Biotic Ligand Model

Last updated

The Biotic Ligand Model (BLM) is a tool used in aquatic toxicology that examines the bioavailability of metals in the aquatic environment and the affinity of these metals to accumulate on gill surfaces of organisms. BLM depends on the site-specific water quality including such parameters as pH, hardness, and dissolved organic carbon. In this model, lethal accumulation values (accumulation of metal on the gill surface, in the case of fish, that cause mortality in 50% of the population) are used to be predictive of lethal concentration values that are more universal for aquatic toxicology and the development of standards. [1] Collection of water chemistry parameters for a given site, incorporation of the data into the BLM computer model and analysis of the output data is used to accomplish BLM analysis. [2] Comparison of these values derived from the model, have repeatedly been found to be comparable to the results of lethal tissue concentrations from acute toxicity tests. [3] The BLM was developed from the gill surface interaction model (GSIM) and the free ion activity model (FIAM). [2] Both of these models also address how metals interact with organisms and aquatic environments. [4] Currently, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) uses the BLM as a tool to outline Ambient Water Quality Criteria (AWQC) for surface water. [5] [6] Because BLM is so useful for investigation of metals in surface water, there are developmental plans to expand BLM for use in marine and estuarine environments.

Contents

History

Current knowledge of how specific water quality parameters alter the toxicity of metals to aquatic life is still growing. [2]

In 1973, Zitko et al. provided evidence that the free metal ion played a stronger role in determining toxicity than did the metals overall concentration. [2] Shortly after, in 1976, Zitko et al. established that Ca2+ and Mg2+ (hardness cations) were in competition with metal ions at the binding sites of the metals. [2]

This competition at the binding site resulted in lower toxicity of metals as the hardness of the water they were in increased. Pagenkopf et al. used a chemical equilibrium model to explain how water chemistry will control which form of a metal is present and how that was related to the metal's toxicity. [2] [4] Both of these findings helped establish that metal toxicity and availability is directly related to the free ion activity of the metal. [2]

This led to the development of what is now called the free-ion activity model (FIAM). [7] [2] The FIAM describes effects of metals based on metal speciation and their subsequent interactions with organisms. [2] The free ion activity model was created to explain original observations about behaviors of metals in aquatic organisms and to examine the “universal importance of free metal ion activities in determining the uptake, nutrition and toxicity cationic trace metals”. [8]

It is now known that aqueous concentrations of metals are poor predictors of the bioavailability of a particular metal. [9] Further, as the biotic ligand model addresses, the binding of trace metal to a site is not only dependent on the concentration of the metal in question. [8]

Parent et al. describe cell surface interactions according to the FIAM by saying that the biological response that is elicited is the result of the concentration of cell surface complexes, either metal or metal ligand. [9] The original FIAM did not address other roles that ligands play besides complexing metals and how these other roles could affect the biological response of an organism. [9]

Around the same time that the free ion activity model was proposed, the gill surface interaction model (GSIM) was introduced by Pagenkopf in 1983. [2] The model was put into use in order to evaluate toxicity test results of metals as well as metals in mixtures. [2]

Pagennkopf outlined that the compilation of previous studies on metals necessitated further examination of how metal toxicity changes as a function of pH, hardness and complexation capacity for the toxicity of metals to fishes. [4]

In the gill surface interaction model both metal hardness and complexation are included. Pagenkopf lays out several major concepts that are the basis of the GSIM. [4]

  1. Trace metals alter gill function in fish (acutely) and the fish die as a result of respiratory failure.
  2. Some trace metal species are significantly more toxic than others.
  3. Gill surfaces can form complexes with the metal species and hydrogen ions that are present in the water.
  4. Metal exchange between the gills and test waters are fast when compared to the time needed to perform a bioassay.
  5. Gill surfaces have a determinate interaction capacity per unit weight.
  6. Competitive inhibition occurs between the calcium and magnesium and the toxicants which include trace-metals and hydrogen ions .

