Culion leper colony

The Culion leper colony is a former leprosarium located on Culion, an island in the Palawan province of the Philippines. It was established by the U.S. government in order to rid leprosy from the Philippine Islands through the only method known at the time: isolating all existing cases and gradually phasing out the disease from the population. ^[1] In addition to segregating the disease from the rest of the population, the island was later established in order to offer a better opportunity for people afflicted with leprosy to receive adequate care and modern treatments. ^[2]

Historical background

Origin of leprosy in the Philippines

The first known origin of leprosy in the Philippines dates back to time of the first Spanish Exploration of the Philippines. In the sixteenth century, Franciscan Friars established a shelter for the care of those afflicted with leprosy close to their monastery in Manila, where the hospital San Juan de Dios is located. ^[3] In 1632, the Emperor of Japan, knowing that the Spanish Catholic Church had an interest in caring for those afflicted with disease, sent one hundred and thirty four Japanese known sufferers of leprosy by ship to Manila. The Spanish Franciscans, initially reluctant to accept the shipment from the emperor, eventually took in the Japanese patients and housed them in the Hospital of San Lazaro in Manila. ^[4] However, the emperor's shipment of Japanese citizens infected with leprosy is not attributed as the main source of Leprosy in the colonies, as the Philippines is known to have had commerce with other Asian countries known to have been afflicted with the leprosy. ^[5]

By 1830, approximately four hundred lepers were patients in Leper Colonies established by Catholic priests at Manila, Cebu and Nueva Caceres. ^[3] Those afflicted with leprosy were segregated from the rest of the population but still allowed to have contact with family, inhabitants and other members of the island. ^[6] The purpose of the hospitals and leprosy establishments on the islands at that time wasn't to eradicate the disease or segregate it from the rest of the population but instead to provide humanitarian aid. ^[5] The Hospital of San Lazaro in Manila was run by Franciscan Friars until September 1898, when it was turned over to the American authorities. ^[7] The other Islands, Cebu, Palestina, and Nueva Cáceres were ordered abandoned by General Leonard Wood. ^[5]

Move from the islands to Culion and transfer to American power

By the time American forces landed in the Philippines at the beginning of the twentieth century, surveys estimated that approximately 3,500 to 4,000 people with leprosy were living on the islands and some 1,200 new cases were developing each year. ^{[3] [6]} With this burgeoning patient population throughout the colony, American Forces shifted the colony's purpose from giving humanitarian aid to seeking to establish a formal, segregated island to control the spread of the diseases and ultimately exterminate it. Military authorities surveyed two locations, one at Culion and one at Cagayan de Jolo and found Culion to be the most desirable location. $50,000 was given to the colony by the Second Philippine Commission on October 27, 1902 for the creation of the Culion Leper Colony under the Director of Health Victor Heiser. ^[3] However, construction did not begin until 1905 due to issues financing the project and conflicting opinions amongst medical professionals arguing whether segregation was an appropriate method of controlling and eradicating the disease. Not until May 27, 1906, did the first 370 patients from Cebu land on Culion carried by two Coast Guard cutters. ^[8] These two ships made multiple trips to different parts of the Philippines and brought patients to Culion.^{[ citation needed ]}

Structure, function and government of Culion

Segregation system

By Act 1711 of the Philippine Commission, passed September 12, 1907, Victor G. Heiser was given full responsibility of the segregation program. ^[3] Heiser was given the responsibility of locating, segregating, and moving any known person afflicted with Leprosy in the Philippines to Culion. His plan was to remove patients first from well isolated islands with few infected people so that the spread of the disease could be prevented where it was not firmly entrenched. ^[3] The segregation system initially received resistance from Filipinos afflicted with leprosy. In an attempt to popularize the island so that patients went to Culion willingly, Heiser sent agents to Filipino towns to disseminate information about Culion's housing, the type of food the residents would eat, and the medical facilities available. Nevertheless, many of the islands' inhabitants made great effort to evade Heiser's segregation program. ^[3] The public would also tip off the authorities about people who were possibly infected with leprosy. Many Filipinos, in acts of revenge, would anonymously notify authorities of a purported case of leprosy in hope of having them removed from the island. Even politicians, using leprosy's negative public image, would anonymously report their political foes' family members as carriers of leprosy for their own political gain. ^[3]

Staff

The island was initially staffed by one physician, Dr. Charles F. de Mey, five French sisters of the Congregation of the Sisters of Saint Paul of Chartres (SPC), a Jesuit priest and several other employees. ^[3] The staff eventually grew to include a Chief Physician, twelve clinical physicians, one dental surgeon, one pharmacist, twenty-one graduate nurses, thirteen sisters of the Sisters of Saint Paul of Chartres and 150 nursing aids. ^[9]

Infrastructure

Members of the Culion leper colony in an undated photograph. The women in the center appear to be playing the kulintang traditional instrument.

