Aroup Chatterjee

Last updated

Aroup Chatterjee
Aroup Chatterjee.jpg
Chatterjee in 2013
Born (1958-06-23) 23 June 1958 (age 65)
Ballygunge, Calcutta, India
Nationality British
Occupation(s) Author, physician
SpouseZelpha Kittler
Children3

Aroup Chatterjee (born 23 June 1958) is a British Indian author and physician. [1] He was born in Calcutta, and moved to the United Kingdom in 1985. He is the author of the book Mother Teresa: The Untold Story (originally published as Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict), a work which challenges the widespread regard of Mother Teresa as a symbol of philanthropy and selflessness. [2]

Contents

Chatterjee's criticism inspired the documentary Hell's Angel that was shown on Channel 4, a British television channel. The documentary was written by a well-known critic of Mother Teresa, Christopher Hitchens, who co-produced it with journalist and filmmaker Tariq Ali. Chatterjee and Hitchens were the two Devil's advocates, or hostile witnesses to Catholic Church procedures for the beatification of Mother Teresa in 2003. [1]

Life and career

Chatterjee was born in 1958 [3] and raised in the city of Calcutta, West Bengal, India, before moving to the United Kingdom in 1985. In the 1970s and 1980s while studying at Calcutta Medical College he worked part-time for a left-wing political party campaigning against poverty and later worked at a hospital where he regularly treated patients from the oldest and poorest districts of the city as well as refugees from the civil war with what is now Bangladesh. [3] Later, while living in the UK, he became concerned by the increasingly common portrayal of the widespread destitution and disease in his native Calcutta which stemmed from press reporting of the work of Mother Teresa. At that point he describes his attitude to Mother Teresa as "If anything, I was positively inclined towards her" although he says he never saw any of her nuns in the slums. [4] However it was this image at odds with his own experience as a doctor in Calcutta that caused him to look more closely at her work and reputation.

I was mystified and perturbed. So I wanted to look into it ... still I thought she was a superb lady who was not faultless, but somehow, this image of Calcutta had permeated the world imagery. I thought it was probably a kind of offshoot or a corollary of her image and it was not her doing. [4]

From the 1990s onwards he began to uncover what he calls a "cult of suffering" [3] which Mother Teresa and her followers in the Missionaries of Charity were running back in Calcutta supported by her friend Pope John Paul II. [5] In February 1993, Chatterjee sent a proposal for a short documentary to Vanya Del Borgo, associate producer of Bandung Productions which was owned by Tariq Ali. [6] The proposal was passed to a Channel 4 commissioner who approved it, and Del Borgo with Chatterjee's proposal began work, approaching journalist and author Christopher Hitchens to write and present it. [6] The documentary became the 1994 film Hell's Angel. [7] Chatterjee found the documentary "too sensationalist" and Hitchens went on to write his book The Missionary Position. [8] Chatterjee spent the next year travelling and interviewing people who had worked closely with Mother Teresa and the Missionaries of Charity and began to campaign against the conditions in Nirmal Hriday, also known as the Kalighat Home for the Dying in Calcutta. [3] In particular he heard stories of lack of basic hygiene, [9] the absence of any pain medication [10] [11] and the frequent reuse of hypodermic needles. [3] Chatterjee then began work on a book, eventually released by Meteor Books in 2002 under the original title Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict. [12] Chatterjee says in addition to the hours of interviews, "I started in pre Internet days and I spent months in libraries in London. I also travelled the world researching it. I followed slum dwellers, beggars, destitute children with a video camera. I interviewed hundreds of people. I stood with video camera outside Teresa's home for hours." [13]

Following the publication of his book, Chatterjee continued to speak out against what he calls the "bogus and fantastic figure" of Mother Teresa, [14] acting as Devil's advocate in the process of her sainthood. He continues to work as a physician in London [13] where he lives with his Irish wife, who was raised as a Catholic, and their three children.[ citation needed ]

