The Blood Red Tape of Charity

Last updated

The Blood Red Tape of Charity
The Blood Red Tape of Charity still.jpg
A still from the lost film (Chaney is on the left)
Directed by Edwin August
Written byEdwin August
Produced by Pat Powers
StarringEdwin August
Unknown
Lon Chaney [1]
Distributed by Universal Film Manufacturing Company
Release date
  • September 26, 1913 (1913-09-26)
Running time
1 reel [1]
CountryUnited States
LanguagesSilent
English intertitles

The Blood Red Tape of Charity is a 1913 American silent short propaganda drama film written, directed and starring Edwin August and produced by Pat Powers. August wrote the scenario with the intent to highlight the evils of organized charity while entertaining the viewers. The film focuses on William Weldon, a telegraph lineman who is injured on the job and cannot work for several weeks. The family seeks aid from charity organizations, but "red tape" regulations prevent the family from receiving timely assistance. A gentleman thief named Marx decides to do one last job for the benefit of the family. He forces a doctor to treat the Weldon's invalid daughter Alice before proceeding to rob a charity ball's attendees. Marx pawns the stolen articles and saves the family before turning himself in to the police.

Contents

The film was released on September 26, 1913, and played in theaters throughout the United States. The unbilled cast list has been stated to include Lon Chaney in the role of the pawn broker. The Charity Organization Societies sought to produce a film to counter the negative portrayal of charities in The Blood Red Tape of Charity. P. L. Whitney stopped short of directly calling the film's portrayal dangerous, but advocated that charity members use the media to highlight the film's faults and exaggerations. Patricia Erens would use the surviving film still of the pawn broker, claimed to be Lon Chaney by scholars, as an example of Jewish character archetypes that were prominent in silent films. The film is now considered lost, with only a surviving still and the plot details available online. [2] [3]

Synopsis

The film's plot survives because of Universal's publication of the details in Moving Picture News . The official description is as follows:

"Charity, through excessive organization, often defeats its own purpose. William Weldon, a telegraph lineman, is the father of a large family, and finds it a hard struggle to make ends meet on his small wages. By a fall from a telegraph pole one afternoon he sustains injuries which force a lay-off for several weeks. His family is left destitute and, after a time, seek aid from various charity organizations. In each case the organization promises to make a full investigation and do what they can, but by the time all the red tape and rules are complied with, the family would starve. In the meantime, Marx, a gentleman thief who has a secret retreat in the same building in which the Weldon family live, meets the invalid daughter, Alice Weldon. She tells him of the family's condition and Marx endeavors to aid her, although at the time he is out of ready cash himself. Taking desperate measures, he holds up a doctor and forces him to attend to Weldon's needs. Then, in company with the female leader of the gang, he attends the charity ball. There he makes a haul — plucking jewelry and trinkets from every one with whom he comes in contact. He pawns the stolen articles and uses the money to help the Weldons. After the family has recovered, through Marx's aid, the charity organizations finally send a few dollars and a skimpy supply of food. Marx decides to reform — in fact, his reformation has been intended for some time, and his last "job" was only the outcome of his desire to do a worthy charity. He goes to the police, declares himself, and surrenders. Marx is sentenced, and while sitting in his cell a vision of Alice appeared before him, repaying him for his sacrifice and charity." [4]

Cast

It is possible that Mary Charleston was a part of the cast due to Edwin August's having been noted as working with her in Powers' productions. [6]

Production

According to an interview with Dorothy Donnell, Edwin August wrote The Blood Red Tape of Charity with an intent on showing the evils of organized charity. [7] He also directed the production. [5]

Within months of completing this production, August would leave Universal. Donnell stated that August was tired of earning money for other people when he would make more under his own brand. [7]

The film's cast and credits were unbilled and very few details emerged, but two scholars have claimed that it featured Lon Chaney. Jon Mirsalis states that Chaney has an unbilled part as a pawnbroker. [5] Michael Blake notes that Chaney had a role in the film, but also states that the film had only one reel and lists the production code as 0119. Blake's claim that it was a single reel is the subject of dispute because the release was originally referred to as a two-reel production in publications and many advertisements. Indeed, Blake's book cites a review from "Moving Picture World" that stated "Edwin August has written a brilliant two-part drama along this theme....", but he doesn't state if a two-part movie means one or two reels. [8] [9]

