The Polish Peasant in Europe and America

Last updated
The Polish Peasant in Europe and America
Znaniecki 1918 the polish peasant in europe and america cover.png
Cover (or one of the intro pages) of the first (1918) edition of the book
Author Florian Znaniecki, William I. Thomas
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Subject Sociology, immigration
Media typePrint

The Polish Peasant in Europe and America is a book by Florian Znaniecki and William I. Thomas, considered to be one of the classics of sociology. The book is a study of Polish immigrants to the United States and their families, based on personal documents, and was published in five volumes in the years 1918 to 1920.

Contents

Theme

At the turn of the 20th century, Poles accounted for about a quarter of all new immigrants to the United States. [1] Chicago was host to about 350,000 Poles and had the third largest population of Poles (after Warsaw and Łódź). [1]

The Polish Peasant in Europe and America was the culmination of research by American sociologist William I. Thomas and Polish scholar Florian Znaniecki, carried out primarily during their time at the University of Chicago and supported by a substantial grant from millionaire Helen Culver. [2] [3] It is a study of Polish immigrants to America and their families based on personal documents (primarily letters) as well as on documents such as brochures, newspaper articles, parish and court documents, and so on. [2] [4] [5]

The work opens with an introduction, or Methodological Note, written primarily by Znaniecki, in which he discusses the history and structure of Polish countryside, and the study's methodology. [6] [7] This topic is of primary concern of tomes one and two, with tomes three to five focusing on the recent changes to the Polish countryside, and the transformation of Polish peasant-immigrants in America. [4] [6] The third tome's major focus is the analysis an autobiography of one peasant, Władysław Wiśniewski. [8] [9]

Thomas was the originator of this study, having taken interest in studying immigrant communities of Chicago already in the 1890s. [10] He was also the originator of the concept of studying written materials for sociological insight, and initially intended this work to be a collection of translated and annotated primary documents. Znaniecki convinced him to extend this project into a larger work, one with a more detailed analysis of the topic subject, its methodology and corresponding theory. [11]

Thomas and Znaniecki intended to explore the relation between individuals and society, focusing on groups such as families and neighborhoods, and community ties, which they believed were key to social change. They argue that the Polish community was shaped less by US government policies, and more by its own culture and social ties. They stress the importance of the group, and attribute social disorganization to cases when individuals become isolated from a group (see also anomie). [12] The authors start by analyzing the circumstances of Polish countryside and reasons for immigration, [12] and in conclusion discuss the transformation of said immigrants, show that the Poles are becoming not American but Polish-Americans, a new ethnic group, as their culture is changing to fit the American context, but retaining some unique characteristics. [13]

The five tomes totaled about 2,232 pages. [1] They were published over three years: in 1918 (volumes I and II), 1919 (volume III) and 1920 (volumes IV and V). [14]

Controversies

The work has been subject to two major controversies. The first concerns a society scandal that enveloped Thomas around 1918, which resulted in him losing his professorship at the University of Chicago, and the University of Chicago Press cancelling its deal with the authors about the printing of the first edition. Subsequently the book was published in the less prestigious Gorham Press from Boston. [15] [16]

The second controversy concerns the question of authorship, in particular with regards to whether Thomas or Znaniecki should be considered the primary author. The book's idea originated with Thomas; however after seeing Znaniecki's proposal for changing it from a collection of primary materials into an analytical piece, and reading his proposed re-framing introduction, Thomas proposed to him that they become co-authors. [17] [18] Dulczewski in his biography of Znaniecki concludes that the question is moot, as both had contributed to this work significantly and "neither would have been able to author this work by themselves". [19] While some consider Znaniecki to be a junior writer, Thomas himself wrote that "it would be quite impossible to establish who wrote what", and Bulmer concludes that "to regard Zaniecki as merely Thomas' assistant is incorrect... he took a major part in drafting the book... the two were true collaborators", with Znaniecki's skill in philosophy, methodology and the subject matter of Polish society complementing Thomas' expertise in sociology, social psychology, and the Polish-American Chicago community. [20]

Significance

This five-volume work is considered a classic of empirical sociology. [2] [14] Martin Bulmer in 1986 described it as a "neglected classic... landmark because it attempted to integrate theory and data in a way no American study had done before". [21] In the introduction to the 1996 edition, Eli Zaretsky argues it can be seen as a "founding work" of American sociology. [22]

It is a valuable contribution to the methodological development of the social sciences in the United States. [23] [24] The book had begun a shift from theoretical research into one grounded in empirical data. [21] Bulmer notes that "the subsequent use in sociological research of personal documents, such as life histories, letters, diaries, and other first-person material, may in large measure be traced back to the influence of The Polish Peasant. (This approach is known as content analysis, and this study has also been described as a classic case study of this approach [25] ). The life story of Władek was the first systematically collected sociological life history". [26]