Mother Teresa: The Untold Story

In December 2002 independent publisher Meteor Books, owned by Bhagbat Chakraborty, published Chatterjee's book under the title Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict. [13] In 2016 the same book was reissued under a new title, Mother Teresa: The Untold Story by Fingerprint! publishers after being taken up by literary agent Kanishka Gupta. [13] The book covers her life and her rise to fame following the documentary Something Beautiful for God by Malcolm Muggeridge, the Calcutta home for the dying and the practices of running it, [14] the non-consensual death bed baptisms of Hindus and Muslims, [15] [16] the pathetic hygienic practices in the homes run by her, [17] her very limited connections with Kolkata and the masses [18] and the vast amount of financial donations given to the charity but not spent at Nirmal Hriday. [19] He covers her Nobel Peace Prize and the speech in which she claimed to have saved tens of thousands of destitute people; Chatterjee estimates in his book the real number was 700. [5] He also writes about the celebrities and the powerful people who had audiences with her, and the controversies surrounding the money she accepted from dictators such as Haitian president Jean-Claude Duvalier, convicted fraudster Charles Keating and disgraced publisher Robert Maxwell. [20] [17] The book looks at the worldwide reach of the Missionaries of Charity and examines the available evidence for her financial accounts [5] [21] along with her personal crusade against abortion and contraception. [14] He blames the West, especially the United States, for creating her benevolent image as a saviour in the backdrops of a ravaged subcontinent. [17] The final chapters address her death, funeral and beatification and Chatterjee's own involvement as an official Devil's advocate or hostile witness and the transcripts of the proceedings.[ citation needed ] Chatterjee sums up his view of Mother Teresa's life's work as:

Principally, she was a ... medieval ideologue – who taught that abortion had to be banned at any cost. And any means could serve to achieve that end. That was her. [6]

Critical reception

The self-published book has been praised for the content. Times Higher Education praised the book as necessary and well-documented, which could have been improved with editing. [18] The Irish Times praised the content and advocated for its wide dissemination in light of its seriousness but noted Chatterjee's personal agenda to have undermined its credibility. It criticized the book for suffering from glaring errors of syntax, missing words, repetitions et al. and for his often contradictory assertions. [22] A review by Tim Challies praised the extensive documentation in the book, consisting of multitude of examples, though noting the shoddy organizing, as a result of being self-published. [23] The far-left Socialist Review favourably received it as "a valuable contribution to unmasking the real Teresa". [24]

The Telegraph praised the 2016 reprint as a brutally honest and relentlessly scathing read which gives readers an impartial point of view. [25] A review in The Quint described it as a disconcerting book that had exhaustive details and consisted of laborious arguments though parts of it did appear to be inarticulate rants and failed to be objective. [17]

Devil's advocate

On the path to Mother Teresa's sainthood, a process Chatterjee has described as "a superstitious, black magic ceremony", [14] Chatterjee acted as one of two official Devil's advocates during the process of her beatification in 2003, the other being Christopher Hitchens. [26] In order to begin the requirements of beatification, the first step on the way to sainthood, the Catholic Church was required to announce a first miracle ascribed to Mother Teresa, which it did on 1 December 2002, the alleged miraculous cure of Monica Besra of a cyst caused by tuberculosis. [27] Chatterjee pointed out the cure was a result of medical treatment Besra received from superintendent of the Balurghat Hospital and not the placing of metal jewellery on her body.[ citation needed ] His position was also confirmed by her doctor Ranjan Mustafi, speaking of the nine months of drugs and treatment he provided: "I've said several times that she was cured by the treatment." [28] Initially both Besra [4] and her husband called the miracle "a hoax", [29] as did Prabir Ghosh from the Kolkata Humanist Association, who runs a programme raising awareness of holy men who dupe ordinary Indians into paying for supposed miracle cures. [27] During the process, the Catholic Church allows consultation with doubters where the miracle is contested. In his book, Chatterjee details his deposition to the committee, his correspondence with the official postulator Brian Kolodiejchuk, and the transcripts of his questions and answers. [30]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Canonization</span> Declaration that a deceased person is an officially recognized saint

Canonization is the declaration of a deceased person as an officially recognized saint, specifically, the official act of a Christian communion declaring a person worthy of public veneration and entering their name in the canon catalogue of saints, or authorized list of that communion's recognized saints.

