Dangers of the Mail

Last updated

Dangers of the Mail
Dangers of the Mail DC Highsmith.jpg
Mechau's Dangers of the Mail photographed by Carol M. Highsmith
Artist Frank Mechau
Year1937
SubjectAttack on a mail coach
Dimensions210 cm× 550 cm(84 in× 216 in)
Location William Jefferson Clinton Federal Building, Washington, D.C.

Dangers of the Mail is a 1937 mural by Frank Mechau installed in the William Jefferson Clinton Federal Building (formerly the Post Office Department Building) in Washington, D.C. Commissioned by Treasury Department Section of Fine Arts, the mural is one of 25 New Deal artworks in the building. Dangers of the Mail faced criticism and objections at the time of its creation for lewdness and in the 21st century for stereotypical portrayals of Native Americans and depictions of sexualized violence causing a hostile workplace environment. Since the early 2000s, the mural has been curtained from public view and is viewable only by appointment.

Contents

History

The mural was commissioned through the Section of Fine Arts [1] in 1935 in a New Deal art project designed to incorporate large works of art in the building. The mural was one of several specified to be "Romantic Subject Matter in the History of the Post" commissioned for the newly constructed headquarters of the Post Office Department. [2]

Frank Mechau was recruited for the program by Edward Rowan, then assistant director of the section. [1] Dangers of the Mail was completed in 1937, [1] installed on the fifth floor of the Post Office Department Building, and unveiled in September. [1] [2]

Description

Detail from Dangers of the Mail Dangers of the Mail DC Highsmith (cropped).jpg
Detail from Dangers of the Mail

Dangers of the Mail portrays the ambush and violent attack by Native Americans on a mail stagecoach and its occupants. [1] Researcher Jessy Ohl describes the central painting as showing three "naked white women (being) scalped in a sexually explicit manner" in the bottom right hand of the artwork, where they are shown kneeling and bent awkwardly toward the sky and ground by three Native Americans. [2] The Washington Post in 2000 reported a critic saying of the scene, "That so much plays into the stereotype of the sexually violent savage. He's going to either rape her or scalp her or both". [3] Art historian Karal Ann Marling describes the figures of the women as "clearly female, to be sure, thanks to volumetric mass". [4]

Along with the main painting, there are five vignettes below the main painting and simpler designs along the top and side borders. [1] The mural is 7 by 18 feet (2.1 by 5.5 m). [2]

Objections

In March 1937, before it had been unveiled, images appeared in a two-page spread in Time , which drew "thousands of letters of protest" of the nudity and criticism for historical inaccuracies. [1] [5] Other critics objected to the portrayal of nude female figures being scalped or strangled; some to government-funded portrayals of female nudity and "lewd content". [1] [2] [5] [4] The controversy over the nude female figures eventually required Rowan and Mechau to defend the work, with Rowan making arguments that the nude figures were small and merely "symbolic motifs" and Mechau arguing that the women were being only "roughly handled". [1] Rowan instructed Mechau to finish the work and get it installed as quickly as possible on the expectation that once the mural was in effect a fait accompli, the objections would eventually blow over. [4] He dismissed suggestions that the figures be painted in clothing as likely to result in renewed negative publicity. [4] He recommended Mechau look for historical evidence that Native Americans "actually tore the clothes from their victims" and told him to avoid the press, postal leadership, and legislators. [4]

Mechau with the mural Frank Mechau with Dangers of the Mail.jpg
Mechau with the mural

Mechau arrived for the installation with documentation about scalping techniques and, according to art historian Marling, "Indian preferences in the matter of costuming appropriate for victims". [4] The painting was installed in September 1937, after which Bureau of Indian Affairs commissioner John Collier ridiculed Rowan's and Mechau's earlier statements defending the depictions, calling the painting "a slaughter against pioneer women". [1] [4] Washington's Evening Star, without mentioning the nude women, immediately called the mural "Art at its Worst", said it had "shocked all who have seen it", accused "government doles" of "foster[ing]...radicalism in art", and accompanied its review with a recounting of Phoebe Atwood Taylor's Octagon House , a story of a town so scandalized by an offensive post office mural that members of the community broke in after hours and painted over it. [4]

After the early objections to the mural, the Treasury Department Section of Fine Arts developed a new review policy for mural designs that might be controversial. [4]

New objections to the mural arose after 2000 when the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) made the building its headquarters. This time, several EPA employees argued that the mural, along with five others in the building, conveyed stereotypical portrayals of women and Native Americans and contributed to a hostile work environment. [1] [2]

