When Helping Hurts

Last updated
When Helping Hurts: Alleviating Poverty Without Hurting the Poor. . . and Yourself
When Helping Hurts, by Steve Corbett and Brian Fikkert, book cover, 2nd edition.jpg
AuthorSteve Corbett, Brian Fikkert
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
GenreNon-fiction
Publisher Moody Publishers
Publication date
June 24, 2009
Media typePrint, e-book
Pages232 pages
ISBN 0802457053

When Helping Hurts: Alleviating Poverty Without Hurting the Poor. . . and Yourself is a 2009 non-fiction book by Steve Corbett and Brian Fikkert. The book was first published on June 24, 2009 through Moody Publishers and explores and dissects common perceptions on poverty and the means to relieve it, from a Christian perspective. [1] In 2012, Moody published a revised, second edition. By June 2015, When Helping Hurts had sold more than 300,000 copies and been translated into 5 languages. [2]

Contents

Synopsis

When Helping Hurts uses the Bible and the Great Commission to state that the church's mission should be to help the poor and the desolate. Corbett and Fikkert state that the definition of poverty will change depending on who is defining it, with the poor defining it through the psychological and social scope while more wealthy churches emphasize the lack of material things or a geographical location. The authors emphasize that this can cause a harmful cycle where North American churches provide material resources and evangelism to the poor, which reinforces the poor people's sense of inferiority and lack of self-esteem, which in turn increases the original problem. [3] Corbett and Fikkert give several hypothetical scenarios to illustrate this cycle and then offer several solutions that they say can alleviate poverty. They promote the use of asset-based community development as a strategy, arguing that focusing on what resources and abilities that the community already has is often more helpful and more empowering than focusing on what the community doesn't have. This prevents paternalism where outside workers provide the "only" answer. [4]

Structure

The book was originally divided into three parts: the mission of the church and the Christian view of poverty, discussion on poverty and examples of harmful poverty alleviation, and strategies for addressing poverty. The second edition added a fourth part that gave additional resources to bring about real change in church and community.

Christian view of poverty (according to the authors)

According to the authors, the Christian view of poverty comes from a proper understanding of why Jesus came to earth, namely, to bring healing to the entire cosmos and be supreme over all the universe. They cite a model Bryant L. Myers develops in Walking with the Poor: Principles and Practices of Transformational Development that describes humans as being in relationship with God, Self, Others, and the Rest of Creation. This comes from the concept that God originally designed humans in His image, and therefore as relational beings. This contrasts with a view that Jesus came only to save mankind from their sin so they could go to heaven. Referring to Colossians 1, they say Jesus came not only to save souls, but also to reconcile all things to God, or “to put into right relationship all that He created”. They quote Bryant Myers, "Poverty is the result of relationships that do not work, that are not just, that are not for life, that are not harmonious or enjoyable. Poverty is the absence of shalom in all its meanings." Lesa Engelthaler in Christianity Today wrote that the premise of the book is that, "in one way or the other, every human being is poor." [2]

Shame. Fear. Unhappiness. Depression. Inferiority. Powerlessness. Dissatisfaction. Voicelessness. [5] :51 No one wants these attributes in their daily lives but this is what a person in poverty feels every day. From, not only a Christian view, but from the view of any person whether they are well off or have to live from day to day, understand that no human should live in poverty whether it be in physical, emotional, or spiritual poverty. [5] :57 Unfortunately, when people think of the word poverty their mind immediately thinks of material things or money. “Poverty is not just a lack of money. It is not just hunger and need for shelter or clothing. Many poor people are plagued with social and spiritual poverty, and their view of their value is also affected.” [6] For Christians, poverty alleviation stems from the Bible, first and foremost, and the key is to bring people to Jesus Christ while also providing necessary help. For many, especially in the western world, poverty is seen as a lack of material things. [7] Lack of housing, food, water, clothes etc., but for people and organizations that base themselves in Christianity it is more than just providing the basic necessities but also, as it says in ‘When Helping Hurts’ by Steve Corbett and Brian Fikkert, “Poverty is rooted in broken relationships, so the solution to poverty is rooted in the power of Jesus’ death and resurrection to put all things into right relationship again”. [5] :54,73