The advocatus diaboli is a former official position within the Catholic Church, the Promoter of the Faith: one who "argued against the canonization (sainthood) of a candidate in to uncover any character flaws or misrepresentation of the evidence favoring canonization".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Missionaries of Charity</span> Roman Catholic religious order founded by Mother Teresa

The Missionaries of Charity is a Catholic centralised religious institute of consecrated life of Pontifical Right for women established in 1950 by Mother Teresa, now known in the Catholic Church as Saint Teresa of Calcutta. As of 2023, it consisted of 5,750 members religious sisters. Members of the order designate their affiliation using the order's initials, "M.C.". A member of the congregation must adhere to the vows of chastity, poverty, obedience, and the fourth vow, to give "wholehearted free service to the poorest of the poor." Today, the order consists of both contemplative and active branches in several countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mother Teresa</span> Albanian-Indian Catholic saint (1910–1997)

Mary Teresa Bojaxhiu MC, better known as Mother Teresa, was an Albanian-Indian Catholic nun and the founder of the Missionaries of Charity. Born in Skopje, then part of the Ottoman Empire, at the age of 18 she moved to Ireland and later to India, where she lived most of her life. On 4 September 2016, she was canonised by the Catholic Church as Saint Teresa of Calcutta. The anniversary of her death, 5 September, is her feast day.

<i>The Missionary Position: Mother Teresa in Theory and Practice</i> 1995 book by Christopher Hitchens

The Missionary Position: Mother Teresa in Theory and Practice is a book by the British-American journalist and polemicist Christopher Hitchens published in 1995. It is a critique of the work and philosophy of Mother Teresa, the founder of an international Roman Catholic religious congregation, and it challenges the mainstream media's assessment of her charitable efforts. The book's thesis, as summarized by one critic, was that "Mother Teresa is less interested in helping the poor than in using them as an indefatigable source of wretchedness on which to fuel the expansion of her fundamentalist Roman Catholic beliefs."

<i>Hells Angel</i> (TV programme) 1994 British film

Hell's Angel is a television documentary programme criticising Mother Teresa which premiered in the UK on Channel 4's Without Walls arts strand on 8 November 1994. It was hosted by Christopher Hitchens, directed by Jenny Morgan, and produced by journalist Tariq Ali. Hitchens and Ali co-wrote the programme's script. Hitchens originally titled the documentary Sacred Cow, but the film's backers instead chose Hell's Angel as the title.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lorenzo Ruiz</span> Filipino saint

Lorenzo Ruiz, also called Saint Lorenzo of Manila, is a Filipino saint venerated in the Catholic Church. A Chinese Filipino, he became his country's protomartyr after his execution in Japan by the Tokugawa Shogunate during its persecution of Japanese Christians in the 17th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Public image of Mother Teresa</span> Views about Mother Teresas charity work

Catholic nun and missionary Anjezë Gonxhe Bojaxhiu, commonly known as Mother Teresa and known as Saint Teresa of Calcutta since 2016, has a complicated public image. She has been widely admired by many for her charitable work, which lead to her being awarded the Nobel Peace Prize "for work undertaken in the struggle to overcome poverty and distress, which also constitutes a threat to peace". During her life she was highly celebrated, receiving multiple awards and honorary degrees, as well as consistently ranking as one of the world's most admired people. She is also venerated by many Catholics who consider her a saint and ask for her intercession.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kalighat Home for the Dying</span>

Kalighat, the Home of the Pure Heart is a hospice for the sick, destitute and the dying established by St. Mother Teresa in Kalighat, Kolkata, India. Before Mother Teresa sought permission to use it, the building was an old abandoned Hindu temple to the goddess Kali, the Hindu goddess of time and change. It was founded by St. Mother Teresa on her 42nd birthday in 1952, two years after she established Missionaries of Charity in Kolkata.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sanal Edamaruku</span> Indian rationalist (born 1955)

Sanal Edamaruku is an Indian author and rationalist. He is the founder-president and editor of Rationalist International, the president of the Indian Rationalist Association and the author of 25 books and other articles. In 2012, after examining an alleged miracle at a local church in Mumbai, he was charged under India's blasphemy law, causing him to voluntarily exile to Finland.

