X-Ray of a Lie

Last updated • 5 min readFrom Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia
Radiografía de una mentira
X-Ray of a Lie title screen.jpg
Directed byWolfgang Schalk
Written by
  • Wolfgang Schalk
  • Thaelman Urgelles
Produced by
  • El Gusano de Luz
  • Wolf Productions C.A.
Edited by
  • Wolfgang Schalk
  • Thaelman Urgelles
Distributed byWolfproductions C.A.
Release date
  • 2004 (2004)
Running time
80 min
CountryVenezuela
Languages
  • Spanish
  • English

X-Ray of a Lie (Spanish : Radiografía de una mentira) is a 2004 documentary film examining another film, The Revolution Will Not Be Televised , about the events of the Llaguno Overpass events, before the 2002 Venezuelan coup attempt. The X-Ray documentary, directed by Wolfgang Schalk and written by Schalk and Thaelman Urgelles  [ es ], accuses Kim Bartley and Donacha O'Briain of omissions and distortion in The Revolution Will Not Be Televised. [1] It premiered on DVD in Venezuela in July 2004. [2]

Contents

Background

X-Ray of a Lie was produced from the efforts of Wolfgang Schalk and Thaelman Urgelles  [ es ], Venezuelan TV producers and engineers, as a response to the film The Revolution Will Not Be Televised. Schalk, with twenty years of experience in the industry, [3] investigated the Revolution film over five months, [4] and said he had discovered "one lie after another". [3] When, he said, "it became clear that the producers had 'changed the order of the events to fit a story that appeals to audiences'," he organized an October 2003 cinematic conference that included a general, media representatives and the chief of police to discuss and analyze the film. Schalk complained that The Revolution Will Not Be Televised "did not meet the ethical standards of the BBC" and an internet petition documenting complaints about the film was circulated. [4] Schalk said the main faults were editing to take events out of order, distortion of the events at Puente Llaguno, and others. [3] Before making X-Ray, Schalk denounced The Revolution Will Not Be Televised, stating that it was a violation of ethical codes and a work of propaganda. [3] [5]

Schalk writes, "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised is a propaganda film designed to distort the Venezuelan reality. Its authors used the good faith and patronage of recognized European TV Corporations as the BBC, RTE, ZDF, NPS/Cobo, Arte and YLE. X Rays of a lie shows the grave omissions, informative bias and direct lies of the film." [2]

Urgelles and Schalk argue that The Revolution Will Not Be Televised ignores or misrepresents important details, including: [6]

  1. Gunmen: the Puente Llaguno gunmen shot marchers. The documentary says they fired into the air, based on images taken at a different time.
  2. Tank mobilization: tanks went to the presidential palace to protect the president. The documentary says they went to oust the president.
  3. Private television signals: the government took down the signals of RCTV, Venevisión and Televén on 11 April. This is omitted from the film.
  4. Chávez resignation announcement: General Lucas Rincón announced to the nation on television that the military had requested Chávez's resignation and he had accepted. This is omitted from the film. Lucas Rincón later became Interior Minister for the Chávez administration. [7]
  5. State television: VTV personnel left the facility peacefully. The documentary says the facility was overtaken and the signal disrupted.
  6. Metropolitan Police: the police did not repress citizens during Carmona's interim presidency. The film distorts the reality with manipulated editing.
  7. Private television attacked: private TV stations were attacked by government supporters. The documentary says the channels had decided not to broadcast information about Chávez's return to power.

Phil Gunson, writing in the Columbia Journalism Review , says of The Revolution Will Not Be Televised: "they omit key facts, invent others, twist the sequence of events to support their case, and replace inconvenient images with others dredged from archives". [7] Gunson writes that: "While the shooting was going on, Chávez commandeered all radio and TV frequencies for a speech that lasted almost two hours. He had used this prerogative up to seventeen times during the previous day. When private TV channels split the screen during his speeches to show the accompanying violence, the president ordered the National Guard to shut them down. None of this is featured in [The Revolution Will Not Be Televised], which wrongly claims that state TV (VTV) was 'the only channel to which he had access.' Later that evening, VTV went off the air after its staff deserted. The film implies that it was taken over by coup-plotters, and even fabricates a sequence in which the TV screen goes blank during a government legislator's interview. ... A group of senior officers ... is presented in the film as if they were the high command. Their leader, Vice-Admiral Hector Ramirez Perez, is identified as the head of the navy. He was not. With one solitary exception, these generals and admirals had not 'fled abroad' ... as the film claims. ... the directors omit all mention of an announcement by General Rincon that Chávez had resigned, later calling it 'supplementary to the main, key fact of the story'." [7]

