Christianity Is Stupid

Last updated
"Christianity Is Stupid"
Song by Negativland
from the album Escape from Noise
Released1987 (1987)
Genre Experimental music
Length3:54
Label SST Records
Songwriter(s)

"Christianity Is Stupid" is a song from Negativland's 1987 concept album, Escape from Noise . [1]

Contents

Background

In the song, Negativland rearranges words and phrases to form a different meaning. They sampled phrases from a sermon by Estus Pirkle (from his 1968 LP, If Footmen Tire You, What Will Horses Do? , itself later adapted into a film of the same name). [2] [3] Pirkle's narrative included an imagined visit to the US under Communism where public loudspeakers constantly proclaim "Christianity is stupid! Communism is good! Give up!" These phrases were altered and mixed with appropriately march-like heavy metal music and various other sound effects.

In 2004, the song was made into a video entitled "The Mashin' of the Christ" that sampled many Jesus Christ-topic films and footage from Marxist-Leninist countries. [4]

Hoax press release

Negativland issued a press release saying that the song "Christianity Is Stupid" had played a role in the David Brom murders. [5] The press release implied that Brom had listened to Negativland's song "Christianity Is Stupid" before the fatal quarrel with his religious parents. [6] [7] The group claimed they were "advised by Federal Official Dick Jordan not to leave town pending an investigation into the Brom murders". [2] Brom, 16 at the time, had killed his family with an axe. Negativland's press release was picked up by San Francisco Bay Area media, including local CBS News affiliate KPIX. Negativland recorded much of the news about their supposed influence on Brom, and in 1989 worked this material into another album called Helter Stupid . [8]

In reality, there was no official named "Dick Jordan", and Brom did not possess any Negativland music. Pundits and journalists took the press release at face value, though generally expressing skepticism (with the exception of KPIX). [9] Negativland refused further comment, supposedly on the advice of their attorney "Hal Stakke", another fictional person invented by the band. The resulting media coverage is lampooned in the title track of their 1989 album, Helter Stupid , whose insert also includes background information behind the band's prank. [10] [11]

Media coverage of the hoax in subsequent years has tended to amplify its effectiveness, e.g. claiming that "With stunning ease, the story marched its way up the media ranks, culminating in high-profile lead newscasts on San Francisco prime-time TV, not to mention a lengthy article in the Village Voice. [6] In fact, KPIX evening news was not prime time and the two paragraph piece in the Village Voice reporting on the band's claim noted "their vagueness makes one ponder if this is just publicity." [12]

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>Escape from Noise</i> 1987 studio album by Negativland

Escape from Noise is the fourth studio album by Negativland. It marked the band's first release on an established independent record label, SST Records. On the album, they continued to develop their experimental style, as well as incorporating elements of pop music with shorter tracks and more conventional melodies. "Christianity Is Stupid", a track featuring samples from the propaganda movie If Footmen Tire You, What Will Horses Do?, proved to be an enduring signature song: the band and the release gained widespread attention a year later due to an SST press release falsely implying that murderer David Brom had listened to the song before killing his family members.

<i>Helter Stupid</i> 1989 studio album by Negativland

Helter Stupid is Negativland's fifth studio album, released in 1989. It is a concept album focused on the media coverage of a hoax formulated by the band claiming that "Christianity Is Stupid" from their previous album, Escape from Noise, had inspired David Brom to murder his family in Rochester, Minnesota, as well as other moral panics related to popular music.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Helter Skelter (song)</span> 1968 song by the Beatles

"Helter Skelter" is a song by the English rock band the Beatles from their 1968 album The Beatles. It was written by Paul McCartney and credited to Lennon–McCartney. The song was McCartney's attempt to create a sound as loud and dirty as possible. It is regarded as a key influence in the early development of heavy metal. In 1976, the song was released as the B-side of "Got to Get You into My Life" in the United States, to promote the Capitol Records compilation Rock 'n' Roll Music.

<i>Tested</i> 1997 live album by Bad Religion

Tested is a live album by punk rock band Bad Religion. It was recorded in the USA, Canada, Germany, Estonia, Denmark, Italy and Austria, in 1996, and released in 1997. It is Bad Religion's second live album. Instead of using crowd microphones and mobile studios like most live albums, the band tapped the inputs, for a result that portrays Bad Religion's live sound without crowd noise. It also includes three new songs; "Dream of Unity," "It's Reciprocal," and the title track.

<i>Miaow</i> (album) 1994 studio album by the Beautiful South

Miaow is the fourth album by English pop rock group the Beautiful South. It was released in 1994 via GO! Discs. As with most Beautiful South albums, the songs were written by Dave Rotheray and Paul Heaton. The cover originally depicted numerous dogs seated in a music hall with a gramophone on the stage. However, HMV made the band withdraw it as it mocked their trademark dog, and the band put out a second cover depicting four dogs in a boat. Both paintings were created by Michael Sowa.

<i>If Footmen Tire You, What Will Horses Do?</i> 1971 American film

If Footmen Tire You, What Will Horses Do? is a 1971 American Christian exploitation film directed by Ron Ormond, featuring Southern Baptist minister Estus Pirkle.

<i>The ABCs of Anarchism</i> 1999 EP by Negativland and Chumbawamba

The ABCs of Anarchism is an EP by American electronic group Negativland and British rock band Chumbawamba. A three-track collection, it incorporates samples of songs from Chumbawamba's Tubthumper (1997) as well as music by the then-current artists including Ice Cube and the Spice Girls, and television shows such as M*A*S*H and Teletubbies. The release's lyrics focus on political theory and children's media.

