Cascade chart (NDI interval reliability)

Last updated

Cyclic loads Cyclic loads.png
Cyclic loads

A cascade chart is tool that can be used in damage tolerance analysis to determine the proper inspection interval, based on reliability analysis, considering all the context uncertainties. The chart is called a "cascade chart" because the scatter of data points and downward curvature resembles a waterfall or cascade. This name was first introduced by Dr. Alberto W Mello in his work "Reliability prediction for structures under cyclic loads and recurring inspections". Materials subject to cyclic loads, as shown in the graph on the right, may form and propagate cracks over time due to fatigue. Therefore, it is essential to determine a reliable inspection interval. There are numerous factors that must be considered to determine this inspection interval. The non-destructive inspection (NDI) technique must have a high probability of detecting a crack in the material. If missed, a crack may lead the structure to a catastrophic failure before the next inspection. On the other hand, the inspection interval cannot be too frequent that the structure's maintenance is no longer profitable.

Contents

NDI methods

NDI is a process used to examine materials without causing damage to the structure. The main purpose of using NDI techniques is to comb the surface of a material for small cracks that could affect the integrity of the entire structure. Because the structure is intended to be used again, it is essential that the methods of investigating materials for cracks does not damage the structure in any way.

Some of the most common NDI methods are:

Some of the techniques are more accurate and can detect small cracks. For example, visual inspection is the least reliable method because the human eye can only resolve and identify cracks on the order of millimeters. The table below shows an important parameter of crack size for each method with a 0% chance of detection (a0). This is based on the resolution of each method. This number can be used in a Weibull-like distribution to map the probability of detection as a function of crack size.

a0 for various NDI methods
AccessibilityUltrasoundDye penetrantX-RayVisual
Excellent0.508 mm0.762 mm1.524 mm2.54 mm
Good1.016 mm1.524 mm3.048 mm5.08 mm
Fair2.032 mm3.048 mm6.096 mm10.16 mm
Not Easy3.048 mm4.572 mm9.144 mm15.24 mm
Difficult4.064 mm6.096 mm12.19 mm20.32 mm

As the table shows, the minimum detectable parameter increases from the ultrasound method to the visual method and from excellent accessibility to difficult accessibility. In any case, it is important to have a maintenance plan that allows multiple opportunities to find a crack that may be small and difficult to access.

Cascade chart

A cascade chart is an alternative way from the traditional damage tolerance analysis (DTA) methodology for determining a reliable inspection interval. It uses the scatter from crack growth simulations, uncertainty in material properties, and probability of detection distribution to determine the NDI interval, given a desired cumulative probability of detection under a given confidence level.

Probability of detection

The probability of detection (POD), a function of the NDI method, accessibility, and crack size, can be modeled by the equation below.

In this equation, a0 is defined as the crack size below which detection is impossible. α, and λ, on the other hand, are parameters related to the chosen NDI method that determine the shape of the probability curve. The number of inspections of a structure is directly related to the probability of a detecting a crack in that structure. The more chances that an inspector has to find the crack, the more likely he or she will be to find the crack and prevent further damage to the structure. The equation below describes the total probability of detecting a crack based on each individual inspection's probability.

The variable pi represents the probability of detection for each crack size, and the variable n represents the number of inspections conducted. Due to all the factors that play a role in determining the probability of detection, there will always be a non-zero probability that a crack will be missed, no matter what NDI method is used to inspect the structure.

Creating the chart

Example Crack Growth Curve Crack growth.png
Example Crack Growth Curve

The process for creating the cascade chart shown on the right begins with modeling the crack growth over a time interval, number of cycles, or number of flight hours.