Reception

Brian A. Nelson, who wrote The Silence and the Scorpion: The Coup Against Chavez and the Making of Modern Venezuela , says X-Ray of a Lie includes a "blow-by-blow of [The Revolution's] manipulations". [8] Nelson says Baralt Avenue  [ es ] was not empty as the film portrays, "so the filmmakers put a black bar at the top of the frame to hide the Metropolitan Police trucks that were still there", among other manipulations. [8]

Venezuela's El Universal said in 2004 the ethics of The Revolution Will Not Be Televised winning international acclaim for the government version of events should be examined, and says the film has "conceptual errors, manipulated editing, omission of crucial information, half lies and pure lies" and that X-ray of a Lie deconstructs these inaccuracies. [6] [9]

A C Clark, a pseudonymous author who has expressed anti-Chavez sentiment in the book The Revolutionary Has No Clothes: Hugo Chavez's Bolivarian Farce, says the film accurately uncovers the "mendacity and tendentiousness of The Revolution Will Not Be Televised". [10] Variety says The Revolution Will Not be Televised is a "pro-Chavist docu", adding that X-Ray of a Lie, "exposes the manipulation behind The Revolution". [11]

According to Human Rights Watch, the Venezuelan government "allegations have never been examined in court", and the X-Ray documentary accuses Bartley and O'Briain of "omissions and distortion". [1]

Bartley and Ó Briain say that it is "not insignificant that Schalk has led the well-resourced campaign, linked to [the opposition], to discredit and suppress [the film]". [12]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hugo Chávez</span> President of Venezuela from 1999 to 2013

Hugo Rafael Chávez Frías was a Venezuelan politician and military officer who served as the 52nd president of Venezuela from 1999 until his death in 2013, except for a brief period of forty-seven hours in 2002. Chávez was also leader of the Fifth Republic Movement political party from its foundation in 1997 until 2007, when it merged with several other parties to form the United Socialist Party of Venezuela (PSUV), which he led until 2012.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Venevisión</span> Venezuelan private television channel founded in 1961

Venevisión is a Venezuelan free-to-air television channel and one of Venezuela's largest television networks, owned by the Cisneros Media division of Grupo Cisneros. It was founded in 1961 by Diego Cisneros. It is one of the major telenovela producers in the world, along with Televisa, TV Azteca, Telemundo, TV Globo, Caracol Televisión, RCN Televisión, ABS-CBN, GMA Network and Channel 3.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2002 Venezuelan coup attempt</span> Attempt to remove President Hugo Chávez from office

A failed coup d'état on 11 April 2002 saw the president of Venezuela, Hugo Chávez, ousted from office for 47 hours before being restored to power. Chávez was aided in his return to power by popular support and mobilization against the coup by loyal ranks in the military.

The assassination of Danilo Anderson took place on 18 November 2004, in Caracas, Venezuela. Danilo Baltasar Anderson was a Venezuelan environmental state prosecutor investigating more than 400 people accused of crimes during the Llaguno Overpass events and the failed 2002 coup d'état attempt. He was assassinated by a car bomb on his way home from attending postgraduate classes at aged 38. In 2005 several people were convicted of masterminding the assassination, though the investigation had flaws and was marred with allegations of corruption.

"The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" is a poem and song by Gil Scott-Heron.

