Carved stone balls

Last updated

Carved stone ball, classed as Neolithic Room 51, British MuseumDSCF6620.jpg
Carved stone ball, classed as Neolithic
Three Scottish examples, in Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum, Glasgow Kelvingrove Art Gallery and MuseumDSCF0239 11.JPG
Three Scottish examples, in Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum, Glasgow
Exceptionally elaborately decorated ball from Towie in Aberdeenshire, dated from 3200-2500 BC Towriepetrosphere.jpg
Exceptionally elaborately decorated ball from Towie in Aberdeenshire, dated from 32002500 BC

Carved stone balls are petrospheres dated from the late Neolithic, to possibly as late as the Iron Age, mainly found in Scotland, but also elsewhere in Britain and Ireland. They are usually round and rarely oval, and of fairly uniform size at around 2+34 inches or 7 cm across, with anything between 3 and 160 protruding knobs on the surface. They range from having no ornamentation (apart from the knobs) to extensive and highly varied engraved patterns. [2] A wide range of theories has been produced to explain their use or significance, with none gaining very wide acceptance.

Contents

They are not to be confused with the much larger smooth round stone spheres of Costa Rica.

Age and distribution

Carved stone balls date as old as 5,200 years old, coming from the late Neolithic to at least the Bronze Age. [3]

Nearly all have been found in north-east Scotland, the majority in Aberdeenshire, the fertile land lying to the east of the Grampian Mountains. A similar distribution to that of Pictish symbols led to the early suggestion that carved stone balls are Pictish artefacts. [2] (p 55) The core distribution also reflects that of the Recumbent stone circles. As objects they are very easy to transport and a few have been found on Iona, Skye, Harris, Uist, Lewis, Arran, Hawick, Wigtownshire and fifteen from Orkney. Outside Scotland examples have been found in Ireland at Ballymena, in England at Durham, Cumbria, Lowick, and Bridlington. A single example was found in Norway in a medieval cairn. Recent theory is that the Norway example was carried home by a Viking from an expedition to Scotland. [4] The larger (90mm diameter) balls are all from Aberdeenshire, bar one from Newburgh in Fife.

By the late 1970s, a total of 387 had been recorded. [2] (p 55) Of these, by far the greatest concentration (169) was found in Aberdeenshire. By 1983 the number had risen to 411 [5] and by 2015 over 425 balls had been recorded. [3] A collection of over 30 carved balls from Scotland, Ireland and northern England is held by the British Museum. [6]

Archaeological context

Many of the balls have not had their discovery site recorded and most are found as a result of agricultural activity. Five were found at the Neolithic settlement of Skara Brae and one at the Dunadd hillfort. The distribution of the balls is similar to that of mace-heads, which were both weapons and prestige objects used in ceremonial situations. [2] (pp 62–63) The lack of context is likely to distort the interpretation. Random finds are only likely to have been picked up and entered a collection if they were aesthetically appealing. Damaged and plain balls were less likely to find a market than decorated examples so some more decorated examples might be fraudulent.

Balls of plain sandstone with the facets from shaping still clearly visible were found at Traprain Law in East Lothian. A significant number have already been found here and are known from other southern Scottish Iron Age sites. They may date from the fourth to third centuries BC. These balls are not ornamented and do not have knobs. [7]

In 2013, archaeologists discovered a carved stone ball at Ness of Brodgar, a rare find of such an object in situ in "a modern archaeological context". [8] Early, undecorated, polished stone balls have also been found 'in-situ' inside a 5,500 year-old tomb at Tresness on Orkney by Professor Vicki Cummings. [9]

Physical characteristics

Materials

Another example, displayed at the British Museum Room 51, British MuseumDSCF6621.jpg
Another example, displayed at the British Museum

Many balls are said to be made of "greenstone", a general term for all varieties of dark, greenish igneous rocks, including diorites, serpentinite, and altered basalts. Including Old Red Sandstone, 43 are sandstone, 26 greenstone, 12  quartzite, and 9 were serpentinite; these had been carved. Some were made of gabbro – a difficult material to carve. Round and oval natural shaped sandstones are sometimes found.

