Nichols was 27 years of age when he broke into professional baseball in 1925. Pitching for the New Haven Profs of the higher-level Eastern League—a team then owned by future Baseball Hall of Fame executive George M. Weiss—Nichols won 15 games,lost 20,and compiled a 2.93 earned run average in 43 games and 304 innings of work. The following year,he was more successful,winning 13 and losing six,with an ERA of 2.37. [1]
He earned a promotion all the way to the National League Pirates,where he appeared in three games as a relief pitcher between July 30 and August 4,1926,but posted a poor 8.22 ERA. Pittsburgh sent Nichols back to New Haven,where in 1927,he won six of ten decisions and sported an earned run average well below 3.0 at 2.60. But in a second trial with the Pirates,who were headed for the 1927 National League pennant,Nichols again fared poorly. He pitched in eight games,all in relief,lost all three of his decisions,and put up a mediocre 5.86 earned run average (which,unfortunately,would be the best ERA of his MLB career). His last appearance in a Buc uniform came on July 23,two months before the Pirates played in the 1927 World Series.
Nichols was drafted by another contending club,John McGraw's New York Giants,that off-season,but 1928 turned out to be the worst season of his major league career. Nichols allowed 13 runs (seven earned) and 11 hits in only three games and 2