Based on an initial crack size, ai, the crack growth curve can vary significantly, causing the crack to reach its critical size in different lengths of time. This contributes to the scatter of the cascade chart. Based on the manufacturing of different materials, the example considers a typical minimum flaw in a material as about 0.127 mm (0.005"). Knowing that the new structures are deeply inspected before being put in service, the example considers a maximum undetectable crack size as about 1.27 mm (0.05") for a new structure. To simulate the variation of possible initial crack sizes, the Monte Carlo simulation method was used to randomly generate values between the given limits. In addition, the method randomly generated parameters for the crack growth curve. Based on typical variation of material properties, the constants C and m in the equation below can be varied to represent different crack growth rates. Uncertainties in loads and geometric factors affecting the stress intensity factor can also be incorporated to simulate different crack growth curves.

The probability of detection distribution curve for a chosen NDI method is superimposed to the crack growth curve, and the inspection interval is systematically changed to compute the cumulative probability of detection for a crack growing from the minimum to the critical size. The simulation is repeated several times, and a distribution of inspection interval versus structural reliability can be formed. To refine the randomization of the values, the Latin Hypercube procedure was also introduced.

As it is clear in the chart, the scatter in NDI decreases as the intervals are reduced and reliability is increased. Several sources of uncertainties can be included in the simulations, such as variation in material properties, the machining quality, the inspection methods, and accessibility of the crack. In the cascade chart, the reliability curve is presented with scatter (i.e. not every point is well defined by the negative quadratic curve). Therefore, it is necessary to make use of a confidence interval.

Using the chart

There are two variables that play a role in the selection of the inspection interval using the cascade chart. These variables are the probability of detection over the lifetime of the structure and the confidence level for the stated probability. As one of the graph's axes is probability, it is fairly easy to find the data points that match a specific probability. In aerospace structural analysis, it is common to consider 99.9999% probability (0.0001% risk) to be improbable and 99.99999% probability (0.00001% risk) to be extremely improbable. Then, the confidence interval is used to select a point where a specified percentage of the data points lies to the right of the selected point. For example, a 95% confidence interval means that 95% of the simulated cases must fall to the right of this point. This specific point is marked, and the respective point on the x-axis represents the suggested inspection interval. Furthermore, to derive the estimated risk per flight hour, the risk percentage can be divided by the number of flight hours described in the inspection interval. Hopefully, using this process, the inspection interval will lead to a higher percentage of cracks being detected before failure, ensuring greater flight safety. A final important observation is that improving the NDI method can increase the number of flight hours needed before re-inspection while maintaining a relatively low risk level.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nondestructive testing</span> Evaluating the properties of a material, component, or system without causing damage

Nondestructive testing (NDT) is any of a wide group of analysis techniques used in science and technology industry to evaluate the properties of a material, component or system without causing damage. The terms nondestructive examination (NDE), nondestructive inspection (NDI), and nondestructive evaluation (NDE) are also commonly used to describe this technology. Because NDT does not permanently alter the article being inspected, it is a highly valuable technique that can save both money and time in product evaluation, troubleshooting, and research. The six most frequently used NDT methods are eddy-current, magnetic-particle, liquid penetrant, radiographic, ultrasonic, and visual testing. NDT is commonly used in forensic engineering, mechanical engineering, petroleum engineering, electrical engineering, civil engineering, systems engineering, aeronautical engineering, medicine, and art. Innovations in the field of nondestructive testing have had a profound impact on medical imaging, including on echocardiography, medical ultrasonography, and digital radiography.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fatigue (material)</span> Initiation and propagation of cracks in a material due to cyclic loading

In materials science, fatigue is the initiation and propagation of cracks in a material due to cyclic loading. Once a fatigue crack has initiated, it grows a small amount with each loading cycle, typically producing striations on some parts of the fracture surface. The crack will continue to grow until it reaches a critical size, which occurs when the stress intensity factor of the crack exceeds the fracture toughness of the material, producing rapid propagation and typically complete fracture of the structure.

