United States National Research Council rankings

Last updated

The United States National Research Council had conducted a survey, and compiled a report, on United States Research-Doctorate Programs approximately every 10 years, although the time elapsed between each new ranking had sometimes exceeded 10 years.

Contents

Methodology

Data collection for the most recent report began in June 2006; [1] it was released on September 28, 2010. These rankings did not provide exact ranks for any university or doctoral program; rather, a statistical range was given. This was because "the committee felt strongly that assigning to each program a single number and ranking them accordingly would be misleading, since there are significant uncertainties and variability in any ranking process." [2]

Two series of rankings were offered:

The factors included in these computations included [4] the number of publications per faculty member, citations per publication (except in computer science and the humanities), fraction of the faculty supported by grants and number of grants per faculty member, diversity of the faculty and students, student GRE scores, graduate student funding, number of Ph.D.s and completion percentage, time to degree, academic plans of graduating students, student work space, student health insurance, and student activities.

Reception

The rankings have both been praised and criticized by academics.

Physicist Peter Woit stated that historically the NRC rankings have been the "gold standard" for academic department ratings. [5] The rankings were also called "the gold standard" by biomedical engineer John M. Tarbell [6] and in news releases by Cornell University [7] and the University of California. [8] The Center for a Public Anthropology praised the National Research Council's 2010 rankings as "an impressive achievement" for its move away from reputational rankings and toward data-based rankings, but also noted that the lack of specific rankings reduced clarity even as it improved accuracy. [9] William Colglazier and Jeremiah P. Ostriker defended the rankings in the Chronicle of Higher Education , [10] responding to a critique by Stephen M. Stigler. [11]

Sociologist Jonathan R. Cole, one of the members of the NRC committee that produced the ranking, critiqued the final result. Cole objected to the committee's choice not to include any "measures of reputational standing or perceived quality" in the survey, which he called "the most significant misguided decision" in the recent study. Cole also critiqued the various statistical inputs and the weight assigned to each. [12] The Computing Research Association and various computer science departments also expressed "serious concerns" about vaguely defined reporting terms leading to inconsistent data, inaccuracies in the data, and the use of bibliometrics from the ISI Web of Knowledge despite its poor coverage of many computer science conferences. [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] Geographers A. Shortridge, K. Goldsberry, and K. Weessies found significant undercounts in the data and poor sensitivity to "noise" in the rankings, concluding that "We caution against using the 2010 NRC data or metrics for any assessment-oriented study of research productivity." [18] The rankings were also critiqued by sociologist Fabio Rojas. [19]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Delft University of Technology</span> Dutch university

Delft University of Technology, also known as TU Delft, is the oldest and largest Dutch public technical university, located in Delft, Netherlands. As of 2022 it is ranked by QS World University Rankings among the top 10 engineering and technology universities in the world. In the fields of architecture and civil engineering, it was ranked 2nd in the world, after MIT.

The University of New South Wales (UNSW), also known as UNSW Sydney, is a public research university based in Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. It is one of the founding members of Group of Eight, a coalition of Australian research-intensive universities.

Postgraduate education involves learning and studying for academic or professional degrees, academic or professional certificates, academic or professional diplomas, or other qualifications for which a first or bachelor's degree generally is required, and it is normally considered to be part of higher education. In North America, this level is typically referred to as graduate school.

The Doctor of Education is a research or professional doctoral degree that focuses on the field of education. It prepares the holder for academic, research, administrative, clinical, or professional positions in educational, civil, private organizations, or public institutions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Middle East Technical University</span> Public technical university in Turkey

Middle East Technical University is a public technical university located in Ankara, Turkey. The university emphasizes research and education in engineering and natural sciences, offering about 41 undergraduate programs within 5 faculties, 105 masters and 70 doctorate programs within 5 graduate schools. The main campus of METU spans an area of 11,100 acres (4,500 ha), comprising, in addition to academic and auxiliary facilities, a forest area of 7,500 acres (3,000 ha), and the natural Lake Eymir. METU has more than 120,000 alumni worldwide. The official language of instruction at METU is English.

