Dengjiatun incident

Dengjiatun Incident

A contemporary comic depicting Chinese and Japanese troops fighting in Dengjiatun.
Native name	郑家屯事件
English name	Dengjiatun incident
Date	13 August 1916
Venue	The city of Dengjiatun
Location	Jilin, Republic of China
Cause	Merchant dispute
Participants	Fengtian Army Japanese Imperial Army
Outcome	Chinese apology Failure to defeat Babojab
Deaths	16
Non-fatal injuries	6

The Dengjiatun Incident was a conflict that broke out between Chinese and Japanese forces in August 1916 during the Republican era of China in the eponymous town of Dengjiatun, Liaobei province (now part of Shuangliao, Jilin province). It led to the deaths of 12 Japanese citizens and 4 Chinese citizens, and resulted in a Chinese apology to Japan.

Background

In 1905, the Japanese and Chinese Qing governments signed a treaty (Chinese name: 中日会议东三省事宜条约, Japanese name: 滿洲善後条約) conferring the right for military occupation of the South Manchuria Railway from the Russian Empire to the Japanese. In August 1904, Japanese troops entered the city of Dengjiatun under the pretense of having been accidentally attacked by Chinese policemen while the Japanese troops were undergoing military training nearby. Despite protests from the Chinese government, the Japanese military continued to occupy Dengjiatun. ^[1]

In 1916, in the midst of the National Protection War, Mongol prince Babojab launched an attempt for Manchu and Mongol independence. Babojab entered Inner Mongolia with his troops but was defeated by Fengtian Army general Wu Junsheng. With more than 500 of his troops killed, Babojab retreated from the area, and Fengtian warlord Zhang Zuolin reinforced nearby Liaoyuan county, where Dengjiatun was located, with the 28th Division of the Fengtian Army. ^[2]

Events

According to some accounts, on August 13, 1916, a Chinese child was eating watermelon in Dengjiatun when he accidentally flicked some seeds onto the clothes of Japanese merchant Kishimoto Kiyokishi (Japanese: 吉本喜代吉) ^[3] , who then beat the child in anger. Other accounts claim that a child was selling fish for 30 dollars, and Kishimoto insisted on buying the fish for 10 dollars, leading to him beating the child when the child refused ^{[note 1]} . A Fengtian soldier in the 28th Division saw this and got into a scuffle with Kishimoto. The crowd that gathered around assisted the Chinese soldier, and Kishimoto went to the Japanese police to file a report after being badly beaten. A Japanese policeman Kawase, upon finding nobody at the local Chinese police station, went straight to the encampment of the 28th Division to settle the issue. ^{[3] : 198} However, the Chinese troops refused to talk, and beat Kawase instead. Kawase then requested assistance from the Japanese troops stationed in the area. ^{[1] [4] [5]}

Japanese lieutenant Matsuo Hikoji ^{[3] : 187} then lead around 20 troops into the Fengtian encampment demanding to meet the soldier that beat Kishimoto. ^[6] During the dispute, a Japanese soldier cut off the right hand of a Fengtian soldier ^{[3] : 195,198}, resulting in the break-out of a gunfight. Troops from both sides were wounded and killed, including Kawase the policeman. As the Japanese troops were outnumbered by the 300 or so Chinese troops in the 28th Division, they retreated from the encampment. ^{[4] [5]}

Three days later, Japanese reinforcements arrived at the break of dawn and set up 5 cannons outside Dengjiatun. Captain Iue sent a notice to county executive Jing Zhaofeng, demanding Chinese troops to withdraw from the area immediately. After discussion between Jing and the 28th Division, they decided to move the encampment outside the city limits. ^[1] However, when Jing went to report the decision to the Japanese troops, Iue and the other commanders seized and Jing and did not let him leave. He was only released after trading for Jing's son to use as a hostage. ^[7]

On August 24, the Japanese troops occupied the former Fengtian barracks, reinforcing their numbers to more than 1500 troops by the end of the month. The Japanese troops then established a consulate and police station. ^{[1] [5]}