Limit State Design (LSD), also known as Load And Resistance Factor Design (LRFD), refers to a design method used in structural engineering. A limit state is a condition of a structure beyond which it no longer fulfills the relevant design criteria. The condition may refer to a degree of loading or other actions on the structure, while the criteria refer to structural integrity, fitness for use, durability or other design requirements. A structure designed by LSD is proportioned to sustain all actions likely to occur during its design life, and to remain fit for use, with an appropriate level of reliability for each limit state. Building codes based on LSD implicitly define the appropriate levels of reliability by their prescriptions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fracture mechanics</span> Study of propagation of cracks in materials

Fracture mechanics is the field of mechanics concerned with the study of the propagation of cracks in materials. It uses methods of analytical solid mechanics to calculate the driving force on a crack and those of experimental solid mechanics to characterize the material's resistance to fracture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Failure mode and effects analysis</span> Analysis of potential system failures

Failure mode and effects analysis is the process of reviewing as many components, assemblies, and subsystems as possible to identify potential failure modes in a system and their causes and effects. For each component, the failure modes and their resulting effects on the rest of the system are recorded in a specific FMEA worksheet. There are numerous variations of such worksheets. An FMEA can be a qualitative analysis, but may be put on a quantitative basis when mathematical failure rate models are combined with a statistical failure mode ratio database. It was one of the first highly structured, systematic techniques for failure analysis. It was developed by reliability engineers in the late 1950s to study problems that might arise from malfunctions of military systems. An FMEA is often the first step of a system reliability study.

In engineering, damage tolerance is a property of a structure relating to its ability to sustain defects safely until repair can be effected. The approach to engineering design to account for damage tolerance is based on the assumption that flaws can exist in any structure and such flaws propagate with usage. This approach is commonly used in aerospace engineering, mechanical engineering, and civil engineering to manage the extension of cracks in structure through the application of the principles of fracture mechanics. A structure is considered to be damage tolerant if a maintenance program has been implemented that will result in the detection and repair of accidental damage, corrosion and fatigue cracking before such damage reduces the residual strength of the structure below an acceptable limit.

Reliability engineering is a sub-discipline of systems engineering that emphasizes the ability of equipment to function without failure. Reliability describes the ability of a system or component to function under stated conditions for a specified period. Reliability is closely related to availability, which is typically described as the ability of a component or system to function at a specified moment or interval of time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acoustic emission</span>

Acoustic emission (AE) is the phenomenon of radiation of acoustic (elastic) waves in solids that occurs when a material undergoes irreversible changes in its internal structure, for example as a result of crack formation or plastic deformation due to aging, temperature gradients, or external mechanical forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ultrasonic testing</span> Non-destructive material testing using ultrasonic waves

Ultrasonic testing (UT) is a family of non-destructive testing techniques based on the propagation of ultrasonic waves in the object or material tested. In most common UT applications, very short ultrasonic pulse waves with centre frequencies ranging from 0.1-15 MHz and occasionally up to 50 MHz, are transmitted into materials to detect internal flaws or to characterize materials. A common example is ultrasonic thickness measurement, which tests the thickness of the test object, for example, to monitor pipework corrosion and erosion. Ultrasonic testing is extensively used to detect flaws in welds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Magnetic flux leakage</span> Non-destructive testing method

Magnetic flux leakage is a magnetic method of nondestructive testing to detect corrosion and pitting in steel structures, for instance: pipelines and storage tanks. The basic principle is that the magnetic field "leaks" from the steel at areas where there is corrosion or missing metal. To magnetize the steel, a powerful magnet is used. In an MFL tool, a magnetic detector is placed between the poles of the magnet to detect the leakage field. Analysts interpret the chart recording of the leakage field to identify damaged areas and to estimate the depth of metal loss.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fracture toughness</span> Stress intensity factor at which a cracks propagation increases drastically

In materials science, fracture toughness is the critical stress intensity factor of a sharp crack where propagation of the crack suddenly becomes rapid and unlimited. A component's thickness affects the constraint conditions at the tip of a crack with thin components having plane stress conditions and thick components having plane strain conditions. Plane strain conditions give the lowest fracture toughness value which is a material property. The critical value of stress intensity factor in mode I loading measured under plane strain conditions is known as the plane strain fracture toughness, denoted . When a test fails to meet the thickness and other test requirements that are in place to ensure plane strain conditions, the fracture toughness value produced is given the designation . Fracture toughness is a quantitative way of expressing a material's resistance to crack propagation and standard values for a given material are generally available.

