Vacated victory

Last updated

The LSU Tigers football program and head coach Les Miles (pictured) had 37 wins from 2012 to 2015 vacated by the NCAA. LSU AUBURN 2.JPG
The LSU Tigers football program and head coach Les Miles (pictured) had 37 wins from 2012 to 2015 vacated by the NCAA.

In American college athletics, a vacated victory is a win that the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) has stripped from an athletic team, usually as punishment for misconduct related to their sports programs. The team being punished is officially stripped of its victory, but the opposing team retains its loss—thus, vacated victories are different from forfeits, in which the losing team is given the win. The practice of vacating victories has been criticized by players and sports journalists, but remains one of the NCAA's preferred penalties for infractions related to past misconduct. [2] Over 160 college football teams and 270 college basketball teams [nb 1] have had wins vacated. [3]

Contents

Definition

A vacated victory is distinct from a forfeit, which simply reverses the outcome of a contest: when a game is forfeited, the team that won records a loss and the team that lost records a win. [4] [5] By comparison, a vacated win only removes regular season and tournament wins from the record of the penalized team. [4] The opposing, non-penalized team retains all losses corresponding to vacated games in the regular season (although tournament losses are stricken). [5]

History

In the process of regulating infractions, the NCAA received complaints that their punishments did not penalize the actual perpetrators. [2] Prospective measures, like scholarship reductions or postseason bans, affected athletes who were unrelated to the original violation. [6] To remedy this, the NCAA's committee on infractions adopted the practice of vacating wins as a punishment that would be linked to the specific wrongdoers. [7] The NCAA has broad authority to apply this punishment, but is more likely to do in cases of major systemic fraud in a program or where academically ineligible players have competed. [6] When issuing punishments in the past, the NCAA Committee on Infractions ordered that regular season games be forfeited by the offending team while NCAA tournament games be vacated. More recently, forfeits have not been used at all, and both regular season and tournament games have been vacated. [8]

The precise first use of a vacated win as punishment is unclear. According to Sports Reference, the first recorded use of the punishment in college basketball took place after the 1961 NCAA gambling scandal. [9] The Saint Joseph's Hawks had four games in the NCAA tournament vacated, including their third-place finish. [10] [11]

The first collegiate national title to be vacated was the 1971 men's soccer championship. [12] [13] The Howard Bison were ruled to have fielded ineligible players, although analysts and historians have argued Howard was targeted because of the racial makeup of the team. [14] [15] As of 2018, 20 college programs have had a national title vacated. [12]

The NCAA has vacated wins as a punishment for academic misconduct, [16] impermissible financial benefits, [17] and player sex scandals. [18] [19] After making the punishment official, the NCAA requires schools to return trophies and take down any references (such as banners) to vacated achievements. [19] The NCAA has in some instances also vacated losses in tournaments or championship games, serving to vacate a team's appearance in the tournament or title contest.

Records between teams

By striking the win but not the corresponding loss, vacated victories result in anomalies such as games with losers but no winners, unbalanced series records, [nb 2] and inconsistent measures of head-to-head streaks. [nb 3]

The NCAA does not maintain official records between any two opposing teams, and initially it had no official policy for the treatment of vacated victories in calculating either series records or win/loss streaks between any two opposing teams. Various media outlets commented on the inconsistency between opponents' series records inherent to vacated victories. In June 2009, both the ESPN.com SEC Blog and the Chattanooga Times Free Press discussed NCAA sanctions against the Alabama Crimson Tide football program; each stated that games with vacated wins do not count at all in a series record between two teams. [20] [21] Later, the NCAA's rules were updated to state that "all team and coaches’ streaks (such as wins, postseason appearances, team statistical streaks, and so on) are terminated by the vacancy of a contest." [5]

Criticism

Athletes, administrators, and sports journalists have criticized the practice of vacating wins, arguing that it is arbitrary, confusing, and disproportionate to the infractions it punishes. [22] [16] [23] Those opposed to the punishment note that the NCAA is effectively asking fans and schools to pretend that the game never happened. [17] [6] Former competitors and fans often reject the punishment, saying that the NCAA cannot take away the on-field accomplishments or memories of games. [19] [24] [2]

The practice of vacating victories has also been called insufficiently preventative, as schools are still able to keep money they received from their vacated accomplishments [25] and fans still consider the on-field result to be "real". [6]