Three national rankings of universities in the United Kingdom are published annually – by The Complete University Guide, The Guardian and jointly by The Times and The Sunday Times. Rankings have also been produced in the past by The Daily Telegraph andFinancial Times. UK Universities also rank highly in global university rankings with 8 UK Universities ranking in the top 100 of the three major global rankings - QS World University Rankings, Times Higher Education World University Rankings and Academic Ranking of World Universities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Walden University</span> U.S. university

Walden University is a private online for-profit university headquartered in Minneapolis, Minnesota. It offers Bachelor of Science, Master of Science, Master of Business Administration, Master of Public Administration, Master of Public Health, Education Specialist, Doctor of Education, Doctor of Business Administration, and Doctor of Philosophy degrees.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Doctor of Theology</span> Doctoral degree

Doctor of Theology is a terminal degree in the academic discipline of theology. The ThD, like the ecclesiastical Doctor of Sacred Theology, is an advanced research degree equivalent to the Doctor of Philosophy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Università della Svizzera italiana</span> University in Canton Ticino, Switzerland

The Università della Svizzera italiana, sometimes referred to as the University of Lugano in English-speaking contexts, is a public Swiss university established in 1995, with campuses in Lugano, Mendrisio and Bellinzona. USI is the only university in Switzerland where the official language is Italian, but many of its programs are in English.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">University of Rijeka</span>

The University of Rijeka is in the city of Rijeka with faculties in cities throughout the regions of Primorje, Istria and Lika.

The American University School of Public Affairs (SPA) is an institution of higher education and research located in Washington, D.C. that grants academic degrees in political science, public administration, public policy, and justice, law and criminology. Established in 1934 as part of American University, the school houses three academic departments - Public Administration & Policy, Government, and Justice, Law & Criminology - as well as ten centers and institutes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">O'Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs</span> Public policy school in Bloomington and Indianapolis, Indiana, U.S.

The O'Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs is one of the undergraduate and graduate schools of Indiana University, and is the largest public policy and environmental studies school of its kind in the United States. Founded in 1972, as the Indiana University School of Public and Environmental Affairs, it was the first school to combine public management, policy, and administration with the environmental sciences. The school was founded on the IU Bloomington campus, and today also has a campus at Indiana University – Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI). O'Neill School Bloomington is the top ranked school of public affairs in the United States. The school received a facelift and expansion when the Paul O'Neill Graduate Center opened for classes in the Spring 2017 semester due to the growing influx of students. On March 4, 2019, the name was changed to the O'Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs, in honor of alumnus Paul H. O'Neill, who served as the United States Secretary of the Treasury in 2001–2002.

The Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index (FSPI), a product of Academic Analytics, is a metric designed to create benchmark standards for the measurement of academic and scholarly quality within and among United States research universities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frankfurt School of Finance & Management</span> Business school in Germany

Frankfurt School of Finance & Management Frankfurt School of Finance & Management is a private university with a right to award doctorates, recognized under Hesse’s Higher Education Act. The parent organization is the Frankfurt School of Finance & Management Foundation. Frankfurt School has a second campus in HafenCity in Hamburg and a study center in Munich, as well as offices in developing and emerging countries in cities such as Nairobi and Amman.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Doctor of Philosophy</span> Postgraduate academic degree awarded by universities in many countries

A Doctor of Philosophy is the most common degree at the highest academic level awarded following a course of study. PhDs are awarded for programs across the whole breadth of academic fields. Because it is an earned research degree, those studying for a PhD are required to produce original research that expands the boundaries of knowledge, normally in the form of a dissertation, and defend their work before a panel of other experts in the field. The completion of a PhD is often a requirement for employment as a university professor, researcher, or scientist in many fields. Individuals who have earned a Doctor of Philosophy degree may, in many jurisdictions, use the title Doctor with their name, although the proper etiquette associated with this usage may also be subject to the professional ethics of their own scholarly field, culture, or society. Those who teach at universities or work in academic, educational, or research fields are usually addressed by this title "professionally and socially in a salutation or conversation." Alternatively, holders may use post-nominal letters such as "Ph.D.", "PhD", or "DPhil". It is, however, considered incorrect to use both the title and post-nominals at the same time.

A Bachelor of Science in Information Technology,, is a bachelor's degree awarded for an undergraduate program in the information technology. The degree is normally required in order to work in the Information technology industry.

The School ofJournalism & Mass Communication is the journalism school of the University of Wisconsin–Madison. Located in Vilas Communication Hall, the School offers two undergraduate programs, two Master of Arts programs in Journalism, and a doctoral program jointly administered with the Department of Life Sciences Communication.

