Wotton v Queensland (No 5)

Last updated

Wotton v Queensland (No 5)
Coat of Arms of Australia.svg
Court Federal Court of Australia
Full case nameLex Wotton, Agnes Wotton & Cecilia Wotton
v
State of Queensland & Commissioner of the Police Service
Decided5 December 2016
Citation(s) [2016] FCA 1457
Legislation cited Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)
Case history
Prior action(s)No 1 [2015] FCA 910
No 2 [2015] FCA 1073
No 3 [2015] FCA 1074
No 4 [2015] FCA 1075
Court membership
Judge(s) sitting Mortimer J
Area of law
Unlawful racial discrimination; representative proceedings (class actions)

Wotton v Queensland (the Palm Island Class Action case) is a class action lawsuit brought against the State of Queensland and the Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service on behalf of 447 Aboriginal Australians and Torres Strait Islanders who live on Palm Island in Queensland, Australia.

Contents

The class action arose out of the events surrounding the death in police custody of Mulrunji Doomadgee on 19 November 2004, the subsequent protests by the community, which led to the police station being burned down on 26 November 2004, and the police response to those protests. The first applicant in the class action, Lex Wotton, was alleged to have been the "ring leader" in what police called the "Palm Island riot", and was subsequently convicted of "riot causing damage".

The case was heard between September 2015 and May 2016, with an appeal brought and then withdrawn in early 2017. In May 2018, the plaintiffs were granted a A$30-million-dollar settlement and an apology by the Queensland Government.

The class action

In 2013, Lex Wotton, as well as his wife Cecilia and Mother Agnes, filed a class action lawsuit on behalf of Indigenous Australian people who lived on Palm Island against the State of Queensland and the Commissioner of the Police Service, alleging that the police had committed acts of unlawful racial discrimination, in breach of section 9(1) of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) in the investigation into Mulrunji's death in custody and in the subsequent police response to the unrest in the community. [1] [2]

The Wottons' legal team included Lex Wotton's long-standing lawyer, Stewart Levitt of law firm Levitt Robinson Solicitors, as well as prominent anti-discrimination barrister Chris Ronalds SC, Aboriginal barrister Joshua Creamer, and barrister Shaneen Pointing. [3]

Initial trial

The initial trial of the claims of Lex, Agnes and Cecilia Wotton, and the issues common to their claims and the claims of the class members was heard in Townsville over a total of 22 days, between September 2015 and May 2016. On 5 December 2016, Justice Mortimer handed down a 1,806 paragraph judgment, making nine declarations that the police had engaged in acts of unlawful racial discrimination, for which the State was vicariously liable. [3]

Justice Mortimer also ordered that the State of Queensland pay $95,000 in compensation to Lex Wotton, $10,000 to Agnes Wotton, and $115,000 to Cecilia Wotton. [3] According to the Wottons' legal team, the judgment left the door open for potentially hundreds of claims for compensation by Aboriginal residents of Palm Island who were affected by the police conduct. [4]

Appeal

In January 2017, Queensland Attorney-General Yvette D'Ath instructed the Crown Solicitor to file an appeal from Justice Mortimer's judgment. [5] The decision was quickly denounced by the State Member for Townsville, Scott Stewart, and the Federal Member for Herbert, Cathy O'Toole, whose electorates include Palm Island and both of whom were members of D'Ath's Australian Labor Party. [6]

On 28 February 2017, D'Ath announced to the parliament that the appeal was being withdrawn after the State had received "a further considered legal advice about the state's prospects of success on appeal". [7] [8]

Class action settlement

In May 2018, the 447 members of the community involved in the class action were granted a A$30 million dollar settlement and an apology by the Queensland Government. [9] [10]

By May 2020, not all of the money had been distributed, owing to errors in the list of recipients. [11]

Alleged vilification

On 18 May 2020, Nine Network, in a "9News investigation", revealed the recipients of the compensation spent some of their money on cars and boats. [12] Its online report, titled "Palm Island riot compensation spent on luxury boats, sports cars and motorbikes" reported that some of the compensation money paid to the class action recipients had "been spent on luxury items including sports cars, luxury boats and dune buggies". While it reported on one man who had invested money for his family, it also cited a teenager who had bought three cars, and the sale of a boat for A$70,000. [11] On 19 May 2020, the Daily Mail printed an article substantially based on the Nine report. [13]

In August 2020 a group of Palm Islanders lodged a complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission, under Section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act. Stewart Levitt of Levitt Robinson Solicitors said that the report was inaccurate and racist, implying that Palm Islanders did not deserve the compensation and were spending it irresponsibly. [14] The community subsequently sued Nine in the Federal Court of Australia for A$30 million. [15]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Cook University</span> Public university in North Queensland, Australia

