Early life and education
Mach was born in Strongsville, Ohio. He began acting at an early age, performing extensively at Cleveland-area theaters such as Cleveland Heights' Cain Park and the Cassidy Theatre in Parma Heights. After graduating from Strongsville High School, he was accepted into and attended Baldwin-Wallace College Conservatory of Music, majoring in musical theater. His second year at Baldwin-Wallace was spent with the international tour of the musical Rent. [6]
During those four years at Baldwin-Wallace, he played leading roles in such as "Leo Frank" in Parade, "Anatoly" in Chess, "Pippin" in Pippin, "Harold" in Harold & Maude, "Burrs" in Andrew Lippa's The Wild Party , and "Jamie" in The Last Five Years. [7] He graduated with a musical theatre degree in 2010, concluding with a showcase that led to jump-start his career, and months later joined the First National Tour of Wicked. [8]
Career
During his sophomore year at Baldwin-Wallace College Conservatory of Music in 2010, Mach toured with the musical Rent as "Gordon" and as the understudy for both leading roles of "Mark" and "Roger". After returning to college from tour, he landed the lead role of "Austin" in the Playhouse Square production of I Love You Because, earning him his Actor's Equity card. [9]
The week of his graduation, he moved to New York City to star in the first reading of Disney's Newsies. [10] Three months later, he joined the First National Tour of Wicked in the Ensemble and the understudy for "Fiyero". [6] After a year of touring with Wicked, he made his Broadway Debut as the standby for Hunter Parrish as "Jesus" in the First Broadway Revival of Godspell. [11]
While as an off-stage standby in Godspell, Mach created a brand new concert series, Broadway Sings, [12] in response to the disorganization and blasé structure of the NYC concert scene. The series takes a well-known pop artist and reconfigures, rearranges, and re-orchestrates their hits for a 14-piece orchestra. Each song is co-arranged by the Broadway performer singing the song; the performers each have a say in how their song sounds, based on their strengths as a vocalist. [13]
In 2013, he was cast in the Broadway production of Hands on a Hardbody, written by Phish frontman Trey Anastasio and lyricist Amanda Green. [14] Later that year, he was cast as the leading role of "Nick Hurley" in the First National Tour of Flashdance. [4]
While on tour in Flashdance in 2014, he was wowed by a production of Witness Uganda at American Repertory Theater, a show in which there were no roles written for him. After a lengthy rewriting process (and renaming the show Invisible Thread), the creative team, led by director Diane Paulus, changed the leading woman's role to a male character. Mach later auditioned in 2015 and was cast as "Ryan" in the Off-Broadway production at Second Stage Theater. The same week, he was cast in the World Premiere production of Waitress at American Repertory Theater, written by Sara Bareilles and also directed by Diane Paulus. [8]
Following Waitress, he starred in three North American premieres: as "Robert E. Lee Prewitt" in From Here To Eternity at Finger Lakes Musical Theater Festival, written by Tim Rice; [15] as "Simon" in Mrs. Miller Does Her Thing, a play with music at Washington D.C.'s Signature Theater, directed and written by James Lapine and starring Debra Monk and Boyd Gaines; [16] and as "Charles Gordon Windsor, Jr." in Mystic Pizza, the musical adaptation of the 1988 movie, at Ogunquit Playhouse. [17]
In 2017, he appeared as "Quasimodo" in the regional premiere of The Hunchback of Notre Dame, a joint production produced by Idaho Shakespeare Festival and Great Lakes Theater.
In 2018, he was cast as "Harry" in the Broadway production of Kinky Boots. He also understudied the role of "Charlie Price", stepping in for pop stars such as Jake Shears, Tyler Glenn, Mark Ballas, Conor Maynard, and David Cook. He closed the production in 2019. [18]
In 2022, he was cast as "Tyler" in the Off-Broadway production of Merrily We Roll Along starring Daniel Radcliffe and understudying Tony Winner Jonathan Groff in the role of "Franklin Shepard". [19] During the run, it was announced the show would move to Broadway [20] and in 2023, the show opened at the Hudson Theater with the Off-Broadway cast intact. [21]
In 2024, he was cast in the leading role of "William Shakespeare" in the First National Tour of the Broadway musical & Juliet which will play in cities such as Chicago, Washington D.C., Boston, Los Angeles, and San Diego. [3]
On television, he has had supporting roles in "FBI" on CBS, "Uncoupled" starring Neil Patrick Harris on Netflix, "The Blacklist" on NBC, "Monsterland" on Hulu, and the cancelled "Codes of Conduct" directed by Steve McQueen. [22] In 2024, he was cast opposite Nathan Lane in the second season of Elsbeth on CBS. [22]