Using these six concepts Pagenkopf looked at copper, zinc, cadmium, lead, combinations of metals, and hydrogen ion concentration using effective toxicant concentration. Per the results Pagenkopf assessed the applicability of the model and came up with several steps to using the GSIM. The required data are pH, alkalinity, hardness and total trace-metal content of a water sample. Once these parameters are obtained, the next step is to calculate the speciation of the metals in the water sample. Then look at the competitive interaction factor (CIF) and the effective toxicant concentration (ETC) of the metals—then effective toxicant concentration is compared to laboratory observations. The limitations of the FIAM and GSIM were important in the genesis of the BLM and both the FIAM and the GSIM led to the development of the biotic ligand model. [2]

Quantitative Information

The BLM is used to predict the lethal accumulation (LA50) of metals on the gill surface that results in mortality of 50% of the exposed individuals. [3] [10] Accumulation of metals on the gill surface is dependent on the specific area's water quality as the metal's bioavailability for binding with the ligand will be determined by what's in the water that the metal is likely to complex to other than the ligand on the gill surface of the fish. [3] There are ten major inputs of water quality that the EPA recommends should be put into the Biotic Ligand Model to produce an estimation of the area's water quality. Two additional inputs (percent humic acid and sulfide) may also be used in some cases, though the EPA has cautioned against their extensive use due to their minimal effect and inconsistent reporting in scientific documents. [5] Temperature of the water is one factor for consideration in the BLM, though it's been found to have a lesser effect than some of the other parameters. With respect to BLM, pH can have a large effect on the metal's ability to bind to the biotic ligand. Higher pH will decrease the metal's toxicity as the metal (in the case of copper) will complex more readily with carbonate and other organics that are dissolved in the water. [3] With increasing pH, fewer protons are available to compete for a spot on the biotic ligand, so looking at this factor alone, it would seem that increasing pH would increase the metal's toxicity as it would have less competition for a binding site. However, the complexation effect that increasing pH has on the metal makes it less bioavailable for binding to the biotic ligand. [10] Dissolved Organic Carbon (DOC) is another important factor among the BLM inputs. Increasing dissolved organic carbon decreases the metal's toxicity as the metal will bind with the dissolved organic carbon, making it less bioavailable for uptake by the biotic ligand. [10] The major cations that have been found to have a significant impact on BLM are Ca2+, Mg2+, Na+ and K+. Major anions, including SO4− and Cl− also may be responsible for changing the metal's binding affinity for the biotic ligand. Alkalinity has a lesser effect on the BLM partitioning coefficients than do DOC and pH. Partitioning coefficients are used to determine the binding affinity of the metal to the biotic ligand. These coefficients are produced by the BLM following input from the above parameters.

Limitations/Uncertainty

The Biotic Ligand model has several limitations and uncertainties. These uncertainties are important to address when utilizing the BLM for management of water resources. Water quality standards are based on total or dissolved metal concentrations. Water quality criteria [11] are often derived using extrapolations from lab tests and data. Data is derived from lab tests using standardized laboratory methods and is generally not representative of the dynamic environmental conditions experienced in the field over a broad range of species.

Types of Biotic Ligand Models

EPA's Biotic Ligand Model and Water Quality Criteria

Section 304(a)(1) of the Clean Water Act (CWA) requires that “the Administrator,” or Administrator of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, develop a water quality criteria that is based on current scientific information and judgment, data, contaminant concentrations, and the protection of human health and the environment. [12] [11] Water quality criteria are one of the goals of the EPA's Water Quality Standards (WQS) under the CWA. WQS are set by each state and determine the quality of specific water bodies based on its designated use, WQC, and anti-degradation policies. [13] As of 2007 the EPA accepts use of BLM to help produce site specific freshwater WQC values for copper. [14] The inputs for this model are: temperature, aquatic cations (Ca2+, Mg2+, Na+, and K+), aquatic anions (Cl− and SO42−), sulfide, pH, alkalinity, and DOC. The EPA has a working version of their BLM on their website.

