The Tender Trap (play)

Last updated
The Tender Trap
Written by Max Shulman and Robert Paul Smith
Directed by Michael Gordon
Date premieredOctober 13, 1954
Place premiered Longacre Theatre
Original language English
SubjectBachelor tries to dodge matrimony
Genre Farce
SettingManhattan apartment of Charlie Reader, mid-1950s

The Tender Trap is a 1954 play by Max Shulman and Robert Paul Smith. [1] It is a three-act farce, with a small cast, one setting, and moderate pacing. The story concerns a bachelor with a trio of professional women and a recent college grad as girl friends, who tries to avoid their suggestions of marriage.

Contents

The play's original Broadway performance was produced by Clinton Wilder, staged by Michael Gordon, and starred Robert Preston, Kim Hunter, and Ronny Graham. [2] The play was profitable but a venue scheduling conflict forced it to close early while still making money. [3] Popular with community theatre and regional theatre during the 1950s, it has never had a Broadway revival, but was adapted by its authors for a 1955 MGM film release.

Characters

Listed in order of appearance within their scope.

Leads

Supporting

Featured

Off stage

Synopsis

Charlie Reader lives in a terrace apartment on Manhattan's Upper East Side, overlooking the Queensboro Bridge. He is a bachelor, a transplant from the Midwest, who has no need to go out and find female companionship... they come to him. At 6pm on a Saturday evening he is necking with one Poppy Matson on his living room couch, when old buddy Joe McCall shows up unexpectedly. McCall is a chemist who has invented a pill to cure the common cold. He's come to visit Charlie to get ideas about testing and marketing it. Charlie welcomes him and introduces Poppy, and later his other girl friends. Joe is astonished at how the girls show up to clean Charlie's apartment, cook him meals, and bring him gifts like fish and cheese. Poppy, Jessica, and Sylvia have good careers but are feeling the urge to get married now that they are in their early thirties. The fourth and youngest girl friend, Julie Gillis, is equally in pursuit of Charlie but won't fall in line with his suggestions.

The constant parade of femininity affects Joe, who up till now had entertained no stray thoughts about his marriage. He begins gravitating towards Sylvia, while Charlie finds himself more and more intrigued with Julie. Earl Lindquist finds Joe's pills are worthless, so there's no longer a reason for him to stay, but Charlie, under the press of unexpected competition blurts out a proposal to Sylvia. Aghast, he realizes the only thing to do is proposed to Julie as well. Joe, trying to stave off his return to wife and family, makes a half-hearted play for Sylvia. She forcefully reminds him about his wife, and decides Charlie isn't for her either, and so walks out on both men. Julie, however, has no intention of letting pride get between her and Charlie, and so the play ends with their engagement.

Original production

Background

The first public word of The Tender Trap came during February 1954, when Irene Mayer Selznick reportedly took an option on it. [4] Nothing more was published until the end of April, when Clinton Wilder announced he would produce it for an early Fall premiere, with rehearsals to start in August. [5] Within two weeks, Wilder announced that Michael Gordon would stage the play. [6] By June 1954, Paul Morrison had been signed to do the set design, and it was reported rehearsals would start August 30, with tryouts in New Haven [fn 1] and Boston before a mid-October premiere on Broadway. [7]

Clinton Wilder, a cousin of the playwright Thorton Wilder, [8] had said nothing about financial backing for the production. Columnist Joe Hyams reported that MGM had bought The Tender Trap and planned to mount a Broadway production before making a film of it. [9] By early August Kim Hunter, Jack Manning, Janet Riley, Julia Meade, and Parker McCormick had been signed for the cast. [10] Not until mid-August was it confirmed that Robert Preston had been signed for one of the male leads, [11] while comedian Ronny Graham was cast for the other male lead just four days before rehearsals started. [12]