It was a major influence on the Chicago school, providing a model for much future research. [24] [27] It contributed to the development of the social disorganization theory [24] [28] and became a landmark study of Americanization (in the word's original meaning, i.e. how do new immigrants to United States become "Americans"). [29] [30] It was also one of the earliest works to study the topic of immigration to the United States, particularly with regards to trying to understand both the European and the American social context. [31]

In 1937 the Social Science Research Council listed the book as one of the six most important works in social sciences. [29] A year later, Herbert Blumer headed a commission which produced an extensive, approximate 200-pages analysis of the book, and became the first tome in a series of Critiques of Research in the Social Science. [29] By 1939 it had at least 30 English reviews and 10 in different languages. [29]

A Polish edition, Chłop polski w Europie i Ameryce, was published in 1976. [32]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peasant</span> Agricultural laborer or farmer with limited land ownership

A peasant is a pre-industrial agricultural laborer or a farmer with limited land-ownership, especially one living in the Middle Ages under feudalism and paying rent, tax, fees, or services to a landlord. In Europe, three classes of peasants existed: non-free slaves, semi-free serfs, and free tenants. Peasants might hold title to land outright, or by any of several forms of land tenure, among them socage, quit-rent, leasehold, and copyhold.

Life history is an interviewing method used to record autobiographical history from an ordinary person's perspective, often gathered from traditionally marginalized groups. It was begun by anthropologists studying Native American groups around the 1900s, and was taken up by sociologists and other scholars, though its popularity has waxed and waned since. One of the major strengths of the life history method is that it provides a kind of voice from a social milieu that is often overlooked or indeed invisible in intellectual discourse.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Science studies</span> Research area analyzing scientific expertise

Science studies is an interdisciplinary research area that seeks to situate scientific expertise in broad social, historical, and philosophical contexts. It uses various methods to analyze the production, representation and reception of scientific knowledge and its epistemic and semiotic role.

The Chicago school refers to a school of thought in sociology and criminology originating at the University of Chicago whose work was influential in the early 20th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Florian Znaniecki</span> Polish and American philosopher and sociologist

Florian Witold Znaniecki was a Polish and American philosopher and sociologist who taught and wrote in Poland and in the United States. Over the course of his work, he shifted his focus from philosophy to sociology. He remains a major figure in the history of Polish and American sociology; the founder of Polish academic sociology, and of an entire school of thought in sociology. He won international renown as co-author, with William I. Thomas, of the study, The Polish Peasant in Europe and America (1918–1920), which is considered the foundation of modern empirical sociology. He also made major contributions to sociological theory, introducing terms such as humanistic coefficient and culturalism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of sociology</span>

Sociology as a scholarly discipline emerged, primarily out of Enlightenment thought, as a positivist science of society shortly after the French Revolution. Its genesis owed to various key movements in the philosophy of science and the philosophy of knowledge, arising in reaction to such issues as modernity, capitalism, urbanization, rationalization, secularization, colonization and imperialism.

Herbert George Blumer was an American sociologist whose main scholarly interests were symbolic interactionism and methods of social research. Believing that individuals create social reality through collective and individual action, he was an avid interpreter and proponent of George Herbert Mead's social psychology, which he labeled symbolic interactionism. Blumer elaborated and developed this line of thought in a series of articles, many of which were brought together in the book Symbolic Interactionism. An ongoing theme throughout his work, he argued that the creation of social reality is a continuous process. Blumer was also a vociferous critic of positivistic methodological ideas in sociology.

Humanistic sociology is a domain of sociology which originated mainly from the work of the University of Chicago Polish philosopher-turned-sociologist, Florian Znaniecki. It is a methodology which treats its objects of study and its students, that is, humans, as composites of values and systems of values. In certain contexts, the term is related to other sociological domains such as antipositivism. Humanistic sociology seeks to shed light on questions such as, "What is the relationship between a man of principle and a man of opportunism?"

<span class="mw-page-title-main">W. I. Thomas</span> American sociologist (1863–1947)

William Isaac Thomas was an American sociologist, understood today as a key figure behind the theory of symbolic interactionism.

Analytic induction is a research strategy in sociology aimed at systematically developing causal explanations for types of phenomena. It was first outlined by Florian Znaniecki in 1934. He contrasted it with the kind of enumerative induction characteristic of statistical analysis. Where the latter was satisfied with probabilistic correlations, Znaniecki insisted that science is concerned with discovering causal universals, and that in social science analytic induction is the means of discovering these.

The life course approach, also known as the life course perspective or life course theory, refers to an approach developed in the 1960s for analyzing people's lives within structural, social, and cultural contexts. It views one's life as a socially sequenced timeline and recognizes the importance of factors such as generational succession and age in shaping behavior and career. Development does not end at childhood, but instead extends through multiple life stages to influence life trajectory.

Everett Cherrington Hughes was an American sociologist best known for his work on ethnic relations, work and occupations and the methodology of fieldwork. His take on sociology was, however, very broad. In recent scholarship, his theoretical contribution to sociology has been discussed as interpretive institutional ecology, forming a theoretical frame of reference that combines elements of the classical ecological theory of class, and elements of a proto-dependency analysis of Quebec's industrialization in the 1930s.

