The Dream of Reality

Last updated
Low-res-book-cover-The-Dream-of-Reality-Lynn-Segal.jpg
First edition cover
AuthorLynn Segal
Country United States
Language English
Subject Heinz von Foerster, Constructivist epistemology
Genre Philosophy
PublisherWW Norton
Publication date
1986
ISBN 0393700267
OCLC 13005603
LC Class BD161 .S39 1986
Website http://lynnsegal.com/book_dream.html

The Dream of Reality: Heinz von Foerster's Constructivism is a book by Lynn Segal first published in 1986. [1] Segal, a licensed clinical social worker, examines the constructivist epistemology of physicist and philosopher Heinz von Foerster. Originally intended as a transcription of von Foerster's lectures, the book evolved into Segal's interpretation of von Foerster's constructivism written in everyday language. [2]

Contents

Synopsis

The book begins with a foreword by Paul Watzlawick, a preface by the author, and an introduction which provides a synopsis of the book's content and structure. In chapter one, The Myth of Objectivity, Segal introduces the objectivity vs. constructivist epistemology debate, illustrated with examples of making sense of undifferentiated sensory input and eigenvalue puzzles, where the observer is necessary. In chapter two, The Difficulties of Language, the author describes what we can learn about epistemology from syllogisms, paradox, self-reference, and causality, finally focusing on the circular causality described in cybernetics. In the third chapter, Maturana and the Observer, Segal reviews Humberto Maturana's "observer-based science" where the object observed is not assumed to exist independent of the observer. The Nervous System is the next chapter, where Segal surveys the historical theories connecting perception and thought, including theories by Aristotle, Alkmaeon, Hippocrates, Galen, William Harvey, René Descartes, and Santiago Ramón y Cajal. In this chapter the author also looks at the evolution, structure, and function, of the nervous system and its relationship to the endocrine system. The fifth chapter, Computation, examines how computation happens in both computers and brains, using formal logic and trivial and non-trivial logical machines as conceptual tools to distinguish the two. Humans have capacity to "compute" in additional domains beyond mathematical-logical, including sensory and semantic domains. In chapter six, Biocomputation, Segal looks at how neural circuits work to calculate Boolean operations, and how these circuits fire in the presence of different but ignore sameness. In the final chapter, Closure, the author looks at closure across thermodynamics, mathematics, systems theory, and autopoesis. Segal goes on to examine the double closure of the nervous system along its sensorimotor and synapitc-endocrine dimensions. He returns to mathematics to examine recursion theory, cognition, and solipsism. The book ends with an interview with Heinz von Foerster conducted by media studies professor Carol Wilder.

Publication

The first edition of the book was published in 1986 by W. W. Norton. A second edition of the book was published in 2001 by Springer with some corrections from von Foerster. [3]

Reception

The book received both mixed and positive reviews from the mental health and academic communities. Psychiatrist Peter Bruggen, reviewing the book for the Journal of Family Therapy , notes that Segal's discussions around paradox, reality, and the role of the observer are easier to follow than other writers such as Bateson and Maturana, even if Segal's logic is difficult to follow at times. [4] Writing for Contemporary Psychology , David E. Presti questions Segal's application of neuroscience principles to questions of epistemology, [5] while Klaus Krippendorff reviewing for the Journal of Communication praises Segal's ability to clearly present von Foerster's ideas, even if the book doesn't explore counterarguments. [6] Linda Ade-Ridder writes in her review for Family Relations , "Written for anyone interested in exploring the concepts of objectivity and reality, this concise volume translates the ideas behind radical constructivism into a very readable form. Therapists will find the ideas particularly thought-provoking through the exploration of how language and logic shape thinking, especially within psychotheraputic models." [7] In The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Family Therapy , psychiatrist Bill McLeod describes the book as "difficult but rewarding." [8]

Related Research Articles

Warren Sturgis McCulloch was an American neurophysiologist and cybernetician, known for his work on the foundation for certain brain theories and his contribution to the cybernetics movement. Along with Walter Pitts, McCulloch created computational models based on mathematical algorithms called threshold logic which split the inquiry into two distinct approaches, one approach focused on biological processes in the brain and the other focused on the application of neural networks to artificial intelligence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heinz von Foerster</span> Austrian-American scientist and cybernetician (1911–2002)

Heinz von Foerster was an Austrian-American scientist combining physics and philosophy, and widely attributed as the originator of second-order cybernetics. He was twice a Guggenheim fellow and also was a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1980. He is well known for his 1960 Doomsday equation formula published in Science predicting future population growth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Social constructionism</span> Sociological theory regarding shared understandings

