Cheating Cheaters (play)

Last updated
Cheating Cheaters
Written by Max Marcin
Date premieredAugust 9, 1916 (1916-08-09)
Place premiered Eltinge Theatre
Original languageEnglish

Cheating Cheaters is a 1916 play written by Max Marcin. Producer A. H. Woods staged it on Broadway. The play is a melodramatic farce about two groups of jewel thieves who are each posing as a wealthy family in order to rob the other.

Contents

Plot

Nan Carey becomes a member of a group of jewel thieves who pretend they are the wealthy Brockton family in order to gain the confidence of real high society families. While traveling, Nan (using the name Ruth Brockton) attracts the romantic attention of Tom Palmer, who turns out to be one of the Brocktons' neighbors. While attending a tea party thrown by the Palmers, the Brockton gang tricks the Palmers into inviting Nan to stay with them while the rest of the Brocktons are supposedly visiting Chicago. The Brocktons expect this ruse will allow them to steal the Palmers' jewelry. It is then revealed to the audience that the "Palmer family" is another group of thieves, who are planning to steal the Brocktons' jewelry while the Brocktons are out of town.

Thinking the Brocktons have left, the Palmer gang slips into the Brockton mansion, but are captured by the Brocktons. Meanwhile, Nan has gone to the Palmer mansion to burglarize it. Upon her return, the two groups each realize the other is a criminal gang, and they decide to join forces. Their planning is interrupted by detectives from the Ferris Detective Agency, who capture the combined gangs on behalf of the insurance companies for their past victims. Nan is revealed to be Ruth Ferris, head of the agency, who has been working undercover posing as a thief. Because her love for Tom is real and not just part of her cover, she offers him the opportunity to confess and join her agency rather than be turned over to the police.

Productions

The play appeared in a preview production at the Savoy Theater in Asbury Park, New Jersey in June 1916. [1] It debuted on Broadway on August 9, 1916, at the Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre, where it ran for over eight months with 286 performances. [2] [3] The production closed on April 14, 1917. [4] After the Broadway run it went to London's West End, opening at the Strand Theatre in February 1918 with Shirley Kellogg playing Nan. [5]

Cast and characters

Marjorie Rambeau starred in the Broadway production. Marjorie Rambeau 1915.jpg
Marjorie Rambeau starred in the Broadway production.

The characters and cast from the Broadway production are given below:

Cast of the Broadway production
CharacterBroadway cast [6]
Steve WilsonRobert McWade
Antonio VerdiEdouard Durand
George Brockton William Morris
Nell BrocktonAnne Sutherland
Nan Carey/Ruth Brockton Marjorie Rambeau
Ira LazarreFrank Monroe
Mrs. Palmer Winifred Harris
Grace Palmer Gypsy O'Brien
Tom PalmerCyril Keightley
Edward PalmerArthur Barry
Phil PrestonWilliam J. Phinney
Myron T. HanleyFletcher Harvey
Holmes William Riley Hatch

Reception

The New York Times gave a positive review, saying it was "an interesting play that is entertaining all the way through". [6] The review in The Brooklyn Daily Eagle was also positive, calling the play "ingenious, clever and surprising". [7] In The Theatre, Arthur Hornblow praised the play as "delightful entertainment". [8]

In The Evening World , reviewer Charles Darnton called the Eltinge Theatre the "temple of crook-drama" with Woods as its high priest. He said Marcin had written a well-executed version of a common story, but it was entertainment "of the moment" that served only to pass an evening. [9]

Adaptations

Clara Kimball Young starred in the 1919 movie adaptation of the play. Cheating Cheaters (1919) - Ad 1.jpg
Clara Kimball Young starred in the 1919 movie adaptation of the play.

In 1919, actress Clara Kimball Young produced a silent film based on the play, retaining the title Cheating Cheaters . She also co-starred with Jack Holt. Allan Dwan directed. This version is now considered a lost film.

A second silent film adaptation, also titled Cheating Cheaters , was released by Universal Pictures in 1927. It starred Betty Compson and Kenneth Harlan. Edward Laemmle directed.

Universal released a sound film adaptation in 1934, starring Fay Wray and Cesar Romero. It again kept the title Cheating Cheaters . Richard Thorpe directed.

On August 31, 1936, the Lux Radio Theatre presented a radio adaptation, starring June Lang and George Raft. [10]

Related Research Articles

A. H. Woods American theatrical producer

Albert Herman Woods was a Hungarian-born theatrical producer who spent much of his life in the USA. He produced over 140 plays on Broadway, including some of the most successful shows of the period, sometimes under the name of the production company 'Al Woods Ltd.'. Woods built the Eltinge Theatre on Broadway, named for one of his most successful and profitable stars, the female impersonator Julian Eltinge.

