2018 Adelaide Crows pre-season camp

The 2018 Adelaide Crows pre-season camp was a summer camp undertaken by players of the Adelaide Football Club from January 29 to February 2 in the lead-up to the 2018 AFL season. Run by Collective Mind, a consultancy group based in Queensland, the camp was designed to strengthen the mental toughness of the players, a lack of which was blamed by Adelaide's Head of Football Brett Burton and coach Don Pyke for their loss in the 2017 AFL Grand Final.

According to some reports, the camp was "cult-like", and ultimately caused the departure of many senior officials, including both Burton and Pyke. ^[1] It was said to have had the opposite of its intended team building effect, and contributed to a rapid deterioration in Adelaide's onfield form.

Information on the events of the camp was limited until a July 2020 article by journalist Sam McClure, who obtained details from various former Adelaide players. In February 2022, Nine Entertainment retracted McClure's July 2020 article and other camp-related publications due to a defamation lawsuit from Collective Minds. ^[2] However, some claims in the publications were later supported or corroborated by players. ^[3]

Background

Having faced numerous hardships throughout previous seasons such as the murder of coach Phil Walsh and the death of assistant coach Dean Bailey, the Adelaide Football Club had a successful year in 2017 and finished as minor premiers at the end of the 2017 home-and-away season. ^{[4] [5]} Captain Taylor Walker was widely regarded as one of the best in the league, and the shock and pain that had been felt by many in the club as a result of the murder of Walsh had been routed into a strong desire to honour his memory by winning a premiership. ^[6] However, in the Grand Final, when they faced the Richmond Football Club, Adelaide were soundly beaten. Instead of the close match many were anticipating, Richmond won by eight goals, and dominated the entire match. ^{[7] [8]} The large loss demoralised the playing group, with many being unable to face the media. ^[8] Nevertheless, there was a strong feeling that Adelaide would bounce back from the loss and perform well again the next season. ^[7]

Collective Minds

Collective Minds is a consultancy group based in Queensland, which is "hired by sporting teams and businesses to build a mentally resilient culture", ^[1] had worked with Adelaide throughout the 2017 season, and had generally been perceived as effective, if unorthodox. On one occasion after the Grand Final loss, they had every player run successive 100-metre sprints while the theme song of the Richmond Football Club played on repeat over loudspeakers. ^[1] Collective Minds and the Adelaide Football Club had a multi-year regimen with each other. ^[9] Prior to the camp, Crows players were made to sign non-disclosure agreements barring them from publicly discussing the events of the camp. ^[10]

Allegations about the camp

The camp, run by Collective Minds and masterminded by Head of Football at Adelaide Brett Burton and Amon Woulfe, a self-proclaimed "coach, facilitator and trainer", who is not a registered psychologist, took place in a forest about an hours drive away from Broadbeach, Queensland, a suburb of Gold Coast. ^[1] It was run with the intention of strengthening the mental capabilities of the players, which had been blamed by senior staff as the cause for their Grand Final loss. ^[1] The players were not told where they were going prior to the trip. ^[1] Players were divided into three groups, based on their playing experience, prior to the journey to the camp. Group One, consisting of the more senior Adelaide players, namely Eddie Betts, Matt Crouch, Richard Douglas, Bryce Gibbs, Kyle Hartigan, Josh Jenkins, Tom Lynch, Rory Sloane, Daniel Talia and captain Walker, were the target of the most severe regimen. ^{[1] [11]} The second group, consisting of Mitch McGovern, Curtly Hampton, Paul Seedsman and Brodie Smith, had a less severe experience, though it was still described as "weird". ^[1] The third group, consisting of the more junior players, were subject to what was deemed to be a regular fitness camp. ^[1] Players were housed in tepees for the duration of the camp. ^[1] According to an unnamed Adelaide insider who was quoted by the Herald Sun , the camp was "like a trance", with this unnamed insider also claiming that players had had difficulty remembering what had occurred on the camp. ^[12]