Cast

Cast for the tryout in Boston and during the original Broadway run
RoleActorDatesNotes and sources
Charlie Reader Ronny Graham Sep 25, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955Graham was cast because he was "tall, lean, occasionally awkward and not at all handsome". [13]
Joe McCall Robert Preston Sep 25, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955
Sylvia Crewes Kim Hunter Sep 25, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955
Poppy MatsonParker McCormickSep 25, 1954 - Oct 30, 1954McCormick left for a larger role in One Eye Closed by Justin Sturm, which flopped. [14]
Marrian WaltersNov 01, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955Walters (1923–1990) had an award-winning career on stage and as a costumer. [14] [15] [16]
Jessica Collins Julia Meade Sep 25, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955
Julie GillisJanet RileySep 25, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955From Simcoe, Ontario, she was married to Werner Klemperer at the time of this production. [17]
Earl Lindquist Jack Manning Sep 25, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955
Sol Schwartz Joey Faye Sep 25, 1954 - Jan 8, 1955Faye was the only original Broadway cast member to appear in the MGM motion picture.

Tryout

The play had a two-week tryout at the Wilbur Theatre in Boston starting September 25, 1954. Critic Cyrus Durgin of The Boston Globe reviewed it twice; while expressing an overall positive assessment on both occasions, he also highlighted problems with the third act. [18] [19] He felt the strength of the work lay in Shulman and Smith's dialogue and humor, which was superior to most farces; in the control director Michael Gordon kept over the action and in reconciling two such different acting styles as those of Robert Preston and Ronny Graham; and in the general excellence of the cast. [18] [19] He also appreciated the whimsical touch Paul Morrison gave to the set, placing a horseshoe over the door leading to Charlie's bedroom. [18] [19]

Durgin suggested the character of Sol Schwartz should be dropped, as it added nothing to the storyline. [19] He also thought the entire sub-plot involving Joe McCall was weak, a reflection of playwriting inexperience by Shulman and Smith. [18] He further pointed out the ambivalent appeal of the main character, Charlie Reader who "has two sides: he's a louse if you take him seriously, and a character if you find his amusing aspects." [18] Ronny Graham, who played Charlie, also commented on this dichotomy in a later interview: "In Boston it wasn't set yet, it wasn't cleared and squared away and I could feel them hating this boy". [13]

Premiere and reception

The play premiered on October 13, 1954, at the Longacre Theatre on Broadway. The Longacre was not yet air-conditioned, and the temperature in Manhattan that day was a record high 85 °F (29.4 °C). [20] Two critics mentioned the heat in their reviews, suggesting that it affected timing and audience response. [1] [2] John Chapman of the Daily News maintained The Tender Trap was "a skillfully contrived and very enjoyable farce", but suggested the director and authors should cut "twelve minutes out of the comedy, six of them in the last act". [2] Brooks Atkinson praised the performances of Robert Preston and Kim Hunter, but faulted the writers for what he termed "a ready made comedy". [1] The Tender Trap he wrote "has a promising appearance. But the quality of the merchandise is inferior". [1]

Walter Kerr was dubious about the comedy's approach to relationships. [21] He pointed out that Kim Hunter's pleasing and professional character wound up turning away from both the male leads and going it alone. [21] Louis Sheaffer was dismissive about The Tender Trap, calling it "flat" and suggesting it "tries hard to be funny". [22]

Closing

After 102 performances, The Tender Trap closed on Broadway on January 8, 1955. [3] It was still doing well at the box office, but had to make way at the Longacre Theatre for a new play, Festival. [3] The play was sold to three new producers (Jay Lurye, Arthur Waxman, and Bernard Simon) who took it on the road starting with Philadelphia's Walnut Theatre on January 25, 1955. [23] Only two original cast, Janet Riley and Joey Faye, and replacement Marrian Walters, went with the touring company. [23]

Film adaption

Before the play had even started rehearsals, Max Shulman and Paul Smith had sold the movie rights to MGM. [9] The characters' background was switched from pharmaceuticals and other occupations to show business. Perhaps mindful of Walter Kerr's observation, Shulman and Smith added a rebound romance and wedding scene at the end for Sylvia Crewes (Celeste Holm), which also provided the denounment for the romance between Charlie Reader (Frank Sinatra) and Julie Gillis (Debbie Reynolds).