HydroQual/Windward BLM

The BLM was originally developed by researchers at HydroQual Inc. [10] [15] The BLM software (up to version 2.2.3) was available at the HydroQual website for zinc, copper, lead, silver, and cadmium for aquatic freshwater systems only, although marine models were in the works. [16] The HydroQual team also developed the BLM software distributed by US EPA. HydroQual was a privately owned science, research, and engineering company founded in 1980. In 2010, HydroQual was purchased by HDR Inc [17] and the HydroQual website, including the BLM pages, have been retired. The research team at HydroQual that worked on the BLM have moved to Windward Environmental [18] where a new BLM website is maintained. [19]

Current and Future Studies

Currently, the EPA recognizes the use of the BLM in the identification and cleanup of copper. This is because of the extensive characterization and testing performed using copper to predict toxic outcomes of metal exposure in various environmental conditions (pH, DOC, temperature, etc.) . Another version of the BLM is underway by HydroQual who is in the processes of developing the TBLM with Copper and Nickel for predicting metal effects in soil. [16] The future characterization of metals for the BLM like Ag, Zn, Pb, Al, Ni, and Cd on aquatic systems and organisms will help develop the BLM for a broader range of metals for which it can be certain to predict and assess potential impacts. The BLM is limited as it is only a predictive tool, but it has useful applications in aquatic toxicology.

Related Research Articles

Nitrate Type of ion, commonly found in explosives and fertilisers

Nitrate is a polyatomic ion with the chemical formula NO−
3. Salts containing this ion are called nitrates. Nitrates are common components of fertilizers and explosives. Almost all inorganic nitrates are soluble in water. An example of an insoluble nitrate is bismuth oxynitrate.

Chronic toxicity, the development of adverse effects as a result of long term exposure to a contaminant or other stressor, is an important aspect of aquatic toxicology. Adverse effects associated with chronic toxicity can be directly lethal but are more commonly sublethal, including changes in growth, reproduction, or behavior. Chronic toxicity is in contrast to acute toxicity, which occurs over a shorter period of time to higher concentrations. Various toxicity tests can be performed to assess the chronic toxicity of different contaminants, and usually last at least 10% of an organism's lifespan. Results of aquatic chronic toxicity tests can be used to determine water quality guidelines and regulations for protection of aquatic organisms.

Water pollution Contamination of water bodies

Water pollution is the contamination of water bodies, usually as a result of human activities, so that it negatively affects its uses. Water bodies include lakes, rivers, oceans, aquifers, reservoirs and groundwater. Water pollution results when contaminants are introduced into these water bodies. Water pollution can be attributed to one of four sources: sewage discharges, industrial activities, agricultural activities, and urban runoff including stormwater. It can be grouped into surface water pollution or groundwater pollution. For example, releasing inadequately treated wastewater into natural waters can lead to degradation of these aquatic ecosystems. Water pollution can also lead to water-borne diseases for people using polluted water for drinking, bathing, washing or irrigation. Water pollution reduces the ability of the body of water to provide the ecosystem services that it would otherwise provide.

Aquatic toxicology

Aquatic toxicology is the study of the effects of manufactured chemicals and other anthropogenic and natural materials and activities on aquatic organisms at various levels of organization, from subcellular through individual organisms to communities and ecosystems. Aquatic toxicology is a multidisciplinary field which integrates toxicology, aquatic ecology and aquatic chemistry.

Industrial wastewater treatment Processes used for treating wastewater that is produced by industries as an undesirable by-product

Industrial wastewater treatment describes the processes used for treating wastewater that is produced by industries as an undesirable by-product. After treatment, the treated industrial wastewater may be reused or released to a sanitary sewer or to a surface water in the environment. Some industrial facilities generate wastewater that can be treated in sewage treatment plants. Most industrial processes, such as petroleum refineries, chemical and petrochemical plants have their own specialized facilities to treat their wastewaters so that the pollutant concentrations in the treated wastewater comply with the regulations regarding disposal of wastewaters into sewers or into rivers, lakes or oceans. This applies to industries that generate wastewater with high concentrations of organic matter, toxic pollutants or nutrients such as ammonia. Some industries install a pre-treatment system to remove some pollutants, and then discharge the partially treated wastewater to the municipal sewer system.

