| Year | Program | Episode | Studios | Network |
|---|
2011 (39th) [1] [2] |
|---|
| The Simpsons | Gracie Films | Fox |
| Archer | FX Productions | FX |
| Green Lantern: The Animated Series | Warner Bros. Animation | Cartoon Network |
| Mad |
| Star Wars: The Clone Wars | Lucasfilm Animation, Ltd. |
| Hoops & Yoyo Ruin Christmas | Hallmark | CBS |
| Mary Shelley's Frankenhole | Season 2 | Starburns Industries, Inc. | Adult Swim |
| Prep & Landing: Naughty vs. Nice | Walt Disney Animation Studios | ABC |
2012 (40th) [3] |
|---|
| Robot Chicken DC Comics Special | Stoopid Buddy Stoodios | Adult Swim |
| Archer | "Space Race, Part 1" | Floyd County Productions and FX Productions for FX | FX |
| Bob's Burgers | "Ear-sy Rider" | 20th Century Fox TV | Fox |
| Motorcity | "Blond Thunder" | Disney Television Animation | Disney XD |
| Mad | "FrankenWinnie/ParaMorgan" | Warner Bros. Animation | Cartoon Network |
| South Park | "Raising the Bar" | Central Productions | Comedy Central |
2013 (41st) [4] |
|---|
| Futurama | The Curiosity Company in association with 20th Century Fox Television | Comedy Central |
| Archer | Floyd County Productions | FX |
| Bob's Burgers | Twentieth Century Fox Television | Fox |
| Tron: Uprising | Disney Television Animation | Disney XD |
| Motorcity | Titmouse, Inc. |
2014 (42nd) [5] |
|---|
| The Simpsons | Gracie Films in Association with 20th Century Fox Television | Fox |
| Archer | FX Productions | FX |
| Back to Backspace | Cartoon Network Studios | Cartoon Network |
| Regular Show |
| Bob's Burgers | 20th Century Fox Television | Fox |
| Mike Tyson Mysteries | Warner Bros. Animation | Adult Swim |
| Rick and Morty | Starburns Industries, Inc. |
2015 (43rd) [6] [7] |
|---|
| The Simpsons | "Halloween of Horror" | Gracie Films in association with 20th Century Fox Television | Fox |
| BoJack Horseman | "Brand New Couch" | The Tornante Company, ShadowMachine | Netflix |
| Bob's Burgers | "Can't Buy Me Math" | 20th Century Fox Television, Bento Box Entertainment | Fox |
| Moonbeam City | "Quest for Aquatica" | Titmouse, Inc., Comedy Central | Comedy Central |
2016 (44th) [8] [9] |
|---|
| Bob's Burgers | "Glued, Where's My Bob?" | Bento Box Entertainment | Fox |
| BoJack Horseman | "Fish Out of Water" | Tornante Productions, LLC for Netflix | Netflix |
| Long Live the Royals | "Punk Show" | Cartoon Network Studios | Cartoon Network |
| The Venture Bros. | "Hostile Makeover" | Titmouse, Inc. | Adult Swim |
| The Simpsons | "Barthood" | Gracie Films in Association with 20th Century Fox Television | Fox |
2017 (45th) [10] [11] |
|---|
| Rick and Morty | "Pickle Rick" | Williams Street | Adult Swim |
| Big Mouth | "Am I Gay?" | Netflix | Netflix |
| BoJack Horseman | "Stupid Piece of Sh*t" | Tornante Productions, LLC for Netflix |
| Robot Chicken | "Freshly Baked: The Robot Chicken Santa Claus Pot Cookie Freakout Special: Special Edition" | Stoopid Buddy Stoodios | Adult Swim |
| Samurai Jack | "XCIII" | Adult Swim |
2018 (46th) [12] [13] |
|---|
| BoJack Horseman | "The Dog Days are Over" | Tornante Productions, LLC for Netflix | Netflix |
| Bob's Burgers | "The Bleakening, Parts 1 and 2" | 20th Century FOX Television/Bento Box Entertainment | Fox |
| Big Mouth | "The Planned Parenthood Show" | Netflix | Netflix |
| Human Kind Of | "Desperately Seeking Social Skills" | Cartuna for Facebook Watch | Facebook Watch |
| The Venture Bros. | "The Saphrax Protocol" | Titmouse, Inc. for Adult Swim | Adult Swim |
2019 (47th) [14] [15] |
|---|
| BoJack Horseman | Tornante Productions, LLC for Netflix | Netflix |
| Harley Quinn | Warner Bros. Animation | DC Universe |
| Tuca & Bertie | Tornante Productions, LLC for Netflix | Netflix |
| Big Mouth | Netflix |
| Undone | Tornante Company and Amazon Studios | Amazon Prime Video |
|