Release

Contemporary newspaper advertising a double feature with The Blood Red Tape of Charity The Blood Red Tape of Charity - newspaperad - 1913.jpg
Contemporary newspaper advertising a double feature with The Blood Red Tape of Charity

The film was released on September 26, 1913, by Universal Film Manufacturing Company under the Powers label. [9] On August 15, 1913, prior to the film's release, the Daily Capital Journal of Salem, Oregon contained a brief section on Edwin August which lists The Blood Red Tape of Charity as one of his latest successes. [6] This occurred more than a month prior to the film's release, and is not known to have appeared in any other source or any known pre-release viewing event. After the film was released nationwide, advertisements for its viewing appeared in newspapers including in El Paso, Texas, [10] Chicago, Illinois, [11] Indiana, [12] Iowa, [13] [14] Ohio, [15] Nebraska, [16] Kansas, [17] and Pennsylvania. [18] [19]

Reception

Jon C. Mirsalis's website cites a review in Moving Picture World which states, "There is considerable strength in the offering, but it has some bad faults. One of these is melodramatic and insincere acting. The photography is good and in spite of numerous absurdities the picture has strong moments." [5] Descriptive ads for the film were often informative; an ad by the Crystal Theater indicates that August wrote and acted in the film, but also did not shy away from film's depiction of charity organizations and instead promoted the film's defining message as "Charity Organizations Pay Dearly for Incompetency". [13] Another advertisement cites the New York World review detailing the propaganda film's intent to gain public attention to incite a "regeneration" of charitable organizations. [20] An advertisement in the El Paso Herald by the Alamo Theater described the film as "a beautiful story of love, devotion and charity. It is a strong moral lesson and should appeal to the "charity workers" in this country." [10] The advertisement also said the film would make viewers more charitable and good, [10] but that the film's critique on charity workers in particular would be far from appealing or well received.

The film provoked a response by the Charity Organization Societies because of its melodramatic and exaggerated depiction of the family's suffering due to regulation delays. In its response to letters about the film, the Charity Organization Bulletin wished for a scenario to be written and produced to "give a true picture of the work done by organized charity." [21] In the book The Charity Organization Movement in the United States: A Study in American Philanthropy, Volume 19, the film is said to be to an attack on organized charity by a distortion of the facts. [22]

These characterizations were accurate, as August's intention to instruct and entertain audiences of the evils of organized charity makes The Blood Red Tape of Charity a propaganda film by definition. [7]

Another response by P. L. Whitney, Extension Secretary of United Charities, stopped short of calling the film outright dangerous, but noted its intent and the "poetic justice" that surrounds the two secretaries, one of whom results in Marx postponing his retirement, and later takes their jewelry to provide for the family.[ clarification needed ] Whitney advised the editor and readers to keep watch for the film and use the media to highlight its faults and exaggerations. [23]

Patricia Erens used the film still of the pawnbroker, claimed by Mirsalis to be Lon Chaney, as an example of the common depictions of Jews in her book The Jew in American Cinema . [5] [24]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lon Chaney</span> American actor (1883–1930)

Leonidas Frank "Lon" Chaney was an American actor and makeup artist. He is regarded as one of the most versatile and powerful actors of cinema, renowned for his characterizations of tortured, often grotesque and afflicted, characters and for his groundbreaking artistry with makeup. Chaney was known for his starring roles in such silent horror films as The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1923) and The Phantom of the Opera (1925). His ability to transform himself using makeup techniques that he developed earned him the nickname "The Man of a Thousand Faces".

