1974 Norfolk mid-air collision

Last updated

1974 Norfolk mid-air collision
Accident
Date9 August 1974
Summary Mid-air collision
SiteFordham Fen, Norfolk, England
52°34′00″N00°24′00″E / 52.56667°N 0.40000°E / 52.56667; 0.40000
Total fatalities3
Total survivors0
First aircraft
Phantom FGR.2 at NAS Patuxent River c1970.jpg
An RAF Phanton FGR.2 similar to the accident aircraft
Type McDonnell-Douglas F-4M Phantom FGR.2
OperatorEnsign of the Royal Air Force.svg  Royal Air Force
Registration XV493
Flight origin RAF Coningsby
Crew2
Fatalities2
Second aircraft
Piper PA-25-235 Pawnee AN0275432.jpg
A Piper Pawnee similar to the accident aircraft
Type Piper PA-25-235 Pawnee
OperatorADS (Aerial) Limited
RegistrationG-ASVX
Flight originBroomfield
Crew1
Fatalities1
Survivors0

The 1974 Norfolk mid-air collision happened on 9 August 1974 at Fordham Fen, Norfolk, England when a Royal Air Force McDonnell-Douglas F-4M Phantom FGR.2 of No. 41 Squadron RAF (41 Sqn) collided with a Piper PA-25-235 Pawnee crop spraying aircraft. [1] All three aviators were killed: the pilot and navigator of the Phantom and the pilot of the Pawnee. [1] The Phantom pilot was a Royal Air Force Group Captain and station commander of RAF Coningsby. [1] It was the first collision between a civil aircraft and a military fast jet in the United Kingdom low flying military training system.

Contents

Aircraft

The Pawnee registered G-ASVX was a single-engined single-seat crop spraying aircraft built in 1974. [2] The Phantom serial number XV493 was a twin-engined two-seat, all-weather military strike/interceptor aircraft. [2]

Accident

The Pawnee had departed earlier on 9 August 1974 from Southend Airport to a disused airfield at Broomhill, near Downham Market in Norfolk. Broomhill was used as a temporary base to refuel the aircraft and to load pesticide. At about 14:04 the aircraft had finished spraying a field 6.5 mi (10.5 km) south of Broomhill and was returning to replenish the pesticide hopper. The Phantom departed RAF Coningsby at 13:51 to fly a low-level navigation and reconnaissance flight at no lower than 250 feet (76 m) above ground level. The Phantom was following a standard low-flying route; the Pawnee pilot was aware that military low-flying routes were in the area but the exact routing was classified and not released by the military. About 14:08 about 1 km (1,100 yd) west of the village of Hilgay, and at an estimated height of around 300 ft (91 m) the Phantom, flying at a speed of about 420 kn (780 km/h), struck the Pawnee on its right side. The Pawnee disintegrated, while the Phantom, on fire and shedding parts of its structure, continued on its heading for a further 1 kilometre (1,100 yd) before it hit the ground inverted. All three aviators were killed: the pilot and navigator of the Phantom and the pilot of the Pawnee. [2]

Investigation

Both aircraft were found to have been maintained correctly and were legally authorised for the flights. Farmwork Services, who had chartered the Pawnee, had informed the local police authority about their proposed operation and type of chemical to be used. Nothing in the regulations required them to inform the military although Farmwork Services had, as usual, informed nearby RAF Marham (an operational airfield about 8 nmi (15 km) from the accident) that they would be spraying an extensive area of Norfolk between June and the end of August 1974. [2]

Investigation of the wreckage failed to determine if either had a working anti-collision light and it was only possible to determine the height of the accident by the use of eyewitness accounts. The collision occurred in good visibility at an estimated height above ground level of 300 ft (91 m). The investigation could find no evidence to suggest that either of the pilots had a medical problem or that either aircraft had any defect that would have contributed to the accident. [2]

The rules of the air state that the Pawnee should have given way to the Phantom which was closing from the right. But it was accepted that at a closing speed of about 400 kn (740 km/h) the time needed by the Pawnee pilot to assess the situation and execute a manoeuvre was minimal. It was also a requirement of the Phantom pilot to make sure that he did not collide with the Pawnee but clearly in this accident the lack of time was an element. Also the military aircraft had only just turned on to the heading and with the Pawnee 15° to his left the view may well have been obstructed by the Phantom's canopy frame. [2]

While it accepted the need for the Royal Air Force to practise low level high-speed flying the investigation report was concerned about the lack of information on the military low-flying route available to civil pilots, particularly those involved with crop spraying, pipeline, and powerline inspection. [2]

