A Separate Creation

Last updated
A Separate Creation: The Search for the Biological Origins of Sexual Orientation
A Separate Creation.jpg
Cover of the first edition
Author Chandler Burr
LanguageEnglish
Subject Sexual orientation
Publisher Hyperion
Publication date
1996
Publication placeUnited States
Media typePrint (Hardcover and Paperback)
Pages354
ISBN 978-0786882403

A Separate Creation: The Search for the Biological Origins of Sexual Orientation, also published with the subtitle How Biology Makes Us Gay, is a 1996 book about the development of sexual orientation by the journalist Chandler Burr. It received mainly positive reviews, commending it as a useful discussion of scientific research on sexual orientation and the politics surrounding the issue.

Contents

Summary

Burr discusses biological research on sexual orientation by scientists such as the neuroscientist Simon LeVay, the psychiatrist Richard Pillard, the psychologists J. Michael Bailey, Heino Meyer-Bahlburg, and Anke Ehrhardt, and the geneticist Dean Hamer. He writes that a neuroanatomical study published in 1991 was the "first major biological investigation of sexual orientation", and that it was followed by research into genes and hormones. He also discusses the views of critics of the research, such as the evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin. [1]

Publication history

A Separate Creation was published by Hyperion in 1996, under the full title A Separate Creation: The Search for the Biological Origins of Sexual Orientation. [2] The book was published as A Separate Creation: How Biology Makes Us Gay by Bantam Press in 1997. [3]

Reception

Mainstream media

A Separate Creation received positive reviews from Ray Olson in Booklist , [4] Genevieve Stuttaford in Publishers Weekly , [5] the neurologist Richard Cytowic in The Washington Post , [6] the historian Jonathan Kirsch in the Los Angeles Times , [7] the philosopher Michael Ruse in The Times Literary Supplement , [8] and W. P. Anderson in Choice, [9] a mixed review from Gail Vines in New Scientist , [10] and a negative review from the historian Roy Porter in The New York Times Book Review . [11] The book was also reviewed by Jon Turney in the Times Higher Education Supplement , [12] and discussed by Norman Podhoretz in Commentary . [13]

Olson credited Burr with writing about science well and with covering the arguments of both supporters and critics of biological explanations of sexual orientation and the associated political issues. He suggested that the arguments of scientists who think some findings are "either not so significant, misleading, or downright erroneous" were often more convincing than those of scientists on the other side of the debate. He concluded that A Separate Creation might be "both the gay studies book of the year and the popular-science book of the year." [4] Stuttaford described the book as a "detailed, elegantly written report" on scientific research on sexual orientation, crediting Burr with dispassionately reviewing the scientific and political controversy created by LeVay's 1991 hypothalamus study. [5] Cytowic credited Burr with "disclosing the political meaning of sexual-orientation research" and with "revealing the media's absurd questions and abysmal grasp of science." [6] Kirsch called the book "enlightening" and an "earnest and mostly successful" effort to explain the findings of genetic research. He credited Burr with providing a "compelling profile" of the scientists involved in sexual orientation research and with explaining the politics of the issue. [7]

Ruse considered A Separate Creation a good discussion of its topic. He noted that it had appeared at the same time as several other books about biological research on homosexuality, suggesting that this showed that "publishers know a good thing when they see it." [8] Anderson wrote that Burr provided an "absorbing and comprehensive" discussion of biological research on sexual orientation, and a clearly written "reader-friendly interpretation" of the topic, with a broad presentation of recent findings. He concluded that A Separate Creation would be interesting to both scientists and the general public. [9] Vines described A Separate Creation as a "racy paean to the putative gay gene" and "a masterpiece of American journalese". She wrote that A Separate Creation contained "little analysis and lots of hype", but credited Burr with speaking to many researchers interested in searching for a biological basis to homosexuality, and concluded that the book was worth reading, "If you can stomach this sort of thing". [10] Porter called A Separate Creation a dispiriting comment on the state of science, writing that sexual orientation researchers have made exaggerated claims based on limited and sometimes flawed evidence. [11]

Podhoretz described the book as a "breathless account" of its topic. [13]

Gay media

A Separate Creation received a positive review from the physician Lawrence D. Mass in Lambda Book Report. [14] The book was also reviewed by Stephen H. Miller in the New York Native . [15] An excerpt appeared in The Advocate . [16] Burr's "Gay Gene" website, based on his book, was listed as a "hot web site" by The Advocate in 1998. [17] Tom Moon discussed Burr's views in the San Francisco Bay Times . [18]