Notes

  1. ↑ Nothing further is heard about a tryout in New Haven; the first performance of the play was done in Boston.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edith Taliaferro</span> American actress (1894–1958)

Edith Taliaferro was an American stage and film actress of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. She was active on the stage until 1935 and had roles in three silent films. She is best known for portraying the role of Rebecca in the 1910 stage production of Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Marriott (actor)</span> American actor

John Marriott was an American actor of the stage, film and screen, whose career spanned five decades. His acting career began on the stage in Cleveland, prior to his moving to New York City, where he was a regular performer on the Broadway stage. In the 1940s he also began to perform in films, when he reprised his role from the hit Broadway play, The Little Foxes, in the William Wyler movie of the same name, starring Bette Davis. While he appeared infrequently in films, he was quite active in theater, both on Broadway and in regional productions. His final performance was on-screen, in the Al Pacino film, Dog Day Afternoon.

The Lark is a 1952 play about Joan of Arc by the French playwright Jean Anouilh.. It was first presented at the Théâtre Montparnasse, Paris in October 1953. Translated into English by Christopher Fry in 1955, it was then adapted by Lillian Hellman for the Broadway production in the same year.

<i>Sag Harbor</i> (play) 1899 play by James Herne

Sag Harbor, sub-titled An Old Story, is an 1899 comedy, the last play written by American author James Herne. It has four acts and three settings, all within Sag Harbor, New York, while the action covers a two-year time span. The play is a rural comedy, with two brothers competing for the same girl, and an older widower wooing a shy spinster. The play avoids melodrama, emphasising the realistic nature of its characters, though as one critic pointed out they occasionally do unreal things.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wesley Addy</span> American actor (1913–1996)

Robert Wesley Addy was an American actor of stage, television, and film.

<i>The Tender Trap</i> (film) 1955 film by Charles Walters

The Tender Trap is a 1955 American comedy film starring Frank Sinatra, Debbie Reynolds, David Wayne, and Celeste Holm. Directed by Charles Walters, the CinemaScope Eastman Color production was based on the 1954 play The Tender Trap by Max Shulman and Robert Paul Smith.

Dream Girl is a 1945 two-act comedy by Elmer Rice, with a large cast, multiple sets, and quick pacing. It depicts a day in the life of a daydreaming bookstore manager, whose vivid fantasies form much of the play's action. The work makes great demands on the actress playing this part, as she is on stage constantly, must make costume and mood changes while jumping between sets, and delivers long soliloquies and a Shakespearean speech. According to some reviewers, her spoken lines were the longest female part known up to that time, nearly as long as Hamlet. The dream fantasies prompted comparison to the short story "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty", but critics at the time more often suggested the play Lady in the Dark as an influence.

Murray Kinnell was a British-born American actor, recognized for playing smooth, gentlemanly, although rather shady characters. He began acting on the English stage in 1907, toured in the United States from 1912 through 1914, then returned to England where he served in the British Army during World War I. After the war, he emigrated to the US. He appeared in 71 films between the pre-code era of 1930 and 1937. He later served the Screen Actors Guild in several positions for 16 years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Washington Square Players</span> Theatre group

The Washington Square Players (WSP) was a theatre troupe and production company that existed from 1915 to 1918 in Manhattan, New York City. It started as a semi-amateur Little Theatre then matured into a Repertory theatre with its own touring company and drama school. It received national newspaper coverage and sparked like-minded companies across the country. After it ceased operating, three of its members founded the Theatre Guild.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harold R. Heaton</span> American cartoonist and actor

Harold Robertson Heaton was a newspaper artist whose work focused on cartoons. His prodigious body of work contributed to the development of political cartoons. He also illustrated books and produced sketches and paintings. He left newspaper work in 1899 to begin acting on the stage, and later wrote plays as well. He returned to cartooning for six years beginning in 1908, but continued acting while doing so. He appeared in many Broadway productions through 1932. A brief retrospective on his employment with the Chicago Tribune, from October 1942, mentioned his obituary had been printed "a few years ago".

