Valparaiso University deaccessioning controversy

Last updated December 05, 2024

In early 2023, Valparaiso University in Valparaiso, Indiana, U.S., under the leadership of president José Padilla, announced that it had decided to sell three paintings in its collection to fund dormitory renovations. The proposed sale of three paintings— Mountain Landscape (c. 1849) by Frederic Edwin Church, The Silver Veil and the Golden Gate (1914) by Childe Hassam, and Rust Red Hills (1930) by Georgia O'Keeffe—sparked fierce opposition, including protests from faculty and students, and from Richard H. W. Brauer, founder and director of the university's Brauer Museum of Art where the paintings were exhibited.

Background

In early 2023, university president Padilla argued that the university's declining enrollment and financial situation necessitated the sale of three paintings from the permanent collection of the Brauer Museum of Art. Padilla also threatened to cut additional programs and positions. The university board and administration declared that the paintings represent assets that "are not core or critical to the educational mission or strategic plan" to increase enrollment and grow the university.^[1] To cut costs, the university shut down its law school in 2020 and no longer offers degrees in secondary education and French. By selling the paintings, Valparaiso will raise more than the projected $8–10 million needed to build new student housing,^[2] with the O'Keeffe painting alone worth $10–15 million.^[3]

Museum association opposition

The proposed sale was opposed by the Association of Art Museum Directors (AAMD), the American Alliance of Museums (AAM), the Association of Academic Museums and Galleries (AAMG), and the Association of Art Museum Curators (AAMC). The ethical guidelines and best practices of deaccessioning require that proceeds from any art sales must be used solely for art, not for infrastructure projects like the kind Valparaiso intended to complete. According to the AAMD, when a museum generally sells work to raise money, the proceeds are usually conserved for other artworks, either for the purpose of obtaining new works or to preserve the old ones.^[4] The Brauer Museum was not a member of AAMD or the AAMC, but the director of the museum was a member of the AAMG and the museum itself was an unaccredited member of AAM.^[5]

Lawsuit

Brauer and Philipp Brockington filed suit in Indiana state court against the university, arguing that the proposed sale violated the original Sloan trust agreement, which requires revenue from paintings that are sold to be put back into the Sloan purchase fund. The university countered that Brauer's original purchase of an impressionist painting by Hassam and a modernist work by O'Keeffe, violated the Sloan agreement which specified that the funds were only to be used to buy "conservative", or representational, non-abstract works of art.^[6] The university also argued that they needed to sell the painting to address their deficit and student decline, and that a dormitory renovation would increase enrollment. The university noted that the Brauer Museum is not professionally accredited, and therefore does not have to follow the ethical standards and guidelines of deaccessioning common to accredited museums.^[7] Brauer and Brockington were denied standing by the court. Todd Rokita, the Indiana attorney general, reviewed the case and supported the position taken by Valparaiso.^[8]

Firing of staff and museum closure

In June 2024, the university eliminated the position of museum director and 13 other staff members and closed the Brauer Museum indefinitely, citing a restructuring effort.^[3]

Related Research Articles

Valparaiso, colloquially Valpo, is a city in and the county seat of Porter County, Indiana, United States. The population was 34,151 at the 2020 census. It is part of the Chicago metropolitan area.

Georgia Totto O'Keeffe was an American modernist painter and draftswoman whose career spanned seven decades and whose work remained largely independent of major art movements. Called the "Mother of American modernism", O'Keeffe gained international recognition for her meticulous paintings of natural forms, particularly flowers and desert-inspired landscapes, which were often drawn from and related to places and environments in which she lived.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Valparaiso University</span> Lutheran university in Valparaiso, Indiana, US

Valparaiso University (Valpo) is a private university in Valparaiso, Indiana, United States. It is an independent Lutheran university with five colleges. It enrolls nearly 2,300 students and has a 350-acre (140 ha) campus.

Barbara Buhler Lynes is an art historian, curator, professor, and preeminent scholar on the art and life of Georgia O'Keeffe. She retired on February 14, 2020 from her position as the Sunny Kaufman Senior Curator at the NSU Museum of Art in Fort Lauderdale, Florida to continue her scholarly work on O'Keeffe and American modernism. From 1999 to 2012, she served as the founding curator of the Georgia O'Keeffe Museum in Santa Fe, New Mexico, where she curated or oversaw more than thirty exhibitions of works by O'Keeffe and her contemporaries. Lynes was also the Founding Emily Fisher Landau Director of the Georgia O'Keeffe Museum Research Center from 2001 to 2012. Prior to her work at the Georgia O'Keeffe Museum, Lynes served as an independent consultant to the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. from 1992 to 1999 and has taught art history at Vanderbilt University, Dartmouth College, Montgomery College, and the Maryland Institute College of Art (MICA).

Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art is a museum of American art in Bentonville, Arkansas. The museum, founded by Alice Walton and designed by Moshe Safdie, officially opened on 11 November 2011. It offers free public admission.

The Georgia O'Keeffe Museum is dedicated to the artistic legacy of Georgia O'Keeffe, her life, American modernism, and public engagement. It opened on July 17, 1997, eleven years after the artist's death. It comprises multiple sites in two locations: Santa Fe, New Mexico, and Abiquiu, New Mexico. In addition to the founding Georgia O'Keeffe Museum in Santa Fe, the O'Keeffe includes: the Library and Archive within its research center at the historic A.M. Bergere house; the Education Annex for youth and public programming; Georgia O'Keeffe's historic Abiquiu Home and Studio; the O'Keeffe Welcome Center in Abiquiu; and Museum Stores in both Santa Fe and Abiquiu. Georgia O'Keeffe's additional home at the Ghost Ranch property is also part of the O'Keeffe Museum's assets, but is not open to the public.

The Brauer Museum of Art was an art museum at Valparaiso University, a private university in Valparaiso, Indiana. It was home to a collection of 19th- and 20th-century American art, world religious art, and Midwestern regional art. It was located in the Valparaiso University Center for the Arts (VUCA). Prior to the museum's opening, the university's collection was housed and displayed within several buildings across campus. It was named the Brauer Museum of Art in 1996 to honor the collection's long-time director and curator, Richard H. W. Brauer. The university began exploring selling parts of its art collection in 2023, to significant controversy and adverse legal action, and closed the museum in the summer of 2024.

Mark A. Heckler is a former president of Valparaiso University. He was named the 18th president of the university on July 1, 2008, succeeding Alan Harre, and served until September 1, 2020, when he was named president emeritus.

Art museums in the United States and the United Kingdom have been hit especially hard by the 2008–2012 global recession. Dwindling endowments from wealthy patrons forced some museums to make difficult and controversial decisions to deaccession artwork from their collections to gain funds, or in the case of the Rose Art Museum, to close the institution and sell the entire collection.

The Greenville County Museum of Art (GCMA) is an art museum located in Greenville, South Carolina. Its collections focus mainly on American art, and its holdings include works by Andrew Wyeth,Jasper Johns, William Henry Johnson, Andy Warhol, Romare Bearden, Jacob Lawrence, Alma Thomas, Helen Turner, Charles Wilson Peale, Eric Fischl, Marylyn Dintenfass, and Leonardo Drew. Southern American and South Carolina-based artists, such as Elizabeth O'Neill Verner, are also represented.

The Georgia Museum of Art is an art museum in Athens, Georgia, United States, associated with the University of Georgia (UGA). The museum is both an academic museum and, since 1982, the official art museum of the state of Georgia. The permanent collection consists of American paintings, primarily 19th- and 20th-century; American, European and Asian works on paper; the Samuel H. Kress Study Collection of Italian Renaissance paintings; growing collections of southern decorative arts and Asian art; and a strong collection of works by African American artists. It numbers more than 17,000 works, growing every year.

Maier Museum of Art at Randolph College features works by American artists from the 19th through 21st centuries. Randolph College has been collecting American art since 1907 and the Maier Museum of Art now houses its collection of several thousand American paintings, prints, drawings, and photographs from the 19th and 21st centuries.

Hazel Hannell was an American artist and activist. She was known for her pottery, watercolors, woodblock prints, activism for the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore and development of the Chesterton Arts Fair. She taught pottery in her studio at home and watercolor painting at The Clearing Folk School in Ellison Bay, Wisconsin through her connection to fellow Prairie Club member Jens Jensen. She died in Ashland, Oregon while living with Harriet Rex Smith at age 106.

Deaccessioning is the process by which a work of art or other object is permanently removed from a museum's collection to sell it or otherwise dispose of it.

Georgiana Uhlyarik-Nicolae, also known as Georgiana Uhlyarik is a Romanian-born Canadian art curator, art historian, and teacher. She is currently the Fredrik S. Eaton Curator of Canadian Art at the Art Gallery of Ontario (AGO). She has been part of the team or led teams that created numerous exhibitions, on subjects such as Betty Goodwin, Michael Snow, and Kathleen Munn among others and collaborated with art organizations such as the Tate Modern, and the Jewish Museum, New York.