Examples made from hornblende gneiss and granitic gneiss were noted, both very difficult stone to work. Granitic rocks were also used; and the famous Towie example from Aberdeenshire may be serpentinised picrite. The highly ornamented examples were mainly made of sandstone or serpentine. [2] (p 54) A significant number have not as yet been fully inspected or tested to ascertain their composition.

Experimental archaeology

Full replicas have been made using authentic manufacturing techniques (pecking and grinding) by A.T. Young. [10] It was shown that they could be made using prehistoric technology with no recourse to the use of metal tools. [10] [11]

Size, shape, and knobs

Of the 387 carved stone balls known in 1976 (now about 425), 375 are about 70 mm in diameter, but twelve are known with diameters of 90 to 114 mm. Only 7 are oval. They are therefore about the size of tennis balls or oranges. Nearly half have 6 knobs.[ citation needed ]

Carved stone ball shape
[ citation needed ]
Carved
protrusions
Number
of finds
3 knobs3
4 knobs43
5 knobs
3
6 knobs~240
7 knobs18
8 knobs
9
9 knobs3
10–55 knobs52
70–160 knobs14

Ornamentation

Carved stone ball with low-profile knobs Human Prehistory in the Kelvingrove carved stone ball Aberdeenshire.JPG
Carved stone ball with low-profile knobs

The decoration used falls into three categories:

More than one design is used on the same ball and the standard of artwork varies from the extremely crude to the highly expert which only an exceptionally skilled craftsman could have produced. Some balls have designs on the interspaces between the knobs which must be significant in the context of the speculated use of these artefacts.

Twenty-six of the six-knobbed balls are decorated. The Orkney examples are unusual, being either all ornamented or otherwise unusual in appearance, such as the lack, bar one example, of the frequently found six-knobbed type. Metal may have been used to work some of the designs.

The Towie ball from Aberdeenshire has some design similarities with the carvings on the Folkton Drums. These were found in a tumulus in England and are made of chalk with elaborate carvings, among which are distinct oculi or eyes. [12] Concentric carved lines on stone balls appear to be stylised oculi. This ball also has a roughly triangular arrangement of three dots in an interspace between the knobs. This appears to be identical to the arrangement of dots found on the Parkhill silver chain terminal ring, found near Aberdeen, a Pictish artefact. It is possible that the dots represent a name, as some of the Pictish symbols at least are thought to represent personal names. [13]

Spirals or plastic ornament which is similar to Grooved Ware is found on the Aberdeenshire examples, this being a type of late Neolithic pottery not known in the north-east but common in Orkney and Fife. The Newgrange carvings in Ireland show strong similarities to those found on some balls. A continuous spiral is found on one and elements of chevrons, zig-zags and concentric triangles are also found, stimulating comparisons with petrosomatoglyph symbolism. Mostly the different knobs have different or sometimes no ornamentation. A 'golf-ball' variety of ornamentation is found on a few balls. The carving does not appear to have any practical purpose in general, however it has been suggested that one type, with very distinct knobs, was used for processing copper ores (see under 'Function'). Some of the bold triangles and criss-cross incisions seem to be more Iron Age in character than Neolithic or Bronze Age. [2] (p 62)

Function

Glasgow example Human Prehistory in the Kelvingrove carved stone ball Turriff.JPG
Glasgow example

Suggested ceremonial use

Suggested practical use

Megalith construction aid

Another in Glasgow Human Prehistory in the Kelvingrove carved stone ball Alford.JPG
Another in Glasgow

A theory on the movement of megalithic stones for monuments has been put forward as a result of an observed correlation between standing stone circles and a concentration of carved stone balls. The suggestion is that the stone balls might have been used like ball bearings for transporting big stones. [11]

Many of the late Neolithic stone balls have diameters differing by only a millimetre, suggesting that uniform size was important for their purpose. This led to the suggestion that they might have been meant to be used together, or interchangeably. By mapping find-sites in Aberdeenshire, Scotland, it can be shown that often these small stone spheres were found in the vicinity of Neolithic megalithic circles.

