Those Who Love (1926 film)

Last updated

Those Who Love
Directed by Paulette McDonagh
P. J. Ramster
Written by Paulette McDonagh
Produced by Paulette McDonagh
Starring Marie Lorraine
William Carter
CinematographyJack Fletcher
MCD Productions
Distributed byJ. C. Williamson Films
Release dates
September 1926 (premiere)
22 November 1926 (cinema release) [1]
Running time
6,000 feet
Languages Silent film
English intertitles
Budget£1,000 [2]

Those Who Love is a 1926 silent film, produced in Australia, about the son of a knight who falls in love with a dancer. Only part of the film survives today and it is held by the National Film and Sound Archive.


Everyone's called it a "creditable little picture". [3]


Barry Manton, William Carter, the son of Sir James, falls in love with a dancer, Bebe Doree but his father disapproves and bribes Bebe to disappear. Hurt, Barry leaves home and becomes a labourer on the docks. He meets poor but honest Lola Quayle in a cabaret and offers her a place to live after she resists the advances of a pub owner. They stay in separate rooms but fall in love during a storm and he later marries her. Barry's father wants him to return home and sends a solicitor over to approach him. Not wanting to get between Barry and his family, Lola runs away.

Years later, Barry lives in an attic, having rejected wealth and position and taken to drink, while Lola works as a nurse, looking after their son, Peter. Barry is injured and Lola recognises him at hospital. She visits Sir James and asks for money for a specialist and the family is united. [4]



This was the first feature film from the McDonagh sisters, Paulette, Phyllis and Isobel. They came up with the story in the prep room of their own boarding school. Says Phyllis McDonagh:

In those days every Australian-made film made us out to be a lot of bushwhackers, on the 'Dad and Dave' theme. The three of us talked and talked and decided if Australia was going to compete overseas we'd have to meet overseas standards by making interior films – technically difficult then. [5]

The film was entirely financed by the girl's father. Says Phyllis:

Father always believed in us. And when we proved on paper we knew what we were about, he let us have our head. We had a down-to-earth approach. We thought well ahead and planned the details meticulously. We knew talent wasn't enough if it was half baked. [5]

The McDonaghs formed a production company, MCD Productions, and started pre-production. Isobel was to star, Phyllis was to do production design and publicity, and Paulette would help with direction. Before filming commenced, their father died of a heart attack. Their mother was a trained nurse and a group of Sydney doctors suggested she open a convalescent home for their use. The family moved into "Drummoyne House", a 22-room house in the Sydney suburb of Drummoyne built by convicts. Two wings were set aside for the convalescent home and another section was turned into a film studio.

The McDonaghs originally hired P. J. Ramster to direct but were unhappy with his work and replaced him with Paulette. [2] The interiors were shot mostly at the home in Drummoyne, with additional scenes filmed at the Bondi studios of Australasian Films and exteriors done around Sydney. [6]

Shooting took four weeks in all. A number of days were lost when the cast and crew's eyes were damaged from the lights, and their cinematographer fell ill with influenza. [5]


The film was given a vice-regal premiere in September 1926 attended by Governor Sir Dudley de Chair, whose daughter Elaine had a part in the film. Dr McDonagh had been J. C. Williamson's surgeon and the film was distributed commercially by J. C. Williamson Ltd [7] It performed well at the box office, with Phyllis McDonagh later claiming the movie earned twice its cost. [5]

Gregory Balcombe of Union Theatres said his company distributed the film to help the local industry, although it should not have cost more than £1,000. [8]

Related Research Articles

Efftee Studios was an early Australian film and theatre production studio, established by F.W. Thring in 1930. It existed until Thring's death in 1935. Initially Efftee Films was based in Melbourne and used optical sound equipment imported from the US.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phyllis Barry</span> English actress (1908–1954)

Phyllis Barry was an English film actress. Born in Leeds, West Riding of Yorkshire, England, to Seth Henry and Bertha Hillyard, Barry appeared in over 40 films between 1925 and 1947.

The Cheaters is a 1930 Australian silent film directed by Paulette McDonagh and starring Isabel McDonagh. Phyllis McDonagh worked as art director. The McDonagh sisters made a number of self-funded films together in the late 1920s and early 1930s.

<i>The Far Paradise</i> 1928 film

The Far Paradise is a 1928 Australian silent film directed by Paulette McDonagh and starring Marie Lorraine the stage name of Isabel McDonagh. This is the second feature from the McDonagh sisters.

For the Term of His Natural Life is a 1927 Australian film based on the 1874 novel by Marcus Clarke, directed, produced and co-written by Norman Dawn. It was the most expensive Australian silent film ever made and remains one of the most famous Australian films of the silent era.

