A Birthday Cake for George Washington

Last updated

A Birthday Cake for George Washington
GW Birthday Cake Book.jpg
Author Ramin Ganeshram
IllustratorVanessa Brantley-Newton
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Genre Children's fiction
Published2016 by Scholastic Press, an imprint of Scholastic, Inc.
Pages32
ISBN 978-0-545-53823-7

A Birthday Cake for George Washington is a children's picture book written by Ramin Ganeshram and illustrated by Vanessa Brantley-Newton, published by Scholastic and first released on January 5, 2016. [1] It is narrated by Delia, the daughter of Hercules, one of George Washington's slaves who worked for him as a cook. The book tells the story of Hercules and Delia baking a birthday cake for Washington. [2] Scholastic pulled the book on January 17, 2016 in response to criticism that the illustrations depicted an overly-positive portrayal of slavery.

Contents

Criticism

While generally praised by traditional reviewers, Vicky Smith wrote about problems with the book in her article "Smiling Slaves in a Post-A Fine Dessert World" [3] in Kirkus Reviews on January 4, 2016. Smith, Kirkus Reviews' children's and teen book editor, compared the book to A Fine Dessert by Emily Jenkins, another picture book which proved controversial because it depicted images of smiling slaves. She notes that Ganeshram did not mention in the narrative that when the real life Hercules escaped to freedom from Washington, he was forced to leave his daughter behind. Smith concluded that "It’s easy to understand why Ganeshram opted to leave those details out of her primary narrative: they’re a serious downer for readers, and they don’t have anything to do with the cake. But the story that remains nevertheless shares much of what ‘A Fine Dessert’’s critics found so objectionable: it’s an incomplete, even dishonest treatment of slavery.” [4]

This was followed by more critiques, including of the illustrations of the characters as “smiling slaves” and thereby whitewashing the history of slavery and presenting an "offensively sanitized version" of slavery to children. [2] Among the critics were Kiera Parrott, who wrote in School Library Journal that the book was "highly problematic" and that it "convey[s] a feeling of joyfulness that contrasts starkly with the reality of slave life". [5] [6] As of January 18, the book had received over 100 one-star ratings on Amazon.com. [7]

On January 13, 2016, a critical review of the book by librarian Edith Campbell [8] was posted on the Facebook page of the Washington, DC-based nonprofit Teaching for Change, alongside a photo of the book’s back cover. On this same day, Leslie MacFadyen of the National Ferguson Response Network entered the conversation and developed the hashtag #slaverywithasmile. This took the discussion beyond the children’s literature world to parents, educators, and activists. It also caught the attention of major media outlets, including the Atlanta Black Star, The Root, and Fusion. [9] Thousands signed a protest petition at Change.org. Food historian Michael W. Twitty critiqued historical elements of the book in The Guardian while author Steve Sheinkin discussed the book in an Actually podcast. [10] Debbie Reese of American Indians in Children’s Literature—who had played a major role drawing public attention to the Mexican American studies ban in Tucson—documented the evolution of events on her blog. [11] Author Daniel José Older tweeted about the book. Older's tweets, the petition, and a summary of the campaign were published on Common Dreams. [12]

The controversy evolved into discussions about how to present enslavement in children’s books. [13]

Withdrawal

Scholastic withdrew the book on January 17, 2016 following the criticism. [14] [15] In a statement, the publisher said:

Scholastic has a long history of explaining complex and controversial issues to children at all ages and grade levels. We do not believe this title meets the standards of appropriate presentation of information to younger children, despite the positive intentions and beliefs of the author, editor, and illustrator. [1]

Reaction to withdrawal

The decision to withdraw the book was criticized by anti-censorship activists like the National Coalition Against Censorship (NCAC) and the PEN American Center, which released a statement saying that "Those who value free speech as an essential human right and a necessary precondition for social change should be alarmed whenever books are removed from circulation because they are controversial". [6] The NCAC's statement also defended the book by saying that it had helped promote discussion about how Americans remember slavery. [16] Scholastic responded to this statement by accusing both the NCAC and PEN of not correctly reading Scholastic's initial statement, and asserting that the book was withdrawn "not in response to criticism, but entirely and purposefully because this title did not meet our publishing standards" [17] although Scholastic, not the author, or illustrator, was solely in charge of the publishing process. [18]

In an interview with the Associated Press, the author responded to the public outcry and withdrawal of the book, stating that she had continually voiced concerns about the “over jovial” depiction of the enslaved characters [18] but that she had been repeatedly ignored by the publisher. [19] The book’s editor Andrea Davis Pinkney and illustrator Vanessa Brantley-Newton did not respond for requests for comment from the Associated Press.