<i>London After Midnight</i> (film) Lost 1927 American silent film

London After Midnight is a lost 1927 American silent mystery horror film directed and co-produced by Tod Browning and starring Lon Chaney, with Marceline Day, Conrad Nagel, Henry B. Walthall and Polly Moran. The film was distributed by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, and was written by Waldemar Young, based on the story "The Hypnotist" which was written by Browning. Merritt B. Gerstad was the cinematographer, and the sets were designed by Cedric Gibbons and Arnold Gillespie. Harry Sharrock was the assistant director. The film cost $151,666.14 to produce, and grossed $1,004,000. Chaney's real-life make-up case can be seen in the last scene of the film sitting on a table, the only time it ever appeared in a film.

<i>The Penalty</i> (1920 film) 1920 film

The Penalty is an American psychological thriller crime film starring Lon Chaney and originally released in 1920 by Goldwyn Pictures. The movie was directed by Wallace Worsley, and written by Philip Lonergan and Charles Kenyon, based upon the pulp novel by Gouverneur Morris. The supporting cast includes Charles Clary, Doris Pawn, Jim Mason, and Claire Adams. The copyright for the film was owned by Gouverneur Morris, who wrote the novel on which the film was based. The budget for the film was $88,868.00. Portions of the film were shot in San Francisco.

<i>The Wicked Darling</i> 1919 film

The Wicked Darling is a 1919 American silent crime film directed by Tod Browning, and starring Priscilla Dean, Wellington A. Playter and Lon Chaney as pickpocket "Stoop" Connors. This was the first time Lon Chaney appeared in a Tod Browning film, and many other collaborations between the two men would follow.

The Honor of the Family is a 1912 American silent short drama film produced by the Rex Motion Picture Company. The film is a melodramatic one between two brothers and a woman named Marja. Gerald admires the girl and warns his visiting brother, Claude, to leave her alone. Infatuated, Claude and Marja secretly marry before Claude returns to England with a promise to return for her. As the months pass, Marja becomes broken-hearted and attempts suicide, but ends up crippled for life. Claude dies and Gerald cares for Marja, even forging a letter to keep her spirits up. Marja comes to love Gerald and all is revealed on a later date.

The Ways of Fate is a 1913 American silent short romance film produced by the American Film Manufacturing Company. The film's directorial and producer roles have been both attributed to Allan Dwan, but other sources point to Wallace Reid as director. The film's fictional plot is centered on Jim Conway, who grew up wanting to avenge his father's death and headed West to seek his father's killer. Lost in the mountains, he is saved by a young woman and the two fall in love. After a few weeks with her, Conway reveals the reason he came west and the young woman's father overhears it. The old man confesses to killing Conway's father, over a game of cards, and bares his chest. Conway refuses to take revenge, because love had diminished such feelings. The film was released on April 19, 1913 and it had a widespread national release. It is not known whether the film currently survives, but it is presumed lost.

<i>Suspense</i> (1913 film) 1913 film

Suspense is a 1913 American silent short film thriller directed by Lois Weber and Phillips Smalley. Weber also wrote the scenario and stars in the film with Valentine Paul. The film features early examples of a split screen shot and a car chase.

<i>Shon the Piper</i> 1913 film

Shon the Piper is a 1913 American silent short historical romantic drama film directed by Otis Turner, starring Robert Z. Leonard and Lon Chaney. The film follows a Scottish Duke who disguises himself as a piper and falls in love with a woman by the name of Madge. The woman's father refuses to let the two marry because he wants his daughter to marry the Laird of the Isla. At the wedding, Shon steals Madge away and a battle ensues between the clans.

<i>Poor Jakes Demise</i> 1913 film

Poor Jake's Demise is a 1913 American silent short slapstick comedy film directed by Allen Curtis featuring Max Asher, Louise Fazenda, and Lon Chaney. The film focuses on Jake who finds his wife in a compromising position with another man and later takes his revenge with a seltzer bottle. It is one of several slapstick comedy films Chaney made for Universal at the start of his career and is also his first credited screen role.

The Sea Urchin is a 1913 American silent short romantic drama film directed by Edwin August and starring Jeanie MacPherson and Lon Chaney. The film was the earliest known character role by Lon Chaney and the first screenplay by MacPherson. The story follows a hunchback fisherman who finds a young girl and raises her into womanhood with the intention of marrying her. The film was released on August 22, 1913, and was played across the United States. The film is presumed lost.