If this is the Christian view on poverty, then material things are not going to be able to provide what is really needed. Not only may this be the wrong approach but you may end up doing more harm than good. Material things are not always the answer to everything. Most westerners consciously or unconsciously believe that in order to alleviate poverty, material things must be given, or money must be given in order to obtain those material things like when you see an ad on TV asking to feed the poor in some ‘third world’ country. [8] Your first thought may be something like this, “If I donate, this money will be used for food, water, clothes…” Of course there’s nothing wrong with that, It’s Great!. [5] :74,76 But is that really what they need when a family has just been killed? No, they need emotional support like any other person. When your government is collapsing, you don’t need money (necessarily) you need a good person, a smart person, in a position of power to move in the right direction.

The giving of material things isn’t bad, but it isn’t always good. In the book ‘When Helping Hurts,’ poverty alleviation is described as, “....the ministry of reconciliation: moving people closer to glorifying God by living in right relationship with God, with self, with others, and with the rest of creation“. [5] :74 Poverty alleviation is not just the giving of material things it is about taking care of the whole human being: the social, emotional, mental, physical, and spiritual aspects of the person. [9] To be able to alleviate poverty properly, the right mindset is needed. Believing that money or material things can solve your problems will instead cause poverty to be elevated instead of being alleviated. A first step to alleviating poverty is changing the mindset of those who want to help and those who need help. Material things aren’t everything. This is a step that every organization, spiritually based or not, needs to take if they are to aid the poor. You must not look at just the surface but on the inside as well. Looks can be deceiving and if you don’t consider every aspect of the human being then you will be doing more harm than good. Poverty isn’t just a lack of material things but also a lack of what makes a person human. Pride. Self-esteem. Courage. Happiness. These are things that money can’t buy and that money cannot give you. [5] :51,52

Reception

Reception for When Helping Hurts has been positive, with World Magazine's Joel Belz calling it "solid stuff". [10] Mission Studies gave a positive review for When Helping Hurts, saying it was "based on good theological premises" and "is a very useful and accessible contribution to Christian relief and development". [11] Charity organization Children of the Nations cited it as one of their "favorite books" and as a recommended read. [12]

Criticism

When asked if he has regrets about the book, Fikkert said that he has found many people stop helping for fear that it is causing unintended hurt, saying some call it “When Helping Hurts paralysis”. He said this misses the point, “The point was a pause and some redirection.” [2] In the Preface of the second edition, they address this, saying Christians should multiply their efforts, while considering their methods of helping the poor.

Related Research Articles

Christianity and Judaism Comparison of Christianity and Judaism

Christianity is rooted in Second Temple Judaism, but the two religions diverged in the first centuries of the Christian Era. Christianity emphasizes correct belief, focusing on the New Covenant as mediated through Jesus Christ, as recorded in the New Testament. Judaism places emphasis on correct conduct, focusing on the Mosaic covenant, as recorded in the Torah and Talmud.

Christian socialism is a religious and political philosophy that blends Christianity and socialism, endorsing left-wing politics and socialist economics on the basis of the Bible and the teachings of Jesus. Many Christian socialists believe capitalism to be idolatrous and rooted in the sin of greed. Christian socialists identify the cause of social inequality to be the greed that they associate with capitalism. Christian socialism became a major movement in the United Kingdom beginning in the 19th century. The Christian Socialist Movement, known as Christians on the Left since 2013, is one formal group, as well as a faction of the Labour Party.

Christian anarchism Movement in political theology

Christian anarchism is a Christian movement in political theology that claims anarchism is inherent in Christianity and the Gospels. It is grounded in the belief that there is only one source of authority to which Christians are ultimately answerable—the authority of God as embodied in the teachings of Jesus. It therefore rejects the idea that human governments have ultimate authority over human societies. Christian anarchists denounce the state, believing it is violent, deceitful and, when glorified, idolatrous.