Mass considered Burr a "gay-positive essentialist" and A Separate Creation "a valuable historical document" comparable to the journalist Randy Shilts' And the Band Played On (1987). [14]

Other evaluations and responses

Ron Good and Mark Hafner discussed A Separate Creation in The American Biology Teacher . [19]

The feminist Germaine Greer and the evolutionary biologist Marlene Zuk praised A Separate Creation. [20] [21] However, the book was criticized by the philosophers Timothy F. Murphy and Edward Stein. [22] [23] Murphy wrote that Burr incorrectly stated that LeVay's 1991 neuroanatomical report on the hypothalamus was the first major biological investigation of sexual orientation. He noted that scientific study of the determinants of sexual orientation dates to the 19th century and that many investigations of the possible biological basis of homosexuality preceded LeVay's work. [22] Stein, who noted that Burr was a journalist by background, called him "unsophisticated" for failing to discuss social constructionist views and accepting claims about the factors that cause homosexuality in fruit flies, including the discovery of a single gene that supposedly controls courtship behavior between male flies. He argued that such animal research commits the fallacy of anthropomorphism and is irrelevant to understanding sexual orientation in humans. [23]

The psychologist Louis A. Berman described Burr's evaluation of the biological evidence as optimistic. Berman, who believes that writers supportive of gay rights have ignored professional literature dealing with efforts to change sexual orientation, noted in this connexion that though Burr conducted a two-hour interview with the psychoanalyst Charles Socarides, Burr does not mention this. [24] According to Burr, his argument that in A Separate Creation that sexual orientation is innate prompted a call by Southern Baptists to boycott Disney films and theme parks because the book was published by Hyperion, a subsidiary of The Walt Disney Company. [25]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chandler Burr</span> American journalist

Chandler Burr is an American journalist, author, and museum curator.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Simon LeVay</span> British-American neuroscientist (born 1943)

Simon LeVay is a British-American neuroscientist.

<i>Gay Science</i> 1997 book by Timothy F. Murphy

Gay Science: The Ethics of Sexual Orientation Research is a 1997 book by the philosopher Timothy F. Murphy about scientific research on sexual orientation.

<i>Virtually Normal</i> 1995 book by Andrew Sullivan

Virtually Normal: An Argument About Homosexuality is a book about the politics of homosexuality by the political commentator Andrew Sullivan, in which the author criticizes four different perspectives on gay rights in American society, which he calls the "Prohibitionist", "Liberationist", "Conservative", and "Liberal" views, seeking to expose internal inconsistencies within each of them. He also criticizes the philosopher Michel Foucault and gay rights activists he considers influenced by Foucault, and argues in favor of same-sex marriage and an end to the don't ask, don't tell policy, which banned service by openly gay people in the US military. However, he makes a case against legislation aimed at preventing private discrimination against gay people.

<i>Virtual Equality</i> 1995 book by Urvashi Vaid

Virtual Equality: The Mainstreaming of Gay and Lesbian Liberation is a 1995 book about gay rights by lawyer and civil rights activist Urvashi Vaid, in which the author argues that LGBT movements in the United States have been only partially successful in achieving their goals, and that gay and lesbian Americans continue to suffer from discrimination and other problems. Vaid maintains that the American gay rights movement must reconsider its tactics and move from advocacy of civil equality to aiming at social change.

<i>Why Freud Was Wrong</i> 1995 book by Richard Webster

Why Freud Was Wrong: Sin, Science and Psychoanalysis is a book by Richard Webster, in which the author provides a critique of Sigmund Freud and psychoanalysis, and attempts to develop his own theory of human nature. Webster argues that Freud became a kind of Messiah and that psychoanalysis is a pseudoscience and a disguised continuation of the Judaeo-Christian tradition. Webster endorses Gilbert Ryle's arguments against mentalist philosophies in The Concept of Mind (1949), and criticizes many other authors for their treatment of Freud and psychoanalysis.

<i>One Hundred Years of Homosexuality</i> 1990 book by David M. Halperin

One Hundred Years of Homosexuality: and other essays on Greek love is a 1990 book about homosexuality in ancient Greece by the classicist David M. Halperin, in which the author supports the social constructionist school of thought associated with the French philosopher Michel Foucault. The work has been praised by several scholars, but criticized by others, some of whom have attributed to Halperin the view that the coining of the word "homosexuality" in the nineteenth century brought homosexuality into existence. The book was often reviewed alongside John J. Winkler's The Constraints of Desire (1990).