A 2005 complaint, filed on behalf of EPA employees regarding six murals in what was then called the Ariel Rios Federal Building, asserted that the various murals depicted Native Americans in a racist manner. [6] [7] [8] As the controversy wore on, Dangers of the Mail became the primary issue (most of the original complaints were about the Dangers of the Mail, another Mechau mural entitled Pony Express, and Ward Lockwood's Opening of the Southwest and Consolidation of the West). [9]

''Dangers of the Mail'' with its curtains open for viewing Dangers of the Mail by Frank Mechau 1937.jpg
''Dangers of the Mail'' with its curtains open for viewing

In 2007, the General Services Administration, which is responsible for the management of federal buildings in the United States, agreed to install a movable screen in front of Dangers of the Mail and to "incorporate revised interpretative materials to address the history of the art and the controversy associated with the mural". A "comprehensive interpretive program" was developed for all 22 murals in the building, including Mechau's Dangers of the Mail and Pony Express, Lockwood's Opening of the Southwest and Consolidation of the West, William C. Palmer's Covered Wagon Attacked by Indians, and Karl R. Free's French Huguenots in Florida, which were the ones named in the filing. [9] [7]

Access for viewing

Researcher Jessy Ohl recounts learning of the mural's existence through a colleague at the EPA who told of "a ritualistic practice of viewing the painting for new members of the agency". [2] As of 2019, access for viewing requires scheduling an appointment with a General Services Administration employee. [2]

Critical analysis

In 1982 art historian Marling pointed out that the women in the bottom right of the painting were the only figures in the painting without faces or clothing and that they "(existed) solely to be preyed upon and maimed". [4] :256

In 2015, the Colorado Springs Business Journal called it possibly "the nation's most dangerous painting". [5] In 2010 Sandra Starr, writing in Smithsonian's American Indian magazine, called it "easily the most controversial of all these (images of Native Americans in New Deal commissioned post office art)". [10]

Ohl, in 2019, wrote, "Far from reflecting an impartial or even faintly recorded 'History of the Post', Dangers of the Mail instead condenses titillating imagery of Western expansion epitomized in early American literature, film, television, and theatrical performance." [2]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Jefferson Clinton Federal Building</span> United States historic place

The William Jefferson Clinton Federal Building is a complex of several historic buildings located in the Federal Triangle in Washington, D.C., across 12th Street, NW from the Old Post Office. The complex now houses the headquarters of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Section of Painting and Sculpture</span> American New Deal work-relief project (1934–1943)

The Treasury Section of Painting and Sculpture was a New Deal art project established on October 16, 1934, and administered by the Procurement Division of the United States Department of the Treasury.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louise Emerson Ronnebeck</span> American artist (1901–1980)

Louise Emerson Ronnebeck was an American painter now best known for her work as a muralist. She submitted entries to 16 competitions for the Section of Painting and Sculpture, winning and completing two commissions. Although her body of work included a significant number of both commissioned frescoes as well as easel paintings, few are known to have survived.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eldon B. Mahon United States Courthouse</span> United States historic place

The Eldon B. Mahon United States Courthouse is a courthouse of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas and the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit located in Fort Worth, Texas. Built in 1933, the building was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 2001 and was renamed in honor of district court judge Eldon Brooks Mahon in 2003.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ethel Magafan</span> American painter and muralist

Ethel Magafan was an American painter and muralist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States post office murals</span> New Deal-era public art

United States post office murals are notable examples of New Deal art produced during the years 1934–1943.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rosalind Bengelsdorf</span> American painter

Rosalind Bengelsdorf was an American painter, art critic and educator. She is also known as Rosalind Bengelsdorf Browne and as Rosalind Browne.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edith Barry</span> American painter

Edith Cleaves Barry (1884–1969) was an American sculptor, painter, illustrator and designer born in Boston Massachusetts. She studied at the Art Students League in New York City and with Frank DuMond and Richard E. Miller. Barry was the founder and served as the director of the Brick Store Museum in Kennebunk, Maine from 1936 to 1945.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Fleck</span> American painter

Joseph Amadeus Fleck was an American painter and muralist. His works include The Red Man of Oklahoma Sees the First Stage Coach, in Hugo, Oklahoma, and First Mail Crossing Raton Pass and Unloading the Mail in Raton, in Raton, New Mexico.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frank Mechau</span> American painter

Frank Albert MechauJr. was an American artist and muralist. His work has been featured in many national and international exhibitions. Many of his paintings are currently in private collections and museums around the U.S., and his murals are on the walls of public buildings in Colorado, Nebraska, Texas, and Washington, D.C.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Verona Burkhard</span> American artist