Bioindicator Indicator species that can be used to reveal the qualitative status of an environment

A bioindicator is any species or group of species whose function, population, or status can reveal the qualitative status of the environment. The most common indicator species are animals. For example, copepods and other small water crustaceans that are present in many water bodies can be monitored for changes that may indicate a problem within their ecosystem. Bioindicators can tell us about the cumulative effects of different pollutants in the ecosystem and about how long a problem may have been present, which physical and chemical testing cannot.

Aquatic biomonitoring

Aquatic biomonitoring is the science of inferring the ecological condition of rivers, lakes, streams, and wetlands by examining the organisms that live there. While aquatic biomonitoring is the most common form of biomonitoring, any ecosystem can be studied in this manner.

Environmental toxicology

Environmental toxicology is a multidisciplinary field of science concerned with the study of the harmful effects of various chemical, biological and physical agents on living organisms. Ecotoxicology is a subdiscipline of environmental toxicology concerned with studying the harmful effects of toxicants at the population and ecosystem levels.

Copper toxicity Type of metal poisoning

Copper toxicity is a type of metal poisoning caused by an excess of copper in the body. Copperiedus can occur from eating acidic foods cooked in uncoated copper cookware, an IUD, or from exposure to excess copper in drinking water and other environmental sources, or the genetic condition Wilson's disease.

Freshwater environmental quality parameters

Freshwater environmental quality parameters are those chemical, physical or biological parameters that can be used to characterise a freshwater body. Because almost all water bodies are dynamic in their composition, the relevant quality parameters are typically expressed as a range of expected concentrations.

Tissue residue is the concentration of a chemical or compound in an organism's tissue or in a portion of an organism's tissue. Tissue residue is used in aquatic toxicology to help determine the fate of chemicals in aquatic systems, bioaccumulation of a substance, or bioavailability of a substance, account for multiple routes of exposure, and address an organism's exposure to chemical mixtures. A tissue residue approach to toxicity testing is considered a more direct and less variable measure of chemical exposure and is less dependent on external environmental factors than measuring the concentration of a chemical in the exposure media.

Pre-spawn mortality is a phenomenon where adult coho salmon, Oncorhynchus kisutch, die before spawning when returning to freshwater streams to spawn. It is also known as Urban Runoff Mortality Syndrome in more recent studies. This occurrence has been observed in much of the Puget Sound region of the Pacific Northwest. During fall migration, salmonids pass through urban watersheds which are contaminated with stormwater runoff. As the coho salmon pass through these waters, many will show symptoms of lethargy, loss of equilibrium and disorientation, and die within a few hours of showing these symptoms. These symptoms and behaviors are prevalent after rain events. Mortality often occurs before salmon have the opportunity to spawn, which is determined by cutting open female carcasses and observing for unfertilized eggs. Rates of pre-spawn mortality could impact the local salmon populations. Based on model projections, if rates continue, populations of coho salmon could become extinct within the next few decades.

The olfactory system is the system related to the sense of smell (olfaction). Many fish activities are dependent on olfaction, such as: mating, discriminating kin, avoiding predators, locating food, contaminant avoidance, imprinting and homing. These activities are referred to as “olfactory-mediated.” Impairment of the olfactory system threatens survival and has been used as an ecologically relevant sub-lethal toxicological endpoint for fish within studies. Olfactory information is received by sensory neurons, like the olfactory nerve, that are in a covered cavity separated from the aquatic environment by mucus. Since they are in almost direct contact with the surrounding environment, these neurons are vulnerable to environmental changes. Fish can detect natural chemical cues in aquatic environments at concentrations as low as parts per billion (ppb) or parts per trillion (ppt).

Simultaneously extracted metals/Acid-volatile sulfide (SEM-AVS) is an approach used in the field of aquatic toxicology to assess the potential for metal ions found in sediment to cause toxic effects in organisms dwelling in the sediment. In this approach, the amounts of several heavy metals in a sediment sample are measured in a laboratory; at the same time, the amount of acid-volatile sulfide is determined. Based on the chemical interactions between heavy metals (SEM) and acid-volatile sulfide (AVS), the concentrations of these two components can be used to assess the potential for toxicity to sediment-dwelling organisms.