James Cook University (JCU) is a public university in North Queensland, Australia. The second oldest university in Queensland, JCU is a teaching and research institution. The university's main campuses are located in the tropical cities of Cairns and Townsville, and one in the city state of Singapore. JCU also has study centres in Mount Isa, Mackay, Thursday Island and Rockhampton. A Brisbane campus, operated by Russo Higher Education, delivers undergraduate and postgraduate courses to international students. The university's main fields of research include environmental sciences, biological sciences, mathematical sciences, earth sciences, agricultural and veterinary sciences, technology and medical and health sciences.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Racial Discrimination Act 1975</span>

The Racial Discrimination Act 1975(Cth) is an Act of the Australian Parliament, which was enacted on 11 June 1975 and passed by the Whitlam government. The Act makes racial discrimination in certain contexts unlawful in Australia, and also overrides state and territory legislation to the extent of any inconsistency.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Palm Island, Queensland</span> Locality consisting of a group of islands in Queensland, Australia

Palm Island is a locality consisting of an island group of 16 islands, split between the Shire of Hinchinbrook and the Aboriginal Shire of Palm Island, in Queensland, Australia. The locality coincides with the geographical entity known as the Palm Island group, also known as the Greater Palm group, originally named the Palm Isles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Green Island (Queensland)</span> Place in Queensland, Australia

Green Island is a marine island and locality in the Cairns Region, Queensland, Australia. In the 2016 census Green Island had a population of 25 people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fantome Island</span> Island in Australia

Fantome Island is one of the islands in the Palm Island group. It is neighboured by Great Palm Island and is 65 km (40 mi) north-east of Townsville, Queensland on the east coast of Australia. The island is small with an area of 7.8 km2 (3.01 sq mi) and is surrounded by a fringing reef. The Djabugay (Aboriginal) name for this island is Eumilli Island.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">North Queensland</span> Region in Queensland, Australia

North Queensland or the Northern Region is the northern part of the Australian state of Queensland that lies just south of Far North Queensland. Queensland is a massive state, larger than many countries, and its tropical northern part has been historically remote and undeveloped, resulting in a distinctive regional character and identity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Saibai Island</span> Suburb of Torres Strait Island Region, Queensland, Australia

Saibai Island, commonly called Saibai, is an island of the Torres Strait Islands archipelago, located in the Torres Strait of Queensland, Australia. The island is situated north of the Australian mainland and south of the island of New Guinea. The island is a locality within the Torres Strait Island Region local government area. The town of Saibai is located on the north-west coast of the island. According to the 2016 census, Saibai Island had a population of 465 people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fly Island</span> Island in Queensland

Fly Island is a tiny uninhabited island in the Great Palm Island group. Along with nine of the other islands within the Palm Islands group, it falls under the local government area of the Aboriginal Shire of Palm Island.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Coconut Island (Queensland)</span> Town in Queensland, Australia

Coconut Island, Poruma Island, or Puruma in the local language, is an island in the Great North East Channel near Cumberland Passage, Torres Strait, Queensland, Australia. One of the Torres Strait Islands, Coconut Island is 130 kilometres (81 mi) northeast of Thursday Island. Administratively, Coconut Island is a town and Poruma Island is the locality within the Shire of Torres.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electoral district of Townsville</span> State electoral district of Queensland, Australia

Townsville is an electoral district of the Legislative Assembly in the Australian state of Queensland. The seat is one of four within the Townsville urban area in North Queensland, and covers the Eastern and Northern suburbs of the City of Townsville as well as Magnetic Island and Palm Island.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aboriginal Shire of Palm Island</span> Local government area in Queensland, Australia

The Aboriginal Shire of Palm Island is a special local government area of Queensland, Australia, managed by the Palm Island Aboriginal Shire Council under a Deed of Grant in Trust granted to the community on 27 October 1986. The local council was previously the Palm Island Community Council, which had far fewer powers. The shire is located on the Palm Island group, off the north Queensland coast near the city of Townsville.

The 2004 Palm Island death in custody incident relates to the death of an Aboriginal resident of Palm Island, Cameron Doomadgee on Friday, 19 November 2004 in a police cell. The death of Mulrunji led to civic disturbances on the island and a legal, political and media sensation that continued for fourteen years.

The trial of Lex Wotton relates to the events surrounding the Townsville, Queensland proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court concerning the actions taken by Palm Island Aboriginal Shire Council member Wotton during the 26 November 2004 Palm Island riots.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Racism in Australia</span> Overview of racial discrimination in Australia

Racism in Australia comprises negative attitudes and views on race or ethnicity which are related to each other, are held by various people and groups in Australia, and have been reflected in discriminatory laws, practices and actions at various times in the history of Australia against racial or ethnic groups.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Great Palm Island</span>

Great Palm Island, usually known as Palm Island, is the largest island in the Palm Islands group off Northern Queensland, Australia. It is known for its Aboriginal community, the legacy of an Aboriginal reserve, the Palm Island Aboriginal Settlement. The original inhabitants of the island were the Manbarra people, also known as the Wulgurukaba, who were removed to the mainland by the Queensland Government in the 1890s. The island is also sometimes referred to as Bwgcolman, which is the name given to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people from disparate groups who were deported from many areas of Queensland to the reserve in 1918, and their descendants.

