Butler Handicap

Last updated
Butler Handicap
Discontinued stakes race
Location Empire City Race Track,
Yonkers, New York (1935-1942)
Jamaica Race Course,
Jamaica, New York (1943-1953)
Inaugurated1935-1953
Race type Thoroughbred - Flat racing
Race information
Distance1116 M
SurfaceDirt
Trackleft-handed
QualificationThree-years-old and up

The Butler Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race first run at Empire City Race Track in Yonkers, New York in 1935 as the Butler Memorial Handicap. The race was named in honor of Empire City Race Track owner James Butler who had died in 1934. [1] Due to wartime rationing regulations, in 1943 the race was moved to Jamaica Race Course in Jamaica, New York and would remain there until its cancellation in 1953. [2]

Contents

Historical notes

The 1935 inaugural Butler Memorial was won by future U.S. Racing Hall of Fame inductee Discovery. He was owned by Alfred Vanderbilt Jr. who would win this race three times, the most by an owner in its history. Other Butler Handicap winning horses who went on to have Hall of Fame careers were Assault, Seabiscuit, and Stymie. [3] [4] [5]

In 1942, Tola Rose pulled off a major upset in front of more than 34,000 racing fans when he beat 1941 U.S. Triple Crown winner Whirlaway by four lengths. [6] The win by Tola Rose set a new Empire City track record in what would prove to be the last time the race would be run at that facility. [7]

Hall of Fame jockey Johnny Longden won the 1944 Butler Handicap while riding with a broken foot and a back with two broken vertebrae. When Longden finally went to see a doctor about his extreme pain he was told he might never ride again. Six months later he was back in the saddle. [8]

Lucky Draw's win in the 1946 edition of the Butler Handicap marked the first of six track records he would set that year. [9] [10]

The final running of the Butler Handicap took place on November 14, 1953 and was won by Quiet Step, a horse ridden by future Hall of Fame inductee Ted Atkinson for owner Bernard Heiman's Apheim Stable and trainer Kay Jensen. [11]

Records

Speed record:

Most wins:

Most wins by a jockey:

Most wins by a trainer:

Most wins by an owner:

Winners

Year
Winner
Age
Jockey
Trainer
Owner
Dist.
(Miles)
Time
1953Quiet Step4 Ted Atkinson Kay Jensen Apheim Stable (Bernard H. Heiman)1316 M1:57.80
1952Marcador3 Hedley Woodhouse Norman R. McLeodSaxon Stable (Max Prestridge & Riley Allison)1316 M1:56.00
1951 Oil Capitol 4Lois C. Cook Harry Trotsek Hasty House Farm & Cora M. Trotsek 1316 M1:56.80
1950 Loser Weeper 5 Eric Guerin Carey Winfrey Alfred G. Vanderbilt Jr. 1316 M1:55.00
1949 Conniver 5 Arnold Kirkland William Post Harry La Montagne 1316 M1:57.20
1948 Donor 4 Robert Permane George P. (Maj) Odom W. Deering Howe 1316 M1:58.00
1947 Assault 4 Eddie Arcaro Max Hirsch King Ranch 1316 M1:56.60
1946 Lucky Draw 5 Hedley Woodhouse Bert Mulholland George D. Widener Jr. 1316 M1:55.20
1945 Stymie 4 Robert Permane Hirsch Jacobs Ethel D. Jacobs 1316 M1:56.60
1944First Fiddle5 Johnny Longden Edward L. MulrenanEdward L. Mulrenan1316 M1:56.00
1943Thumbs Up4 Otto Grohs Carl A. Roles Louis B. Mayer 1316 M1:56.20
1942 Tola Rose 5 Warren Mehrtens Max Hirsch Arthur J. Sackett1316 M1:56.80
1941Foxbrough5 James Stout James E. Fitzsimmons Belair Stud 1316 M1:58.20
1940Can't Wait5 Basil James J. Thomas Taylor Myron Selznick 1316 M1:57.60
1939Lovely Night3 Nick Wall Henry McDaniel Florence L. Clark 1316 M1:57.40
1938 Esposa 6 Nick Wall Matthew P. Brady Middleburg Stable 1316 M1:57.60
1937 Seabiscuit 4 Red Pollard Tom Smith Charles S. Howard 1316 M1:58.60
1936Good Gamble4Lee Fallon Bud Stotler Alfred G. Vanderbilt Jr. 1316 M1:58.20
1935 Discovery 4 John Bejshak Bud Stotler Alfred G. Vanderbilt Jr. 118 M1:53.00

Related Research Articles

Santa Anita Park is a Thoroughbred racetrack in Arcadia, California, United States. It offers some of the prominent horse racing events in the United States during early fall, winter and in spring. The track is home to numerous prestigious races including both the Santa Anita Derby and the Santa Anita Handicap as well as hosting the Breeders' Cup in 1986, 1993, 2003, 2008, 2009, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2016 and 2019. Since 2011, the Stronach Group are the current owners.