A humanistic coefficient is a conceptual object, methodological principle, or method of conducting social research wherein data analysis stresses the perceived import of analyzed experiences to their participants. The term was coined by Polish sociologist Florian Znaniecki.

The following events related to sociology occurred in the 1910s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sociology in Poland</span> Polish field of study

Sociology in Poland has been developing, as has sociology throughout Europe, since the mid-19th century. Although, due to the Partitions of Poland, that country did not exist as an independent state in the 19th century or until the end of World War I, some Polish scholars published work clearly belonging to the field of sociology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the family</span>

The history of the family is a branch of social history that concerns the sociocultural evolution of kinship groups from prehistoric to modern times. The family has a universal and basic role in all societies. Research on the history of the family crosses disciplines and cultures, aiming to understand the structure and function of the family from many viewpoints. For example, sociological, ecological or economical perspectives are used to view the interrelationships between the individual, their relatives, and the historical time. The study of family history has shown that family systems are flexible, culturally diverse and adaptive to ecological and economical conditions.

Helena Znaniecki Lopata was a Polish-born American sociologist, author and researcher.

In philosophy and sociology, culturalism is the central importance of culture as an organizing force in human affairs. It is also described as an ontological approach that seeks to eliminate simple binaries between seemingly opposing phenomena such as nature and culture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Martyn Hammersley</span> British sociologist (born 1949)

Martyn Hammersley is a British sociologist whose main publications cover social research methodology and philosophical issues in the social sciences.

Biographical research is a qualitative research approach aligned to the social interpretive paradigm of research. The biographical research is concerned with the reconstruction of life histories and the constitution of meaning based on biographical narratives and documents. The material for analysis consists of interview protocols (memorandums), video recordings, photographs, and a diversity of sources. These documents are evaluated and interpreted according to specific rules and criteria. The starting point for this approach is the understanding of an individual biography in terms of its social constitution. The biographical approach was influenced by the symbolic interactionism, the phenomenological sociology of knowledge, and ethnomethodology. Therefore, biography is understood in terms of a social construct and the reconstruction of biographies can give insight on social processes and figurations, thus helping to bridge the gap between micro-, meso-, and macro- levels of analysis. The biographical approach is particularly important in German sociology. This approach is used in the Social Sciences as well as in Pedagogy and other disciplines. The Research Committee 38 "Biography and Society" of the International Sociological Association (ISA) was created in 1984 and is dedicated "to help develop a better understanding of the relations between individual lives, the social structures and historical processes within which they take shape and which they contribute to shape, and the individual accounts of biographical experience ".

References

  1. 1 2 3 Bulmer 1986 , p. 50
  2. 1 2 3 Piotr Sztompka (2002). Socjologia: Analiza społeczeństwa. Znak. pp. 52–53. ISBN   978-83-240-0218-4.
  3. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , p. 47
  4. 1 2 Dulczewski 1984 , p. 169
  5. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , p. 52
  6. 1 2 Dulczewski 1984 , pp. 145–54
  7. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , p. 56
  8. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , pp. 52–4
  9. ↑ Dulczewski 1984 , pp. 166–9
  10. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , p. 46
  11. ↑ Dulczewski 1984 , pp. 141–4
  12. 1 2 Zaretsky, Znaniecki & Thomas1996 , pp. xxii–xiv
  13. ↑ Zaretsky, Znaniecki & Thomas 1996 , p. 105
  14. 1 2 Zaretsky, Znaniecki & Thomas 1996 , pp. 11
  15. ↑ Dulczewski 1984 , pp. 164–6
  16. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , pp. 59–60
  17. ↑ Zaretsky, Znaniecki & Thomas 1996 , p. xi
  18. ↑ Dulczewski 1984 , p. 143
  19. ↑ Dulczewski 1984 , p. 184
  20. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , p. 49
  21. 1 2 Bulmer 1986 , p. 45
  22. ↑ Zaretsky, Znaniecki & Thomas 1996 , p. ix
  23. ↑ Dulczewski 1984 , p. 180
  24. 1 2 3 Bulmer 1986 , p. 58
  25. ↑ Leonard Cargan (19 January 2007). Doing Social Research. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. p. 78. ISBN   978-0-7425-7731-2.
  26. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , p. 54
  27. ↑ Zaretsky, Znaniecki & Thomas 1996 , p. xiv
  28. ↑ Bulmer 1986 , p. 61
  29. 1 2 3 4 Dulczewski 1984 , pp. 175–7
  30. ↑ Dulczewski 1984 , pp. 180–4
  31. ↑ Zaretsky, Znaniecki & Thomas 1996 , p. x
  32. ↑ Isaac, William. "Results for 'Chłop polski w Europie i Ameryce'". Worldcat.org. Retrieved 2014-05-29.

Bibliography

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.