A blade inspection method is the practice of monitoring the condition of a blade, such as a helicopter's rotor blade, for deterioration or damage. A common area of focus in the aviation industry has been the detection of cracking, which is commonly associated with fatigue. Automated blade condition monitoring technology has been developed for helicopters and has seen widespread adoption. The technique is routinely mandated by airworthiness authorities for engine inspections. Another commercial sector where such monitoring has become important is electricity generation, particularly on wind farms.

Alternating current field measurement (ACFM) is an electromagnetic technique for non-destructive testing detection and sizing of surface breaking discontinuities. It was derived from the methods used in eddy-current testing and works on all metals, ferrous or non-ferrous. Since it doesn't require direct electrical contact with the surface it can work through thin coatings such as paint. This practice is intended for use on welds in any metallic material.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Plot (graphics)</span> Graphical technique for data sets

A plot is a graphical technique for representing a data set, usually as a graph showing the relationship between two or more variables. The plot can be drawn by hand or by a computer. In the past, sometimes mechanical or electronic plotters were used. Graphs are a visual representation of the relationship between variables, which are very useful for humans who can then quickly derive an understanding which may not have come from lists of values. Given a scale or ruler, graphs can also be used to read off the value of an unknown variable plotted as a function of a known one, but this can also be done with data presented in tabular form. Graphs of functions are used in mathematics, sciences, engineering, technology, finance, and other areas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Industrial computed tomography</span> Computer-aided tomographic process

Industrial computed tomography (CT) scanning is any computer-aided tomographic process, usually X-ray computed tomography, that uses irradiation to produce three-dimensional internal and external representations of a scanned object. Industrial CT scanning has been used in many areas of industry for internal inspection of components. Some of the key uses for industrial CT scanning have been flaw detection, failure analysis, metrology, assembly analysis and reverse engineering applications. Just as in medical imaging, industrial imaging includes both nontomographic radiography and computed tomographic radiography.

The wafer bond characterization is based on different methods and tests. Considered a high importance of the wafer are the successful bonded wafers without flaws. Those flaws can be caused by void formation in the interface due to unevenness or impurities. The bond connection is characterized for wafer bond development or quality assessment of fabricated wafers and sensors.

Terahertz nondestructive evaluation pertains to devices, and techniques of analysis occurring in the terahertz domain of electromagnetic radiation. These devices and techniques evaluate the properties of a material, component or system without causing damage.

Welding of advanced thermoplastic composites is a beneficial method of joining these materials compared to mechanical fastening and adhesive bonding. Mechanical fastening requires intense labor, and creates stress concentrations, while adhesive bonding requires extensive surface preparation, and long curing cycles. Welding these materials is a cost-effective method of joining concerning preparation and execution, and these materials retain their properties upon cooling, so no post processing is necessary. These materials are widely used in the aerospace industry to reduce weight of a part while keeping strength.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fatigue testing</span> Determination of a material or structures resiliency against cyclic loading

Fatigue testing is a specialised form of mechanical testing that is performed by applying cyclic loading to a coupon or structure. These tests are used either to generate fatigue life and crack growth data, identify critical locations or demonstrate the safety of a structure that may be susceptible to fatigue. Fatigue tests are used on a range of components from coupons through to full size test articles such as automobiles and aircraft.

Stress testing is a form of deliberately intense or thorough testing, used to determine the stability of a given system, critical infrastructure or entity. It involves testing beyond normal operational capacity, often to a breaking point, in order to observe the results.

References