José D. Padilla is the 19th President of Valparaiso University. Padilla was most recently vice president, university counsel, and secretary of the University of Colorado system, and previously held similar roles for 15 years at DePaul University.

Rust Red Hills is a 1930 landscape painting by American artist Georgia O'Keeffe. It depicts red and brown hills under a glowing red and yellow sky in northern New Mexico, most likely in the vicinity of Taos. At its initial exhibition in 1931, O'Keeffe indicated that it was one of her own best-loved paintings from that time period. The work is currently held by the Brauer Museum of Art, but in 2023, Valparaiso University, which runs the museum, announced they planned to sell the painting and two others to raise money to renovate the student dormitories. Art associations protested the pending sale as an ethical violation of the deaccessioning process.

Mountain Landscape, previously known as Sunset—West Rock, New Haven, is an 1849 landscape painting by American artist Frederic Edwin Church of the Hudson River School, completed during his early period. The work depicts a mountain landscape with a lake and a small farm in the Northeastern United States based on Church's travels through the state of Vermont. The painting was originally part of the Nickerson art collection but was later donated to Valparaiso University as part of the Sloan bequest in 1953 and exhibited at the Brauer Museum of Art. In 2023, the university proposed selling the painting as an asset to fund dormitory renovations, leading to a contentious debate about the ethics of deaccessioning artwork.

The Silver Veil and the Golden Gate is a late period, coastal landscape painting by American Impressionist Childe Hassam. Completed in 1914 during one of his visits to California, the piece depicts the Golden Gate Strait, a narrow passage connecting the San Francisco Bay to the Pacific Ocean, as seen near Sausalito. The "silver veil" refers to the San Francisco fog that frequently envelops the region.

The California series by Childe Hassam is a series of approximately 28 works based on American Impressionist Childe Hassam's visits to Northern California at least three times, in 1904, 1908, and 1914, and Southern California at least once in 1927. The works between 1904 and 1914 feature images from the San Francisco Bay Area, while the 1927-28 works feature images from Los Angeles, San Diego, and Santa Barbara. Out of his approximately 4000 works, Hassam's focus on California is relatively small, with only 12 major California paintings completed between 1914 and 1919. Additional minor works in the series include approximately 16 or so etchings from 1916 to 1928. Most of the works made in 1928 were based on drawings from 1927. 11 of the 12 California paintings were created in 1914 and first exhibited as part of the "California Group" of 106 paintings total in the Exhibition of Pictures by Childe Hassam at the Montross Gallery in New York in 1915. A twelfth painting in the series, California, has been dated to 1919. The majority of Hassam's Calfiornia etchings were first exhibited at the American Academy of Arts and Letters in 1927.

References

↑ Jones, Shelly (February 15, 2023). "Valparaiso University students protest plan to sell three paintings, including a Georgia O'Keeffe". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
↑ Richardson, Kalia (March 10, 2023). "Its Georgia O'Keeffe Is Worth Millions. And Its Dorms Need Updating". The New York Times . Archived from the original on September 28, 2024. Retrieved October 23, 2024.
1 2 Lavalley, Amy (June 21, 2024). "Valparaiso University cuts 14 staff, including museum director, in restructuring effort". Chicago Tribune . Archived from the original on September 4, 2024. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
↑ Boucher, Brian Boucher (September 4, 2024). "A Court Approves Valparaiso's Plan to Sell Artworks". Artnet News . Archived from the original on December 4, 2024. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
↑ "Joint Statement on Brauer Museum of Art, Valparaiso University". Association of Art Museum Directors . Archived from the original on September 17, 2024. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
↑ Cui, Liya (September 4, 2024). "Indiana Court Allows Valparaiso University to Sell O'Keeffe Painting". Reuters . Retrieved October 30, 2024.
↑ Boucher, Brian (July 1, 2024). "'It Defames Me': Brauer Museum Founding Director Blasts Valparaiso University's Ongoing Deaccessioning Plan" Archived December 4, 2024, at archive.today . Artnet . Retrieved October 23, 2024.
↑ LaValley, Amy (June 20, 2023). "Indiana AG files for dismissal of lawsuit against Valpo U over artwork sale". Post-Tribune. Retrieved October 29, 2024.