Cello scrotum

Last updated

Cello scrotum is a hoax medical condition originally published as a brief case report in the British Medical Journal in 1974. [1] [2] [3] As its name suggests, it was purportedly an affliction of the scrotum affecting male players of the cello.

Contents

History

Baroness Murphy, originator of the hoax Official portrait of Baroness Murphy crop 3.jpg
Baroness Murphy, originator of the hoax

The original letter [1] was written by Elaine Murphy but signed by her husband John. The journal had printed an earlier report about 'guitar nipple', [4] a condition said to occur when some styles of guitar playing excessively irritate the player's nipple (a form of contact dermatitis similar to jogger's nipple), which Murphy and her husband believed was likely a joke.

Murphy now points out that even a cursory study of the cellist's posture would show that the 'cello scrotum' complaint would not occur. The unlikelihood of a cellist's posture contributing to scrotal injury was raised back in 1974, but seems to have been overlooked. [5]

Murphy admitted the hoax in 2009 in another letter to the BMJ [6] [7] after an article in the 2008 Christmas edition of the BMJ made reference to the complaint. [8] The truth of the case report had already been questioned in the medical literature in 1991. [9] Others have cited it, [10] although expressing scepticism. [11] [12]

The implications of this and other hoax medical letters for evidence-based medicine and public understanding of science were discussed by Séamus Mac Suibhne. [10]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sebaceous gland</span> Gland to lubricate the hair and skin

A sebaceous gland or oil gland is a microscopic exocrine gland in the skin that opens into a hair follicle to secrete an oily or waxy matter, called sebum, which lubricates the hair and skin of mammals. In humans, sebaceous glands occur in the greatest number on the face and scalp, but also on all parts of the skin except the palms of the hands and soles of the feet. In the eyelids, meibomian glands, also called tarsal glands, are a type of sebaceous gland that secrete a special type of sebum into tears. Surrounding the female nipple, areolar glands are specialized sebaceous glands for lubricating the nipple. Fordyce spots are benign, visible, sebaceous glands found usually on the lips, gums and inner cheeks, and genitals.

<i>The BMJ</i> British peer-reviewed medical journal

The BMJ is a weekly peer-reviewed medical journal, published by BMJ Group, which in turn is wholly-owned by the British Medical Association (BMA). The BMJ has editorial freedom from the BMA. It is one of the world's oldest general medical journals. Previously called the British Medical Journal, the title was officially shortened to BMJ in 1988, and then changed to The BMJ in 2014. The journal is published by BMJ Publishing Group Ltd, a subsidiary of the British Medical Association (BMA). The current editor-in-chief of The BMJ is Kamran Abbasi, who was appointed in January 2022.

Auspitz's sign is the appearance of punctate bleeding spots when psoriasis scales are scraped off, named after Heinrich Auspitz. It may also be seen in Darier's disease and actinic keratosis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Calcinosis cutis</span> Medical condition in which calcium deposits form in the skin

Calcinosis cutis is an uncommon condition marked by calcium buildup in the skin and subcutaneous tissues. Calcinosis cutis can range in intensity from little nodules in one area of the body to huge, crippling lesions affecting a vast portion of the body. Five kinds of the condition are typically distinguished: calciphylaxis, idiopathic calcification, iatrogenic calcification, dystrophic calcification, and metastatic calcification.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dyshidrosis</span> Inflammatory disease of the skin in humans

Dyshidrosis is a type of dermatitis, characterized by itchy vesicles of 1–2 mm in size, on the palms of the hands, sides of fingers, or bottoms of the feet. Outbreaks usually conclude within three to four weeks, but often recur. Repeated attacks may result in fissures and skin thickening. The cause of the condition is not known.

Selenium disulfide, also known as selenium sulfide, is a chemical compound and medication used to treat seborrheic dermatitis, dandruff, and pityriasis versicolor. It is applied to the affected area as a lotion or shampoo. Symptoms frequently return if treatment is stopped.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Exanthem</span> Widespread rash occurring on the body

An exanthem is a widespread rash occurring on the outside of the body and usually occurring in children. It is usually caused by a virus, but an exanthem can be caused by bacteria, toxins, drugs, other microorganisms, or as the result from autoimmune disease.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eczema herpeticum</span> Medical condition

Eczema herpeticum is a rare but severe disseminated infection that generally occurs at sites of skin damage produced by, for example, atopic dermatitis, burns, long-term usage of topical steroids or eczema. It is also known as Kaposi varicelliform eruption, Pustulosis varioliformis acute and Kaposi–Juliusberg dermatitis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fissure of the nipple</span> Medical condition

Fissure of the nipple, colloquially referred to as jogger's nipple, is a condition that is the result of chafing of one or both nipples. This can occur in both men and women during physical exercise such as long-distance running where there is prolonged friction between the nipple and clothing. The issue is also commonly seen in surfers who do not wear rash guards or wetsuits.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Elaine Murphy, Baroness Murphy</span>

Elaine Murphy, Baroness Murphy is a British independent politician and a member of the House of Lords.

Interstitial granulomatous dermatitis with arthritis (IGDA) or Ackerman dermatitis syndrome is a skin condition that most commonly presents with symmetrical round-to-oval red or violet plaques on the flanks, armpits, inner thighs, and lower abdomen.