Social constructionism is a term used in sociology, social ontology, and communication theory. The term can serve somewhat different functions in each field; however, the foundation of this theoretical framework suggests various facets of social reality—such as concepts, beliefs, norms, and values—are formed through continuous interactions and negotiations among society's members, rather than empirical observation of physical reality. The theory of social constructionism posits that much of what individuals perceive as 'reality' is actually the outcome of a dynamic process of construction influenced by social conventions and structures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constructivism (philosophy of science)</span> Branch in philosophy of science

Constructivism is a view in the philosophy of science that maintains that scientific knowledge is constructed by the scientific community, which seeks to measure and construct models of the natural world. According to constructivists, natural science consists of mental constructs that aim to explain sensory experiences and measurements, and that there is no single valid methodology in science but rather a diversity of useful methods. They also hold that the world is independent of human minds, but knowledge of the world is always a human and social construction. Constructivism opposes the philosophy of objectivism, embracing the belief that human beings can come to know the truth about the natural world not mediated by scientific approximations with different degrees of validity and accuracy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sociocybernetics</span> Research field

Sociocybernetics is an interdisciplinary science between sociology and general systems theory and cybernetics. The International Sociological Association has a specialist research committee in the area – RC51 – which publishes the (electronic) Journal of Sociocybernetics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constructivism (philosophy of education)</span> Philosophical viewpoint about the nature of knowledge; theory of knowledge

Constructivism is a theory in education which posits that individuals or learners do not acquire knowledge and understanding by passively perceiving it within a direct process of knowledge transmission, rather they construct new understandings and knowledge through experience and social discourse, integrating new information with what they already know. For children, this includes knowledge gained prior to entering school. It is associated with various philosophical positions, particularly in epistemology as well as ontology, politics, and ethics. The origin of the theory is also linked to Swiss developmental psychologist Jean Piaget's theory of cognitive development.

Radical constructivism is an approach to epistemology that situates knowledge in terms of knowers' experience. It looks to break with the conception of knowledge as a correspondence between a knower's understanding of their experience and the world beyond that experience. Adopting a skeptical position towards correspondence as in principle impossible to verify because one cannot access the world beyond one's experience in order to test the relation, radical constructivists look to redefine epistemology in terms of the viability of knowledge within knowers' experience. This break from the traditional framing of epistemology differentiates it from "trivial" forms of constructivism that emphasise the role of the knower in constructing knowledge while maintaining the traditional perspective of knowledge in terms of correspondence. Radical constructivism has been described as a "post-epistemological" position.

Second-order cybernetics, also known as the cybernetics of cybernetics, is the recursive application of cybernetics to itself and the reflexive practice of cybernetics according to such a critique. It is cybernetics where "the role of the observer is appreciated and acknowledged rather than disguised, as had become traditional in western science". Second-order cybernetics was developed between the late 1960s and mid 1970s by Heinz von Foerster and others, with key inspiration coming from Margaret Mead. Foerster referred to it as "the control of control and the communication of communication" and differentiated first order cybernetics as "the cybernetics of observed systems" and second-order cybernetics as "the cybernetics of observing systems".

Ranulph Glanville was an Anglo-Irish cybernetician and design theorist. He was a founding vice-president of the International Academy for Systems and Cybernetic Sciences (2006–2009) and president of the American Society for Cybernetics (2009–2014).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Humberto Maturana</span> Chilean biologist and philosopher (1928–2021)

Humberto Maturana Romesín was a Chilean biologist and philosopher. Many consider him a member of a group of second-order cybernetics theoreticians such as Heinz von Foerster, Gordon Pask, Herbert Brün and Ernst von Glasersfeld, but in fact he was a biologist, scientist.

In psychology, constructivism refers to many schools of thought that, though extraordinarily different in their techniques, are all connected by a common critique of previous standard approaches, and by shared assumptions about the active constructive nature of human knowledge. In particular, the critique is aimed at the "associationist" postulate of empiricism, "by which the mind is conceived as a passive system that gathers its contents from its environment and, through the act of knowing, produces a copy of the order of reality".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stuart Umpleby</span>

Stuart Anspach Umpleby is an American cybernetician and professor in the Department of Management and Director of the Research Program in Social and Organizational Learning in the School of Business at the George Washington University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">American Society for Cybernetics</span> Organization

The American Society for Cybernetics (ASC) is an American non-profit scholastic organization for the advancement of cybernetics as a science, a discipline, a meta-discipline and the promotion of cybernetics as basis for an interdisciplinary discourse. The society does this by developing and applying cybernetics’ concepts which are presented and published via its conferences and peer-reviewed publications. As a meta-discipline, it creates bridges between disciplines, philosophies, sciences, and arts. The ASC is a full member of the International Federation for Systems Research (IFSR).