Catholic social teaching, commonly abbreviated CST, is an area of Catholic doctrine concerning matters of human dignity and the common good in society. The ideas address oppression, the role of the state, subsidiarity, social organization, concern for social justice, and issues of wealth distribution. Its foundations are widely considered to have been laid by Pope Leo XIII's 1891 encyclical letter Rerum novarum, which advocated economic distributism. Its roots can be traced to the writings of Catholic theologians such as St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Augustine of Hippo. It is also derived from the concepts present in the Bible and the cultures of the ancient Near East.

Prosperity theology is a religious belief among some Protestant Christians that financial blessing and physical well-being are always the will of God for them, and that faith, positive speech, and donations to religious causes will increase one's material wealth. Material and especially financial success is seen as a sign of divine favor.

The Members of the Covenant were an important part of early Syriac Christianity. Before the advent of monasticism proper, most Syriac churches would consist of a community focused around the members of the covenant: men and women who had committed themselves to sexual abstinence and the service of the church. This name is the English translation of the Syriac bnay qyāmâ, literally sons of the covenant. A male member of the covenant was called bar qyāmâ, or son of the covenant; a female member was bat qyāmâ, or daughter of the covenant.

The image of God is a concept and theological doctrine in Christianity, as well as in Judaism. This concept is a foundational aspect of Christian and Jewish understandings of human nature. It stems from the primary text in Genesis 1:27, which reads: "So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them." The exact meaning of the phrase has been debated for millennia.

Centesimus annus is an encyclical which was written by Pope John Paul II in 1991 on the hundredth anniversary of Rerum novarum, an encyclical issued by Pope Leo XIII in 1891. It is part of a larger body of writings, known as Catholic social teaching, which trace their origin to Rerum novarum and aim to relate the teachings of Jesus to the industrial age.

The New Church (Swedenborgian) Several historically related Christian denominations influenced by theologian Emanuel Swedenborg

The New Church is any of several historically related Christian denominations that developed as a new religious group, influenced by the writings of scientist and mystic Emanuel Swedenborg (1688–1772).

Stewardship is a theological belief that humans are responsible for the world, and should take care and look after it. Believers in stewardship are usually people who believe in one God who created the universe and all that is within it, also believing that they must take care of creation and look after it. Creation includes animals and the environment. Many religions and denominations have various degrees of support for environmental stewardship. It can have political implications, such as in Christian Democracy.

Catholic spirituality

Catholic spirituality includes the various ways in which Catholics live out their Baptismal promise through prayer and action. The primary prayer of all Catholics is the Eucharistic liturgy in which they celebrate and share their faith together, in accord with Jesus' instruction: "Do this in memory of me." The Catholic bishops at the Second Vatican Council decreed that "devotions should be so drawn up that they harmonize with the liturgical seasons, accord with the sacred liturgy, are in some fashion derived from it, and lead the people to it, since, in fact, the liturgy by its very nature far surpasses any of them." In accord with this, many additional forms of prayer have developed over the centuries as means of animating one's personal Christian life, at times in gatherings with others. Each of the religious orders and congregations of the Catholic church, as well as lay groupings, has specifics to its own spirituality – its way of approaching God in prayer to foster its way of living out the Gospel.

Ten Commandments in Catholic theology Influence of Hebrew Bible law of Moses in doctrines of the Roman Catholic Church

The Ten Commandments are series of religious and moral imperatives that are recognized as a moral foundation in several of the Abrahamic religions, including the Catholic Church. As described in the Old Testament books Exodus and Deuteronomy, the Commandments form part of a covenant offered by God to the Israelites to free them from the spiritual slavery of sin. According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church—the official exposition of the Catholic Church's Christian beliefs—the Commandments are considered essential for spiritual good health and growth, and serve as the basis for Catholic social teaching. A review of the Commandments is one of the most common types of examination of conscience used by Catholics before receiving the sacrament of Penance.

Christian deism

Christian deism is a standpoint in the philosophy of religion stemming from Christianity and Deism. It refers to Deists who believes in the moral teachings—but not the divinity—of Jesus. Corbett and Corbett (1999) cite John Adams and Thomas Jefferson as exemplars.

Christian views on sin Christian views on sin

Sin is an immoral act considered to be a transgression of divine law. The doctrine of sin is central to Christianity, since its basic message is about redemption in Christ.