Verona Burkhard (1910–2004) was an American artist, known for her murals painted for the U.S. Treasury Department. She participated in four public projects including three United States post office murals and five murals completed for the Immigration and Naturalization Service. She has works in the permanent collections of the Smithsonian American Art Museum and the Western Colorado Center for the Arts. As of 2015, her murals completed for the post offices of Powell, Wyoming; Deer Lodge, Montana; and Kings Mountain, North Carolina are still hanging in the buildings which were the original post offices. In addition to her public artworks, Burkhard received the 1943 Alger Award from the National Association of Women Artists and was one of the first honorees of the "Colorado Women of Achievement" program in 1966.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tracy Montminy</span> American artist

Tracy Montminy, who completed early works as Elizabeth Tracy, (1911–1992) was an American artist and muralist. During the WPA's era, she painted murals in civic buildings, including murals in the library in Cambridge, Massachusetts; the fire and police building of Saugus, Massachusetts; the Milton, Massachusetts, post office; Medford, Massachusetts City Hall; the post office of Downers Grove, Illinois; and the post office in Kennebunkport, Maine, as well as others both in the U.S. and abroad. She was an art instructor at the University of Missouri and the American University of Beirut, continuing her own painting projects simultaneously with her teaching into the 1980s. Upon her death, she established a trust to create the Montminy Art Gallery in Columbia, Missouri.

Fay Elizabeth Davis was an American artist, graphic designer and muralist who created three post office murals as part of the art projects for the New Deal's Section of Painting and Sculpture.

<i>Tornado over Kansas</i> 1929 painting by John Steuart Curry

Tornado over Kansas, or simply The Tornado, is a 1929 oil-on-canvas painting by the American Regionalist painter John Steuart Curry. It depicts a dramatic scene in which a family races for shelter as a tornado approaches their farm, and has compositional connections to Curry's earlier 1928 painting Baptism in Kansas. The artist is believed to have been influenced by Baroque art and photographs of tornadoes. He developed a fear of natural disasters and a reverence towards God during his childhood, both of which are apparent in the painting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karl R. Free</span> American painter and museum curator (1903–1947)

Karl Rudolph Free was an American artist and museum curator, best known for his New Deal-era post office murals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">New Deal artwork</span> U.S. work-relief output (1933–1942)

New Deal artwork is an umbrella term used to describe the creative output organized and funded by the Roosevelt administration’s New Deal response to the Great Depression. This work produced between 1933 and 1942 ranges in content and form from Dorothea Lange’s photographs for the Farm Security Administration to the Coit Tower murals to the library-etiquette posters from the Federal Art Project to the architecture of the Solomon Courthouse in Nashville, Tennessee. The New Deal sought to “democratize the arts” and is credited with creating a “great body of distinguished work and fostering a national aesthetic.”

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ward Lockwood</span> American painter (1894–1963)

John Ward Lockwood was an American painter, art teacher and veteran of two world wars.

Octagon House is a 1937 serialized novel by Phoebe Atwood Taylor that was distributed by the Associated Press and appeared in multiple newspapers in the United States.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 "Frank Mechau". www.gsa.gov. Retrieved October 24, 2022.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Ohl, Jessy J.; Potter, Jennifer E. (January 2, 2019). "Traumatic encounters with Frank Mechau's Dangers of the Mail". Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies. 16 (1): 26–42. doi:10.1080/14791420.2019.1593470. ISSN   1479-1420. S2CID   150684033.
  3. Shen, Fran (November 20, 2000). "History and the EPA's Big Picture; '30s Mural Draws Stares and Critics". www.washingtonpost.com. Retrieved October 24, 2022.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Marling, Karal Ann (1982). Wall-to-wall America: Post Office Murals in the Great Depression. U of Minnesota Press. pp. 248–259. ISBN   978-0-8166-3673-0.
  5. 1 2 3 Hazlehurst, John (June 8, 2015). "City could lay claim to 'dangerous' work". Colorado Springs Business Journal. Retrieved October 24, 2022.
  6. Shott, Chris (August 26, 2005). "Mural Dilemma". Washington City Paper. Archived from the original on October 4, 2022. Retrieved October 9, 2022.
  7. 1 2 "Background – Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law". lawyerscommittee.org. 2015. Retrieved October 9, 2022.
  8. "Flathead War Party: The Story Behind the Hamilton, Montana Post Office Mural" (PDF).
  9. 1 2 Smith, Barbara Leigh (2014). "Whose story should be told? Representations of Native Americans in Public Art". evergreen.edu. Archived from the original on October 9, 2022. Retrieved October 9, 2022.
  10. Starr, Sandra (Fall 2010). "Indians in the Post Office: Dangers of the Mural" (PDF). Smithsonian. p. 41.