In October 2020, the NCAA stripped the UMass women's tennis team of its 2017 Atlantic 10 Conference championship over the improper reimbursement of a $252 phone bill, leading to a public outcry. [26] [27] One writer called the decision the "single worst miscarriage of justice" in the NCAA's history, as the original error was minor and the university had self-reported. [28] The players involved disputed the punishment, arguing that vacating their victories placed them in the same category as cheaters who gained a competitive advantage from misconduct. [28]

Notable punishments

Basketball

Football

Other sports

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ Here, "team" refers to an individual team season: one athletic program may have wins vacated from consecutive seasons, which are counted separately.
  2. ↑ Suppose that Team A and Team B played 10 times, with Team A winning 7 games and Team B winning 3. The series record stands at 7–3 in favor of Team A. If one of Team A's victories in the series is vacated, Team A would have a 6–3 record against Team B, while Team B would have a 3–7 record against Team A.
  3. ↑ Suppose that the winners of a 10-game series between Team A and Team B are as follows: BBAABAAAAA. Normally we would say that Team A has a 5-game winning streak over Team B, or that Team B has a 5-game losing streak to Team A, and the statements would be equivalent. However, if Team A's victory in the eighth game of the series were subsequently vacated, Team B would still have a 5-game losing streak to Team A, but Team A would, depending upon interpretation, have either a 4-game winning streak, or a 2-game winning streak over Team B.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Houston Nutt</span> American football player and coach (born 1957)

Houston Dale Nutt Jr. is a former American college football coach and player. He formerly worked for CBS Sports as a college football studio analyst. Previously, he served as the head football coach at Murray State University (1993–1996), Boise State University (1997), the University of Arkansas (1998–2007), and the University of Mississippi (2008–2011). Nutt's all-time career winning percentage is just under 59 percent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bob Stoops</span> American football player and coach (born 1960)

Robert Anthony Stoops is an American football coach who is the head coach for the Arlington Renegades of the United Football League (UFL). He was the head football coach at the University of Oklahoma from 1999 through the 2016 season, and on an interim basis during the 2021 Alamo Bowl. He led the Oklahoma Sooners to a record of 191–48 over his career. His 2000 Oklahoma Sooners football team won the 2001 Orange Bowl, which served as the BCS National Championship Game, and earned a consensus national championship. Since 2020, Stoops has been a head coach with the XFL, coaching the Renegades in 2020 and has been re-signed for 2023. Stoops' Renegades won the XFL Championship in 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Calipari</span> American college basketball coach (born 1959)

John Vincent Calipari is an American basketball coach who is the head coach at the University of Arkansas. He was the head coach at the University of Kentucky from 2009 until the end of the 2023–2024 season, which he led to one NCAA National Championship in 2012. He has been named Naismith College Coach of the Year three times, and was inducted into the Basketball Hall of Fame in 2015.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">USC Trojans football</span> American college football team at University of Southern California

The USC Trojans football program represents the University of Southern California in the sport of American football. The Trojans compete in the Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and the Big Ten Conference.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lane Kiffin</span> American football coach (born 1975)

Lane Monte Kiffin is an American football coach who is the head coach at Ole Miss. Kiffin was the offensive coordinator at USC from 2005 to 2006, head coach of the National Football League's Oakland Raiders from 2007 to 2008, head coach at the University of Tennessee in 2009, and at USC from 2010 to 2013. He was the youngest head coach in modern NFL history at the time when he joined the Raiders, and, for a time, was the youngest head coach of a BCS Conference team in college football. Kiffin was the offensive coordinator at the University of Alabama from 2014 until 2016, when he was hired to be the head coach at Florida Atlantic, a position he held until December 2019, when he became the head coach at Ole Miss.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2006 Rose Bowl</span> 2006 edition of the Rose Bowl American Football championship

The 2006 Rose Bowl Game, played on January 4, 2006, at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, California, was an American college football bowl game that served as the BCS National Championship Game for the 2005 NCAA Division I-A football season. It featured the only two unbeaten teams of the season: the defending Rose Bowl champion and reigning Big 12 Conference champion Texas Longhorns played Pacific-10 Conference titleholders and two-time defending AP national champions, the USC Trojans. Texas would defeat USC 41–38 to capture its fourth football championship in program history and first consensus national title since 1969. The game was a back-and-forth contest; Texas's victory was not secured until the game's final nineteen seconds. Vince Young, the Texas quarterback, and Michael Huff, a Texas safety, were named the offensive and defensive Rose Bowl Players of the Game. ESPN named Young's fourth-down, game-winning touchdown run the fifth-highest rated play in college football history. The game is the highest-rated BCS game in TV history with 21.7% of households watching it, and is often considered the greatest Rose Bowl game of all time, as well as the greatest college football game ever played.