The University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee is a doctoral-degree granting public research university that consists of 14 colleges and schools, and 70 academic centers, institutes and laboratory facilities. It offers a total of 180 degree programs, including 94 bachelor's, 53 master's and 32 doctorate degrees. The School of Freshwater Sciences is the only graduate school of freshwater science in the U.S. and the third in the world. The School of Architecture and Urban Planning, the College of Nursing and the College of Health Sciences are the largest in Wisconsin.

William Eric Leifur Grimson is a Canadian-born computer scientist and professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where he served as Chancellor from 2011 to 2014. An expert in computer vision, he headed MIT's Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science from 2005 to 2011 and currently serves as its Chancellor for Academic Advancement.

Azer Bestavros, is the Inaugural Associate Provost for Computing and Data Sciences and the William Fairfield Warren Distinguished Professor of Computer Science at Boston University. Prior to his appointment in 2019 to lead the Faculty of Computing and Data Sciences, he was the Founding Director of The Rafik B. Hariri Institute for Computing and Computational Science & Engineering. He joined Boston University in 1991 as an assistant professor in the Department of Computer Science, which is part of the university's College of Arts & Sciences. He was promoted to the rank of associate professor in 1998 and to the rank of full professor in 2003. From 2000 to 2007, he served as chair of the Department of Computer Science. Prior to joining Boston University, he worked as an instructor, teaching fellow, software engineer, and technical consultant for various organizations and technology companies, including the Eastern Mediterranean Regional Office of World Health Organization, Awad Associates, Harvard University, and AT&T Research Laboratories.

References

  1. ↑ Morse, Robert (July 9, 2009), "The Wait for the National Research Council Rankings Continues", U.S. News & World Report
  2. 1 2 "A Data-Based Assessment of Research-Doctorate Programs in the United States: Frequently Asked Questions" (2010). United States National Research Council.
  3. ↑ Assessment of Research Doctorate Programs, U.S. National Academies
  4. ↑ "A Data-Based Assessment of Research-Doctorate Programs in the United States" (2010).
  5. ↑ Peter Woit, "NRC Rankings" (September 27, 2010). Not Even Wrong.
  6. ↑ "NRC Ranks CCNY PhD Program Among Best in US" (September 19, 2011). City College of New York.
  7. ↑ Susan Kelley, "CU awaits release of gold standard of grad school rankings" (September 16, 2010). Cornell University.
  8. ↑ Andy Evangelista, "Ph.D. programs rank high in National Research Council report Archived 2012-03-03 at the Wayback Machine " (September 28, 2010). University of California.
  9. ↑ "Overview." Center for a Public Anthropology.
  10. ↑ E. William Colglazier and Jeremiah P. Ostriker, "Counterpoint: Doctoral-Program Rankings—the NRC Responds." (October 17, 2010). Chronicle of Higher Education.
  11. ↑ David Glenn, "A Critic Sees Deep Problems in the Doctoral Rankings" (September 30, 2010). Chronicle of Higher Education.
  12. ↑ Cole, Jonathan R. (April 24, 2011), "Too Big to Fail: How 'better than nothing' defined the National Research Council's graduate rankings", Chronicle of Higher Education
  13. ↑ Erroneous NRC Ranking Data for UW CSE Archived 2010-10-01 at the Wayback Machine , University of Washington Department of Computer Science and Engineering, retrieved 2010-09-29.
  14. ↑ NRC Doctoral Rankings and Computer Science, Peter Harsha, Computing Research Association, September 28, 2010. Retrieved 2010-09-29.
  15. ↑ Glenn, David (October 6, 2010), "Computer Scientists Cry Foul Over Data Problems in NRC Rankings", Chronicle of Higher Education
  16. ↑ Grimson, Eric (May 2010), "Dangers of Rankings with Inaccurate Data", Computing Research News
  17. ↑ Bernat, Andrew; Grimson, Eric (December 2011), "Doctoral program rankings for U.S. computing programs: the national research council strikes out", Communications of the ACM , 54 (12): 41–43, doi: 10.1145/2043174.2043203
  18. ↑ Shortridge, Ashton; Goldsberry, Kirk; Weessies, Kathleen (2011), "Measuring Research Data Uncertainty in the 2010 NRC Assessment of Geography Graduate Education", Journal of Geography, 110 (6): 219–226, doi:10.1080/00221341.2011.607510
  19. ↑ "NRC Rankings: Was It a Big Fail?? (September 30, 2010). Orgtheory.net.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.