Cause

The investigation determined "The accident occurred because neither pilot saw the other aircraft in time to avoid collision. The 'see and be seen' principle was inadequate for preventing collision in the circumstances that existed. A significant feature which contributed to the accident was the absence of any system for co-ordinating military and civil low flying activities in the low flying areas and link routes." [2]

Recommendations

The accident report made seven recommendations: [2]

  1. That the location and vertical extent of the low flying areas and link routes should be made available.
  2. Private pilots should be alerted to the nature of military low flying activities and the need to avoid them.
  3. An advisory service be provided to enable civil pilots to co-ordinate their activities with the military.
  4. That civil aircraft involved in low flying activities should be painted as conspicuously as possible and fitted with high-power collision warning lights preferably strobe type. Also recommended that the military consider fitment of strobe type high-power collision warning lights to aircraft engaged in low level training.
  5. The military review their need for airspace for low-level high-speed operations and withdraw any areas not needed.
  6. That the upper limit of the military low flying link routes be limited to 1,000 ft (300 m) instead of 2,000 ft (610 m), if not possible then 1,500 ft (460 m) should be considered.
  7. That the rules of the air be amended to allow aircraft with the right of way to climb and if necessary pass over the other aircraft.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">RAF Coltishall</span> Former RAF station in Norfolk, England

Royal Air Force Coltishall, more commonly known as RAF Coltishall, is a former Royal Air Force station located 10 miles north-north-east of Norwich, in the English county of Norfolk, East Anglia, which operated from 1939 to 2006.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2002 Überlingen mid-air collision</span> Fatal collision over Germany

On 1 July 2002, BALBashkirian Airlines Flight 2937, a Tupolev Tu-154 passenger jet, and DHL International Aviation ME Flight 611, a Boeing 757 cargo jet, collided in mid-air over Überlingen, a southern German town on Lake Constance, near the Swiss border. All of the passengers and crew aboard both planes were killed, resulting in a total death toll of 71.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">RAF Coningsby</span> Royal Air Force main operating base in Lincolnshire, England

Royal Air Force Coningsby or RAF Coningsby, is a Royal Air Force (RAF) station located 13.7 kilometres (8.5 mi) south-west of Horncastle, and 15.8 kilometres (9.8 mi) north-west of Boston, in the East Lindsey district of Lincolnshire, England. It is a Main Operating Base of the RAF and home to three front-line Eurofighter Typhoon FGR4 units, No. 3 Squadron, No. 11 Squadron and No. 12 Squadron. In support of front-line units, No. 29 Squadron is the Typhoon Operational Conversion Unit and No. 41 Squadron is the Typhoon Test and Evaluation Squadron. Coningsby is also the home of the Battle of Britain Memorial Flight (BBMF) which operates a variety of historic RAF aircraft.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">No. 23 Squadron RAF</span> Defunct flying squadron of the Royal Air Force

Number 23 Squadron is a squadron of the Royal Air Force responsible for 'day-to-day space operations', having been reformed in January 2021, as the first "space squadron". Up until its disbandment in October 2009, it operated the Boeing Sentry AEW1 Airborne Warning And Control System (AWACS) aircraft from RAF Waddington, Lincolnshire.

de Havilland Express Type of aircraft

The de Havilland Express, also known as the de Havilland D.H.86, was a four-engined passenger aircraft manufactured by the de Havilland Aircraft Company between 1934 and 1937.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Avro York</span> 1942 transport aircraft family by Avro

The Avro York was a British transport aircraft developed by Avro during the Second World War. The design was derived from the Avro Lancaster heavy bomber, several sections of the York and Lancaster being identical. Due to the importance of Lancaster production, York output proceeded slowly until 1944, after which a higher priority was placed upon transport aircraft.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Piper PA-25 Pawnee</span> American agricultural aircraft

The PA-25 Pawnee is an agricultural aircraft produced by Piper Aircraft between 1959 and 1981. It remains a widely used aircraft in agricultural spraying and is also used as a tow plane, or tug, for launching gliders or for towing banners. In 1988, the design rights and support responsibility were sold to Latino Americana de Aviación of Argentina.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">No. 56 Squadron RAF</span> Flying squadron of the Royal Air Force

Number 56 Squadron, also known as No. 56 Test and Evaluation Squadron (TES), nicknamed the Firebirds for their ability to always reappear intact regardless of the odds, is one of the oldest and most successful squadrons of the Royal Air Force, with battle honours from many of the significant air campaigns of both the First and Second World Wars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1976 Zagreb mid-air collision</span> Fatal collision of passenger flights over Yugoslavia (now Croatia)