Canonization of Josemaría Escrivá de Balaguer discusses John Paul II's decision to canonize Josemaría Escrivá, founder of the Prelature of the Holy Cross and Opus Dei, more commonly known as Opus Dei.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teresa Demjanovich</span> Ruthenian Greek Catholic religious sister (1901–1927)

Miriam Teresa Demjanovich, SC was an American Ruthenian Greek Catholic Sister of Charity who was beatified by the Catholic Church in 2014. The beatification ceremony was the first to take place in the United States, being held in Newark, New Jersey.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Maria Bernarda Bütler</span> Franciscan missionary (1848–1924)

María Bernarda Bütler, born Verena Bütler, was a Swiss religious sister. She founded the Franciscan Missionary Sisters of Mary Help of Sinners and served in the missions in Ecuador and Colombia. Bütler worked for the care of the poor in these places until her exile from Ecuador and entrance into Colombia where she worked for the remainder of her life. The congregation moved there with her, and continued to expand during her time there until her death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beatification of Pope John Paul II</span>

Pope John Paul II reigned as pope of the Roman Catholic Church and sovereign of the Vatican City State for 26 years from October 1978 to his death, on 2 April 2005. Since his death, many thousands of people have been supporting the case for beatifying and canonising Pope John Paul II as a saint. His formal beatification ceremony took place on 1 May 2011.

Euphrasia Eluvathingal was an Indian Carmelite nun of the Syro-Malabar Church, which is an Eastern Catholic Church in Kerala. Euphrasia is said to have had a vision of the Holy Family, at which point the illness she had long felt ceased. She was canonised as a saint by Pope Francis on 23 November 2014 in Vatican City. Since the beheading of St. John the Baptist is celebrated on August 29, the feast of St. Euphrasia is postponed to August 30 .

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teofilo Camomot</span> Filipino archbishop and Venerable

Teofilo Bastida Camomot was a Roman Catholic Archbishop from the Philippines. Ordained a diocesan priest of the Archdiocese of Cebu on 14 December 1941, he was eventually appointed an auxiliary bishop on 23 March 1955 and receiving the titular see of Clysma. He became coadjutor archbishop of the Archdiocese of Cagayan de Oro on 10 June 1958, becoming titular archbishop of Marcianopolis. While waiting for then-archbishop James Hayes to retire, Camomot resigned for health reasons on 17 June 1970. He was killed in a vehicular accident in San Fernando on 27 September 1988 at the age of 74. A process was started which may lead to his canonization as a saint.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Assunta Marchetti</span> Italian Roman Catholic religious sister

Assunta Marchetti was an Italian Roman Catholic religious sister and the co-founder of the Missionary Sisters of Saint Charles Borromeo Scalabrinians; she worked in Brazil from 1895 until her death. She has been beatified as a Blessed Mother. Her priest brother Giuseppe is titled as Venerable on the path to sainthood.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Giuditta Vannini</span> Italian Roman Catholic nun

Giuditta Vannini – also known as Giuseppina – was an Italian Roman Catholic nun who became a Camillian. Together with Luigi Tezza she established the religious congregation known as the Daughters of Saint Camillus. She and her two siblings were orphaned as children and were placed in different homes; she was raised and educated in Rome under nuns where her vocation to the religious life was strengthened. Vannini later tried joining a religious order but was forced to leave during her novitiate period after suffering from ill health. She and Tezza met in 1891 and founded a religious congregation of which Vannini served as Superior General until her death while Tezza was exiled to Peru around 1900.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clelia Merloni</span> Italian nun

Clelia Merloni was an Italian Roman Catholic nun and the founder of the Apostles of the Sacred Heart of Jesus. Merloni was destined to follow her father into the business world but renounced his anti-religious sentiment and instead went down the religious path. Internal complications led to Merloni's fall from grace and she went into self-imposed exile where she received a dispensation to break from her religious vows. She later rejoined the congregation as a nun not long before her death.

