| Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Venue / City | Off. MVP | Def. MVP |
|---|
| 1993 | Providence (1) | 1–0 | Connecticut | Glay Field • Providence, RI | Jen Mead, Providence |
| 1994 | St. John's (1) | 1–0 | Boston College | Morrone Stadium • Storrs, CT | Cristin Burtis, St. John's |
| 1995 | Notre Dame (1) | 1–0 | Connecticut | Owen T. Carroll Field • South Orange, NJ | Amy Van Lacke, Notre Dame |
| 1996 | Notre Dame(2) | 4–3 | Connecticut | Alumni Stadium • Notre Dame, IN | Cindy Daws, Notre Dame |
| 1997 | Notre Dame(3) | 6–1 | Connecticut | Yurcak Field • Piscataway, NJ | Anne Makinen, Notre Dame |
| 1998 | Notre Dame (4) | 1–0 | Connecticut | Morrone Stadium • Storrs, CT | Anne Makinen, Notre Dame |
| 1999 | Notre Dame(5) | 4–2 | Connecticut | Yurcak Field • Piscataway, NJ | Jenny Streiffer, Notre Dame |
| 2000 | Notre Dame(6) | 1–0 | Connecticut | Alumni Stadium • Notre Dame, IN | Mia Sarkesian, Notre Dame |
| 2001 | Notre Dame(7) | 2–1 | West Virginia | Yurcak Field • Piscataway, NJ | Amanda Guertin, Notre Dame |
| 2002 | Connecticut(1) | 1–0 | West Virginia | Morrone Stadium • Storrs, CT | Salla Ranta, UConn |
| 2003 | Villanova (1) | 1–1 (7–6 p) | Boston College | Yurcak Field • Piscataway, NJ | Beth Totman, Boston College | Laura Koch, Villanova |
| 2004 | Connecticut (2) | 2–1 | Notre Dame | Morrone Stadium • Storrs, CT | Kristen Gracyk, UConn | Zahra Jalalian, UConn |
| 2005 | Notre Dame(8) | 5–0 | Connecticut | Valley Fields • Milwaukee, WI | Katie Thorlakson, Notre Dame | Jill Krivacek, Notre Dame |
| 2006 | Notre Dame(9) | 4–2 | Rutgers | Morrone Stadium • Storrs, CT | Kerri Hanks, Notre Dame | Kim Lorenzen, Notre Dame |
| 2007 | West Virginia (1) | 1–1 (5–3 p) | Notre Dame | Dick Dlesk Stadium • Morgantown, WV | Kim Bonilla, West Virginia | Carolyn Blank, West Virginia |
| 2008 | Notre Dame(10) | 1–0 ( a.e.t. ) | Connecticut | Alumni Stadium • Notre Dame, IN | Melissa Henderson, Notre Dame | Carrie Dew, Notre Dame |
| 2009 | Notre Dame(11) | 2–1 | Marquette | Morrone Stadium • Storrs, CT | Lauren Folkes, Notre Dame | Jessica Schuveiller, Notre Dame |
| 2010 | West Virginia (2) | 1–0 | South Florida | Yurcak Field • Piscataway, NJ | Meghan Lewis, West Virginia | Kerri Butler, West Virginia |
| 2011 | West Virginia(3) | 2–0 | Louisville | Dick Dlesk Stadium • Morgantown, WV | Blake Miller, West Virginia | Bry McCarthy, West Virginia |
| 2012 | Marquette (1) | 1–0 | Georgetown | Rentschler Field • East Hartford, CT | Taylor Madigan, Marquette | Ally Miller, Marquette |
| 2013 | Marquette(2) | 2–0 | DePaul | Valley Fields • Milwaukee, WI | Mary Luba, Marquette | Emily Jacobson, Marquette |
| 2014 | DePaul(1) | 2–0 | Georgetown | Belson Stadium • Queens, NY | Amber Paul, DePaul | Sarah Gorden, DePaul |
| 2015 | Butler (1) | 1–0 | Providence | Morrison Stadium • Omaha, NE | Catherine Zimmerman, Providence | Randi DeLong, Butler |
| 2016 | Georgetown (1) | 2–0 | Marquette | Shaw Field • Washington, D.C. | Grace Damaska, Georgetown | Marian Paul, Georgetown |
| 2017 | Georgetown(2) | 3–0 | Butler | Campus Sites [n 1] | Rachel Corboz, Georgetown | Elizabeth Wenger, Georgetown |
| 2018 | Georgetown(3) | 1–0 | Butler | Campus Sites [n 1] | Caitlin Farrell, Georgetown | Kelly Ann Livingstone, Georgetown |
| 2019 | Xavier (1) | 2–0 | Georgetown | Morrison Stadium • Omaha, NE [n 2] | Brooke Sroka, Xavier | Grace Bahr, Xavier |
| 2021 (Spring) | Georgetown(4) | 2–1 ( a.e.t. ) | Butler | Chapey Field • Providence, RI | Jenna Menta, Georgetown | Julia Leas, Georgetown |
| 2021 | Georgetown (5) | 1–0 | St. John's | Corcoran Field • Cincinnati, OH [n 2] | Sydney Cummings, Georgetown | Julia Leas, Georgetown |
| 2022 | Georgetown(5) | 1–0 | Xavier | Maryland SoccerPlex • Boyds, MD [n 2] | Tatum Lenain, Georgetown | Julia Leas, Georgetown |
| 2023 | Georgetown(6) | 2–0 | Xavier | Allie Winstanley, Georgetown | Brianne Riley, Georgetown |
| 2024 | Connecticut (3) | 2–1 ( a.e.t. ) | Xavier | Lucy Cappadona, Connecticut | Chioma Okafor, Connecticut |