Resolution

The Beijing government wished for the local Fengtian government to handle the affair, but the Japanese government demanded to negotiate with the Beijing government directly. Talks began with Japanese diplomat Hayashi Gonsuke on August 19, 1916. On September 2, Hayashi listed eight demands to minister Chen Jintao: ^{[5] [4] [8]}

1. To severely reprimand 28th Division commander Feng Delin,
2. To severely reprimand the soldiers and officers involved in the incident and demote all officers of the 28th Division,
3. To issue a public apology and command all Northeastern army commanders order their troops to avoid conflict with Japanese troops,
4. To acknowledge Japan's right to station police and consultants in Southern Manchuria,
5. To hire Japanese military consultants in Chinese armies while in Southern Manchuria and Inner Mongolia,
6. To hire Japanese military instructors,
7. To compensate Japanese victims or the relatives of the dead,
8. To dispatch the military-governor of Fengtian to apologize in-person to Japanese colonial administrators.

After the fifth and sixth demands were removed, the Beijing government accepted the demands in January 1917, demoting the division commander, punishing involved officers, compensating Kishimoto with 500 yuan, issuing a notice to treat Japanese citizens politely, and sending the Fengtian military-governor to apologize to the Kantou Toufuku administrator and the Consul General stationed in Fengtian. ^{[1] [5] [9]}

On April 14, 1917, Japanese troops left Dengjiatun. ^[10]

Consequences

Because Chinese troops retreated from Dengjiatun, the plan to encircle Babojab's forces fell through. Under the support of Japanese troops, Babojab's Manchu and Mongol forces switched into Japanese military uniforms and detonated the Raoyang River bridge, cutting off the Fengtian troops from pursuing them. ^[11]

The incident also played a role in changing Japanese policy towards China. The Japanese government ended their support of the Royalist Party in favor of Zhang Zuolin. ^[2] Feng Delin, the reprimanded 28th Division commander, began to step away from military affairs. In 1917, after a failed bid to support warlord Zhang Xun's Manchu Restoration, Feng retired to become a businessman. ^[5]

Footnotes

1. A politician working for Gotō Shinpei, Kamezō Nishihara  [ ja ], commented on the incident that it was common at the time for Japanese expats to enforce unfair transactions ^{[3] : 198}

References

1. "不应忘记的抗战前夜—记1916年失落的郑家屯事件". 新浪看点. 2018-09-02. Archived from the original on 2018-09-23. Retrieved 2018-09-23.
2. "日本人四次暗杀张作霖!揭开历史真相，探究个中细节". 军事中国. 2017-03-22. Archived from the original on 2018-09-23. Retrieved 2018-09-23.
3. 霍耀林 (2017). 鄭家屯事件についての一考察 (PDF). 近代日本研究 (in Japanese). 34. 慶應義塾福沢研究センター: 185–220. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2019-02-24. Retrieved 2018-09-23.
4. "郑家屯事件：中国兵被打死 张作霖正月给日军道歉". 腾讯. 2016-08-31. Archived from the original on 2018-09-23. Retrieved 2018-09-23.
5. "日本侵略者策划"郑家屯事件"". 人民网. 2016-09-18. Archived from the original on 2018-09-23. Retrieved 2018-09-23.
6. 张忠绂主编 (2012). 中华民国外交史 1911-1921. 北京：华文出版社. pp. 157–158. ISBN   978-7-5075-3581-5.
7. 张圻福主编 (1995). 中华民国外交史纲. 北京：人民日报出版社. p. 55. ISBN   7-80002-737-6.
8. 齐钟久主编；中国革命博物馆编 (2000). 近代中国报道 1839-1919 插图本. 北京：首都师范大学出版社. p. 772. ISBN   7-81039-607-2.
9. ""郑家屯事件"结案 张作霖正月给日军道歉". 凤凰网. 2014-01-28. Archived from the original on 2018-09-23. Retrieved 2018-09-23.
10. 王立章主编；中共吉林省委党史研究室编 (2001). 百年回首 写进历史的吉林. 北京：中央文献出版社. p. 495. ISBN   7-5073-0890-1.
11. 赵健英主编；胡续源，魏连生副主编 (1996). 双辽纵横. 长春：吉林摄影出版社. p. 38. ISBN   7-80606-020-0.