As more resources became available, the colony began to put effort into expanding construction and building its own community. Over four-hundred houses, a theatre, a town hall, a school, a piped water supply with reservoirs and a sanitary sewer system were built for the colony's patients and staff. ^[3] Since leprosy confined only patients in its most severe form to bed, patients were allowed to organize their own municipal government with its police force, civic courts and currency system isolated from the rest of the Philippine islands. ^[10]

Municipal government

Under the direction of Heiser, the colony's municipal government was made up of a Chief Physician and representatives from each tribal group living on the island, composing of the Visayan, Tagalog, Ilocano, Bicolano, Ilongo, Moro, English and Americans. Each representative, by popular vote, was elected every two years by person of both sexes and of age between 18 and 60 years old. ^[9] This system was established in 1908, making it the first instance of women's suffrage in the Philippines.^{[ citation needed ]}

A police force enforced the laws set up by the Chief Physician and the representatives and regularly patrolled the outlying districts and maintained order inside the colony. The police force, made up of patients, also played a role in maintaining the island's cleanliness and sanitary conditions. In addition to a police force, a civil court system was established where petty cases were discussed. ^[9]

Marriage, family and its religious influence on the island

Religious organizations on the island influenced the role of marriage, and consequently parenthood, in patients' lives. Before Filipino authorities established a ban on marriage in the colony, Christian groups on the island, along with authorities, took an active stand against the marriage between lepers, citing that "marital life is not conducive to their own well being ... they usher into the world healthy and innocent children who are born only to be separated from their parents and placed under the care of the Welfare Commissioner or of a relative, so that they may not suffer the fate of their progenitors." ^[9] Authorities were also opposed to marriage due to statistics at the time showing that if babies were not removed from their mothers before they were six months old, approximately half of them would become leprous. ^[3] This led to a problem for Heiser in which, without the support of a law giving him authority to remove a child, he had to either somehow convince a leprous mother to turn over her child or, without the removal of the child, be forced to possibly allow the mother to expose leprosy to her child.^{[ citation needed ]}

Identification of leprosy, modes of treatment and native remedies at Culion

The epidemiology of leprosy transmission was still hotly debated at the time of the leprosarium's existence. Hundreds of remedies had been tried but none yielded promising results all while patients alternately recovered and relapsed for reasons not understood. Natives used remedies ranging from hot baths to rubbing leaves on leprous lesions to spiritual charms. ^[3] Heiser admitted that Western medicine often failed to identify those who were afflicted with leprosy.

It sometimes seemed as though the mere intuition of the less progressive people grasped more than the scientific wisdom of the Western World. The Common people of the East can often, by mere glance, detect a leper when the American or European physician, after clinical examination, fails to find evidence of the disease. In such cases, bacteriological examinations will often show that the ignorant native is right. Dr. Strong was once riding through the streets of Manila in his carromata when a Filipino sanitary inspector stopped him and informed him the driver was a leper. Dr. Strong was outraged, but the inspector’s diagnosis turned out to be true.

— Victor G. Heiser, An American Doctor's Odyssey

The use of Chaulmoogra oil, first demonstrated in a Louisiana leper colony, became an effective way of treating the disease as a number of cases became negative after the first year. However, the treatment was very slow in improvement and recovery. ^[3]

The effectiveness of Chaulmoogra oil brought other problems as well. People treated with Chaulmoogra oil, although free of the disease, suffered great physical mutilations caused by leprous sores. With the negative stigma of leprosy and unsightly sores, normal reintegration back into society after successful treatment became an almost impossible task. Authorities segregated part of the island where leprosy-free but badly mutilated patients could earn a living. ^[3] Health-education, as proposed by the World Health Organization, was aimed to control this stigmatization. ^[11]