The 2005 USC Trojans football team represented the University of Southern California in the 2005 NCAA Division I-A football season, winning the Pacific-10 Conference (Pac-10), and playing for the NCAA Division I-A national championship. The team was coached by Pete Carroll, led on offense by quarterback and 2004 Heisman Trophy winner Matt Leinart, and played their home games in the Los Angeles Coliseum.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oklahoma Sooners football</span> Football team of the University of Oklahoma

The Oklahoma Sooners football team represents the University of Oklahoma (OU) in college football at the NCAA Division I Football Bowl Subdivision level in the Southeastern Conference (SEC). The program began in 1895 and is one of the most successful in history, having won 949 games and possessing a .725 winning percentage, both sixth all-time. Oklahoma has appeared in the AP poll 905 times, including 101 No. 1 rankings, both third all-time. The program claims seven national championships, 50 conference championships, 167 first-team All-Americans, and seven Heisman Trophy winners. The school has had 29 former players and coaches inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame and holds the record for the longest winning streak in Division I history with 47 straight victories. Oklahoma is also the only program with which four coaches have won more than 100 games each.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">UCLA–USC rivalry</span> American collegiate athletics rivalry

The UCLA–USC rivalry is the American collegiate athletics rivalry between the UCLA Bruins sports teams of the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and USC Trojans teams of the University of Southern California (USC).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2005 Orange Bowl</span> College football game

The 2005 Orange Bowl was the BCS National Championship Game of the 2004 NCAA Division I-A football season and was played on January 4, 2005, at Pro Player Stadium in Miami Gardens, Florida. The game matched the USC Trojans against the Oklahoma Sooners. Both teams entered with undefeated, 12–0 records. Despite only being a 1-point favorite, USC defeated Oklahoma by a score of 55–19, led by quarterback Matt Leinart. ESPN named Leinart's performance as one of the top-10 performances in the first ten years of the BCS system.

The 2004 USC Trojans football team represented the University of Southern California in the 2004 NCAA Division I-A football season. The 2004 Trojans football team won the 2004 BCS National Championship by winning the 2005 Orange Bowl, that year's BCS National Championship Game. The team also won the AP title for the second year in a row. It was the Trojans' first unanimous national championship since 1972, and the second time a team had gone wire-to-wire, with the Trojans holding the number 1 spot in the polls all season. The team was coached by Pete Carroll in his fourth year with the Trojans, and played their home games in the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum. The team is widely considered one of the greatest college football teams of all time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Notre Dame–USC football rivalry</span> American college football rivalry

The Notre Dame–USC football rivalry is an American college football rivalry between the Notre Dame Fighting Irish football team of the University of Notre Dame and USC Trojans football team of the University of Southern California, customarily played on the Saturday following Thanksgiving Day when the game is in Los Angeles or on the second or third Saturday of October when the game is in South Bend, Indiana.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alabama–Ole Miss football rivalry</span> American college football rivalry

The Alabama–Ole Miss football rivalry is an American college football rivalry between the Alabama Crimson Tide and Ole Miss Rebels. They are charter members of the Southeastern Conference (SEC), and both have competed in the SEC West since 1992.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">UMass Minutemen football</span> University Football Team

The UMass Minutemen football team represents the University of Massachusetts Amherst in the NCAA Division I Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS). The Minutemen compete as an FBS independent. Since 1965, their home games have been played at Warren McGuirk Alumni Stadium on the university's campus in Hadley, Massachusetts.

In the University of Southern California athletics scandal, the University of Southern California (USC) was investigated and punished for NCAA rules violations in the Trojan football, men's basketball and women's tennis programs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Notre Dame–Stanford football rivalry</span> American college football rivalry

The Notre Dame–Stanford football rivalry is an American college football rivalry between the Notre Dame Fighting Irish football team of the University of Notre Dame and Stanford Cardinal football team of Stanford University. As of 2023, the Notre Dame Fighting Irish and Stanford Cardinal have met 37 times, beginning in 1925. The Notre Dame–Stanford game has been played annually since 1997, with the teams meeting at Notre Dame Stadium earlier in the season in even-numbered years, and at Stanford Stadium on the weekend following Thanksgiving in odd-numbered years since 1999. The game typically alternates positions in Notre Dame's schedule with its other former Pac-12 opponent, USC.