Constance Ann Shulman is an American actress. In 1987, Shulman originated the role of Annelle in the first production of Steel Magnolias off Broadway. She later appeared in films Fletch Lives (1989), Men Don't Leave (1990), and Fried Green Tomatoes (1991). She voiced Patti Mayonnaise in the animated sitcom Doug (1991–99) and the 1999 film Doug's 1st Movie. She played Yoga Jones in the Netflix comedy-drama series, Orange Is the New Black from 2013 to 2017, for which she received three Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series.

<i>The Druid Circle</i> 1947 play

The Druid Circle is a 1947 play in three acts written by John Van Druten. It has a medium-sized cast, slow pacing, five scenes, and three settings. A history professor, frustrated to be working at a university near the border of England and Wales, discovers a love letter written by one of his students to a girl. After humiliating them both, the Professor realises too late the meanness of his actions when it rebounds on him. The play's title comes from "Druid", British academic slang denoting a erudite scholar who has lost his sense of humanity, with "Circle" indicating a group of the same.

Old Acquaintance is a 1940 play by the British writer John Van Druten. It is a three-act comedy, with a small cast and two settings. The story is a conflict between two women, childhood friends from Harrisburg, Pennsylvania and now both successful writers. It is all conversation, with exits and entrances the only action. It was considered a "woman's play" by contemporary reviewers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joan Elan</span> English actress (1928–1981)

Joan Elan was an English actress, whose film, stage, and television career occurred mainly in the United States. She is best remembered today for her appearances on television.

Natalie Norwick was an American actor who performed on stage and in television and films over a span of 54 years.

<i>Light Up the Sky</i> (play) Play by Moss Hart

Light Up the Sky is a three-act play written by the American playwright Moss Hart. It is a character-driven satire with the fast pacing of a farce, a simple plot, medium-sized cast, and only one setting. The plot concerns the interrelations of theater people before and after a first-night tryout, when they experience nervous anticipation, perceived failure, and unexpected success in sequence. The play became known before its premiere as well-founded rumors suggested some characters were modelled on actual theater personalities. There are allusions to figures from the larger world of New York shows, including David Belasco and George Jean Nathan, as well as topical references to the late 1940s stage scene. The most egregious of these was Hart's mention of real drama critics then active in Boston, attributing to them spurious quotes for the fictional tryout.

The Tunnel of Love is a three-act play with five scenes and a prologue, written by Joseph Fields and Peter De Vries, adapted from the latter's 1954 novel. It is a comedy with a simple plot, small cast, and only one setting. The action is concerned with the efforts of a married couple to conceive a child and the complications that set in when they decide to try adoption. The staging by Fields features many entrances and exits from the single set with moderate pacing.

Anniversary Waltz is a three-act play, written by Jerome Chodorov and Joseph Fields, and staged by Moss Hart. It is a comedy with a simple plot, medium-sized cast, fast pacing, and only one setting. The action varies from farce to schmaltz, as the Walters celebrate their fifteenth wedding anniversary only to have a family secret go public and send everyone into a frenzy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mary Lee Dearring</span> American actress

Mary Lee Margaret Dearring was an American child actress who was active from 1947 until 1973. Starting as a child model, she performed in films, television, and the stage, including a six-month run on Broadway for Anniversary Waltz, and a regular starring role on a television series as a teenager.

