution of higher education in the United States. It is the oldest of CUNY's 25 institutions of higher learning and is considered its flagship institution.

Thomas Munro was an American philosopher of art and professor of art history at Western Reserve University. He served as Curator of Education for the Cleveland Museum of Art for 36 years (1931–67).

Aspects of philosopher, mathematician and social activist Bertrand Russell's views on society changed over nearly 80 years of prolific writing, beginning with his early work in 1896, until his death in February 1970.

<i>Marriage and Morals</i> 1929 book by Bertrand Russell

Marriage and Morals is a 1929 book by philosopher Bertrand Russell, in which the author questions the Victorian notions of morality regarding sex and marriage.

Horace Meyer Kallen was a German-born American philosopher who supported pluralism and Zionism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1911 Brigham Young University modernism controversy</span>

The 1911 modernism controversy at Brigham Young University was an episode involving four professors at Brigham Young University (BYU), who between 1908 and 1911 widely taught evolution and higher criticism of the Bible, arguing that modern scientific thought was compatible with Christian and Mormon theology. The professors were popular among students and the community but their teachings concerned administrators, and drew complaints from stake presidents, eventually resulting in the resignation of all four faculty members, an event that "leveled a serious blow to the academic reputation of Brigham Young University—one from which the Mormon school did not fully recover until successive presidential administrations."

The political views of American academics began to receive attention in the 1930s, and investigation into faculty political views expanded rapidly after the rise of McCarthyism. Demographic surveys of faculty that began in the 1950s and continue to the present have found higher percentages of liberals than of conservatives, particularly among those who work in the humanities and social sciences. Researchers and pundits disagree about survey methodology and about the interpretations of the findings.

Heresy, Yes—Conspiracy, No was a 283-page anti-communist book by New York University philosophy professor Sidney Hook, which John Day Company, published in May 1953, about conflicts between support for Communism and for academic freedom in America. The book became "perhaps the most influential justification for firing Communists and suspected Communists from university and schools in the early 1950s" during McCarthyism.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Russell, Bertrand, 1872-1970. (1953). Why I am not a Christian : and other essays on religion and related subjects . Edwards, Paul, 1923-2004,, Rouben Mamoulian Collection (Library of Congress). New York. ISBN   0-671-20323-1. OCLC   376363.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  2. McCarthy, Joseph M. (May 1993). The Russell Case: Academic Freedom vs. Public Hysteria (PDF). Educational Resources Information Center. p. 9.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Dewey, John (1941). The Bertrand Russell case. New York: Viking Press. OCLC   1075517285.
  4. Kennedy, Walter B.; White, William R. Jr. (1941). "The Bertrand Russell Case Again". Fordham L. Rev. 10 (2). Fordham University: 196–218. Retrieved November 17, 2017.
  5. "Sex Seer", in Time, November 4, 1929.
  6. Editors, Law Review (1940). "The Bertrand Russell Litigation". The University of Chicago Law Review. 8 (2). The University of Chicago: 316–325. Retrieved November 17, 2017.{{cite journal}}: |last= has generic name (help)
  7. "School Boards--Discretionary Power--Appointment of Professors--Judicial Review (Kay v.Board of Higher Education, 193 Misc. 943 (1940))". St. John's Law Review. 15 (1). St. John's: Article 24. November 1940. Retrieved November 17, 2017.
  8. Russell, Third Earl Bertrand (June 6, 2017). In Praise of Idleness: The Classic Essay with a New Introduction by Bradley Trevor Greive. Macmillan. ISBN   9781250098726.
  9. Feinberg, Barry; Kasrils, Ronald (January 4, 2013). Bertrand Russell's America: His Transatlantic Travels and Writings. Volume One 1896-1945. Routledge. ISBN   9781135099558.
  10. Barnes, Albert C. (c. 1944). The case of Bertrand Russell versus democracy and education /. Merion, Pa. hdl:2027/uc1.$b365974.
  11. Carmichael, Peter A. (1941). "Review of The Bertrand Russell Case". Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors. 27 (5): 601–610. doi:10.2307/40219116. ISSN   0883-1610. JSTOR   40219116.
  12. Montagu, M. F. Ashley (1943). "Review of The Bertrand Russell Case". Isis. 34 (3): 221–222. doi:10.1086/347803. ISSN   0021-1753. JSTOR   225851.

    Bibliography