In various sports, a forfeit is a method in which a match automatically ends, and the forfeiting team loses.

References

  1. ↑ Mandel, Stewart. "Vacated LSU wins leave Les Miles out of CFB Hall of Fame consideration". The Athletic. Retrieved June 22, 2023.
  2. 1 2 3 Bishop, Greg (August 1, 2011). "N.C.A.A. Penalties Erase Wins but Not Memories (Published 2011)". NYTimes.com .
  3. ↑ Tjarks, Jonathan (February 27, 2018). "The NCAA's System Is in Shambles. Its Response? Keep Vacating Wins". The Ringer. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  4. 1 2 Wahl, Grant (November 13, 2002). "When is a forfeit not a loss?". SI.com. Archived from the original on June 4, 2011. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  5. 1 2 3 "NCAA Statistics Policies (updated 2020)" (PDF). NCAA. Archived (PDF) from the original on July 13, 2019. Retrieved November 2, 2020.
  6. 1 2 3 4 Moltz, David. "Pretending They Didn't Happen". Inside Higher Ed. Archived from the original on July 13, 2011. Retrieved November 2, 2020.
  7. ↑ Johnson, Richard (February 20, 2018). "What happens when the NCAA vacates wins? And why do they do it?". SBNation.com. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  8. ↑ "2010-11 NCAA Statistics Policies (updated 9/15/2010)". NCAA. Archived from the original on September 3, 2011. Retrieved November 2, 2020.
  9. ↑ "Forfeits and Vacated Games". College Basketball at Sports-Reference.com. Sports Reference . Retrieved February 22, 2021.
  10. ↑ Sauer, Patrick. "A Forgotten Classic and the Complicated Legacy of the 1961 St. Joe's Hawks". www.vice.com. Vice News . Retrieved February 22, 2021.
  11. ↑ "2007-08 SAINT JOSEPH'S BASKETBALL" (PDF). p. 163. Retrieved February 22, 2021.
  12. 1 2 Norlander, Matt. "Louisville isn't the 1st NCAA champion to vacate a championship -- here are the rest". CBSSports.com. Retrieved February 22, 2021.
  13. ↑ "DI Men's Soccer Championship History". www.ncaa.com. NCAA . Retrieved February 22, 2021.
  14. ↑ Cornish, Stephanie (May 5, 2016). "Spike Lee Chronicles Historic Howard Soccer Team". Afro. Retrieved February 22, 2021.
  15. ↑ Williams, Jack (December 6, 2016). "Howard's history-making men's soccer champions needed to be twice as good". the Guardian. Retrieved February 22, 2021.
  16. 1 2 Bender, Bill. "NCAA misses mark on Notre Dame, proves again vacating wins is stupid". SportingNews.com. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  17. 1 2 Pierce, Charles P. "Reinstate vacated teams to NCAA record books". Sports Illustrated. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  18. ↑ Dwyer, Colin (February 20, 2018). "Louisville Must Vacate Its 2013 National Title After NCAA Upholds Ruling". NPR. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  19. 1 2 3 4 5 Bogage, Jacob. "So your NCAA title was vacated. What do you do with all the trophies and banners?". chicagotribune.com. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  20. ↑ Low, Chris (June 16, 2009). "What does vacating wins really mean?". ESPN.com. ESPN Internet Ventures. Retrieved July 9, 2011. And in terms of the series record, it's as if those games were never played.
  21. ↑ Paschall, David (June 16, 2009). "Rolled back: Tide below .500 for 2000s". TimesFreePress.com. Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. Retrieved July 9, 2011. The Volunteers will get a break, however, in their series record against Alabama because the '05 game in Tuscaloosa no longer will count.
  22. ↑ Schad, Joe (July 26, 2009). "ACC commissioner opposed to vacating games". ESPN.com.
  23. ↑ Dinich, Heather (July 15, 2011). "Former GT center Sean Bedford responds". ESPN.com.
  24. ↑ "Vacating Wins: An Empty Punishment". NESN . July 6, 2009.
  25. ↑ Bahn, Chris (July 8, 2011). "Bahn: Vacating Wins No Real Punishment, How About Coaches And ADs Vacate Their Salaries?". ArkansasSports360. Archived from the original on July 11, 2011. Retrieved November 2, 2020.