<i>The Christian</i> (1923 film) 1923 film by Maurice Tourneur

The Christian (1923) is a silent film drama, released by Goldwyn Pictures, directed by Maurice Tourneur, his first production for Goldwyn, and starring Richard Dix and Mae Busch. The film is based on the novel The Christian by Hall Caine, published in 1897, the first British novel to reach the record of one million copies sold. The novel was adapted for the stage, opening on Broadway at the Knickerbocker Theatre October 10, 1898. This was the fourth film of the story; the first, The Christian (1911) was made in Australia.

<i>The Flying Doctor</i> 1936 Australian film

The Flying Doctor is a 1936 Australian-British drama film directed by Miles Mander and starring Charles Farrell, Mary Maguire and James Raglan. The Royal Flying Doctor Service of Australia operate in the Australian Outback. Noted as Australia's first "sound" feature film, The Flying Doctor was also the country's first feature-length film based on aviation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arthur Shirley</span> Australian actor

Arthur Shirley was an Australian actor, writer, producer, and director of theatre and film. He experienced some success as a film actor in Hollywood between 1914 and 1920.

Two Minutes Silence is a 1933 Australian melodrama set during World War I based on Les Haylen's anti-war play. It was the fourth and last feature film by the Sydney-based McDonagh sisters, Paulette, Isobel and Phyllis, who called it "by far the best picture we produced". It is considered Australia's first anti-war movie and is a lost film.

<i>The Pioneers</i> (1926 film) 1926 film

The Pioneers is a 1926 Australian silent film directed by Raymond Longford. The script had been written by Lottie Lyell but she had died by the time filming started. It was considered a lost film but some surviving footage from it has recently emerged.

<i>Sunrise</i> (1926 film) 1926 film

Sunrise is a 1927 Australian silent film co-directed by Raymond Longford, who took over during filming.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paulette McDonagh</span> Australian film director

Paulette de Vere McDonagh, was an Australian film director, who often worked in collaboration with her sisters Phyllis McDonagh and Isabel McDonagh. In 1933 it was claimed she was one of only five female film directors in the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phyllis McDonagh</span> Australian film producer, production designer and journalist

Phyllis Glory McDonagh was an Australian film producer, production designer and journalist, who often worked in collaboration with her sisters Paulette and Isabella.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marie Lorraine</span> Australian actress

Isabella Mercia McDonagh, also known as Marie Lorraine, was an Australian actress who often worked in collaboration with her sisters Paulette and Phyllis. Isabella, alongside her two sisters made history by owning and running a film production company, therefore becoming the first Australian women to do so.

Percy John Ramster, better known as P.J. Ramster, was an Australian film director. He also ran an acting school, and his students often appeared in his films.

The Tenth Straw is a 1926 Australian silent film heavily inspired by the novel For the Term of His Natural Life. Little is known of the director and cast, but most of the film survives today.

The Royal Commission on the Moving Picture Industry in Australia was held from 1926–1928. It explored a series of issues to do with the Australian film industry, with evidence given by a number of leading figures at the time including Franklyn Barrett, Gayne Dexter, Paulette McDonagh, Stuart F. Doyle, William Gibson, Raymond Longford and Louise Lovely. It made a number of recommendations but its ultimate impact was limited.

McDonagh Productions was a short-lived Australian production company that produced feature and short films. It was run by the McDonagh sisters, Phyllis, Isabel and Paulette. The company eventually went broke after the failure of its last two features.

William George Carter (1902–1952) was an Australian actor whose early acting career was in silent films.

Alan Burke was an Australian writer and film director and producer. His credits include the musical Lola Montez.


  1. "NEW FILMS". The Sydney Morning Herald . National Library of Australia. 13 December 1926. p. 7. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
  2. 1 2 Andrew Pike and Ross Cooper, Australian Film 1900–1977: A Guide to Feature Film Production, Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1998, 136.
  3. "Likely to be Biggest Australian Release in 1928—" The Adorable Outcast."", Everyones., 7 (406 (14 December 1927)), Sydney: Everyones Ltd, nla.obj-578957495, retrieved 2 March 2024 via Trove
  4. "The Mainland Day by Day". The Mercury . Hobart, Tas.: National Library of Australia. 17 September 1926. p. 6. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
  5. 1 2 3 4 "WHEN THREE DASHING SISTERS MADE A MOVIE". The Australian Women's Weekly . National Library of Australia. 21 April 1971. p. 4. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
  6. "The World of Pictures". The Brisbane Courier . National Library of Australia. 12 March 1927. p. 23. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
  7. "MOVIE NOTES". The Horsham Times . Vic.: National Library of Australia. 27 August 1927. p. 4 Edition: Saturday Evening Edition. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
  8. "FILM INDUSTRY". The Register . Adelaide: National Library of Australia. 25 April 1927. p. 14. Retrieved 5 August 2012.