To test the proposal, experimental archeologists built a model system, substituting hard wooden balls made to the same size. The balls were placed into grooves cut in parallel longitudinal wooden 'sleepers'; these supported an overlying carrying-board that the giant test stone rode on. At least in the situation tested, the model showed such heavy transport to be practical. [15] [11]

Platonic solids

The carved stone balls have been taken as evidence of knowledge of the five Platonic solids a millennium before Plato described them. Indeed, some of them exhibit the symmetries of Platonic solids, but the extent of this and how much it depends on mathematical understanding is disputed, as configurations resembling the solids can naturally arise when fitting equal-sized knobs with minimal gaps onto the surface of a sphere.[ citation needed ] There does not appear to be much special attention given to the Platonic solid arrangements over less symmetrical arrangements of knobs over the balls, and some of the five solids do not appear. [16] [17]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Skara Brae</span> Neolithic archaeological site in Scotland

Skara Brae is a stone-built Neolithic settlement, located on the Bay of Skaill on the west coast of Mainland, the largest island in the Orkney archipelago of Scotland. It consisted of ten clustered houses, made of flagstones, in earthen dams that provided support for the walls; the houses included stone hearths, beds, and cupboards. A primitive sewer system, with "toilets" and drains in each house, included water used to flush waste into a drain and out to the ocean.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">High cross</span> Free-standing Christian cross made of stone and often richly decorated

A high cross or standing cross is a free-standing Christian cross made of stone and often richly decorated. There was a unique Early Medieval tradition in Ireland and Britain of raising large sculpted stone crosses, usually outdoors. These probably developed from earlier traditions using wood, perhaps with metalwork attachments, and earlier pagan Celtic memorial stones; the Pictish stones of Scotland may also have influenced the form. The earliest surviving examples seem to come from the territory of the Anglo-Saxon kingdom of Northumbria, which had been converted to Christianity by Irish missionaries; it remains unclear whether the form first developed in Ireland or Britain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brough of Birsay</span> An uninhabited tidal island off the north-west coast of The Mainland of Orkney, Scotland

The Brough of Birsay is an uninhabited tidal island off the north-west coast of The Mainland of Orkney, Scotland, in the parish of Birsay. It is located around 13 miles north of Stromness and features the remains of Pictish and Norse settlements as well as a modern light house.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Westray</span> Island of Orkney, Scotland

Westray is one of the Orkney Islands in Scotland, with a usual resident population of just under 600 people. Its main village is Pierowall, with a heritage centre, the 15th-century Lady Kirk church and pedestrian ferry service to nearby Papa Westray island. Westray has a number of archeological sites dating from 3500 BC, and remains of several Norse-Viking settlements. The spectacular sea cliffs around Noup Head are home to thousands of seabirds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jarlshof</span> Archeological site in Shetland, Scotland

Jarlshof is the best-known prehistoric archaeological site in Shetland, Scotland. It lies in Sumburgh, Mainland, Shetland and has been described as "one of the most remarkable archaeological sites ever excavated in the British Isles". It contains remains dating from 2500 BC up to the 17th century AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prehistoric Scotland</span> Prehistory of Scotland

Archaeology and geology continue to reveal the secrets of prehistoric Scotland, uncovering a complex past before the Romans brought Scotland into the scope of recorded history. Successive human cultures tended to be spread across Europe or further afield, but focusing on this particular geographical area sheds light on the origin of the widespread remains and monuments in Scotland, and on the background to the history of Scotland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pictish stone</span> Monuments erected by early Scottish tribes

A Pictish stone is a type of monumental stele, generally carved or incised with symbols or designs. A few have ogham inscriptions. Located in Scotland, mostly north of the Clyde-Forth line and on the Eastern side of the country, these stones are the most visible remaining evidence of the Picts and are thought to date from the 6th to 9th century, a period during which the Picts became Christianized. The earlier stones have no parallels from the rest of the British Isles, but the later forms are variations within a wider Insular tradition of monumental stones such as high crosses. About 350 objects classified as Pictish stones have survived, the earlier examples of which holding by far the greatest number of surviving examples of the mysterious symbols, which have long intrigued scholars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Celtic art</span> Art associated with Celtic peoples

Celtic art is associated with the peoples known as Celts; those who spoke the Celtic languages in Europe from pre-history through to the modern period, as well as the art of ancient peoples whose language is uncertain, but have cultural and stylistic similarities with speakers of Celtic languages.