Farah Mendlesohn wrote that the decision by Scholastic to withdraw the book was product recall, not censorship, and argued that if "it is acceptable and “free speech” to turn [the story of Hercules] into a happy little story about a slave serving his master joyfully, then I look forward to Scholastic producing a bright little picture book called The Children’s Choir of Terezin." [20]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dav Pilkey</span> American cartoonist and author (born 1966)

David Murray "Dav" Pilkey Jr. is an American cartoonist, author, and illustrator of children's literature. He is best known as the author and illustrator of the children's book series, Captain Underpants, and its spin-off children's graphic novel series Dog Man, the latter published under the respective writer and illustrator pen names of George Beard and Harold Hutchins, which are also the names of the two protagonists of the Captain Underpants series.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Birthday cake</span> Dessert served to celebrate a birthday

A birthday cake is a cake eaten as part of a birthday celebration. While there is no standard for birthday cakes, they are typically highly decorated layer cakes covered in frosting, often featuring birthday wishes and the celebrant's name. In many cultures, it is also customary to serve the birthday cake with small lit candles on top, especially in the case of a child's birthday. Variations include cupcakes, cake pops, pastries, and tarts. In more recent years, it has become a common flavour for confectionery including ice cream, PopTarts, various cereal varieties among others. The flavour is usually vanilla with sweeter hints to imply sprinkles.

<i>The Red Tree</i> (Shaun Tan) 2001 picture book by Shaun Tan

The Red Tree (2001), written and illustrated by Shaun Tan, is a picture book that presents a fragmented journey through a dark world. The text is sparse and the illustrations are dark and surreal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Raina Telgemeier</span> American cartoonist, illustrator, and writer

Raina Telgemeier is an American cartoonist. Her works include the autobiographical webcomic Smile, which was published as a full-color middle grade graphic novel in February 2010, and the follow-up Sisters and the fiction graphic novel Drama, all of which have been on The New York Times Best Seller lists. She has also written and illustrated the graphic novels Ghosts and Guts as well as four graphic novels adapted from The Baby-Sitters Club stories by Ann M. Martin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Coalition Against Censorship</span>

The National Coalition Against Censorship (NCAC), founded in 1974, is an alliance of 50 American non-profit organizations, including literary, artistic, religious, educational, professional, labor, and civil liberties groups. NCAC is a New York–based organization with official 501(c)(3) status in the United States. The coalition seeks to defend freedom of thought, inquiry, and expression from censorship and threats of censorship through education and outreach, and direct advocacy. NCAC assists individuals, community groups, and institutions with strategies and resources for resisting censorship and creating a climate hospitable to free expression. It also encourages the publicizing of cases of censorship and has a place to report instances of censorship on the organization's website. Their annual fundraiser is called the Free Speech Defender Awards. The main goal of the organization is to defend the first amendment, freedom of thought, inquiry, and expression. NCAC's website contains reports of censorship incidents, analysis and discussion of free expression issues, a database of legal cases in the arts, an archive of NCAC's quarterly newsletter, a blog, and Censorpedia, a crowdsourced wiki. In fiscal year 2017, the organization earned a 95.93% rating by Charity Navigator, an organization that assesses the efficacy of nonprofits.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Washington and slavery</span> George Washingtons relationship with slavery

The history of George Washington and slavery reflects Washington's changing attitude toward the ownership of human beings. The preeminent Founding Father of the United States and a hereditary slaveowner, Washington became increasingly uneasy with it. Slavery was then a longstanding institution dating back over a century in Virginia where he lived; it was also longstanding in other American colonies and in world history. Washington's will provided for the immediate emancipation of one of his slaves, and additionally required his remaining 123 slaves to serve his wife and be freed no later than her death, so they ultimately became free one year after his own death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oney Judge</span> Fugitive slave, enslaved by George and Martha Washington