Count Fleet American-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Count Fleet was a champion American Thoroughbred racehorse who is the sixth winner of the American Triple Crown. He won the Belmont Stakes by a then record margin of twenty-five lengths. After an undefeated season, he was named the 1943 Horse of the Year and champion three-year-old. Also a champion at age two, he is ranked as one of the greatest American racehorses of the twentieth century, ranking fifth on the Top 100 Racehorses of the 20th Century. He was inducted into the National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame in 1961.

Suffolk Downs Former race track in East Boston, Massachusetts

Suffolk Downs is a former Thoroughbred race track in East Boston, Massachusetts, United States. The track opened in 1935 after being built by Joseph A. Tomasello for a cost of $2 million. It was sold in May 2017 to a developer who plans to create housing and a shopping district. The final day of live racing at the track was June 30, 2019, with the facility hosting simulcast race wagering thereafter. The only remaining live horse racing in Massachusetts is at Plainridge Park Casino, which has harness racing.

Whirlaway American-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Whirlaway was a champion American Thoroughbred racehorse who is the fifth winner of the American Triple Crown. He also won the Travers Stakes after his Triple Crown sweep to become the first and only horse to win all four races.

The Pimlico Special is a Grade 3 American thoroughbred horse race for horses age three and older over a distance of 1+316 miles held at Pimlico Race Course in Baltimore, Maryland in mid May. The race currently offers a purse of $300,000.

Massachusetts Handicap Former flat horse race

The Massachusetts Handicap, frequently referred to as the "MassCap", was a flat thoroughbred horse race for three-year-olds and up held annually at Suffolk Downs in East Boston, Massachusetts, United States. It was an ungraded stakes race run over a distance of 9 furlongs on dirt. The race received Grade III status by the American Graded Stakes Committee for 2009, but the race was never held. The MassCap was stripped of its graded status in 2011 as a result of not being run for two consecutive years.

The Belmont Derby is an American Grade I stakes race for three-year-old Thoroughbred race horse run over a distance of 1+14 miles on the turf at Belmont Park in July. The purse for the event is US$1,000,000. The event is the first of three of the "Turf Trinity" which was inaugurated in 2019.

The Gallant Fox Handicap is a discontinued Thoroughbred horse race in New York City which was run annually from 1939 through 2009. Hosted by the now defunct Jamaica Race Course in Jamaica, Queens from inception through 1957, it was then moved to Aqueduct Racetrack in the Borough of Ozone Park, Queens, New York. The race was open to horses age three and older and although contested on dirt at various distances for the most part it was a longer distance race.

The Havre de Grace Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race first run on the August 26, 1912 opening day of the new Havre de Grace Racetrack in Havre de Grace, Maryland. Although most of its runnings would take place in early fall, its final edition was run there on April 30, 1949. Due to Federal government wartime regulations, the 1943 edition was held at Laurel Park and in 1945 at Pimlico Race Course. A race for horses age three old or older, it was run on dirt over a distance of 1 1/8 miles with the exception of 1918 when it was set at 1 mile and 70 yards. From inception through 1939, the race was known as the Havre de Grace Cup Handicap.

The Empire City Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race inaugurated on October 22, 1900, as part of the opening day racecard at Empire City Race Track in Yonkers, New York. Sometimes referred in newspaper reports as the Empire City Stakes, it was raced at the Empire City track through 1942 then the following year it moved to the Jamaica Race Course in Jamaica, Queens where it remained until its final running on November 7, 1953.

The Narragansett Special was an American Thoroughbred horse race run annually at Narragansett Park in Pawtucket, Rhode Island. At the time of its inaugural running in 1934, the Narragansett Special offered a purse of $25,000 added money making it the biggest race run at the track. Only Suffolk Downs' Massachusetts Handicap had a bigger purse in New England. Both rich contests drew the best talent that the nation had to offer.

Tola Rose was an American Thoroughbred racehorse who won several stakes races in his career but is best remembered for easily defeating U.S. Triple Crown winner Whirlaway in the 1942 running of the Butler Memorial Handicap. Ridden by Warren Mehrtens in front of a record crowd at Empire City Race Track, Tola Rose won by four lengths and did it in track record time. A year earlier, Tola Rose had finished second in the 1941 Butler Memorial to Belair Stud's Foxbrough.