Genital leiomyomas are leiomyomas that originate in the dartos muscles, or smooth muscles, of the genitalia, areola, and nipple. They are a subtype of cutaneous leiomyomas that affect smooth muscle found in the scrotum, labia, or nipple. They are benign tumors, but may cause pain and discomfort to patients. Genital leiomyoma can be symptomatic or asymptomatic and is dependent on the type of leiomyoma. In most cases, pain in the affected area or region is most common. For vaginal leiomyoma, vaginal bleeding and pain may occur. Uterine leiomyoma may exhibit pain in the area as well as painful bowel movement and/or sexual intercourse. Nipple pain, enlargement, and tenderness can be a symptom of nipple-areolar leiomyomas. Genital leiomyomas can be caused by multiple factors, one can be genetic mutations that affect hormones such as estrogen and progesterone. Moreover, risk factors to the development of genital leiomyomas include age, race, and gender. Ultrasound and imaging procedures are used to diagnose genital leiomyomas, while surgically removing the tumor is the most common treatment of these diseases. Case studies for nipple areolar, scrotal, and uterine leiomyoma were used, since there were not enough secondary resources to provide more evidence.

Erosive pustular dermatitis of the scalp presents with pustules, erosions, and crusts on the scalp of primarily older Caucasian females, and on biopsy, has a lymphoplasmacytic infiltrate with or without foreign body giant cells and pilosebaceous atrophy.

Chevron nail, also known as a herringbone nail, is a rare transient fingernail ridge pattern seen in children, a ridge arising from the proximal nailfold and converging in a V-shaped pattern towards the midpoint distally. The nail growth pattern has no known association with medical problems and tends to resolve by early adulthood.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Silicone granuloma</span> Medical condition

Silicone granulomas are a skin condition that occur as a reaction to liquid silicones, and are characterized by the formation of nodules.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Airbag dermatitis</span> Skin irritation caused by airbag deployment

Airbag dermatitis is skin irritation secondary to the deployment of airbags. The diagnosis of "air bag dermatitis" is relatively recent; the first case was reported in 1994.

Granuloma gluteale infantum is a cutaneous condition that appears in the anogenital region of infants as a complication of diaper dermatitis. According to some, no granulomas are found.

Rheumatoid neutrophilic dermatitis, also known as rheumatoid neutrophilic dermatosis, is a cutaneous condition associated with rheumatoid arthritis.

Garrod's pads, also known as violinist's pads, are a cutaneous condition characterized by calluses on the dorsal aspect of the interphalangeal joints, i.e. the back side of the finger joints. They are often seen in violin, viola, and cello players, along with fiddler's neck and other dermatologic conditions peculiar to string musicians. Although Garrod's pads are conventionally described as appearing on the proximal interphalangeal joint, distal interphalangeal joint involvement has also been described.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Topical steroid withdrawal</span> Medical condition

Topical steroid withdrawal, also known as red burning skin and steroid dermatitis, has been reported in people who apply topical steroids for 2 weeks or longer and then discontinue use. Symptoms affect the skin and include redness, a burning sensation, and itchiness, which may then be followed by peeling.

References

  1. 1 2 Murphy, John M. (11 May 1974). "Letter: Cello scrotum". The BMJ . 2 (5914): 335. doi:10.1136/bmj.2.5914.335-a. PMC   1610985 . PMID   4827125. (Retracted, see doi:10.1136/bmj.b379,  Retraction Watch)
  2. "Peer reveals 'cello scrotum' hoax". Health. BBC News Online. 28 January 2009. Retrieved 2009-01-28.
  3. "'Cello scrotum' exposed as a hoax". CNN . 2009. Retrieved 2009-01-28.
  4. Curtis, P. (27 April 1974). "Letter: Guitar nipple". The BMJ . 2 (5912): 226. doi:10.1136/bmj.2.5912.226-a. PMC   1610876 . PMID   4857619.
  5. Scheuer, P. J.; Gillingham, J. (June 1974). "Musical Bumps". The BMJ . 2 (5917): 504. doi:10.1136/bmj.2.5917.504-a. S2CID   220229890.
  6. Murphy, Elaine; Murphy, John (January 2009). "Murphy's lore". The BMJ . 338: b288. doi:10.1136/bmj.b288. PMID   19174435. S2CID   34252130.
  7. Pavia, Will (January 28, 2009). "Cello scrotum? It's a load of...nonsense, admits Baroness Murphy". The Times .
  8. Bache, Sarah; Edenborough, Frank (December 2008). "A symphony of maladies". The BMJ . 337: a2646. doi:10.1136/bmj.a2646. PMID   19074561. S2CID   43774021.
  9. Shapiro, Philip E. (1991). "'Cello scrotum' questioned". J. Amer. Acad. Dermatology . 24 (4): 665. doi: 10.1016/s0190-9622(08)80178-8 . PMID   1827803. (in reference to Rimmer & Spielvogel 1990)
  10. 1 2 Mac Suibhne, Seamus. A Tale of Two Letters: Doctors, The Public, The Media, and The Evidence. ASIN   B00A1M5N5Y.
  11. Gambichler, Thilo; Boms, Stefanie; Freitag, Marcus (2004). "Contact dermatitis and other skin conditions in instrumental musicians". BMC Dermatology. 4 (4): 3. doi: 10.1186/1471-5945-4-3 . PMC   416484 . PMID   15090069.
  12. Rimmer, Steve; Spielvogel, Richard L. (April 1990). "Dermatologic problems of musicians". J. Amer. Acad. Dermatology . 22 (4): 657–663. doi:10.1016/0190-9622(90)70093-W. PMID   2138638.