Equilibrium partitioning Sediment Benchmarks (ESBs) are a type of Sediment Quality Guideline (SQG) derived by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for the protection of benthic organisms. ESBs are based on the bioavailable concentration of contaminants in sediments rather than the dry-weight concentration. It has been demonstrated that sediment concentrations on a dry-weight basis often do not predict biological effects. Interstitial water concentrations, however, predict biological effects much better. This is true because the chemical present in the interstitial water is the uncomplexed/free phase of the chemical that is bioavailable and toxic to benthic organisms. Other phases of the chemical are bound to sediment particles like organic carbon (OC) or acid volatile sulfides (AVS) and are not bioavailable. Thus the interstitial water concentration is important to consider for effects to benthic organisms.

Bioavailability, in environmental and soil sciences, represents the amount of an element or compound that is accessible to an organism for uptake or adsorption across its cellular membrane. In environmental and agricultural applications, bioavailability most often refers to availability of contaminants, such as organic pollutants or heavy metals, in soil systems and is also used frequently in determining potential risk of land application of sewage sludge or other inorganic/organic waste materials.

Toxicological databases are large compilations of data derived from aquatic and environmental toxicity studies. Data is aggregated from a large number of individual studies in which toxic effects upon aquatic and terrestrial organisms have been determined for different chemicals. These databases are then used by toxicologists, chemists, regulatory agencies and scientists to investigate and predict the likelihood that an organic or inorganic chemical will cause an adverse effect on exposed organisms.

The stabilized liquid membrane device (SLMD) is a passive, integrative sampler that provides an alternative or complementary approach to the conventional water sampling of aqueous metals. The simple device is composed of nonporous low-density plastic lay-flat tubing, which is filled with a chemical mixture containing a chelating agent and a long chain organic acid. The water-insoluble chelating agent-organic acid mixture diffuses in a controlled manner to the exterior surface of the sampler membrane and binds to environmental metals. In practice, the SLMD provides for continuous sequestration of bioavailable forms of trace metals, such as, cadmium (Cd), cobalt (Co), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), and zinc (Zn). The SLMD can also be utilized for in-laboratory preconcentration and speciation of bioavailable trace metals from grab water samples.

In 2015, 251 million tubes of toothpaste were sold in the United States. A single tube holds roughly 170 grams of toothpaste, so approximately 43 kilotonnes of toothpaste get washed into the water systems annually. Toothpaste contains silver nanoparticles, also known as nanosilver or AgNPs, among other compounds.

Stabilized liquid membrane devices

A stabilized liquid membrane device or SLMD is a type of passive sampling device which allows for the in situ, integrative collection of waterborne, labile ionic metal contaminants. By capturing and sequestering metal ions onto its surface continuously over a period of days to weeks, an SLMD can provide an integrative measurement of bioavailable toxic metal ions present in the aqueous environment. As such, they have been used in conjunction with other passive samplers in ecological field studies.