<i>Lady in the Dark</i> Musical

Lady in the Dark is a musical with music by Kurt Weill, lyrics by Ira Gershwin and book and direction by Moss Hart. It was produced by Sam Harris. The protagonist, Liza Elliott, is the unhappy female editor of a fictional fashion magazine who is undergoing psychoanalysis. The musical ran on Broadway in 1941, and in the United Kingdom in 1981. A film version was released in 1944, and a live television special followed in 1954.

<i>Night of January 16th</i> Play by Ayn Rand

Night of January 16th is a theatrical play by Russian-American author Ayn Rand, inspired by the death of the "Match King", Ivar Kreuger. Set in a courtroom during a murder trial, an unusual feature of the play is that members of the audience are chosen to play the jury. The court hears the case of Karen Andre, a former secretary and lover of businessman Bjorn Faulkner, of whose murder she is accused. The play does not directly portray the events leading to Faulkner's death; instead the jury must rely on character testimony to decide whether Andre is guilty. The play's ending depends on the verdict. Rand's intention was to dramatize a conflict between individualism and conformity, with the jury's verdict revealing which viewpoint they preferred.

Niblos Garden

Niblo's Garden was a theater on Broadway, near Prince Street, in SoHo, Manhattan, New York City. It was established in 1823 as "Columbia Garden" which in 1828 gained the name of the Sans Souci and was later the property of the coffeehouse proprietor and caterer William Niblo. The large theater that evolved in several stages, occupying more and more of the pleasure ground, was twice burned and rebuilt. On September 12, 1866, Niblo's saw the premiere of The Black Crook, considered to be the first piece of musical theater that conforms to the modern notion of a "book musical".

Washington Square Players Theatre group

The Washington Square Players (WSP) was a theatre troupe and production company that existed from 1915 to 1918 in Manhattan, New York City. It started as a semi-amateur Little Theatre then matured into a Repertory theatre with its own touring company and drama school, while maintaining its goal of presenting only works of artistic merit. It had a great amount of national newspaper coverage and sparked like-minded companies across the country, before it was forced to disband in 1918 due to wartime economic pressure and personnel shortages. Three of its original members would then found the longer-lived Theatre Guild having much the same purpose.

<i>The Woman on the Jury</i> 1924 film

The Woman on the Jury is a lost 1924 American silent drama film produced and released by Associated First National and directed by Harry Hoyt. It is based on a Broadway stage play, The Woman on the Jury, and stars Sylvia Breamer and Bessie Love. The story was refilmed in 1929 as an early talkie under the title The Love Racket starring Dorothy Mackaill.

<i>Ladies Night</i> (play) 1920 comedy play

Ladies' Night is a three-act play originally written by Charlton Andrews and later reworked by Avery Hopwood. The play was a sex farce with part of the action set in a Turkish bath instead of a bedroom. A. H. Woods staged it on Broadway, where opened under the direction of Bertram Harrison on August 9, 1920 at the Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre. Ladies' Night had a run of 375 performances with the final curtain falling in June 1921. It was revived on Broadway in adapted forms in 1945 and 1950.

<i>The Demi-Virgin</i> 1921 stage play by Avery Hopwood

The Demi-Virgin is a three-act play written by Avery Hopwood. Producer Albert H. Woods staged it on Broadway, where it was a hit during the 1921–22 season. The play is a bedroom farce about former couple Gloria Graham and Wally Deane, both movie actors, whose marriage was so brief that the press speculated about whether Gloria was still a virgin. She attempts to seduce Wally when they are forced to reunite for a movie, but after playing along he surprises her by revealing that their divorce is not valid.

Cheating Cheaters is a lost 1927 American silent film produced and distributed by Universal Pictures. It was directed by Edward Laemmle and starred Betty Compson.

<i>Within the Law</i> (play) Play by Bayard Veiller

Within the Law is a play written by Bayard Veiller. It is the story of Mary Turner, a sales clerk who is wrongly accused of stealing and sent to prison. Upon her release, Turner sets up a gang that engages in shady activities that are just "within the law". After the police try to entrap her, she is mistakenly accused again, this time for murder, but she is vindicated when the real killer confesses.