Ona "Oney" Judge Staines was a biracial woman who was enslaved by the Washington family, first at the family's plantation at Mount Vernon and later, after George Washington became president, at the President's House in Philadelphia, then the nation's capital city. In her early twenties, she absconded, becoming a fugitive slave, after learning that Martha Washington had intended to transfer ownership of her to her granddaughter, known to have a horrible temper. She fled to New Hampshire, where she married, had children, and converted to Christianity. Though she was never formally freed, the Washington family ultimately stopped pressing her to return to Virginia after George Washington's death.

Hercules Posey was an enslaved African owned by George Washington, at his plantation Mount Vernon in Virginia. "Uncle Harkless," as he was called by George Washington Parke Custis, served as chief cook at the Mansion House for many years. In November 1790, Hercules was one of eight enslaved Africans brought by President Washington to Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, then the temporary national capital, to serve in the household of the third presidential mansion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">President's House (Philadelphia)</span> Building in Pennsylvania, United States

The President's House in Philadelphia was the third U.S. Presidential Mansion. George Washington occupied it from November 27, 1790, to March 10, 1797, and John Adams occupied it from March 21, 1797, to May 30, 1800.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ramin Ganeshram</span> American journalist and novelist (born 1968)

Ramin Ganeshram is an American journalist, food writer, and novelist. She is known for her work in polycultural American history and historic foodways.

<i>12 Years a Slave</i> (film) 2013 film directed by Steve McQueen

12 Years a Slave is a 2013 biographical drama film directed by Steve McQueen from a screenplay by John Ridley, based on the 1853 slave memoir Twelve Years a Slave by Solomon Northup, an African American man who was kidnapped in Washington, D.C. by two conmen in 1841 and sold into slavery. He was put to work on plantations in the state of Louisiana for 12 years before being released. The first scholarly edition of David Wilson's version of Northup's story was co-edited in 1968 by Sue Eakin and Joseph Logsdon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Don Tate</span> American writer (born 1963)

Don Tate is an American author and illustrator of books for children. He is also an activist promoting racial and cultural inclusiveness in children's literature. He notes that as a child he had to read the encyclopedia to discover a multicultural world; based on the children's books of his day he "thought the world was white". He co-founded the young African American blog The Brown Bookshelf and helps run the #WeNeedDiverseBooks campaign to improve diversity of material in children's books.

Hercules Mulligan was an Irish-American tailor and spy during the American Revolutionary War. He was a member of the Sons of Liberty.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sophie Blackall</span> Australian artist, author, and childrens book illustrator

Sophie Jocasta Blackall is an Australian artist, author, and illustrator of children's books based in Brooklyn, New York.

<i>Prince & Knight</i> 2018 childrens picture book

Prince & Knight is a children's picture book authored by Daniel Haack and illustrated by Stevie Lewis. Prince & Knight tells the story of a young prince who falls in love with a knight after the two work together to battle a dragon threatening the kingdom. At the conclusion of the book, the two wed.

Leslie MacFadyen, known professionally as Leslie Mac, is an American activist and community organizer. She is a co-founder of the Ferguson Response Network, the co-creator of the Safety Pin Box monthly subscription service, and has created multiple digital campaigns such as #PayBlackWomen and #SlaveryWithASmile.

<i>We Are Water Protectors</i> 2020 picture book

We Are Water Protectors is a 2020 picture book written by Carole Lindstrom and illustrated by Michaela Goade. Written in response to the Dakota Access Pipeline protests, the book tells the story of an Ojibwe girl who fights against an oil pipeline in an effort to protect the water supply of her people. It was published by Roaring Brook Press on March 17, 2020. The book was well received. Critics praised its message of environmental justice, its depiction of diversity, and the watercolor illustrations, for which Goade won the 2021 Caldecott Medal, becoming the first Indigenous recipient of the award. The book also received the 2021 Jane Addams Children's Book Award winner in the Books for Younger Children category.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Robinson (chief executive)</span> American business executive (1937–2021)

Maurice Richard Robinson Jr. was an American business executive and educator. From 1975 until his death in 2021, Robinson was the chief executive officer of Scholastic Corporation. Robinson was noted for bringing many book franchises to younger readers, such as Harry Potter and Captain Underpants.