Estus Washington Pirkle was an American Baptist minister, evangelist, and filmmaker.

<i>U2</i> (EP) Negativland EP

U2 is a withdrawn EP by the experimental music and sound collage band Negativland, released in 1991. The EP and the band gained notoriety when lawyers representing Island Records, the record label of the band U2, sued over misleading artwork and the use of unauthorized sampling.

<i>WYSIWYG</i> (album) 2000 studio album by Chumbawamba

WYSIWYG is the ninth studio album by English rock band Chumbawamba, released on 4 April 2000 by EMI. The album was written and produced by Chumbawamba, with additional production by Neil Ferguson. Originally a continuation of the sound of predecessor Tubthumper (1997), the group scrapped the material from the album's initial recording sessions and sought to explore new sounds with WYSIWYG. The album incorporates elements of pop, dance-pop, alternative rock, and experimental music. Thematically, the album explores various aspects of pop culture that the group had been exposed to due to the success of their 1997 single "Tubthumping". WYSIWYG was promoted with one single: "She's Got All the Friends That Money Can Buy".

<i>Our Favorite Things</i> 2007 video by Negativland

Our Favorite Things is a compilation DVD by the band Negativland, released on November 27, 2007. The original release date on October 23 was skipped due to a pressing error in the DVDs and the bonus CD, a collection of Negativland covers done by an a cappella doo-wop group. It contains 20 of the band's greatest "hits" animated by 20 different artists from all over the United States. The cover parodies the artwork of the film The Sound of Music as well as title of the film's song "My Favorite Things". The front features a "review" from the character Goofy saying, "It's goofy". The people on the cover are dolls.

<i>Negativ(e)land: Live on Tour</i> 1997 live album by Negativland

Negativ(e)land: Live on Tour is a 1997 live album, released by SST Records. It was released against the wishes of the band, who had left SST following the U2 Scandal. It was released to compete with Dispepsi, a Negativland album.

Helter Stupid is a song by Negativland, released on their 1989 album Helter Stupid. It is an audio collage of the media controversy that resulted when, as a prank, Negativland claimed that their song "Christianity Is Stupid" had spurred David Brom to kill his family.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ron Ormond</span> Vaudeville performer, author, and film producer

Ron Ormond was an American author, showman, screenwriter, film producer, and film director of Western, musical, and exploitation films. Following his survival of a 1968 plane crash, Ormond began making Christian films.

<i>Over the Edge, Volume 6: The Willsaphone Stupid Show</i> 1993 compilation album (Edited Radio Show) by Negativland

The Willsaphone Stupid Show is a two CD collection of recordings edited from two different broadcasts on KPFA's Over the Edge radio show, hosted by Don Joyce.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Negativland</span> American experimental music group

Negativland is an American experimental music band that originated in the San Francisco Bay Area in the late 1970s. They took their name from a Neu! track, while their record label is named after another Neu! track. The core of the band consists of Mark Hosler, David Wills, Peter Conheim and Jon Leidecker.

A media prank is a type of media event, perpetrated by staged speeches, activities, or press releases, designed to trick legitimate journalists into publishing erroneous or misleading articles. The term may also refer to such stories if planted by fake journalists, as well as the false story thereby published. A media prank is a form of culture jamming generally done as performance art or a practical joke for purposes of a humorous critique of mass media.

Bill Nelson's Red Noise, or more simply Red Noise, was Bill Nelson's umbrella term for what effectively became a British new wave band formed by himself, his brother Ian (saxophone), Andy Clark (keyboards) and Rick Ford (bass). Dave Mattacks and Steve Peer (drums) both had brief stints in the band.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christian film industry</span> Aspect of Christian media

The Christian film industry is an aspect of Christian media for films containing a Christian-themed message or moral. They are often interdenominational films, but can also be films targeting a specific denomination of Christianity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sister Europe</span> 1980 single by The Psychedelic Furs

"Sister Europe" is a song by the English rock band the Psychedelic Furs, taken from the band's 1980 debut album, The Psychedelic Furs. Written by the band and produced by Steve Lillywhite, it was released in February 1980 by CBS as the album's second single.

References

  1. Buckley, Peter (2003). The Rough Guide To Rock (3 ed.). Rough Guides. p. 713. ISBN   1-84353-105-4.
  2. 1 2 Eric Dregni; Mark Moran; Mark Sceurman (2006). Weird Minnesota. Sterling. p. 24. ISBN   1-4027-3908-7.
  3. If Footmen Tire You What Will Horses Do? - The Cinema Snob posted by Stoned Gremlin Productions on YouTube
  4. "Negativland—Our Favorite Things". CMJ New Music Monthly: 51. December 2007. ISSN   1074-6978.
  5. Bogdanov, Vladimir (2001). All music guide to electronica: the definitive guide to electronic music (4 ed.). Backbeat Books. ISBN   0-87930-628-9.
  6. 1 2 PRANKS! – Pullout – Music Quarterly – The Stranger, Seattle's Only Newspaper
  7. KPIX News : Negativland|Internet Archive
  8. McLeod, Kembrew (2005). Freedom of expression®: resistance and repression in the age of intellectual property. University of Minnesota Press. pp. 117–118. ISBN   0-8166-5031-4.
  9. Reviews – Escape From Noise Archived 2005-11-07 at the Wayback Machine
  10. Thomas Bey William Bailey, MicroBionic: Radical Electronic Music and Sound Art in the 21st Century, p. 153-180.
  11. Guerrilla culture-jam (Metro Times Detroit)
  12. Reviews – Escape From Noise Archived 2005-11-07 at the Wayback Machine