Dunn v. Ray

Last updated

Dunn v. Ray, 586 U.S. ___ (2019), was a February 2019 United States Supreme Court case related to religious freedom. The case attracted media attention in early February 2019.

Contents

Defendant Domineque Hakim Marcelle Ray (May 31, 1976 – February 7, 2019) was on Alabama death row for the rape and murder of a 15-year-old girl, and had been given a life sentence for the murders of two brothers. He was scheduled for execution on February 7, 2019, and argued he had the right to have a Muslim imam present in the execution chamber, instead of the Christian chaplain mandated by Alabama's execution protocol. Ray received a stay from the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals the day before his execution, but Alabama moved for the Supreme Court to vacate the stay of execution. The Supreme Court vacated the stay and Ray was executed on his scheduled date. [1] [2] He was one of 22 people executed in the United States in 2019.

The ruling against Ray was criticized by some commentators. [3] [4]

Background

Ray was found guilty of the February 1994 murder of brothers Reinhard and Ernest Mabins, after they refused to join a gang Ray and accomplice Marcus Owden were attempting to organize. [5]

Ray was also found guilty of the July 15, 1995 kidnapping and rape of 15-year-old Tiffany Harville from her home in Selma, Alabama, committed along with Owden. Ray raped and murdered her, and cut her throat with a knife according to Owden's trial testimony. Harville's body was found abandoned in a field in Dallas County a month after she disappeared. [6] Ray participated in the search for Harville after she was reported missing. [5]

Owden testified against Ray and he was convicted in 1999. Owden was sentenced to life in prison, while Ray received a death sentence by an 11–1 to recommendation by jurors, [7] who found the circumstances of the Harville murder particularly heinous. [5]

However no physical evidence linked Ray to Hartville's murder. The only evidence that the prosecution had that Ray raped and robbed Hartville came from the severely mentally ill man, Marcus Owden who was suffering from Schizophrenia and had delusions and hallucinations. Owden confessed to the crime and avoided the death penalty by implicating Ray. Owden was also the only person who placed Ray in Selma at the time of the murder. [4]

Supreme Court decision

The U.S. Supreme Court also refused to consider Ray's final appeal. [5]

The motion to vacate, filed by Attorney General Steve Marshall noted Ray, like any condemned prisoner, was "given ample time during the days before his execution to meet with his chosen spiritual advisor" and the spiritual advisor could observe the execution from a viewing area if the prisoner wished. [5] Earlier law and precedent established anyone present in the execution chamber at the time of execution must be an employee of the Alabama Department of Corrections and undergo special training for execution protocols. Ray's "last minute" request for the imam only 10 days before execution, after his nineteen years in prison and familiarity with legal appeals and prison procedures and conversion in Islam in 2006, were likely an attempt to delay his execution for murders. [5]

Marshall's appeal also cited multiple procedural errors in the 11th Circuit ruling. [5]

Subsequent decisions

On March 28, 2019, less than two months after Ray's execution, the Supreme Court stayed the execution of Patrick Murphy of the "Texas Seven" over concerns that not allowing him to have a Buddhist spiritual advisor instead of the Christian chaplain or Muslim imams, only two religions' spiritual advisors permitted by Texas to be present in the execution chamber, would violate his Constitutional rights. The ruling on Murphy renewed attention to Ray's case due to the similarity and proximity of the cases, [8] [9] and the lack of explanation from justices Alito, Kavanaugh and Roberts for their latest positions. [10]

In June 2020, after Texas changed its policy to prohibit the presence of all spiritual advisors in execution chambers, the Supreme Court also stayed the execution of Ruben Gutierrez, a Catholic convicted murderer, and ordered consideration of his request to have a spiritual advisor present in the execution chamber at the time of his execution. [11] [12] [13] [14]

In February 2021, the Supreme Court again ruled that excluding spiritual counselors from the execution chamber was not allowed, by intervening in the execution of Willie B. Smith III, a murderer in Alabama. Writing for the court, Justice Elena Kagan said "Alabama has not carried its burden of showing that the exclusion of all clergy members from the execution chamber is necessary to ensure prison security. So the State cannot now execute Smith without his pastor present, to ease what Smith calls the 'transition between the worlds of the living and the dead'." [15] [16]