<i>Something Beautiful for God</i>

Something Beautiful for God is a 1971 book by Malcolm Muggeridge on Mother Teresa. The book was based on a 1969 BBC documentary on Mother Teresa that Muggeridge had undertaken.

References

  1. 1 2 Crawley, William (26 August 2010). "Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict?". BBC. Retrieved 18 December 2015.
  2. ↑ Dutta, Krishna (16 May 2003). "Saint of the gutters with friends in high places". Times Higher Education . Retrieved 4 March 2011.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Schultz, Kai. "A Critic's Lonely Quest". The New York Times. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  4. 1 2 3 IANS. "Mother Teresa's sainthood deeply flawed". The Times of India. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  5. 1 2 3 Dutta, Krishna. "Saint of the gutters with friends in high places". Times Higher Education. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  6. 1 2 3 Gonzales, Hemley. "Chatterjee and Hemley discuss Mother Teresa". missionariesofcharity.wordpress.com. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  7. ↑ Mehta, Hemant. "Listen to Christopher Hitchens Eviscerate Mother Teresa's Legacy in This 1994 Documentary". Friendly Atheist. Patheos. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  8. ↑ Kinchin, David. "Book Review: An Unquenchable Thirst". Huntington News. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  9. ↑ Holznagel, Fritz. "Mother Teresa, the Saint of Calcutta?". Who2 Biographies. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  10. ↑ Gillett, George. "The West's big lie about Mother Teresa". The Salon. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  11. ↑ Bhaumik, Subir; Ganguly, Meenakshi. "Seeker of Souls". Time . Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  12. ↑ B, Sandeep. "Is canonising Mother Teresa Vatican's strategy to gain ground in India?". Firstpost.com. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  13. 1 2 3 4 NAW Staff. "NAW Interview with Aroup Chatterjee". New Asian Writing. Archived from the original on 10 November 2016. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  14. 1 2 3 4 Sherwood, Harriet. "Mother Teresa to become saint amid criticism over miracles and missionaries". The Guardian. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  15. ↑ AFP. "Mother Teresa's legacy under cloud as sainthood nears". Yahoo! News . Retrieved 7 November 2016.
  16. ↑ Stone, Michael. "Mother Teresa Brags About Coerced Deathbed Conversions". Progressive Secular Humanist. Patheos. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  17. 1 2 3 4 "Mother Teresa: How Saintly Was the 'Saint of the Gutters'?". The Quint. Retrieved 10 March 2019.
  18. 1 2 "Saint of the gutters with friends in high places". Times Higher Education. 16 May 2003. Retrieved 10 March 2019.
  19. ↑ Cooke, Bill (2004). "Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict" (PDF). Free Inquiry. 24 (6): 54–55. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  20. ↑ Campbell, Mícheál. "It's a sin". Socialist Review. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  21. ↑ Mathews Thomas, Prince. "Pointing Fingers At Mother Teresa's Heirs". Forbes. Retrieved 5 November 2016.
  22. ↑ "Under the microscope". The Irish Times. Retrieved 10 March 2019.
  23. ↑ Challies, Tim (16 August 2005). "Book Review - Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict". Tim Challies. Retrieved 10 March 2019.
  24. ↑ "It's a Sin". Socialist Review. Retrieved 10 March 2019.
  25. ↑ "The secret lives of saints". The Telegraph . Retrieved 10 March 2019.
  26. ↑ Crawley, William. "Will and Testament". BBC. Retrieved 7 November 2016.
  27. 1 2 Rohde, David. "Her Legacy: Acceptance And Doubts Of a Miracle". The New York Times. Retrieved 7 November 2016.
  28. ↑ Gowen, Annie. "The Vatican believes Mother Teresa cured this woman". Washington Post. Retrieved 7 November 2016.
  29. ↑ Orr, David. "Medicine cured 'miracle' woman – not Mother Teresa, say doctors". The Telegraph. Retrieved 7 November 2016.
  30. ↑ Chatterjee, Aroup (2016). Mother Teresa: The Untold Story. Fingerprint!. ISBN   978-8175993310.


This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.