American presence in Culion

Many American veterans fighting in the Spanish–American War ultimately contracted leprosy while serving overseas. ^[12] Having been under the jurisdiction of the Philippine Health service, the colony was known to have good doctors with the wide experience in treating leprosy, a disease not many doctors had seen except under a microscope. ^[13] American Perry Burgess wrote "Who Walk Alone," a book in which he recounts the experience of an American veteran in isolation at Culion. Burgess served as the President and executive officer of Leonard Wood Memorial for the Eradication of Leprosy from 1928 to 1958. ^[14] The Leonard Wood Memorial funding helped found a research institute on Culion to study leprosy, headed by Dr. Herbert Wade, chief medical officer of Culion from 1927 to 1963. Wade and his associates published hundreds of papers on leprosy, including many in the International Journal of Leprosy, which the Leonard Wood Memorial supported and Wade edited.^{[ citation needed ]}

Decline

Under the appointment-ship of Governor General Leonard Wood, Culion continued to expand its staff and facilities and continued using Chaulmoogra Oil for treatment into the 1920s and 1930s. ^[15] However, it was later shown that 46.4% of the patients discharged as negative subsequently relapsed. ^[15]

Culion's decline began with staff layoffs during the financial crisis of 1933. After 1935, only leprosy patients who preferred life at Culion as opposed to life at a leprosarium closer to their region were shipped to Culion. Due to advanced treatment methods and the influence of regional clinics, Culion lost its eminence as a model leprosarium and had its population reduced to 739 in 1978. ^[15]

Legacy

In May 2017, the Philippine National Commission for UNESCO began its initiative to prepare the dossier of Culion's leprosy documentary heritage, which will be nominated in the future in the Memory of the World Register – Asia and the Pacific. ^[16] In May 2018, the Culion Museum and Archives was officially nominated by the Philippines in the UNESCO Memory of the World Register – Asia and the Pacific. ^[17] On June 18, 2018, Culion Leprosy Archives was officially inscribed to the Memory of the World Register – Asia and the Pacific. The government and the Asia-Pacific bloc aims to nominate the archives further to the International Memory of the World Register. If approved by UNESCO, it will be the fifth internationally recognized documentary heritage of the Philippines, increasing Culion town's feasibility to become a World Heritage Site in the future. ^[18]

References

1. Annual report of the Philippine Commission, 1907, pt. 2
2. Forbes, William Cameron. The Philippine Islands. 12. Kraus Reprint Co., 1976. 341–342. Print.
3. Dr. Heiser, V., An American Doctor's Odyssey. W. W. Norton & Company, 1936
4. Foreman, John. The Philippine Islands. 3rd ed. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 2007. 341–342. eBook. <https://www.gutenberg.org/files/22815/22815-h/22815-h.htm
5. H.W Wade and J. A Basa, "Culion Leper Colony," American Journal of Tropical Medicine, 3 (Sep. 1923)
6. Victor G. Heiser, "Leprosy in the Philippine Islands," Public Health Report, 24 (Aug. 13, 1909)
7. Burkholder, S., & Hart, I. (2008, November 21). History of the San Lazaro Hospital. Retrieved from http://slh.doh.gov.ph
8. Wheeler, M. M. (1913). "The Culion leper colony." The American Journal of Nursing. 13(9), 633–666. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/3403941
9. Thomas, Howard Elsworth. A Study of Leprosy Colony Policies. New York: American Mission to Lepers, 1947
10. Report of the governor general of the Philippine Islands. [1906]. https://quod.lib.umich.edu/p/philamer/ACX1716.1906.002?rgn=main;view=fulltext
11. WHO Expert committee on leprosy: Fourth report (WHO Technical Report Series, No. 459). Geneva: WHO; 1970
12. Merlin L. Brubaker, Chapman H. Binford and John R. Trautman. Public Health Reports (1896–1970), Vol. 84, No. 12 (Dec., 1969), pp. 1051–1058 retrieved from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/4593754?seq=8)
13. Burgess, Perry. Who Walk Alone. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1940
14. Carl, E. (2010, January 10). "Ashtabula County's Forgotten Author of Erie Vista." The Star Beacon. Retrieved from http://starbeacon.com/x546368328/Ashtabula-County-s-forgotten-author-of-Erie-Vista/print
15. Chapman, Ronald Fettes. Leonard Wood and Leprosy in the Philippines. Washington, D.C: University Press of America, 1982. pg 83
16. "PH NatCom visits Culion Island in Palawan | UNACOM".
17. "Nomination Information – Memory of the World Committee for Asia and the Pacific".
18. "Culion Leprosy Archives (2018) – Memory of the World Committee for Asia and the Pacific".

11°53′N120°01′E / 11.883°N 120.017°E / 11.883; 120.017