<i>The Restless Spirit</i> 1913 film

The Restless Spirit is a 1913 American silent short drama film written and directed by Allan Dwan, featuring J. Warren Kerrigan, Lon Chaney, and Pauline Bush. The film is based on Thomas Gray's 1751 poem, Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard, and tells the story of a man who wishes to be a conqueror. A series of illusions follows which show him the futility of conquest when he cannot even conquer his own community.

<i>Back to Life</i> (1913 film) 1913 film by Allan Dwan

Back to Life is a 1913 American silent short drama film directed by Allan Dwan and featuring Pauline Bush, J. Warren Kerrigan, William Worthington and Lon Chaney. This was Chaney's first film with director Allan Dwan, which was followed by a dozen more. The film is now considered lost.

<i>Red Margaret, Moonshiner</i> 1913 film by Allan Dwan

Red Margaret, Moonshiner is a 1913 American silent short romance film directed by Allan Dwan, starring Pauline Bush, Murdock MacQuarrie and Lon Chaney. This film, now considered lost, is a good example of Chaney's early attempts at creating bizarre makeups to enhance his roles, wearing a long beard and wild hair here as "Lon", the old moonshiner. The film's original working title was Warrington's Honor. Some sources say the film was later edited down to one reel and re-released in theaters as Moonshine Blood in 1916.

<i>Bloodhounds of the North</i> 1913 film by Allan Dwan

Bloodhounds of the North is a 1913 American silent short drama film directed by Allan Dwan and starring Murdock MacQuarrie, Pauline Bush, and Lon Chaney. The film is now considered lost. Some sources state the film was edited down to one reel and re-released theatrically in 1916 as Accusing Evidence, but this is disputed.

<i>The Oubliette</i> 1914 film

The Oubliette is a 1914 American silent historical drama film directed by Charles Giblyn, featuring Murdock MacQuarrie, Pauline Bush, and Lon Chaney. It is part one of a four-film series directed by Giblyn called The Adventures of François Villon. The Oubliette was written by Harry G. Stafford, based on a short story of the same name by George Bronson Howard published in The Century Magazine.

Bound on the Wheel is a 1915 American short silent drama film directed by Joe De Grasse and featuring Lon Chaney. It was written by Ida May Park, based on a story by Jules Furthman. The film is now presumed lost.

<i>The Grand Passion</i> 1918 film

The Grand Passion is a 1918 American silent Western film directed by Ida May Park and starring Dorothy Phillips, Jack Mulhall, and Lon Chaney. Ida May Park also wrote the screenplay, based on a novel The Boss of Powderville by Thomas Addison. The film was allegedly shown in some theaters under the title of The Boss of Powderville.

<i>Riddle Gawne</i> 1918 film

Riddle Gawne is a 1918 American silent Western film directed by William S. Hart and Lambert Hillyer, and featuring William S. Hart, Katherine MacDonald and Lon Chaney. The film was co-produced by William S. Hart and Thomas H. Ince. The screenplay was written by Charles Alden Seltzer from his earlier novel The Vengeance of Jefferson Gawne. Chaney historian Jon C. Mirsalis claims that William S. Hart contributed greatly to the screenplay but all other sources credit the writing of the screenplay solely to Charles Alden Seltzer.

<i>Treasure Island</i> (1920 film) 1920 film by Maurice Tourneur

Treasure Island is a 1920 silent film adaptation of the 1883 novel by Robert Louis Stevenson, directed by Maurice Tourneur, and released by Paramount Pictures. Lon Chaney played two different pirate roles in this production, "Blind Pew" and "Merry", and stills exist showing him in both makeups. Charles Ogle, who had played Frankenstein's Monster in the first filmed version of Frankenstein a decade earlier at Edison Studios, portrayed Long John Silver. Wallace Beery was supposed to play Israel Hands, but that role went to Joseph Singleton instead. The film was chosen as one of the Top Forty Pictures of the Year by the National Board of Review.