Experience of Group 1

Upon entering the bus that was to carry them from Broadbeach to the camp, Group 1 was alarmed to be greeted by men wearing combat uniforms and holding what appeared to be automatic firearms, though the guns were revealed to be fake. ^[11] The players were then blindfolded, and were driven for an hour until they arrived at the camp. ^[1] Upon arrival they had their blindfolds removed, and were greeted by roughly 25 camp workers, who refused to reveal the location at which they were. ^[1] Among the first exercises performed by Group 1 was an exercise in which players were told to find a partner and stare at their eyes, alternating which eye they were staring at. ^[1] During the middle of this exercise, Tom Lynch collapsed. He was taken to a bed, where he started to vomit. ^[11] Despite his condition, camp workers refused to call for medical attention, claiming that he was only suffering from dizziness. ^[1] Lynch was only given medical assistance upon the demands of the players, and club doctor Marc Cesana, who was not at the camp and did not know where it was located, was contacted and made to drive to the location and bring Lynch back to Broadbeach to provide medical attention. ^{[11] [1]}

Experience of Group 2 and Group 3

Groups 2 and 3 were subject to a less severe experience than Group 1, with them arriving a day after Group 1 . They were not blindfolded on the drive there, though they were ordered to keep their heads down for the entire trip, while heavy metal music played over loudspeakers. ^[1]

Talking stick

During the first night of the camp, all players were asked to publicly divulge their weaknesses using an Aboriginal Australian digging stick as a Talking stick. ^[13] Eddie Betts, Cam Ellis-Yolmen, Wayne Milera and Curtly Hampton, all of whom are Aboriginal, found this action culturally offensive, and it only contributed to their distaste for the camp. ^[1] Collective Minds has admitted that using the digging stick in the way that they did was a mistake. ^[13]

Wolfgang

According to journalist Sam McClure of The Age, before sunrise on the second day of camp, players were woken up and taken to a worker in the woods, who introduced himself as "Wolfgang". ^[11] One by one, players were then tied with to a tree. The only way for a player to free himself was to crawl to a knife located 10 metres away. ^[14]

While they were attempting to reach the knife, nine of their teammates would hurl abuse at them. This abuse was deeply personal, with barbs calling back to childhood trauma, relationship issues and domestic abuse that had been gleaned from info leaked to the managers of the camp without the consent of the players, derived from confidential disclosures players had made to Adelaide staff. ^[14] In some cases, this information was confidential to the extent that players had not divulged it to their spouses. ^[1] Betts claimed in his autobiography The Boy from Boomerang Crescent that he received insults from camp instructors regarding his upbringing and his mother. ^[15] Jeff Bond, former Chief Psychologist for the Australian Institute of Sport, told The Age that "Using people's personal trauma to drive them is so illogical and dangerous it's not funny". ^[14] Bond also compared many of the measures taken in the camp to ones used for training commandos in the military. ^[1] Adelaide themselves have "strongly disputed" this version of events. ^[12]

Social interactions

Social interaction at the camp was extremely limited, players were ordered not to talk with each other when not performing exercises, and as all phones had been confiscated most players had zero contact with the outside world. The only outside contact allowed was for players who had pregnant spouses, who were allowed a few minutes a day to speak. ^[1]

Aftermath

The camp was not effective in improving the results of the Adelaide Football Club. Adelaide had a poor 2018 season, finishing 12th on the ladder and missing the finals. ^[16] Midway through the 2018 season, Adelaide cut all ties with Collective Minds, who claimed that the decision was mutual. ^[17] After the cutting of ties, Adelaide coach Don Pyke admitted that the camp was a failure. ^[18] Several Adelaide players left the club over the next few seasons. Among the most notable departures were Eddie Betts, who had declared "That [camp] was one of the main reasons why it was so hard to enjoy footy", and returned to his old club Carlton; ^[1] and Mitch McGovern, who left the club after the 2018 season, also to play for Carlton. In June 2020, McGovern's manager Colin Young singled out the camp as the singular reason for McGovern leaving the club. ^[19] All in all, 8 out of Adelaide's best 22 players in 2017 left the club as of July 2020, a turnover amount described as an "exodus". ^[14] Pyke also left the club, resigning at the end of the 2019 season after another subpar season, with Brett Burton and assistant coach Scott Camporeale being sacked a month later. ^{[20] [21]}

In September 2020, Collective Minds sued Nine Entertainment for defamation. ^[22] As a result, Nine retracted 13 publications about the camp in February 2022. ^[23]