<i>The Tall Man</i> (2011 film) 2011 Australian film

The Tall Man is a 2011 Australian documentary film directed by Tony Krawitz. It is about the death of Cameron "Mulrunji" Doomadgee in police custody on Great Palm Island, Palm Islands, Queensland on 19 November 2004.

Debra Sue Mortimer is an Australian judge who has been the Chief Justice of the Federal Court of Australia since 7 April 2023. She was born in New Zealand but has practised law in Australia. She has been a judge of the Federal Court of Australia since 2013, having previously been a Senior Counsel practising at the Victorian Bar in migration law, environmental law and anti-discrimination law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Masig Island, Queensland</span> Suburb of Torres Strait Island Region, Queensland, Australia

Masig Island is an island and locality in the Torres Strait Island Region, Queensland, Australia. In the 2016 census Masig Island had a population of 270 people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vernon Ah Kee</span> Indigenous Australian artist

Vernon Ah Kee is a contemporary Australian artist, political activist and founding member of ProppaNOW. Based primarily in Brisbane, Queensland, Ah Kee is an Aboriginal Australian man with ties to the Kuku Yalandji, Waanji, Yidinji and Gugu Yimithirr peoples in Queensland. His art practice typically focuses on his Aboriginal Australian identity and place within a modern Australian framework, and is concerned with themes of skin, skin colour, race, privilege and racism. Ah Kee has exhibited his art at numerous galleries across Australia, including the Art Gallery of New South Wales (AGNSW) and the Museum of Contemporary Art Australia, and has also exhibited internationally, most notably representing Australia at the 2009 Venice Biennale and the 2015 Istanbul Biennial.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Palm Island Aboriginal Settlement</span> Australian Aboriginal reserve (1914–1975) in Queensland

Palm Island Aboriginal Settlement, later officially known as Director of Native Affairs Office, Palm Island and also known as Palm Island Aboriginal Reserve, Palm Island mission and Palm Island Dormitory, was an Aboriginal reserve and penal settlement on Great Palm Island, the main island in the Palm Island group in North Queensland, Australia. It was the largest and most punitive reserve in Queensland.

References

  1. ↑ "Wotton v State of Queensland - online file". Federal Court of Australia. 5 December 2016.
  2. ↑ "Palm Island Residents Racial Discrimination class action". Levitt Robinson. 31 January 2016.
  3. 1 2 3 Wotton v Queensland (No 5) [2016] FCA 1457 (5 December 2016), Federal Court.
  4. ↑ Anderson, C (22 December 2016). "Islanders in compo bid" . Townsville Bulletin.
  5. ↑ "Qld police appeal Palm Island decision". Brisbane Times. 19 January 2017.
  6. ↑ "MPs against Palm Island appeal" . Townsville Bulletin.
  7. ↑ "Parliament.TV - Queensland Parliament". www.parliament.qld.gov.au. Retrieved 15 March 2017.
  8. ↑ Yvette D'Ath, Attorney-General (28 February 2017). "Wotton and Ors v the State of Queensland and Anor" (PDF). Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) . Queensland: Legislative Assembly. p. 264.
  9. ↑ Lily, Nothling (2 May 2018). "Palm Island riots class action payout 'slap in face' to police, union says". The Courier Mail. Archived from the original on 10 May 2018. Retrieved 12 May 2018.
  10. ↑ Chen, David (1 May 2018). "'It's about healing': Palm Islanders to share $30m class action payment". ABC News. Retrieved 5 March 2020.
  11. 1 2 Heinke, Alex (18 May 2020). "Palm Island riot compensation spent on luxury boats, sports cars and motorbikes". 9News. Retrieved 25 August 2020.
  12. ↑ Meade, Amanda (22 May 2020). "Nine News Palm Island investigation reveals people awarded money went out and spent it". the Guardian. Retrieved 25 August 2020.
  13. ↑ Meade, Amanda (21 August 2020). "Palm Island residents launch human rights complaint over 'racist' Channel Nine and Daily Mail reports". the Guardian. Retrieved 25 August 2020.
  14. ↑ Wainwright, Sofie (20 August 2020). "Palm Islanders to launch action against Channel Nine, Daily Mail over 'racist' reports". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 25 August 2020.
  15. ↑ Bolza, Miklos (13 December 2021). "Nine hit with discrimination class action over $30M Palm Island settlement coverage". Lawyerly. Retrieved 11 November 2022.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.