Similar issues arose again in September 2021 when the Supreme Court stayed the execution of John Henry Ramirez, who requested to have a minister of his choice present and allowed to lay hands on his body and audibly pray during his execution in Texas. [11] [16] In March 2022, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Ramirez's request.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Capital punishment in the United States</span> Legal penalty in the United States

In the United States, capital punishment is a legal penalty throughout the country at the federal level, in 27 states, and in American Samoa. It is also a legal penalty for some military offenses. Capital punishment has been abolished in 23 states and in the federal capital, Washington, D.C. It is usually applied for only the most serious crimes, such as aggravated murder. Although it is a legal penalty in 27 states, 20 states currently have the ability to execute death sentences, with the other seven, as well as the federal government, being subject to different types of moratoriums.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Capital punishment in California</span> Legal penalty in the US state of California

In the U.S. state of California, capital punishment is not allowed to be carried out as of March 2019, because executions were halted by an official moratorium ordered by Governor Gavin Newsom. Before the moratorium, executions had been frozen by a federal court order since 2006, and the litigation resulting in the court order has been on hold since the promulgation of the moratorium. Thus, there will be a court-ordered moratorium on executions after the termination of Newsom's moratorium if capital punishment remains a legal penalty in California by then.

Capital punishment is a legal penalty in the U.S. state of Oklahoma.

A condemned prisoner's last meal is a customary ritual preceding execution. In many countries, the prisoner may, within reason, select what the last meal will be.

Shaka Sankofa was a Texas death-row inmate who was sentenced to death at the age of 17 for the murder of 53-year-old Bobby Grant Lambert in Houston, Texas, on May 13, 1981. He was executed by lethal injection on June 22, 2000, in Huntsville, Texas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Holman Correctional Facility</span> Alabama prison and execution center

William C. Holman Correctional Facility is an Alabama Department of Corrections prison located in Atmore, Alabama. The facility is along Alabama State Highway 21, 9 miles (14 km) north of Atmore in southern Alabama.

Wrongful execution is a miscarriage of justice occurring when an innocent person is put to death by capital punishment. Cases of wrongful execution are cited as an argument by opponents of capital punishment, while proponents say that the argument of innocence concerns the credibility of the justice system as a whole and does not solely undermine the use of the death penalty.

Panetti v. Quarterman, 551 U.S. 930 (2007), is a decision by the Supreme Court of the United States, ruling that criminal defendants sentenced to death may not be executed if they do not understand the reason for their imminent execution, and that once the state has set an execution date death-row inmates may litigate their competency to be executed in habeas corpus proceedings. This decision reaffirmed the Court's prior holdings in Ford v. Wainwright, and Stewart v. Martinez-Villareal.

Capital punishment in Connecticut formerly existed as an available sanction for a criminal defendant upon conviction for the commission of a capital offense. Since the 1976 United States Supreme Court decision in Gregg v. Georgia until Connecticut repealed capital punishment in 2012, Connecticut had only executed one person, Michael Bruce Ross in 2005. Initially, the 2012 law allowed executions to proceed for those still on death row and convicted under the previous law, but on August 13, 2015, the Connecticut Supreme Court ruled that applying the death penalty only for past cases was unconstitutional.

José Ernesto Medellín Rojas, born in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas, was a Mexican national who was executed by lethal injection for the murders of Jennifer Ertman and Elizabeth Peña in Houston, Texas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Capital punishment in Alabama</span> Legal punishment in Alabama

Capital punishment in Alabama is a legal penalty. Alabama has the highest per capita capital sentencing rate in the United States. In some years, its courts impose more death sentences than Texas, a state that has a population five times as large. However, Texas has a higher rate of executions both in absolute terms and per capita.