The Questionnaire Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race named in honor of the horse Questionnaire who was bred and raced by James Butler, the late president and owner of Empire City Race Track. The race was held from its inception in 1938 through 1942 at the Empire City RaceTrack in Yonkers, New York but with the United States becoming involved in World War II, in 1943 rationing and other wartime limitations resulted in the Empire City Association's decision to go back to hosting only harness racing. The Questionnaire Handicap was then moved to the Jamaica Race Course where it would run under the sponsorship of the Empire City Association through 1953 when it had its final running.

The Scarsdale Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race open to horses age three and older first run on October 16, 1918 over a mile and seventy yards on dirt at Empire City Race Track in Yonkers, New York.

The Walden Stakes is a discontinued Thoroughbred horse race run from 1906 through 1948 at Pimlico Race Course in Baltimore, Maryland. Raced on dirt, the event was open to two-year-olds horses of either sex. The race was named in honor of Maryland-based trainer and owner Wyndham Walden, a Hall of Fame inductee who won eleven American Classic Races, capturing the Preakness Stakes seven times and the Belmont Stakes four times.

The Sysonby Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race first run in 1946 at Belmont Park in Elmont, New York. Placed on hiatus after the 1959 edition, the race was revived in 1967 at Aqueduct Racetrack where it would run one last time. An event for horses of either sex age three and older, it was run on dirt over a distance of a mile through 1958 then the following year increased to a mile and a quarter. For the final running in 1967 it became a sprint race of seven furlongs.

The Empire City Gold Cup was an American Thoroughbred horse race first run in 1947 and 1948 at Belmont Park then at Jamaica Race Course from 1949 through 1953 as a race created for horses age three and older. With its lucrative $100,000 purse, it was promoted as an international event in an effort to attract horses from Europe and South America. Run in October or early November it was contested on dirt at a distance of 1 5/8 miles which made it best suited for stayers.

Marguerite was an American Thoroughbred racemare owned by Belair Stud who had to be retired after only one start but who established her place in racing history as the dam of four significant runners.

The Fleetwing Handicap was an American Thoroughbred race for horses age three and older that was run between 1908 and 1953. Inaugurated at Empire City Race Track in Yonkers, New York it remained there through 1942 with the exception of 1915 when it was temporarily hosted by Belmont Park. In 1942 the Empire City Racetrack ended Thoroughbred racing, reverting to its origins as a facility exclusively for harness racing. As such, in 1943 the Fleeting Handicap was transferred to the Jamaica Race Course in Jamaica, Queens, New York.

The Rowe Memorial Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race run between 1930 and 1954 at Bowie Race Track in Bowie, Maryland. A six furlong sprint run on dirt, the event was open to horses age three and older.

References

  1. "Death of Butler". time.com. Time Inc. 1934-03-05. Retrieved 2008-08-20.
  2. "Empire City Inaugurates Summer Meet: Session to be Run at Jamaica Course". Daily Racing Form at University of Kentucky Archives. 1943-06-28. Retrieved 2019-05-23.
  3. "The Crown of Gold". Courier-Journal (Louisville, Kentucky), page 69. 1947-07-20. Retrieved 2019-05-23.
  4. "Seabiscuit Wins In Empire City Handicap Event". Sarasota Herald Tribune, Florida. 1937-07-11. Retrieved 2019-05-22.
  5. "Stymie Comes From 22 Lengths Behind". Decatur Herald (Decatur, Illinois), page 10. 1945-07-29. Retrieved 2019-05-23.
  6. "34,728 See Upset". New York Times. 1942-07-05. Retrieved 2019-05-23.
  7. "Whirlaway Defeated In Butler Handicap". Charleston Gazette Newspaper Archives. 1942-07-05. Retrieved 2019-05-23.
  8. "The price I've paid to stay in racing". Maclean's (magazine). 1958-06-21. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
  9. "Widener's Lucky Draw Wins $50,000 Butler Handicap". Palm Beach Post (Florida), page 13. 1946-07-14. Retrieved 2019-05-22.
  10. "Lucky Draw Sets His Sixth Track Record of Year in Atlantic City Triumph". New York Times. 1946-10-06. Retrieved 2019-05-21.
  11. "Quiet Step Wins Closer At Jamaica". Dayton Daily News (Ohio), page 78. 1953-11-15. Retrieved 2019-05-23.