In August 2022, Eddie Betts released a biography containing previously unknown revelations about what happened at the camp. In response the Adelaide Football Club publicly apologised to him. ^[24] Following the release of Betts's biography, Josh Jenkins released a statement with further details from the camp. His opposition to aspects of the camp led to him being ostracised and was the reason he left the club. ^[25] Bryce Gibbs also spoke out about events that transpired at the camp. ^[26]

References

1. McClure, Sam (July 4, 2020). "Inside the camp that brought down the Adelaide Crows". The Age. Retrieved July 4, 2020. (Retracted)
2. Nine to apologise to Collective Mind for articles about Adelaide Crows' Gold Coast camp, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 4 Feb, 2022
3. "Former Adelaide Crow Bryce Gibbs speaks out about infamous training camp after Eddie Betts book release". ABC. Retrieved 7 August 2022.
4. Morris, Tom (September 23, 2017). "AFL Grand Final 2017: Adelaide Crows' courage through Phil Walsh tragedy and other painful setbacks". Fox Sports. Retrieved July 4, 2020.
5. "Crows receive McClelland Trophy". Adelaide Football Club. September 8, 2017. Retrieved July 4, 2020.
6. Garcia, Sara (September 28, 2017). "AFL grand final: Adelaide Crows will strive to 'get the job done' for Phil Walsh". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved July 4, 2020.
7. Iannela, Antimo; Smith, Matt (September 30, 2017). "AFL 2017 Grand Final: Dejected Crows fans start long trip home". The Advertiser. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
8. Porter, Ashley (September 30, 2017). "Adelaide Crows 'totally devastated' after grand final loss to Richmond Tigers". The Age. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
9. Morris, Tom (March 26, 2018). "A 'cult-like' pre-season camp debacle left senior Adelaide Crows players distressed". Fox Sports. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
10. "Retired Adelaide Crows star Bryce Gibbs says club's 2018 camp 'a disaster'". ESPN. AAP. December 1, 2020. Retrieved December 6, 2020.
11. Zita, David (July 5, 2020). "Adelaide Crows training camp 2018, details, fake weapons, tied to trees, sledges". Fox Sports. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
12. Tiernan, Eamonn (July 16, 2020). "Wife-sharing taunt revealed as infamous AFL camp details exposed". Seven News. Retrieved February 12, 2020.
13. Boisvert, Eugene (August 27, 2018). "Collective Mind denies claims about Adelaide Crows pre-season camp, shifts blame to AFL club". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
14. Riordan, Joey (July 5, 2020). "Players 'sledged' about childhood abuse and personal trauma at 2018 Crows camp". Seven News. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
15. "AFL News: 'Disrespectful to many cultures' - Betts tells all on Crows camp, McVeigh interviews for GWS job". The Roar. 3 August 2022. Retrieved 3 August 2022.
16. Stirling, Mick (September 4, 2018). "Adelaide Crows 2018 AFL season review: Could it have been any worse?". Sporting News. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
17. "Adelaide Crows cut ties with company Collective Mind, following controversial preseason training camp". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. AAP. June 23, 2018. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
18. Angley, Tom (June 23, 2018). "Don Pyke concedes Crows controversial pre-season camp was failure". Nine News. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
19. Larkin, Steve (June 18, 2020). "Agent says Mitch McGovern's exit from Adelaide was due to 2018 preseason camp". Perth Now. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
20. Garcia, Sara; Keane, Daniel (September 12, 2019). "Adelaide Crows coach Don Pyke steps down after four years at the club". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
21. Triple M Footy Newsroom (October 11, 2019). "Brett Burton And Scott Camporeale Sacked As Crows Finalise Football Department Review". Triple M. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
22. Bednall, Jai (September 12, 2020). "Action launched over infamous AFL camp". The Courier Mail. Retrieved February 12, 2021.
23. Eccles, David (2022-02-04). "Nine apologises, retracts Crows pre-season camp stories". InDaily. Retrieved 2022-10-21.
24. "Adelaide Crows apologise to former AFL star Eddie Betts following new book airing claims about preseason training camp". ABC. Retrieved 3 August 2022.
25. "Former Adelaide Crow Josh Jenkins speaks out about controversial camp days after Eddie Betts's book release". ABC. Retrieved 3 August 2022.
26. "Former Adelaide Crow Bryce Gibbs speaks out about infamous training camp after Eddie Betts book release". ABC. Retrieved 7 August 2022.