<i>Homosexualities</i> 1978 book by Alan P. Bell and Martin S. Weinberg

Homosexualities: A Study of Diversity Among Men and Women (1978) is a book by the psychologist Alan P. Bell and the sociologist Martin S. Weinberg in which the authors argue that homosexuality is not necessarily related to pathology and divide homosexuals into five types. Together with Homosexuality: An Annotated Bibliography (1972), it is part of a series of books that culminated in the publication of Sexual Preference in 1981. The work was a publication of the Institute for Sex Research.

<i>Homosexuality: A Philosophical Inquiry</i> 1988 book by Michael Ruse

Homosexuality: A Philosophical Inquiry is a 1988 book by the philosopher Michael Ruse, in which the author discusses different theories of homosexuality, evaluates the moral status of homosexual behavior, and argues in favor of gay rights.

<i>Lesbian/Woman</i> 1972 book by Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon

Lesbian/Woman is a work by the feminist and gay rights activists Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon, in which the authors discuss what it means to be a lesbian. The book was influential and is considered a foundational text of lesbian feminism. Reviewers believed that it benefited from its authors' personal experience as lesbians, and endorsed its criticisms of the treatment of lesbians by religious and professional organizations.

<i>The Anita Bryant Story</i> 1977 book by Anita Bryant

The Anita Bryant Story: The Survival of Our Nation's Families and the Threat of Militant Homosexuality is a 1977 book by Anita Bryant, in which the author provides an account of her evangelical Christian campaign against a gay rights ordinance in Dade County, Florida. The claims Bryant makes about homosexuality in the book have been described as false and unscholarly in nature.

<i>Growing Up Straight</i> (Wyden and Wyden book) 1968 book by Peter and Barbara Wyden

Growing Up Straight: What Every Thoughtful Parent Should Know About Homosexuality is a 1968 guide for parents, by Peter and Barbara Wyden, which he claims can prevent their children from becoming homosexual. Stanley Yolles, head of the National Institute of Mental Health, wrote an introduction.

<i>Male Homosexuality in Four Societies</i> 1985 book by Frederick L. Whitam and Robin Mathy

Male Homosexuality in Four Societies: Brazil, Guatemala, the Philippines and the United States is a 1985 work about male homosexuality by the sociologists Frederick L. Whitam and Robin Mathy.

<i>The Homosexual Matrix</i> 1975 book by Clarence Arthur Tripp

The Homosexual Matrix is a book by American psychologist Clarence Arthur Tripp, in which the author discusses the biological and sociological implications of homosexuality, and also attempts to explain heterosexuality and bisexuality. The book was first published in 1975 by McGraw-Hill Book Company; it was republished in a revised edition in 1987. Based on his review of the evidence, Tripp argues that people do not become homosexual due to factors such as hormone levels, fear of the opposite sex, or the influence of dominant and close-binding mothers, and that the amount of attention fathers give to their sons has no effect on the development of homosexuality. He criticizes Sigmund Freud and argues that psychoanalytic theories of the development of homosexuality are untenable and based on false assumptions. He maintains that sexual orientation is not innate and depends on learning, that early puberty and early masturbation are important factors in the development of male homosexuality, and that a majority of adults are heterosexual because their socialization has made them want to be heterosexual. He criticizes psychotherapeutic attempts to convert homosexuals to heterosexuality and argues in favor of social tolerance of homosexuality and non-conformist behavior in general.

<i>Gay, Straight, and the Reason Why</i> 2011 book by Simon LeVay

Gay, Straight, and the Reason Why: The Science of Sexual Orientation is a book by the neuroscientist Simon LeVay and published by Oxford University Press. The book received mainly positive reviews, praising it for LeVay's wide-ranging overview of scientific research on sexual orientation. In 2012, it received the Bullough Book Award for the most distinguished book written for the professional sexological community published in a given year.

<i>The Sexual Brain</i> 1993 book by Simon LeVay

The Sexual Brain is a 1993 book about brain mechanisms involved in sexual behavior and feelings, and related topics such as sexual orientation, by the neuroscientist Simon LeVay. The book was praised as a well-written work on science. However, some reviewers pointed out factual errors, and noted that LeVay failed to prove that homosexuality has a biological basis.