<i>The Girl in the Limousine</i> (play) Play by Wilson Collison and Avery Hopwood

The Girl in the Limousine is a play written by Wilson Collison and Avery Hopwood. The story is a bedroom farce about a man who accidentally finds himself undressed in the bedroom of his ex-girlfriend. Producer A. H. Woods staged it on Broadway in 1919. The production was a success, closing at the end of January 1920 after 137 performances. The play was adapted into a movie in 1924.

<i>Under Cover</i> (1916 film) 1916 film by Robert G. Vignola

Under Cover is a lost 1916 American silent drama film directed by Robert G. Vignola, written by Doty Hobart and Roi Cooper Megrue, and starring Hazel Dawn, Owen Moore, William Courtleigh Jr., Ethel Fleming, Frank Losee, and Ida Darling. It was released on July 20, 1916, by Paramount Pictures. It was based on the 1914 Broadway play of the same name.

Daniel Harkins American actor

Daniel Howard Harkins was an American stage actor. His career spanned almost 50 years and included performances around the world. He also served as a Union officer during the American Civil War.

<i>Cheating Cheaters</i> (1919 film) 1919 film by Allan Dwan

Cheating Cheaters is a 1919 silent film comedy directed by Allan Dwan and starring Jack Holt and Clara Kimball Young. Young's production company produced. It was released by Select Pictures Corporation.

<i>The Crinoline Girl</i> 1914 play

The Crinoline Girl is a 1914 musical comedy written by Julian Eltinge, Otto Hauerbach, and Percy Wenrich. Producer Al Woods staged it on Broadway.

<i>The Song of Songs</i> (play) Play by Edward Sheldon

The Song of Songs is a 1914 play written by Edward Sheldon, based on the 1908 German novel Das hohe Lied by Hermann Sudermann, which had been translated to English under the title The Song of Songs. Producer A. H. Woods staged the play on Broadway at his Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre, where it was a box office success. The play was the basis of several movie and radio adaptations.

Brewster's Millions is a play written by Winchell Smith and Byron Ongley, based on the 1902 novel of the same name by George Barr McCutcheon. Producers Frederic Thompson and Elmer "Skip" Dundy staged it on Broadway in 1906. The play is about a young man who must spend a million dollars that he has inherited in order to inherit many millions more.

E. J. Rath American novelist

E.J. Rath is the pseudonym of writer Edith Rathbone Jacobs Brainerd who was assisted with many of her writing projects by her husband Chauncey Corey Brainerd, a Washington D.C. correspondent for the Brooklyn Daily Eagle. Several of her stories were adapted into plays and films.

<i>Polly With a Past</i> (play)

Polly With a Past is a play by George Middleton and Guy Bolton. A comedy in three acts, it depicts the efforts of two young men to help a shy friend, Rex, win the attention of the aloof woman he loves; they arrange for their young housekeeper, Polly, to pose as a glamorous French rival for Rex's affections, but this leads to romantic complications.

Beth Franklyn American actress

Beth Franklyn was an American actress.

References

  1. "Cheating Cheaters Opens". Brooklyn Daily Eagle . Vol. 76, no. 171. June 20, 1916. p. II.4 via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  2. Bordman, Gerald (1995). American Theatre: A Chronicle of Comedy and Drama, 1914-1930. New York: Oxford University Press. p.  47. ISBN   0-19-509078-0.
  3. Hischak, Thomas S. (2009). Broadway Plays and Musicals: Descriptions and Essential Facts of More Than 14,000 Shows through 2007. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland. p. 77. ISBN   978-0-7864-3448-0.
  4. "Theatrical Notes". The New York Times. Vol. 66, no. 21, 616. March 31, 1917. p. 9.
  5. Parker, John, ed. (1922). Who's Who in the Theatre: A Biographical Record of the Contemporary Stage (4th ed.). Boston: Small, Maynard & Company. p.  448.
  6. 1 2 "Cheating Cheaters Most Entertaining". Vol. 65, no. 21, 383. August 10, 1916. p. 7.
  7. "Cheating Cheaters a Decided Success". The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . Vol. 76, no. 221. August 10, 1916. p. 7.
  8. Hornblow, Arthur (September 1916). "Mr. Hornblow Goes to the Play". The Theatre. Vol. 24, no. 187. pp. 137–138.
  9. Darnton, Charles (August 10, 1916). "The New Plays: Cheating Cheaters a Trick Crook Play". The Evening World . p. 7.
  10. Billips, Connie J. & Pierce, Arthur (1995). Lux Presents Hollywood: A Show-by-show History of the Lux Radio Theatre and the Lux Video Theatre, 1934–1957. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland & Company. p. 119. ISBN   0-89950-938-X. OCLC   30398765.