Storylines
Books
A Feast for Crows and A Dance with Dragons
Arianne is dissatisfied with her father Doran Martell, believing him to be weak due to his inaction over the deaths of his sister Elia and brother Oberyn at the hands of House Lannister. She fears being replaced as his heir by her younger brother Quentyn Martell due to never having been trained for rule and due to a letter suggesting that Doran intends to name Quentyn heir. Doran has also imprisoned her cousins, the Sand Snakes, seemingly to placate the Iron Throne. To safeguard her birthright to Dorne, free her cousins and avenge her dead family members, Arianne plots to crown Myrcella Baratheon as queen of the Seven Kingdoms in opposition to the incumbent ruler (and Myrcella's younger brother) Tommen Baratheon. By Dornish law, Myrcella would have inherited the title over her brother.
Arianne seduces Arys Oakheart to win his support of Myrcella's claim. The plot is foiled and Myrcella is wounded in the kidnapping attempt. As Arianne confronts Doran after he foils her plans, her father reveals that he has been plotting revenge on Tywin Lannister for many years and was waiting for the perfect time to strike. Now aware of her father's plans and assured she is not being replaced as heir, Arianne reconciles with him.
The Winds of Winter
After the Golden Company invades Westeros, Doran sends Arianne to find out the truth about the claimant Aegon Targaryen.
Reception and analysis
Arianne Martell is the first introduced person of color to serve as a point of view character in A Song of Ice and Fire [1] and is along with Asha Greyjoy and Melisandre considered to be among the minor [lower-roman 1] female point of view characters in the books. [5] She is a popular character among readers [2] [6] and is regarded as one of the most compelling female characters in the series. [6] Arianne's struggle to subvert the patriarchal system of Westeros, both her struggle against her father and her plot to crown Myrcella as queen, [7] has made some readers consider the character a "feminist icon" [2] [3] and "one of Martin's most feminist characters". [8] While not the only woman in the series who feels ignored and overlooked because of her gender, Arianne is the only woman in A Song of Ice and Fire whose independence and authority are also supported by the culture surrounding her since she by Dornish custom is Doran's rightful heir. [9] Since Arianne's storyline explores how laws can be unfair, inconsistent and sexist, her storyline is one of several in the book series that question whether there is such a thing as a rightful ruler. [7]
Arianne is portrayed with a sense of empowerment and as cunning and highly intelligent. She also stands up to men around her who try to act as her superior. [6] Although Arianne is scheming, impulsive and flawed, she has a conscience and is also warm and likeable. [10] Ariana Quiñónes, writing for Hypable in 2015, considered Arianne to in many ways be "the most modern point of view character" in the books due to her "up and down" arc in A Feast for Crows, wherein she makes mistakes but also learns from them. Quiñónes interpreted Arianne's storyline in A Feast for Crows as a coming of age story focusing on female and familial relationships. [3]
Arianne is first presented in the chapter of fellow point of view character Arys Oakheart as a highly sexual person seemingly motivated by little else than sexual desire in Arys. Both Arys and another point of view character, Areo Hotah, make remarks on Arianne's body. [9] Arianne's only on-page sexual encounter is with Arys. [11] In Arianne's own chapters, her behavior towards Arys is revealed to be a role she plays, using her brains and sexuality as weapons; [3] [9] she has sex with Arys in order to convince him of her plot to crown Myrcella. [11] Her main concerns are not sexual but instead to make her plans work and to keep all of her friends and allies safe. Though she did seduce Arys as part of her plans, she also feels remorse for him after he is killed due to her schemes. [9] Arianne's highly sexualized portrayal in the chapters of Arys Oakheart (and to an extent Areo Hotah) strides close to racial tropes of darker-skinned characters being more sexual. Since Arianne is revealed to be more complex in her own chapters, this appears to be intended to reflect real-world stereotypes also being present in the fictional world (which Arianne exploits to her own advantage). [9]
Omission from Game of Thrones
The storyline and political situation in Dorne in the HBO television adaptation differs considerably from that of the books. [12] Among the most prominent alterations is that Arianne was entirely cut from the television series [1] [5] [12] [13] [8] despite being considered an essential character by George R. R. Martin. [14] Instead, Doran's youngest son in the books (Trystane Martell) was changed to be the heir to Dorne. [15] Some aspects of Arianne's character and storyline were transferred to Ellaria Sand, [8] [16] though Ellaria's altered characterization considerably changed her character from that in the books. [16]
The reason for omitting Arianne were never disclosed by the production team but commenters speculated that it mainly had to do with trimming down the storyline because of time constraints. [6] [8] [17] In the books, the storyline expands significantly in A Feast for Crows, introducing several new characters. The showrunners of Game of Thrones however felt that the series needed to stay focused on its already established cast in order to maintain the momentum of the storyline. Even before the fifth season of Game of Thrones (wherein the Dornish plot takes place) the many storylines and characters were also difficult to balance from practical and financial standpoints. [14] In addition to the altered Dornish storyline, Aegon Targaryen's invasion of the Seven Kingdoms, another storyline in which Arianne takes part, was completely omitted from Game of Thrones. [16] The television series had another opportunity to introduce Arianne in its final episode ("The Iron Throne"), wherein a new previously unseen Dornish ruler is featured, but instead made the new ruler of Dorne a man. [18]
As an important character in the Dornish storyline, Arianne's omission from the television adaptation was met with disappointment [6] [19] and some outrage [8] [20] [21] by readers of the book series and has been widely regarded as detrimental to the plot. [2] [3] [15] [22] [23] Her exclusion was also met with some surprise since she is one of the handful of strong and complex major female characters in the books. [20] Themes explored through Arianne in the books, such as female versus male inheritance rights, are on account her absence left largely unexplored in Game of Thrones. [12] Some commenters argued that the omission of Arianne was sexist since it resulted in the omission of a complex female character and her female-driven agenda [21] and replaced a storyline centered on Arianne, and involving multiple women, with a storyline focused on a man, Jaime Lannister, wherein female characters only served to hinder his redemption. [3]