<i>When Bearcat Went Dry</i> 1919 film

When Bearcat Went Dry is a 1919 American silent drama film directed by Oliver L. Sellers from the novel by Charles Neville Buck, and starring Lon Chaney as Kindard Powers. The title refers to a character nicknamed "Bearcat" who promises his girlfriend that he will quit drinking liquor. The plot involving a promise to give up drinking was timely given the passage of the Wartime Prohibition Act, which took effect on June 30, 1919, and banned the sale of alcoholic beverages, and ratification of the Eighteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution in January of the same year.

References

  1. 1 2 Blake, Michael F. (1998). "The Films of Lon Chaney". Vestal Press Inc. Page 2. ISBN   1-879511-26-6.
  2. ↑ "Silent Era : Progressive Silent Film List". www.silentera.com. Retrieved March 11, 2022.
  3. ↑ Moving Picture News (Jul - Oct 1913). MBRS Library of Congress. Cinematograph Publishing Company. July 1913.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: others (link)
  4. ↑ "Moving Picture News (Jul - Oct 1913) (Jul - Oct 1913)". Cinematograph Publishing Company. 1913. p. 444. Retrieved September 11, 2014.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Mirsalis, Jon. The Blood Red Tape of Charity. Lon Chaney.org.
  6. 1 2 "Screen Favorite is clever Photoplay Artist". Daily Capital Journal (Salem, Oregon). August 15, 1913. p. 4. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  7. 1 2 3 "The Motion Picture Story Magazine (Feb-Jul 1914) (Feb-Jul 1914)". The Motion Picture Publishing Co. 1914. p. 845. Retrieved September 11, 2014.
  8. ↑ Blake, Michael F. (2001). The Films of Lon Chaney. Madison Books. p. 2.
  9. 1 2 "Exhibitors' Times (May-Sep 1913) (May-Sep 1913)". Wm. A. Johnston. 1913. p. 28. Retrieved September 11, 2014.
  10. 1 2 3 "(El Paso Herald Ad)". El Paso Herald (El Paso, Texas). September 26, 1913. p. 5. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  11. ↑ "Linden Photodrome". Suburbanite Economist (Chicago, Illinois). September 26, 1913. p. 3. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  12. ↑ "Edwin August at the Colonial". The Huntington Herald (Huntington, Indiana). September 26, 1913. p. 5. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  13. 1 2 "(Crystal Theater Ad)". The Evening Gazette (Cedar Rapids, Iowa). September 26, 1913. p. 11. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  14. ↑ "(Grand Ad)". The Perry Daily Chief (Perry, Iowa). October 20, 1913. p. 2. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  15. ↑ "American Theatre Open From One Till Eleven O'Clock Monday". The Chronicle-Telegram (Elyria, Ohio). September 29, 1913. p. 1. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  16. ↑ "(Crystal Theater Ad)". The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune (North Platte, Nebraska). October 3, 1913. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  17. ↑ "(Lyric Theater Ad)". The Ottawa Daily Republic (Ottawa, Kansas). October 20, 1913. p. 3. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  18. ↑ "(Colonial Ad)". The Indiana Gazette (Indiana, Pennsylvania). November 6, 1913. p. 1. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  19. ↑ "(Gem Theater Ad)". The Daily Republican (Monongahela, Pennsylvania). November 12, 1913. p. 1. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  20. ↑ "(The Patee Ad)". Lawrence Daily Journal-World (Lawrence, Kansas). October 25, 1913. p. 5. Retrieved September 12, 2014– via Newspapers.com.
  21. ↑ "Charity Organization Bulletin]". Charity Organization Department of the Russell Sage Foundation. 1913. pp. 165–167. Retrieved September 11, 2014.
  22. ↑ Watson, Frank Dekker (1922). The Charity Organization Movement in the United States: A Study in American Philanthropy, Volume 19. Macmillan. p.  516 . Retrieved September 11, 2014. Blood Red Tape of Charity.
  23. ↑ The Survey: Social, Charitable, Civic : a Journal of Constructive Philanthropy, Volume 31. Charity Organization Society of the City of New York. 1914. pp. 207–208.
  24. ↑ Erens, Patricia (1988). The Jew in American Cinema . Indiana University Press. pp.  70, 108. ISBN   0253204933.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.