Never Caught: The Washingtons' Relentless Pursuit of Their Runaway Slave, Ona Judge is a non-fiction book by American historian Erica Armstrong Dunbar, published in 2017. The book chronicles the life of Ona Judge, an enslaved woman owned by George and Martha Washington, and her escape from the President's household in Philadelphia in 1796.

References

  1. 1 2 Chan, Melissa (January 18, 2016). "Scholastic Pulls A Birthday Cake for George Washington Amid Slavery Backlash". Time. Retrieved January 27, 2016.
  2. 1 2 Stack, Liam (January 18, 2016). "Scholastic Halts Distribution of 'A Birthday Cake for George Washington'". New York Times. Retrieved January 27, 2016.
  3. ↑ Smith, Vicky (January 4, 2016). "Smiling Slaves in a Post-A Fine Dessert World". Kirkus Reviews. Retrieved January 27, 2017.
  4. ↑ Lee, Paula Young (January 18, 2016). "Smiling slaves at story time: These picture books show why we need more diversity in publishing, too". Salon. Retrieved January 29, 2016.
  5. ↑ Parrott, Kiera (January 18, 2016). "A Birthday Cake for George Washington Review". School Library Journal. Retrieved January 27, 2016.
  6. 1 2 Flood, Alison (January 25, 2016). "'Self-censorship' of children's book depicting smiling slave condemned". The Guardian. Retrieved January 27, 2016.
  7. ↑ Bowerman, Mary (January 18, 2016). "Scholastic pulls controversial George Washington slave book". USA Today. Retrieved January 29, 2016.
  8. ↑ Campbell, Edith (January 13, 2016). "Book Review: A Birthday Cake for George Washington". Crazy QuiltsEdi. Retrieved January 28, 2017.
  9. ↑ Pulliam-Moore, Charles (January 15, 2016). "This new children's book about George Washington depicts slaves as happy bakers". Fusion. Retrieved January 28, 2017.
  10. ↑ Twitty, Michael W (January 19, 2016). "What happens when children's books fail to confront the complexity of slavery?" . Retrieved November 12, 2021.
  11. ↑ Reese, Debbie (January 6, 2016). ""What will they say..." Or, Master Narratives of Smiling Slaves and Smiling Indians". American Indians in Children's Literature. Retrieved January 27, 2017.
  12. ↑ Menkart, Deborah (January 19, 2016). "Under Pressure, Scholastic Recalls Racist Children's Book". Common Dreams. Retrieved January 28, 2017.
  13. ↑ Peralta, Eyder (January 22, 2016). "Teaching Kids About Slavery: Picture Books Struggle With The Task". NPR's All Things Considered. Retrieved January 27, 2016.
  14. ↑ Peralta, Eyder (January 18, 2016). "Amid Controversy, Scholastic Pulls Picture Book About Washington's Slave". NPR. Retrieved January 27, 2016.
  15. ↑ "Scholastic pulls George Washington book over slave cake controversy". The Guardian. Associated Press. January 17, 2016. Retrieved January 27, 2016.
  16. ↑ Charles, Ron (January 22, 2016). "Free speech groups defend 'A Birthday Cake for George Washington'". Washington Post. Retrieved January 28, 2016.
  17. ↑ Charles, Ron (January 25, 2016). "Scholastic defends its free-speech credentials". Washington Post. Retrieved January 28, 2016.
  18. 1 2 "AP NewsBreak: Slavery book author says she had concerns". The Big Story. Retrieved February 21, 2016.
  19. ↑ "Why The Banning Of 'A Birthday Cake For George Washington' Really Matters". The Huffington Post. February 11, 2016. Retrieved February 21, 2016.
  20. ↑ Mendlesohn, Farah (January 27, 2016). "Nothing sweet about A Birthday Cake for George Washington". The Guardian. Retrieved January 28, 2016.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.