Homosexuality: Disease or Way of Life? is a 1956 book by the psychoanalyst Edmund Bergler, in which the author argues that homosexuality is a curable illness. Bergler denies that homosexuality is caused by hormonal or other biological factors, the Oedipus complex, or having a dominant mother and a weak or absent father, instead attributing both male and female homosexuality to pre-Oedipal factors involving an unsolved masochistic conflict with the mother during the earliest period of infancy. According to Bergler, homosexuality in men reflects unconscious fear and hatred of women. Bergler argues that there are several different types of homosexuality, each with a distinct clinical profile. Bergler rejects the existence of bisexuality, maintaining that all supposed bisexuals are homosexuals, and criticizes the work of sex researcher Alfred Kinsey. He characterizes homosexual men as sexually promiscuous, and argues that this promiscuity is a result of their unsatisfying sex lives and masochistic craving for danger. Bergler argues against immediately repealing laws against homosexuality, though he suggests that such laws could perhaps be repealed in the future if other measures against homosexuality proved effective. Bergler proposes the publicizing of his ideas as a measure against homosexuality.

<i>Sex and Reason</i> 1992 book by Richard Posner

Sex and Reason is a 1992 book about human sexuality by the economist and federal judge Richard Posner, in which the author attempts to explain sexual behavior in economic terms and discusses a range of controversial subjects related to sex, proposing reforms in American laws.

<i>What Wild Ecstasy</i> 1997 book by John Heidenry

What Wild Ecstasy: The Rise and Fall of the Sexual Revolution is a 1997 book about the sexual revolution by John Heidenry. The book received mixed reviews. It was described as interesting and Heidenry was complimented for his discussions of figures such as Bob Guccione, Hugh Hefner, Larry Flynt, and Reuben Sturman. However, he was criticized for his research methods. He was accused of plagiarism because of the use he made of material by other writers, receiving criticism in particular from the journalist Philip Nobile. Critics also wrote that he focused disproportionately on pornography and gave insufficient attention to feminism and women's issues.

<i>The Science of Desire</i> 1994 book by Dean Hamer

The Science of Desire: The Search for the Gay Gene and the Biology of Behavior is a 1994 book by the geneticist Dean Hamer and the journalist Peter Copeland, in which the authors discuss Hamer's research into the genetics of homosexuality.

References

  1. Burr 1996, pp. 3–4, 270.
  2. Burr 1996, pp. iii–iv.
  3. Burr 1996, p. iv.
  4. 1 2 Olson 1996, p. 1466.
  5. 1 2 Stuttaford 1996, p. 65.
  6. 1 2 Cytowic 1996, p. 9.
  7. 1 2 Kirsch 1996.
  8. 1 2 Ruse 1996, p. 14.
  9. 1 2 Anderson 1996, p. 481.
  10. 1 2 Vines 1996, p. 41.
  11. 1 2 Porter 1996.
  12. Turney 1997, p. 22.
  13. 1 2 Podhoretz 1996, p. 37.
  14. 1 2 Mass 1996, p. 14.
  15. Miller 1996, p. 18.
  16. McAuley 1996, p. 35.
  17. Haeberli 1998, p. 18.
  18. Moon 2006, p. 11.
  19. Good & Hafner 2000, p. 326.
  20. Greer 1999, p. 344.
  21. Zuk 2002, p. 218.
  22. 1 2 Murphy 1997, p. 238.
  23. 1 2 Stein 1999, pp. 166, 350.
  24. Berman 2003, p. 511.
  25. Burr 2015.

Bibliography

Books
Journals
  • Anderson, W. P. (1996). "A separate creation (Book Review)". Choice. 34.  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Cytowic, Richard E. (1996). "All in the genes". The Washington Post . Vol. 119, no. 271.
  • Good, Ron; Hafner, Mark (2000). "Scientific Understanding of Sexual Orientation: Implications for Science Education". The American Biology Teacher . 62 (5): 326–330. doi:10.2307/4450914. JSTOR   4450914.  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Haeberli, Eric (1998). "Hot Web site". The Advocate (768).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Mass, Lawrence D. (1996). "Born gay?". Lambda Book Report. 5 (1).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • McAuley, J. V. (1996). "Hunting homosexuality". The Advocate (709).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Miller, Stephen H. (1996). "Dissenting Voices". New York Native (692).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Moon, Tom (2006). "Is it Learned or Biological?". San Francisco Bay Times (August 10, 2006).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Olson, Ray (1996). "Upfront: Advance reviews". Booklist . 92 (17).
  • Podhoretz, Norman (1996). "How the Gay-Rights Movement Won". Commentary . 102.  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Ruse, Michael (1996). "Glad to be gay?". The Times Literary Supplement (4883).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Stuttaford, Genevieve (1996). "Forecasts: Nonfiction". Publishers Weekly . 243 (20).
  • Turney, Jon (1997). "Biology to sway the Vatican?". The Times Higher Education Supplement (1280).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Vines, Gail (1996). "Pride and prejudice". New Scientist . 151 (2038).  via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
Online articles