Humans have inhabited Orkney, an archipelago in the north of Scotland, for about 8,800 years: Archeological evidence dates from Mesolithic times. Scandinavian clans dominated the area from the 8th century CE, using the islands as a base for further incursions. In the late 14th century the archipelago became part of Scotland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scottish painted pebbles</span> Early Medieval artifact found in Scotland

Painted pebbles are a class of Early Medieval artifact found in northern Scotland dating from the first millennium CE.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stone ball</span> Spherical man-made artifact composed of stone

In archaeology, a stone ball or petrosphere is the name for any spherical man-made object of any size that is composed of stone. These mainly prehistoric artifacts may have been created or selected, but altered in some way to perform their specific function, including carving and painting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Timeline of prehistoric Scotland</span>

This timeline of prehistoric Scotland is a chronologically ordered list of important archaeological sites in Scotland and of major events affecting Scotland's human inhabitants and culture during the prehistoric period. The period of prehistory prior to occupation by the genus Homo is part of the geology of Scotland. Prehistory in Scotland ends with the arrival of the Romans in southern Scotland in the 1st century AD and the beginning of written records. The archaeological sites and events listed are the earliest examples or among the most notable of their type.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prehistoric Orkney</span> Overview of the prehistoric period on the Orkney Islands, Scotland

Prehistoric Orkney refers only to the prehistory of the Orkney archipelago of Scotland that begins with human occupation. Although some records referring to Orkney survive that were written during the Roman invasions of Scotland, “prehistory” in northern Scotland is defined as lasting until the start of Scotland's Early Historic Period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ness of Brodgar</span> British archaeological site

The Ness of Brodgar is an archaeological site covering 2.5 hectares between the Ring of Brodgar and the Stones of Stenness in the Heart of Neolithic Orkney World Heritage Site on the main Island of Orkney, Scotland. Excavations at the site began in 2003. The site has provided evidence of decorated stone slabs, a stone wall 6 metres (20 ft) thick with foundations, and a large building described as a Neolithic temple. The earliest structures were built between 3,300 and 3,200 BC, and the site had been closed down and partly dismantled by 2,200 BC. It was the main subject of a 2016 BBC Scotland documentary, Britain’s Ancient Capital: Secrets of Orkney, presented by Neil Oliver, Chris Packham, Shini Somara, Andy Torbet, and Doug Allan. For preservation, the site is closed during the winter months and covered in polyethylene plastic and tyres to protect it from the environment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Westray Wife</span>

The Westray Wife is a small Neolithic figurine, 4 centimetres (1.6 in) in height, carved from sandstone. It was discovered during an Historic Scotland dig at the Links of Noltland, on Westray, Orkney, Scotland, in the summer of 2009. It was the first Neolithic carving of a human form to have been found in Scotland, and to date it is the earliest depiction of a face found in the United Kingdom.

The Aberlemno Sculptured Stones are a series of Pictish standing stones originating in and around the village of Aberlemno, Angus, Scotland. Three are located in the village and a fourth, found in 1962, is on display in The McManus in Dundee. They date from the Early Medieval period. A fifth stone standing in the village has signs of carving, but is of unknown authenticity as a Pictish artefact.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prehistoric Shetland</span>

Prehistoric Shetland refers to the prehistoric period of the Shetland archipelago of Scotland, when it was first occupied by humans. The period prior to human settlement in Shetland is known as the geology of Scotland. Prehistory in Shetland does not end until the beginning of the Early Medieval Period in Scotland, around AD 600. More than 5,000 archaeological sites have been recorded in the Shetland Islands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prehistoric art in Scotland</span> Overview and examples of prehistoric art in Scotland