Constructivist Foundations is an international triannual peer-reviewed academic journal that focuses on constructivist approaches to science and philosophy, including radical constructivism, enactive cognitive science, second-order cybernetics, biology of cognition and the theory of autopoietic systems, and non-dualizing philosophy. It was established in 2005 and the editor-in-chief is Alexander Riegler.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cybernetics</span> Transdisciplinary field concerned with regulatory and purposive systems

Cybernetics is a field of systems theory that studies circular causal systems whose outputs are also inputs, such as feedback systems. It is concerned with the general principles of circular causal processes, including in ecological, technological, biological, cognitive and social systems and also in the context of practical activities such as designing, learning, and managing.

The Biological Computer Laboratory (BCL) was a research institute of the Department of Electrical Engineering at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. It was founded on 1 January 1958, by then Professor of Electrical Engineering Heinz von Foerster. He was head of BCL until his retirement in 1975.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bernhard Pörksen</span> German media scholar (born 1969)

Bernhard Pörksen is a German media scholar.

Autonomous agency theory (AAT) is a viable system theory (VST) which models autonomous social complex adaptive systems. It can be used to model the relationship between an agency and its environment(s), and these may include other interactive agencies. The nature of that interaction is determined by both the agency's external and internal attributes and constraints. Internal attributes may include immanent dynamic "self" processes that drive agency change.

Relational constructivism can be perceived as a relational consequence of radical constructivism. In contrary to social constructivism, it picks up the epistemological threads and maintains the radical constructivist idea that humans cannot overcome their limited conditions of reception. Therefore, humans are not able to come to objective conclusions about the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Josef Mitterer</span>

Josef Mitterer is an Austrian philosopher, and a retired professor at the University of Klagenfurt Department of Philosophy.

References

  1. Segal, Lynn (1986). The dream of reality : Heinz von Foerster's constructivism . New York: W. W. Norton. ISBN   978-0393700268. OCLC   13005603.
  2. Book News, Inc. (November 2001). "The dream of reality; Heinz von Foerster's constructivism, 2d ed". Reference and Research Book News. 16 (4). ISSN   0887-3763. Segal, a psychotherapist, initiated this work as a transcription of von Foerster's lecture material; but it evolved instead into an interpretation of von Foerster's ideas in accessible language.
  3. Segal, Lynn (2001). The dream of reality: Heinz von Foerster's constructivism (Second ed.). New York: Springer. ISBN   978-0387951300. OCLC   247384802.
  4. Bruggen, Peter (1987). "Book Reviews: The Dream of Reality: Heinz von Foerster's Constructivism". Journal of Family Therapy. 9 (4): 398.
  5. Presti, David E. (1987). "What Goes Around Comes Around...". Contemporary Psychology. 32 (6): 556–557. doi:10.1037/027236. Discussion proceeds from the myth of objectivity, to arguments that our language misleads us into believing that we discover things about the world rather than invent them, to outlines of notions about the nervous system and computation. However, the arguments proposed often have dubious relevance to the question (such as the derision of localization of function in the central nervous system) and are sometimes very misleading.
  6. Krippendorff, Klaus (1987). "Nourishing the core". Journal of Communication. Spring: 155–158. Segal thus amicably succeeded in making rather profound insights seductively easy to read and in maintaining von Foerster's oratory flair -- one can virtually see von Foerster talk when reading the book....True to one of cybernetics' ethical imperatives -- that choices should always increase the range of options available-- the book opens more doors than it closes. Perhaps Segal could have been more critical and have explored the alternative paths behind these doors.
  7. Ade-Ridder, Linda (April 1987). "Book Briefs: The Dream of Reality: Heinz von Foerster's Constructivism". Family Relations. 36 (2): 222. doi:10.2307/583958. JSTOR   583958.
  8. McLeod, Bill (1990). "Book Reviews: The Dream of Reality: Heinz von Foerster's Constructivism". The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Family Therapy . 11 (3): 187. doi:10.1002/j.1467-8438.1990.tb00820.x. ISSN   0814-723X. This is a difficult but rewarding book. It is difficult in that it skilfully presents the work of Heinz von Foerster while also presenting ideas from philosophy, cybernetics, physics and physiology. It is rewarding for it challenges our ordinary way of thinking and invites confrontation with the constructivist approaches to our knowledge of the world. Also it offers a challenge that if taken up will radically alter the conduct of therapy.