The 1976 Zagreb mid-air collision took place on 10 September 1976, when British Airways Flight 476, a Hawker Siddeley Trident en route from London to Istanbul, collided mid-air with Inex-Adria Aviopromet Flight 550, a McDonnell Douglas DC-9 en route from Split, SFR Yugoslavia, to Cologne, West Germany, near Zagreb in modern-day Croatia. The collision was the result of a procedural error on the part of air traffic controllers in Zagreb.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">West Berlin Air Corridor</span> Airways linking West Berlin to West Germany

During the Cold War era (1945–1991), the West Berlin air corridors, also known as the Berlin corridors and control zone, were three regulated airways for civil and military air traffic of the Western Allies between West Berlin and West Germany passing over East Germany's territory. The corridors and control zone were physically centered on and under control of the all-Allied Berlin Air Safety Center (BASC) in West Berlin. The airspace within these corridors was used by US, UK and French-registered non-combat aircraft belonging to these countries' armed forces and airlines operated by pilots holding those countries' passports. In addition, it was also used by LOT Polish Airlines for regular scheduled services from Warsaw to London and Paris via Schönefeld Airport to the south of East Berlin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hughes Airwest Flight 706</span> 1971 aviation accident in Los Angeles County, California

Hughes Airwest Flight 706 was a regularly scheduled flight operated by American domestic airline Hughes Airwest from Los Angeles, California to Seattle, Washington, with several intermediate stops. On Sunday, June 6, 1971, the McDonnell Douglas DC-9 serving as Flight 706 departed Los Angeles just after 6 p.m. en route to Seattle as a McDonnell Douglas F-4 Phantom II of the United States Marine Corps was approaching Marine Corps Air Station El Toro near Irvine at the end of a flight from Naval Air Station Fallon in Nevada. The two aircraft collided in midair over the San Gabriel Mountains near Duarte, killing all 49 aboard the DC-9 and the F-4 pilot; the F-4 radar intercept officer ejected and survived.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Northrepps Aerodrome</span> Airport in Cromer

Northrepps Aerodrome is a privately owned airfield south west of the village of Northrepps, North Norfolk, England approximately 3 mi (4.8 km) south-south-east of Cromer. It is located next to the A149 road close to its junction with the A 140.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1956 Grand Canyon mid-air collision</span> Mid-air collision on June 30, 1956 over the Grand Canyon

The Grand Canyon mid-air collision occurred in the western United States on June 30, 1956, when a United Airlines Douglas DC-7 struck a Trans World Airlines Lockheed L-1049 Super Constellation over Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona. The first one fell into a canyon and the other one slammed into a rock face. All 128 on board both airplanes perished, making it the first commercial airline incident to exceed one hundred fatalities. The airplanes had departed Los Angeles International Airport minutes apart from each other and headed for Chicago and Kansas City, respectively. The collision took place in uncontrolled airspace, where it was the pilots' responsibility to maintain separation. This highlighted the antiquated state of air traffic control, which became the focus of major aviation reforms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1922 Picardie mid-air collision</span> First fatal mid air collision

The 1922 Picardie mid-air collision took place on 7 April 1922 over Picardie, France, involving British and French passenger-carrying biplanes. The midair collision occurred in foggy conditions. A British aircraft flying from Croydon to Paris with only mail on board collided with a French aircraft flying three passengers from Paris to Croydon, which resulted in seven deaths.

Captain William Schaffner was a pilot in the United States Air Force. He disappeared, presumed dead, flying a BAC Lightning over the North Sea while on exchange with the Royal Air Force.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1948 Northwood mid-air collision</span> Mid air collision over UK

The 1948 Northwood mid-air collision took place on 4 July at 15:03 when a Douglas DC-6 of Scandinavian Airlines System (SAS) and an Avro York C.1 of the Royal Air Force (RAF) collided in mid-air over Northwood in London, UK. All thirty-nine people aboard both aircraft were killed. It was SAS's first fatal aviation accident and was at the time the deadliest civilian aviation accident in the UK. It is still the deadliest mid-air collision in British history.

Air Vice Marshal Robert Stewart Blucke, was a Royal Air Force officer who became Air Officer Commanding-in-Chief at RAF Transport Command in 1952.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Low flying military training</span>

Low flying military training involves military aircraft flying at low altitude to prepare their aircrew, and other military personnel, for nap-of-the-earth flying in wartime. The aircraft types can include advanced trainers, ground-attack aircraft, transports and helicopters.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "Collision over Norfolk". Flight International . IPC Transport Press Ltd. 106 (3413): 146. 15 August 1974. Archived from the original on 21 October 2012.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Air Accidents Investigation Branch; W H Tench (20 June 1975), Report No:9/1975 Piper PA25-235, G-ASVX and Phantom FGR2, XV493. Report on the collision at Fordham Fen, Norfolk, on 9 August 1974 (PDF), London: HMSO, ISBN   0115114262 , retrieved 28 September 2009