References

  1. ↑ Niogi, S; Wood, C.M. (2004). "Biotic Ligand Model, a Flexible Tool for Developing Sit-Specific Water Quality Guidelines for Metals". Environmental Science and Technology. 38 (23): 6177–6192. Bibcode:2004EnST...38.6177N. doi:10.1021/es0496524. PMID   15597870.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Paquin, P.R.; Gorsuch, J.W.; Apte, S.; Batley, G.E.; Bowles, K.C.; Campbell, P.G.C.; Delos, C.G.; Di Toro, D.M.; Dwyer, R.L.; Galvez, F.; Gensemer, R.W.; Goss, G.G.; Hogstrand, C.; Janssen, C.R.; McGeer, J.C.; Naddy, R.B.; Playle, R.C.; Santore, R.C.; Schneider, U.; Stubblefield, W.A.; Wood, C.M.; Wu, K.B. (2002). "The biotic ligand model: a historical overview". Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology C. 133 (1–2): 3–35. doi:10.1016/S1532-0456(02)00112-6. PMID   12428632.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Arnold, W.R.; Santore, R.C.; Cotsifas, J.S. (2005). "Predicting copper toxicity in estuarine and marine waters using the Biotic Ligand Model". Marine Pollution Bulletin. 50 (12): 1634–1640. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2005.06.035. PMID   16040053.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Pagenkopf, G.K. (1983). "Gill Surface Interaction Model for Trace-Metal Toxicity to Fishes: Role of Complexation, pH and Water Hardness". Environmental Science and Technology. 17 (6): 342–347. Bibcode:1983EnST...17..342P. doi:10.1021/es00112a007.
  5. 1 2 Jarvis, C.M.; Wisniewski, L. (2006). "An Introduction to the Biotic Ligand Model". Environmental Protection Agency Presentation.
  6. ↑ Wisniewski, Lauren; Jarvis, Christina (May 10, 2006). "Monitoring Implications of Using the Copper Biotic Ligand Model (BLM) and EPA's Update of Ambient Water Quality Criteria for Copper" (PDF). Advisory Committee on Water Information. U.S. Environmental Protection AgencyOffice of Water, Office of Science & TechnologyStandards & Health Protection Division. Retrieved 21 February 2020.
  7. ↑ Campbell, Peter G. C. (1996). "Interactions Between Trace Metals and Aquatic Organisms: A Critique of the Free Ion Activity Model". Metal Speciation and Bioavailability in Aquatic Systems. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. pp. 45–102. Retrieved 20 February 2020.
  8. 1 2 Brown, P.L.; Markich, S.J. (2000). "Evaluation of the free ion activity model of metal-organism interaction: extension of the conceptual model". Aquatic Toxicology. 51 (2): 177–194. doi:10.1016/s0166-445x(00)00115-6. PMID   11064123.
  9. 1 2 3 Parent, L; Twiss, R.M.; Campbell, P.G.C. (1996). "Influences of Natural Dissolved Organic Matter on the Interaction of Aluminum with the Microalga Chlorella: A Test of the Free-Ion Activity Model of Trace Metal Toxicity". Environmental Science and Technology. 30 (5): 1713–1720. doi:10.1021/es950718s.
  10. 1 2 3 4 Di Toro, D.M.; Allen, H.E.; Bergman, H.L.; Meyer, J.S.; Paquin, P.R.; Santore, R.C. (2001). "Biotic Ligand Model of the Acute Toxicity of Metals. I. Technical Basis". Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry. 20 (10): 2383–2396. doi:10.1002/etc.5620201034. PMID   11596774. S2CID   4831166.
  11. 1 2 Environmental Protection Agency. "Water Quality Criteria" . Retrieved 2012-05-28.
  12. ↑ Environmental Protection Agency. "Clean Water Act. Section 3" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2012-07-18. Retrieved 2012-05-28.
  13. ↑ Environmental Protection Agency. "Water Quality Standards Factsheet" (PDF). Retrieved 2012-05-28.
  14. ↑ Environmental Protection Agency (2012). "BLM and Copper" . Retrieved 2012-05-28.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  15. ↑ Santore, R. C.; Di Toro, D. M.; Paquin, P. R.; Allen, H. E.; Meyer, J. S. (2001-10-01). "Biotic ligand model of the acute toxicity of metals. 2. Application to acute copper toxicity in freshwater fish and Daphnia". Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry. 20 (10): 2397–2402. doi:10.1002/etc.5620201035. ISSN   0730-7268. PMID   11596775. S2CID   21915517.
  16. 1 2 Santore, R.C. "BLM - Biotic Ligand Model". Water Resources Engineering. Archived from the original on 2013-11-21. Retrieved 2012-05-31.
  17. ↑ "HDR acquires HydroQual Inc. and Amnis Engineering | civil + structural ENGINEER". cenews.com. Retrieved 2016-09-13.
  18. ↑ "Windward Announcement" (PDF).
  19. ↑ "Biotic Ligand Model". Windward Environmental. Retrieved 20 February 2020.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.