Thou shalt not steal One of the Ten Commandments (Exod. 20:15)

"Thou shalt not steal" is one of the Ten Commandments of the Jewish Torah, which are widely understood as moral imperatives by legal scholars, Jewish scholars, Catholic scholars, and Post-Reformation scholars.

"Abundant life" is a term used to refer to Christian teachings on fullness of life. It is not an organized movement or a unique doctrine, but a name applied to the teachings and expectations of the groups and people who follow the teachings. Abundant life teachings may include expectations of prosperity and health, but may also include other forms of fullness of life when faced with adverse circumstances.

Spiritual communion

Spiritual communion is a Christian practice of desiring union with Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. It is used as a preparation for Mass and by individuals who cannot receive holy communion.

Christian theology Study of Christian belief and practice

Christian theology is the theology of Christian belief and practice. Such study concentrates primarily upon the texts of the Old Testament and of the New Testament, as well as on Christian tradition. Christian theologians use biblical exegesis, rational analysis and argument. Theologians may undertake the study of Christian theology for a variety of reasons, such as in order to:

Ignatian spirituality, also known as Jesuit spirituality, is a Catholic spirituality founded on the experiences of the 16th-century Spanish saint Ignatius of Loyola, founder of the Jesuit order. The main idea of this form of spirituality comes from Ignatius's Spiritual Exercises, the aim of which is to help one "conquer oneself and to regulate one's life in such a way that no decision is made under the influence of any inordinate attachment." The Exercises are intended to give the person undertaking them a greater degree of freedom from his or her own likes and dislikes, so that their choices are based solely on what they discern God's will is for them. Even in the composition of the exercises by Ignatius early in his career, one might find the apostolic thrust of his spirituality in his contemplation on "The Call of the Earthly King" and in his final contemplation with its focus on finding God in all things.

Christian views on poverty and wealth Different opinions that Christians have held about material riches

There have been a variety of Christian views on poverty and wealth. At one end of the spectrum is a view which casts wealth and materialism as an evil to be avoided and even combated. At the other end is a view which casts prosperity and well-being as a blessing from God.

References

  1. Larkin, Jim (14 August 2010). "'When Helping Hurts' author to speak at Holland Church on better ways to aid the poor". Grand Rapids Press. Retrieved 25 May 2013.
  2. 1 2 3 Engelthaler, Lesa (June 29, 2015). "The Poverty Fighters' Bible". Christianity Today. Retrieved 15 November 2016.
  3. Dees, J.J. (15 December 2012). "A Tale of Two Cultures: Charity, Problem Solving, and the Future of Social Entrepreneurship". Journal of Business Ethics. 111 (3): 328. doi:10.1007/s10551-012-1412-5. S2CID   154806742.
  4. "From Needs to Assets Charting a Sustainable Path Towards | Repair Manual Free Download PDF". Archived from the original on 2015-01-21. Retrieved 2015-01-20.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Corbett, Steve; Fikkert, Brian (June 24, 2009). When helping hurts: How to Alleviate Poverty without Hurting the Poor...and yourself . Moody Publishers. ISBN   978-0802457059.
  6. Kathryn Feliciano, To the Poor, Poverty Is More Than Material, “Institute for faith, works, and economics”, December 26, 2016
  7. PCA foundation, Helping Without Hurting: Christian Generosity and Material Poverty, PCA Foundation, “Biblical Studies”, Sep 7, 2016
  8. About Poverty, Private General Practice Services, “The foundation for community inspiration”, January 2007
  9. William O. Ondari, Poverty and Wealth: A Christian Perspective, "Christ in the Classroom", July 17–29, 2001
  10. "For good or ill?". World Magazine. Retrieved 25 May 2013.
  11. Hanger, Ralph (2011). "When Helping Hurts: How to Alleviate Poverty without Hurting the Poor and Yourself (review)". Mission Studies. 28 (2): 249–250. doi:10.1163/157338311X605971.
  12. "Our Favorite Books: When Helping Hurts". Children of the Nations. Retrieved 25 May 2013.