<i>The Revolution Will Not Be Televised</i> (film) 2003 documentary about Venezuelan coup

The Revolution Will Not Be Televised, also known as Chávez: Inside the Coup, is a 2003 Irish documentary film. It focuses on events in Venezuela leading up to and during the April 2002 coup d'état attempt, which saw President Hugo Chávez removed from office for two days. With particular emphasis on the role played by Venezuela's private media, the film examines several key incidents: the protest march and subsequent violence that provided the impetus for Chávez's ousting; the opposition's formation of an interim government headed by business leader Pedro Carmona; and the Carmona administration's collapse, which paved the way for Chávez's return. The Revolution Will Not Be Televised was directed by Irish filmmakers Kim Bartley and Donnacha Ó Briain. Given direct access to Chávez, the filmmakers intended to make a fly-on-the-wall biography of the president. They spent seven months filming in Venezuela, following Chávez and his staff and interviewing ordinary citizens. As the coup unfolded on 11 April, Bartley and Ó Briain filmed on the streets of the capital, Caracas, capturing footage of protesters and the erupting violence. Later, they filmed many of the political upheavals inside Miraflores, the presidential palace.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Plan Ávila</span> Venezuelan military contingency plan

Plan Ávila is a military contingency plan by the Venezuelan Army to maintain public order in the Venezuelan capital, Caracas. The plan was first implemented in 1989 by the Carlos Andrés Pérez government in response to the Caracazo riots, where hundreds were killed by military and armed police. President Hugo Chávez also ordered activation of the plan in response to the 11 April 2002 Llaguno Overpass events, but high-ranking members of the Armed Forces refused to carry out the plan, wanting to avoid a massacre like the Caracazo.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">RCTV</span> Defunct Venezuelan television station

Radio Caracas Televisión was a Venezuelan free-to-air television network headquartered in the Caracas neighborhood of Quinta Crespo and owned by Empresas 1BC. Radio Caracas Televisión (RCTV) was inaugurated on 15 November 1953 by William H. Phelps, Jr..

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Globovisión</span> 24-hour television news network

Globovisión is a 24-hour television news network. It broadcasts over-the-air in Caracas, Aragua, Carabobo and Zulia on UHF channel 33. Globovisión is seen in the rest of Venezuela on cable or satellite and worldwide from their website. Some of Globovisión's programs can be seen in the United States on cable network Canal Sur and TV Venezuela, a channel offered in DirecTV's Para Todos package. In Latin America, Globovision can be seen in Argentina, Colombia, Chile, Ecuador, Peru, Uruguay and other territories as Aruba, Trinidad and Tobago, Barbados and Curaçao in DirecTV's package.

The Act Constituting the Government of Democratic Transition and National Unity – known colloquially as the "Carmona Decree" or El Carmonazo — was a document drawn up on 12 April 2002 the day following the 2002 Venezuelan coup attempt, which attempted to oust President Hugo Chávez.

<i>¿¡Revolución!?</i> 2006 Canadian film

¿¡Revolución!? is a 2006 political documentary directed by Quebec journalist and filmmaker Charles Gervais. It examines the Bolivarian Revolution led by Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez. It was produced by Télé-Québec, the Quebec government's public television network.

<i>The War on Democracy</i> 2007 film

The War on Democracy is a 2007 documentary film directed by Christopher Martin and John Pilger, who also wrote the narration. Focusing on the political situations in nations of Latin America, the film criticizes both the United States' intervention in foreign countries' domestic politics and its "War on Terrorism". The film was first released in the United Kingdom on 15 June 2007.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2007 Venezuelan RCTV protests</span>

The RCTV protests were a series of protests in Venezuela that began in the middle of May 2007. The cause of the protests was the decision by the government to shut down Venezuela's oldest private television network, Radio Caracas Televisión (RCTV), refusing to renew its broadcasting license and instead creating a new public service channel called TVes, which began operations on 28 May, the same day RCTV's license expired. RCTV had Venezuela's largest viewing audience, with 10 million of the country's 26 million people viewing its shows and soap operas.

<i>South of the Border</i> (2009 film) 2009 American film

South of the Border is a 2009 American documentary film directed by Oliver Stone. The documentary premiered at the 2009 Venice Film Festival. Writer for the project Tariq Ali calls the documentary "a political road movie".

Puente Llaguno: Claves de una Masacre (2004) is a documentary film about the events of the 2002 Llaguno Overpass events in Caracas, Venezuela.