<i>Ramshackle Inn</i> Play by George Batson

Ramshackle Inn is a three-act play, written by George Batson, revised by Owen Davis, and staged by Arthur Sircom. It is a comedy, a melodramatic farce, with a medium-sized cast, moderate pacing, and only one setting. The action takes place during two hours of a stormy evening in the lobby of a dilapidated inn along the seacoast near Gloucester, Massachusetts.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Atkinson, Brooks (October 14, 1954). "Theatre: 'Tender Trap'". New York Times. New York, New York – via NYTimes.com.
  2. 1 2 3 Chapman, John (October 14, 1954). "'Tender Trap' Enjoyable Farce". Daily News. New York, New York. p. 749 – via Newspapers.com.
  3. 1 2 3 "'Trap' to Shut". Daily News. New York, New York. January 4, 1955. p. 395 – via Newspapers.com.
  4. ↑ Adams, Cedric (February 10, 1954). "In This Corner". The Minneapolis Star. Minneapolis, Minnesota. p. 60 – via Newspapers.com.
  5. ↑ "News of the Theater". Brooklyn Daily Eagle. Brooklyn, New York. April 23, 1954. p. 13 – via Newspapers.com.
  6. ↑ "'Clerk' Closes May 22; Williams Opera Listed". Daily News. New York, New York. May 5, 1954. p. 63 – via Newspapers.com.
  7. ↑ "News of the Theater". Brooklyn Daily Eagle. Brooklyn, New York. June 10, 1954. p. 10 – via Newspapers.com.
  8. ↑ Walker, Danton (July 13, 1954). "Broadway". Daily News. New York, New York. p. 70 – via Newspapers.com.
  9. 1 2 Hyams, Joe (July 27, 1954). "In The News". Los Angeles Evening Citizen News. Hollywood, California. p. 14 – via Newspapers.com.
  10. ↑ "Gets New Role". Daily News. New York, New York. August 7, 1954. p. 13 – via Newspapers.com.
  11. ↑ "Play by Robert Ardey To Open Phoenix Season". Daily News. New York, New York. August 18, 1954. p. 498 – via Newspapers.com.
  12. ↑ "Ronnie Graham Cast In Shulman Comedy". The Berkshire Eagle. Pittsfield, Massachusetts. August 26, 1954. p. 10 – via Newspapers.com.
  13. 1 2 Bolton, Whitney (December 2, 1954). "Looking Sideways". Buffalo Evening News. Buffalo, New York. p. 35 – via Newspapers.com.
  14. 1 2 "'Lullaby' Gives Up Sunday; Actress Gets Feature Part". Daily News. New York, New York. November 2, 1954 – via Newspapers.com.
  15. ↑ "Marrian Walters, veteran ACT actress, dies at 67". The Oakland Tribune. Oakland, California. August 6, 1990. p. 2 – via Newspapers.com.
  16. ↑ "Obituaries". The Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles, California. August 7, 1990. p. 122 – via Newspapers.com.
  17. ↑ "Actress Visiting Home". The Brantford Expositor. Brantford, Ontario. August 12, 1954. p. 8 – via Newspapers.com.
  18. 1 2 3 4 5 Durgin, Cyrus (September 27, 1954). "The Stage". The Boston Globe. Boston, Massachusetts. p. 6 – via Newspapers.com.
  19. 1 2 3 4 Durgin, Cyrus (October 3, 1954). "'Tender Trap' Is a Superior Farce-Comedy, Gay and Witty". The Boston Globe. Boston, Massachusetts. p. 92 – via Newspapers.com.
  20. ↑ "Record High for 2d Straight Day". Daily News. New York, New York. October 14, 1954. p. 537 – via Newspapers.com.
  21. 1 2 Kerr, Walter (October 14, 1954). "Edge of Reality Pares Nonsense in 'Tender Trap'". Buffalo Evening News. Buffalo, New York. p. 54 – via Newspapers.com.
  22. ↑ Sheaffer, Louis (October 14, 1954). "'Tender Trap' Flat Comedy About a Playboy Bachelor". Brooklyn Daily Eagle. Brooklyn, New York. p. 12 – via Newspapers.com.
  23. 1 2 Murdock, Henry T. (January 25, 1955). "Comedy Opens At Walnut". Philadelphia Inquirer. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. p. 16 – via Newspapers.com.

Internet Broadway Database, The Tender Trap

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.