Prehistoric art in Scotland is visual art created or found within the modern borders of Scotland, before the departure of the Romans from southern and central Britain in the early fifth century CE, which is usually seen as the beginning of the early historic or Medieval era. There is no clear definition of prehistoric art among scholars and objects that may involve creativity often lack a context that would allow them to be understood.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sculpture in Scotland</span>

Sculpture in Scotland includes all visual arts operating in three dimensions in the borders of modern Scotland. Durable sculptural processes traditionally include carving and modelling, in stone, metal, clay, wood and other materials. In the modern era these were joined by assembly by welding, modelling, moulding and casting. Some installation art can also be considered to be sculpture. The earliest surviving sculptures from Scotland are standing stones and circles from around 3000 BCE. The oldest portable visual art are carved-stone petrospheres and the Westray Wife is the earliest representation of a human face found in Scotland. From the Bronze Age there are extensive examples of rock art, including cup and ring marks and elaborate carved stone battle-axes. By the early Iron Age Scotland had been penetrated by the wider European La Tène culture, and a few examples of decoration survive from Scotland. There are also decorated torcs, scabbards, armlets and war trumpets. The Romans began military expeditions into what is now Scotland from about 71 CE, leaving a direct sculptural legacy of distance slabs, altars and other sculptures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anna Ritchie (archaeologist)</span> British archaeologist

Dr Anna Ritchie OBE, BA, PhD, FSA, Hon FSA Scot is a British archaeologist and historian.

References

  1. "Carved stone ball". National Museums of Scotland. Retrieved 22 March 2008.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Marshall, D.N. (1976–1977). "Carved stone balls". Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. 108: 4–72.
  3. 1 2 "Stone balls". Ashmolean Museum .
  4. Chris L. Stewart-Moffitt (July 2022). The Circular Archetype in Microcosm: The Carved Stone Balls of Late Neolithic Scotland. Archaeopress Publishing Ltd. p. 3. The sole example from Norway was almost certainly found by Vikings during an expedition to Scotland and taken home as a curio; it is documented as being discovered in an early medieval cairn (Breivik 2013:47-49).
  5. Marshall, D.N. (1983). "Further notes on carved stone balls". Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. 113: 628–646. doi: 10.9750/PSAS.113.628.630 . S2CID   257748877.
  6. "Neolithic ball". British Museum . Search collection.
  7. Rees, Thomas; Hunter, Fraser (2000). "Archaeological excavation of a medieval structure and an assemblage of prehistoric artefacts from the summit of Traprain Law, East Lothian, 1996 - 1997". Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. 130: 413–440. doi:10.9750/PSAS.130.413.440.
  8. "Wednesday, 7 August 2013". Orkneyjar (blog). Dig Diary – Ness of Brodgar. 7 August 2013. Archived from the original on 25 March 2014. Retrieved 10 August 2013.
  9. "Polished stone balls some 5,500 years' old discovered in Orkney tomb". University of Central Lancashire.
  10. 1 2 Young, Andrew T. "The Ground Stone Tools of Britain and Ireland: An experimental approach". Archaeology (doctoral research profile). University of Exeter . Retrieved 30 August 2014.
  11. 1 2 3 Secrets of Stonehenge (science documentary / transcript). Nova. PBS. November 2010. — shows an experimental use of them as roller-bearings for megalith transport. Search transcript for key phrase "carved stone balls".
  12. Powell, T.G.E. (1966). Prehistoric Art. Thames & Hudson. ISBN   0-500-20046-7.
  13. Cummins, W.A. (1999). The Picts and their Symbols. Sutton Publishing. p. 92. ISBN   0-7509-2207-9.
  14. Evans, John, Sir (1897). The Ancient Stone Implements, Weapons and Ornaments of Great Britain (2nd ed.). Longmans, Green, & Co. p. 422.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  15. "Discovering the secrets of Stonehenge". Science Daily. 20 November 2010. Retrieved 8 July 2011.
  16. Lloyd, David Robert (2012). "How old are the Platonic solids?". British Society for the History of Mathematics Bulletin. 27 (3): 131–140. doi:10.1080/17498430.2012.670845. S2CID   119544202.
  17. Hart, George (1998). "Neolithic carved stone polyhedra". Virtual polyhedra. georgehart.com.

Sources