Noticiero Digital is a Venezuelan news and opinion website headquartered in Caracas, described by Reporters Without Borders as "a popular website that is critical of President Hugo Chávez". According to its former editor, Roger Santodomingo, Noticiero Digital became popular after the government of Venezuela decided not to renew the broadcast license of cable television network RCTV, saying: "It has become [a] forum for comment that is virtually out of its own management's control because of its totally open nature." As of June 2007, it had 45,000 registered users.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Villa del Cine</span>

Fundación Villa del Cine is a government-funded Venezuelan film and TV production house that was inaugurated on 3 June 2006 by Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez in the city of Guarenas, near the capital, Caracas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bolivarian propaganda</span> Pro-Venezuela/Hugo Chávez nationalist propaganda

Bolivarian propaganda is a form of nationalist propaganda, especially in Venezuela and associated with chavismo, Venezuelan socialism. This type of propaganda has been associated with Hugo Chávez's Bolivarian Revolution, which used emotional arguments to gain attention, exploit the fears of the population, create external enemies for scapegoat purposes, and produce nationalism within the population, causing feelings of betrayal for support of the opposition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Llaguno Overpass events</span> Shootout in Venezuela

The Llaguno Overpass, also known as the Llaguno Bridge, is a bridge in central Caracas, Venezuela, near the Miraflores Palace, made infamous by the events of 11 April 2002, when snipers opened fire upon the crowd of protestors marching on the overpass, also known as El Silencio Massacre, causing 19 deaths and 127 injured people. The events preceded the 2002 Venezuelan coup attempt. The military high command refused Hugo Chávez's order to implement the Plan Ávila as a response to protests against him, a military contingency plan by the army to maintain public order last used in 1989 during The Caracazo, and demanded him to resign. President Chávez was subsequently arrested by the military. Chávez's request for asylum in Cuba was denied, and he was ordered to be tried in a Venezuelan court.

The Bolivarian Revolution, and related Crisis in Venezuela, have been depicted in several films, both fiction and documentary.

References

  1. 1 2 Holland, Alisha (2008). Venezuela: A Decade Under Chavez Political Intolerance and Lost Opportunities for Advancing Human Rights in Venezuela. Human Rights Watch. p. 69.
  2. 1 2 "Radiografía de una mentira (2004) (TV)". IMDB. Retrieved 3 March 2010.
  3. 1 2 3 4 "Un documental plagado de mentiras". El Universal (in Spanish). 30 October 2003. Retrieved 25 February 2010.
  4. 1 2 Campbell, Duncan (22 November 2003). "Chavez film puts staff at risk, says Amnesty". The Guardian . Retrieved 3 March 2010.
  5. ↑ Correia, Alexis (3 October 2003). "Cineastas denuncian manipulación en documental sobre el 11-A". El Nacional (in Spanish). p. B-6.
  6. 1 2 Linzalata, Ernesto (31 July 2004). "Estrenan "Radiografía de una mentira": Cuando la ética es fundamental en la vida". El Universal (in Spanish). Retrieved 2 March 2010.
  7. 1 2 3 Gunson, Phil (1 May 2004). "Director's cut: did an acclaimed documentary about the 2002 coup in Venezuela tell the whole story?". Columbia Journalism Review.
  8. 1 2 Nelson, Brian A (2009). The Silence and the Scorpion: The Coup Against Chavez and the Making of Modern Venezuela. Nation Books, a member of the Perseus Books Group. p. 265. ISBN   978-1-56858-418-8.
  9. ↑ Kaiser, Patricia (2003). "Estrategias discursivas antichavistas de los medios de comunicacion". Revista Venezolana de Economía y Ciencias Sociales (in Spanish). 9 (3).
  10. ↑ Clark, AC (2009). The Revolutionary Has No Clothes: Hugo Chavez's Bolivarian Farce. Encounter Books. p. 91.
  11. ↑ de la Fuente, Anna Maria (18–24 June 2007). "Venezuelan nets tread lightly: RCTV closure quiets Chavez foes". Variety. p. 20 – via LexisNexis. RCTV is not the only web struggling against the threat of government closure. "In Latin America, the new populist regimes like the ones in Ecuador (and Bolivia) are using their popularity to suppress all dissident media to maintain 'good taste and integrity,' " says Wolfgang Schalk, helmer of "X-Rays of a Lie," a docu that exposes the manipulation behind pro-Chavist docu "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised."
  12. ↑ Bartley, Kim; Ó Briain, Donnacha (May–June 2004). "Who's Right? The Filmmakers Respond". Columbia Journalism Review43 (1): 62–63.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.