Alessandro Orsini | |
---|---|
![]() Orsini in 2013 | |
Born | Naples, Italy | 14 April 1975
Nationality | Italian |
Occupation(s) | Sociologist, writer |
Alessandro Orsini (born 14 April 1975) [1] is an Italian sociologist and scholar of terrorism who is an associate professor at LUISS University [2] and is best known in Italy for his controversial views over the Russian invasion of Ukraine. [3] [4]
Orsini was born in Naples, the son of Arturo Orsini, a Jungian psychologist who was later a professor of theory and techniques of personality testing and director of the School of Clinical Psychology at Sapienza University of Rome. When he was fifteen, his family moved to Latina, where he graduated from the Liceo Classico Dante Alighieri. [5] He earned a degree in sociology from Sapienza University followed by a doctorate from Roma Tre University. [1]
In November 2004, Orsini took up a position as a researcher at Libera Università Mediterranea. He had teaching duties, and in 2007 was disciplined by the university for absenteeism. Several well-known sociologists, and the Federation of Education Workers union, wrote to the university in Orsini's support. [6] [7] He was subsequently a researcher in the sociology of political phenomena at the University of Rome Tor Vergata, where from 2013 to 2016 he directed the Centre for Terrorism Studies, with a focus on Islamist terrorism in Europe. [1] His book on ISIS published by Rizzoli Libri won the Cimitile Prize for best work on a current-affairs topic in 2016. [8]
At LUISS University, Orsini is an associate professor and teaches general sociology and sociology of terrorism. From 2011 to 2022, he was also a research affiliate at the Center for International Studies at MIT, in the United States, where he was a Visiting Scholar at both the Department of Political Science and the Center for International Studies. [1] [9] [10] His research interests focus on "strategies for access to violent groups motivated by ideological hate". [1] He is the founder and director of LUISS University's Observatory on International Security and of the news website Sicurezza Internazionale. [1] [11] [12] He is a member of the scientific advisory board of the journal Studies in Conflict and Terrorism, of the Radicalisation Awareness Network of the Council of Europe, and of the "future scenarios" committee of the Stato maggiore della difesa of the Italian Armed Forces. [1]
From 2019 to 2022, Orsini was a columnist on Il Messaggero , writing articles on geopolitical and international issues. Following the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, he left Il Messaggero due to conflicts with the editor Massimo Martinelli. [13] He subsequently became a columnist for Il Fatto Quotidiano upon the invitation of the editor Marco Travaglio. [14]
Based on terrorists' biographies, Orsini has developed what he calls the DRIA model (disintegration, reconstruction, integration, alienation) to explain the process of radicalization. [15] [16] Orsini says this analysis applies to "vocational terrorists". [15] He defines these as people prepared to sacrifice their lives for a politico-religious ideology – an ideology that is marked by the belief that the world, as it is, is entirely corrupted ("radical catastrophism") and destined to be destroyed ("waiting for the end"), as well as an obsession with ridding the world of evil, the dehumanization of enemies, the relishing of martyrdom and persecution, and a belief that the end justifies the means. [15] [17] [18] According to Orsini, this activity answers an unmet spiritual need for meaning in terrorists' lives. [16]
The model comprises four stages: [16] [19]
In 2009, Orsini published a monograph on the motivations of those who joined the Red Brigade, a far-left group, from Rubbettino Editore ; it was originally submitted to il Mulino , Italy's premier publisher in social sciences, who rejected it. [21] Spencer M. Di Scala, a historian specialized in Italian socialism, prefaced the book. [21]
Orsini uses the Red Brigades as a case study for his view that political homicide, whether coming from the extreme left or from neo-Nazi groups, whether from non-state actors or from groups such as the Pol Pot regime that have taken over the state apparatus, is motivated by a messianic form of thinking. [22] [23] [24] Violent religious or political sects succeed in turning their members into terrorists only to the extent that they succeed in indoctrinating them into believing that the group has a spiritual mission to purify the world of corruption. [22] [23]
Upon publication, Richard Drake, a historian of contemporary Europe, Italian history, and terrorism, characterized Orsini's discussion of the background of the Red Brigades as a "tour de force of intellectual history" in its attempts to explain not only the history of Italian terrorism, but the source of terroristic thought as well. [25] Guido Panvini, a social historian focused on European history and political violence and terrorism, thought the wide range of historical parallels cited by Orsini, while offering many insights, might leave the reader somewhat disorientated but found the link Orsini had established between terrorist violence and the behaviour of right-wing radicals and totalitarian regimes particularly interesting. [24] The work went on to win the Acqui Award of History. [26]
Two years later, a translation was published by Cornell University Press. This received quite mixed reviews: while some highlighted its contribution to understanding terrorists' mindset, others criticized, in particular, a lack of historicism.
In the early 2010s, [40] Orsini embedded himself within two fascist militias for a span of three months to gain an auto-ethnographic perspective, later published as Sacrifice: My Life in a Fascist Militia. [41] R. J. B. Bosworth found the work to be an uncritical portrayal that was quite sympathetic towards fascists. [41] Christiane Olivo, specializing in the politics of social dissent in post-Communist East-Central Europe, was struck by Orsini's first-hand description of the rupture with the ambient "bourgeois ideology" of conflict-avoidance and self-preservation that resulted from the fascist groups' emphasis on the practice of combat sports like MMA, which instilled values of self-sacrifice and encouraged seeking out violent conflict (by brawling with far-left groups) as a valorous way of life. [42]
João Bernardo, a Portuguese historian of communism, capitalism, and fascism, stated that while the book "usefully" discusses the development of Bruno Rizzi's political stances from 1937 on, a topic that has been largely lacking in scholarship, he found the book to be "seriously wanting" by not including the broader debate of critical leftist thoughts on the Soviet Union beyond "Trotsky's views pertaining to the Stalinist USSR". By the omission of multiple other views from Italian political thinkers throughout Rizzi's lifetime and their impact on his thinking, the book creates a "Bruno Rizzi palatable to contemporary taste, expurgating everything of which neoliberals are not fond" and ultimately harms understanding of the individual being presented. [43]
Orsini had a rapid rise in popularity as a controversial talk-show guest during the Russian invasion of Ukraine, [44] [45] [46] [47] where he repeatedly expressed his criticism of NATO's expansionism towards Russia and the European Union's diplomatic failure, which he considers to be co-factors of the war in Ukraine. Papers like Corriere della Sera and Le Monde have described Orsini as spreading Russian war propaganda. [44] [48] LUISS University, fearing reputational harms, issued a statement in 2022 expressing its "full solidarity with the Ukrainian people". [48]
In March 2024, Orsini wrote an article in Il Fatto Quotidiano stating that Italian soldiers and vehicles were on duty at the Constanța base in Romania and that they were in imminent danger from a Ukrainian military defeat. [49] The Italian Ministry of Defence rejected the claims stating that Orsini's statements were "completely false. The Italian Air Force servicemen, who were part of the Task Force 'Gladiator' in Constanța, returned to Italy as early as 31 July 2023" adding that "Orsini is either in absolute bad faith or he is not even able to consult normal web sources". [50] [51]
Later on in 2023, Orsini endorsed a law proposed by the Meloni government prohibiting the creation of mosques in garages and sheds. He argued that the law was intended to encourage Muslims to gather in large mosques and thus to prevent isolation and radicalization. [52]