<i>Leal Garcia v. Texas</i> 2011 United States Supreme Court case

Leal Garcia v. Texas, 564 U.S. 940 (2011), was a ruling in which the Supreme Court of the United States denied Humberto Leal García's application for stay of execution and application for writ of habeas corpus. Leal was subsequently executed by lethal injection. The central issue was not Leal's guilt, but rather that he was not notified of his right to call his consulate as required by international law. The Court did not stay the execution because Congress had never enacted legislation regarding this provision of international law. The ruling attracted a great deal of commentary and Leal's case was supported by attorneys specializing in international law and several former United States diplomats.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Doyle Hamm</span> American convicted murderer and botched execution survivor

Doyle Lee Hamm was an American death row inmate in Alabama, who was convicted and sentenced to death for the 1987 murder of Patrick Cunningham, whom he killed while committing a robbery. While on death row, Hamm developed lymphatic cancer, which made it difficult to impossible to achieve the venous access necessary to administer the drugs used in lethal injections. Despite months of warning by Hamm's attorney and human rights observers and a decades' long legal battle, the Alabama Department of Corrections attempted to execute Hamm on February 22, 2018. The unsuccessful execution attempt lasted nearly three hours and drew international attention. In March 2018, Hamm and the state of Alabama reached a confidential settlement, the terms of which precluded a second execution attempt, giving Hamm a de facto sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole, although his sentence was not formally commuted. Hamm remained in prison until his death from cancer-related complications in 2021.

Madison v. Alabama, 586 U.S. ___ (2019), was a United States Supreme Court case regarding the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution, barring cruel and unusual punishment. The case deals with whether the Eighth Amendment prohibits executing a person for a crime they do not remember.

Rodney Rodell Reed is an American death row inmate who was convicted on May 18, 1998, by a Bastrop County District Court jury for the April 1996 abduction, rape, and murder of Stacey Stites, a 19-year-old resident of Giddings, Texas.

Ramirez v. Collier, 595 U.S. ___ (2022), is a United States Supreme Court case related to the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Matthew Reeves</span> American convicted murderer (1977–2022)

Matthew Reeves was an American convicted murderer who was executed by the state of Alabama for the 1996 murder of Willie Johnson Jr. Reeves's case generated attention due to claims he was intellectually disabled.

References

  1. ↑ Liptak, Adam (February 7, 2019). "Justices Allow Execution of Muslim Death Row Inmate Who Sought Imam". The New York Times.
  2. ↑ Stohr, Greg (February 7, 2019). "High Court Lets Alabama Execute Muslim Without Imam in Chamber". Bloomberg Law.
  3. ↑ S. M. (February 12, 2019). "Why did the Supreme Court deny a Muslim's plea for an imam at his execution?". The Economist .
  4. 1 2 Admin, Madeo (February 7, 2019). "State of Alabama Executes Domineque Ray". Equal Justice Initiative. Retrieved March 30, 2024.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Dunn v. Ray, 586 (U.S.2019).
  6. ↑ "Ray v. State". FindLaw. February 4, 2011. Retrieved March 3, 2019.
  7. ↑ "Execution set for Alabama inmate convicted of killing teen". Associated Press. November 9, 2018. Retrieved March 3, 2019.
  8. ↑ "In last-minute ruling, U.S. Supreme Court stops execution of "Texas Seven" prisoner". The Texas Tribune . March 28, 2019. Retrieved February 1, 2023.
  9. ↑ Weiss, Debra Cassens (March 29, 2019). "SCOTUS blocks execution of man denied Buddhist adviser; decision was different in Muslim case". ABA Journal. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
  10. ↑ S. M. (March 29, 2019). "The Supreme Court grants a Buddhist's plea for a spiritual adviser at his execution". The Economist .
  11. 1 2 "Another Texas Death Row Inmate Sees Execution Delayed After Claiming Violation of Religious Freedom". CBS News . September 16, 2021. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
  12. ↑ "No. 19-8695 *** Capital Case *** Ruben Gutierrez, Petitioner v. Luis V. Saenz, et al.". United States Supreme Court.
  13. ↑ Rahman, Khaleda (June 17, 2020). "Supreme Court halts Texas man's execution one hour before scheduled death". Newsweek . Retrieved January 4, 2023.
  14. ↑ "Supreme Court halts execution after chaplain barred from death chamber; Kim Kardashian West hails decision". CBS News . June 17, 2020. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
  15. ↑ "Alabama calls off execution after U.S. Supreme Court says it has to let inmate have pastor present". CBS News . February 12, 2021.
  16. 1 2 Howe, Amy (September 8, 2021). "Court blocks execution, will weigh in on inmate's religious-liberty claims". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.