  26. 1 2 "UMass women's tennis team stripped of title by NCAA over $252 phone bill". The Guardian . London. October 27, 2020.
  27. ↑ Sullivan, Tara (October 24, 2020). "In punishing UMass for a $252 violation, the NCAA's hypocrisy is on full display" . BostonGlobe.com.
  28. 1 2 DeCourcy, Mike (October 29, 2020). "Stripping UMass women's tennis of Atlantic 10 championship could be the worst miscarriage of NCAA justice, ever". www.sportingnews.com.
  29. 1 2 Kirshner, Alex (February 23, 2018). "11 of the best college games the NCAA says didn't happen". SBNation.com. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  30. ↑ Garci, Marlen (August 19, 2009). "NCAA vacates Memphis' '07–08 season record, Final Four run". USA Today. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  31. ↑ Schlabach, Mark (February 20, 2018). "NCAA denies Louisville's appeal, rules Cardinals must vacate 2013 national title". ESPN.com. Retrieved February 21, 2018.
  32. ↑ "Ex-Louisville players' stats, honors restored as part of NCAA settlement". ESPN.com. Associated Press. September 30, 2019. Retrieved October 1, 2019.
  33. ↑ "Penn State wins from Paterno era restored". ESPN.com. January 16, 2015. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  34. ↑ Chiari, Mike (January 16, 2015). "NCAA Restores Joe Paterno's Vacated Wins in Lawsuit Settlement". Bleacher Report. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  35. ↑ Jung, Tristan (February 15, 2019). "The Top 10 vacated games in college football history". Sports Illustrated. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  36. ↑ Dinich, Heather (March 6, 2009). "NCAA penalties extend to 10 FSU sports". ESPN.com . Archived from the original on May 2, 2024. Retrieved December 3, 2024.
  37. 1 2 "NCAA places Georgia Tech on probation". ESPN. July 14, 2011. Retrieved July 14, 2011.
  38. ↑ Sugiura, Ken (November 12, 2011). "Georgia Tech's appeals hearing Sunday". Atlanta Journal. Retrieved April 13, 2013.
  39. ↑ "Year-by-Year Results: 2009" (PDF). Georgia Tech Football Information Guide. Georgia Tech Communications and Public Relations. 2023. p. 191. Retrieved January 28, 2024– via ramblinwreck.com.
  40. ↑ Blair Kerkhoff, Southern Cal stripped of 2005 Orange Bowl victory, The Kansas City Star, June 10, 2010
  41. ↑ Kirshner, Alex (February 21, 2018). "Vacating wins is stupid". SBNation.com. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  42. ↑ Report: USC to keep AP title. ESPN, June 11, 2010.
  43. ↑ Associated Press (February 8, 2010). "SPORTS BRIEFING COLLEGE ATHLETICS; Florida State To Vacate Wins". The New York Times . Retrieved March 24, 2010.
  44. ↑ "Buckeyes vacate wins from last football season". ESPN.com. July 8, 2011. The measures taken by the school included vacating all the Buckeyes' wins from last season, a year in which Ohio State captured a record-tying sixth straight Big Ten title and won an unprecedented seventh straight game over Michigan.
  45. 1 2 Patterson, Chip (March 3, 2016). "Ragin' Cajuns vacate 2013 Sun Belt title, 22 wins due to NCAA violations". CBS Sports . Retrieved December 22, 2019.
  46. ↑ "NCAA appeals committee upholds vacation of Notre Dame wins" . Retrieved February 14, 2022.
  47. 1 2 Mandel, Stewart. "Vacated LSU wins leave Les Miles out of CFB Hall of Fame consideration". The Athletic. Retrieved June 22, 2023.
  48. ↑ Sparks, Adam (July 15, 2023). "These Tennessee football wins under Jeremy Pruitt have been vacated". USA Today . Retrieved July 16, 2023.
  49. ↑ Bonagura, Kyle (September 12, 2017). "USC tweaks Texas, claims 4-0 all-time record". ESPN.com. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  50. ↑ Moriarty, Morgan (September 11, 2017). "USC cites 'NCAA-vacated loss' to change Texas record". SBNation.com. Retrieved December 29, 2021.
  51. ↑ "Archived Team-By-Team Final Statistics". NCAA.org.
  52. ↑ "Records and Results" (PDF). SMU Football 2005 Media Guide. p. 147. Archived from the original (PDF) on November 7, 2011. Retrieved May 29, 2014.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.