Butler English

Last updated

Butler English
Bearer English
Kitchen English
Region Madras, India
Era Madras Presidency through 20th century
Language codes
ISO 639-3 None (mis)
Glottolog butl1235

Butler English, also known as Bearer English or Kitchen English, is a dialect of English that first developed as an occupational dialect in the years of the Madras Presidency in India, but that has developed over time and is now associated mainly with social class rather than occupation. [1] It is still spoken in major metropolitan cities.

Contents

The name derives from its origins with butlers, the head servants of British colonial households, and is the English that they used to communicate with their masters.

Butler English persisted into the second half of the 20th century, beyond the independence of India, and was subject to southern influence in its phonology, in particular the substitution of [je] for [e] and [wo] for [o], leading to distinctive pronunciations of words such as "exit" and "only".

Examples

The following is an example of Butler English as given by writers Priya Hosali and J. Aitchinson:

One master call for come India ... eh England. I say not coming. That master very liking me. I not come. That is like for India that hot and cold. That England for very cold.

Another example, now famous amongst Indian English linguists, is the one given by Hugo Schuchardt, in which a nurse (ayah) describes the butler's practice of secretly taking small amounts of milk for himself from his master's household:

Butler's yevery day taking one ollock for own-self, and giving servants all half half ollock; when I telling that shame for him, he is telling, Master's strictly order all servants for the little milk give it what can I say ma'am, I poor ayah woman?

Features

Structurally, Butler English is akin to a pidgin, with a subject–verb–object word order, deletion of verb inflections, and deletion of prepositions. It has been called a "marginal pidgin" and a "rudimentary pidgin", although Hosali and Aitchinson, listed in Further reading, point out several problems with these classifications. Its major syntactic characteristics are the deletion of auxiliary verbs, the frequent use of "-ing" forms for things other than participles, and the reporting of indirect speech directly. For examples:

The lexical characteristics of Butler English are that its vocabulary is limited and employs specialised jargon. family substitutes for "wife", for example.

Mesthrie notes several "striking similarities" between Butler English and South African Indian English, raising for him the question of whether there was a historical relationship between the two. These include:

He notes various dissimilarities, however:

Further reading

See also

References

  1. "Butler English". The Hindu . 18 February 2003. Archived from the original on 6 June 2004. Retrieved 14 May 2019.
  2.  Priya Hosali and J. Aitchinson, "Butler English: A minimal pidgin?. Journal of Pidgin and Creole Languages" (1986), p. 51–79.