1991 College Baseball All-America Team

Mark Sweeney, the career pinch hit RBI recordholder, was named to the All-America Team in 1991 by both the American Baseball Coaches Association and Collegiate Baseball.

This is a list of college baseball players named first team All-Americans for the 1991 NCAA Division I baseball season. From 1991 to 1999, there were three generally recognized All-America selectors for baseball: the American Baseball Coaches Association, Baseball America , and the Collegiate Baseball Newspaper . ^[1]

Key

A	American Baseball Coaches Association [2]
B	Baseball America [1]
C	Collegiate Baseball Newspaper [1]
	Member of the National College Baseball Hall of Fame
	Unanimous All-American – selected by all 3 organizations
	Consensus All-American – selected by 2 organizations

All-Americans

Position	Name	School	Status	#	A	B	C	Other awards and honors
Starting pitcher	Bill Blanchette	Hawaii		1	—	—	Y
Starting pitcher	John Burke	Florida		1	—	Y	—
Starting pitcher	Craig Clayton	Cal State Northridge	Consensus	2	—	Y	Y
Starting pitcher	Keith Garagozzo	Delaware	Consensus	2	Y	—	Y
Starting pitcher	Bobby Jones	Fresno State	Unanimous	3	Y	Y	Y	ABCA Player of the Year Collegiate Baseball Player of the Year Rotary Smith Award
Starting pitcher	Tony Phillips	Southern Miss		1	—	—	Y
Starting pitcher	Kennie Steenstra	Wichita State	Unanimous	3	Y	Y	Y
Starting pitcher	Steve Whitaker	Long Beach State		1	—	Y	—
Relief Pitcher	Steve Montgomery	Pepperdine		1	Y	—	—
Relief Pitcher	Phil Stidham	Arkansas		1	—	—	Y
Catcher	Michael Daniel	Oklahoma State		1	—	—	Y
Catcher	Pedro Grifol	Florida State	Consensus	2	Y	Y	—
First baseman	David McCarty	Stanford	Unanimous	3	Y	Y	Y	Baseball America Player of the Year
Second baseman	Jimmy Crowley	Clemson		1	Y	—	—
Second baseman	Billy Hall	Wichita State		1	—	—	Y
Second baseman	Steve Rodriguez	Pepperdine		1	—	Y	—
Shortstop	Brent Gates	Minnesota	Unanimous	3	Y	Y	Y
Third baseman	Andy Bruce	Georgia Tech		1	—	—	Y
Third baseman	Scott Stahoviak	Creighton	Consensus	2	Y	Y	—
Outfielder	Mike Kelly	Arizona State	Unanimous	3	Y	Y	Y	Golden Spikes Award
Outfielder	Mike Neill	Villanova		1	Y	—	—
Outfielder	Mark Smith	USC	Consensus	2	—	Y	Y
Outfielder	Mark Sweeney	Maine	Consensus	2	Y	—	Y
Outfielder	Tom Vantiger	Iowa State		1	Y	—	—
Outfielder	Joe Vitiello	Alabama		1	—	Y	—
Designated hitter	Michael Daniel	Oklahoma State		1	—	Y	—
Designated hitter	Gene Schall	Villanova		1	Y	—	—
Designated hitter	Scott Talanoa	Long Beach State		1	—	—	Y
Utility player	Brooks Kieschnick	Texas		1	Y	—	—

References

1. "NCAA Baseball Award Winners" (PDF). NCAA. Retrieved April 12, 2012.
2. "1991 ABCA/Rawlings NCAA Div. I All-America Teams". ABCA.org. Retrieved June 28, 2025.