1995 College Baseball All-America Team

1995 All-Americans included five-time MLB All-Star Todd Helton (left) and current Nebraska Cornhuskers baseball head coach Darin Erstad (right).

This is a list of college baseball players named first team All-Americans for the 1995 NCAA Division I baseball season. From 1994 to 1996, there were four generally recognized All-America selectors for baseball: the American Baseball Coaches Association, Baseball America , Collegiate Baseball Newspaper , and the National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association. In order to be considered a "consensus" All-American, a player must have been selected by at least three of these.

Key

A	American Baseball Coaches Association [1]
B	Baseball America [2]
C	Collegiate Baseball Newspaper [2]
N	National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association [3] – branded as the Smith Super Team
	Member of the National College Baseball Hall of Fame
	Consensus All-American – selected by all four organizations
	Consensus All-American – selected by three organizations

All-Americans

Position	Name	School	#	A	B	C	N	Other awards and honors
Starting pitcher	R. A. Dickey	Tennessee	1	—	—	—	Y
Starting pitcher	Ryan Halla	Auburn	2	Y	—	—	Y
Starting pitcher	Jonathan Johnson	Florida State	2	—	Y	—	Y
Starting pitcher	Matt Morris	Seton Hall	2	Y	Y	—	—
Starting pitcher	Kyle Peterson	Stanford	1	—	Y	—	—
Starting pitcher	Jamey Price	Ole Miss	2	—	—	Y	Y
Starting pitcher	Mark Redman	Oklahoma	4	Y	Y	Y	Y
Starting pitcher	Scott Schultz	LSU	1	—	—	—	Y
Starting pitcher	Ted Silva	Cal State Fullerton	4	Y	Y	Y	Y
Starting pitcher	Jay Tessmer	Miami (FL)	2	—	—	Y	Y
Starting pitcher	Evan Thomas	FIU	2	—	—	Y	Y
Starting pitcher	David Yocum	Florida State	1	—	—	—	Y
Relief pitcher	Scott Winchester	Clemson	2	Y	—	Y	—
Catcher	Javier Flores	Oklahoma	1	—	—	—	Y
Catcher	Shane Gunderson	Minnesota	1	Y	—	—	—
Catcher	A. J. Hinch	Stanford	3	—	Y	Y	Y
First baseman	Sean Casey	Richmond	1	—	—	—	Y
First baseman	Steve Hacker	Southwest Missouri State	3	Y	—	Y	Y
Second baseman	Marlon Anderson	South Alabama	2	—	Y	—	Y
Second baseman	Jason Totman	Texas Tech	3	Y	—	Y	Y
Shortstop	Jason Adams	Wichita State	2	—	—	Y	Y
Shortstop	Gabe Alvarez	USC	2	Y	—	—	Y
Shortstop	Mark Bellhorn	Auburn	1	—	Y	—
Shortstop	Peter Prodanov	Oklahoma State	1	—	—	—	Y
Third baseman	Clint Bryant	Texas Tech	3	—	Y	Y	Y
Third baseman	Toby Kominek	Central Michigan	1	Y	—	—	—
Third baseman	Tal Light	Oklahoma State	1	—	—	—	Y
Outfielder	José Cruz Jr.	Rice	3	Y	Y	—	Y
Outfielder	David Dellucci	Ole Miss	1	—	—	—	Y
Outfielder	Darin Erstad	Nebraska	4	Y	Y	Y	Y	First overall pick in the 1995 MLB Draft
Outfielder	Geoff Jenkins	USC	3	—	Y	Y	Y
Outfielder / DH	Mark Kotsay	Cal State Fullerton	4	Y	Y	Y	Y	Golden Spikes Award Collegiate Baseball Player of the Year Rotary Smith Award College World Series Most Outstanding Player
Outfielder	Shane Monahan	Clemson	2	—	—	Y	Y
Outfielder	Mark Wulfert	New Mexico	1	Y	—	—	—
Designated hitter	John Curl	Texas A&M	2	—	—	Y	Y
Designated hitter	Todd Tatlock	Indiana State	1	Y	—	—	—
Utility player	Todd Helton	Tennessee	4	Y	Y	Y	Y	Dick Howser Trophy ABCA Player of the Year Baseball America Player of the Year Collegiate Baseball Player of the Year
Utility player	Jeff Leaman	Indiana State	1	—	—	—	Y
Utility player	Mark Quinn	Rice	1	—	—	—	Y

See also

List of college baseball awards

References

1. "1995 ABCA/Rawlings NCAA Div. I All-America Teams". ABCA.org. Retrieved July 5, 2025.
2. "NCAA Baseball Award Winners" (PDF). NCAA. Retrieved April 12, 2012.
3. "All-Americans Come to Play". Omaha World-Herald. June 2, 1995. Retrieved August 8, 2025.