Ecologically based invasive plant management

Last updated

Ecologically based invasive plant management (EBIPM) is a decision-making framework to improve the management of invasive plant species. When land managers are faced with infestations of invasive plants, a step by step framework to develop integrated management plans will improve their success at managing these plants. EBIPM is founded on the principles of ecology to manage invasive weed infestations and restore landscapes. The framework combines an ecosystem health assessment (Rangeland Health Assessment), a method to recognize how ecological processes affect causes of succession, ecological principles to guide the choices of tools and strategies to manage invasive plants and how to use adaptive management to generate a step-by-step decision model. [1] The focus of EBIPM is to encourage managers to move away from simply killing the weeds and move toward management efforts that repair the underlying causes of invasion. [2]

Contents

EBIPM guides users through a 5-step process that begins with (step 1) an assessment of rangeland health to (step 2) determine why invasive species are present and what ecological processes are in need of repair. Managers can then (step 3) use ecological principles as targets to (step 4) choose the appropriate tools and strategies that will give them the best chances of successful and lasting results. [3] The final step in the EBIPM process is to use adaptive management to design and implement a management plan.

EBIPM restoration efforts in eastern Oregon. JV restoration 1.jpg
EBIPM restoration efforts in eastern Oregon.

Background

Land managers have historically used one or more of a number of strategies to treat rangelands dominated by invasive plants. [4] Treatments may have included the use of herbicides, targeted grazing, seeding, controlled burning, biological controls, and any number of other rangeland management treatments. [4] The problem with simply applying treatments is that, while initially weeds are controlled, the treatment does not fix the underlying cause of the problem and the invasive species, more often than not, grow again within a short period of time. [2] The main reason for re-occurring weed infestations is that just applying treatments to control the weeds will likely have little-to-no influence on the ecological processes driving plant community change. [4] The EBIPM framework employs ecological principles and the practices land managers have experience in using to mend actual ecological processes that are in disrepair. This strategy has proven to provide more successful and sustainable invasive plant management. [2]
EBIPM is based on ecological succession which was originally theorized by Frederic Clements and explains the concept of plant community change over time. [5] Steward T. A. Pickett furthered the theory into successional management by developing a hierarchical model that includes the causes for plant community change, the controlling ecological processes, and their modifying factors. [6] This model for successional management proposes three general causes of plant community change: site availability, species availability, and species performance. [6]

Site Availability

Site availability refers primarily to the availability of safe sites, or open niches, in the soil profile [7] Safe sites, spots in the soil where a seed can germinate, emerge, establish, and flourish, [7] are created through the process of disturbance, which is a temporary variation in the typical environmental conditions [8] which often significantly affects and alters an ecosystem. [3] Examples of disturbance include human disruption such as recreation, construction, or fire and it also occurs naturally through wildfire, flood, insect infestation, animal activity and other processes including variations in weather. Disturbances create openings for new or different plants which changes the natural succession of a plant community. [3] Disturbance also lessens the competitive intensity between plants, changes conditions in the environment, and alters the supply rates of resources. [3] Understanding site availability creates an opportunity for land managers to direct plant communities in a desired direction by manipulating disturbances to favor desired species. [9] Applying ecological principles related to the process of disturbance can significantly impact and promote germination, establishment, and growth of native and desired species over invasive species. [3]

Species Availability

Species availability relates directly to the ecological processes of reproduction and dispersal, in other words, the availability of species through propagules either present in the soil seedbank or brought in by dispersal [3] Essentially, species availability is the presence and establishment of various species. Seeds have developed a number of adaptations and are dispersed through various methods including wind, water, barbs, hooks, and awns that stick to animals and clothing, are carried in the wind or water...etc. [10]
Typically, invasive species produce more seeds relative to desired native species often giving the invasive species a competitive advantage. [11] Managers can shift competitive balance back to desired or native species by increasing their reproductive capacity and density (adding seeds...seeding treatment), [12] which can lead to higher densities of desired species. This is often enough for desired plants to swing the competitive balance back to their favor. [3]

Species Performance

Species Performance is how well a given species can perform in diverse environmental conditions based on a range of ecological processes including a species' ability to capture and use resources to survive and increase or spread in the environment despite competition, stress, and interference. [3]
The factors defining a given species' ability to survive and thrive in a number of different environmental conditions are:

  1. resource availability and a species' ability to acquire and utilize those resources
  2. response to environment or a plant's ability adapt to changes in environmental conditions (also called ecophysiological plant traits)
  3. life strategy or a plant's life history strategy and the associated trade-offs influencing the survival or death of a species
  4. stress and the ability of a species to either avoid or tolerate stress, and
  5. interference or the level at which a plant is influenced by nearby plants of differing species. [3]
Most invasive species are efficient at taking advantage of extra resources if they become available through disturbance or some other process. [11] This information can be critical to promoting desired species as land managers attempt to give desired species a competitive edge by manipulating the factors influencing how a species performs. [3]

Steps

The EBIPM model is a five-step comprehensive decision tool designed to improve land management decision-making and increase success rates of invasive species management. [13] In fact, one study showed the EBIPM approach improves the likelihood of success by up to 67% relative to traditional management strategies. [13] This article merely provides a list of the steps. For a more comprehensive look at the EBIPM framework, see the external links section below.

Step 1: Complete a Rangeland Health Assessment

A fundamental element of land management is to evaluate the current condition of the land and learn what ecological processes needs to be fixed. One such evaluation or rangeland health assessment, Interpreting Indicators of Rangeland Health, [14] is currently being adopted or implemented by most U.S. government agencies as protocol. [15] In the EBIPM framework, this step identifies the ecological processes in need of repair. [16]
The Bureau of Land Management offers comprehensive trainings on Interpreting Indicators of Rangeland Health and the EBIPM Assessment Guidelines provide an in-depth, how-to guide for completing an assessment as part of the first step of the EBIPM process.

Step 2: Identify Causes of Invasion and Associated Processes Not Functioning

The assessment mentioned in the previous section provides the information for what the current conditions are and EBIPM can inform why those conditions exist and what causes of plant community change/succession and associated processes are not functioning. [17] EBIPM's focus shifts management from trying to kill the weeds to directing the processes driving the three causes of plant community change. This will lead to more predictable and sustainable transitions toward a desired ecosystem. [18]

Step 3: Use Principles to Guide Decision Making

The EBIPM framework is built on the idea tools and strategies are more successful and sustainable when the scientific principles of ecology are considered during the decision-making process. [19] This makes Step 3, and the ecological principles for managing succession, a critical component of the EBIPM process. The ecological principles that provide direction for management were developed from existing scientific literature and are aimed at improving management by providing maximum plant diversity and maximum biomass in the ecosystem. [20] Land managers face difficult decisions in trying to successfully repair and restore complex ecological processes and they often rely solely on their own intuition and experience to determine the tools and strategies they will use. Through the EBIPM approach, land managers combine their knowledge and experience with established ecological principles to choose the best management tools and strategies for dealing with complex problems. [20] This provides an obvious benefit in that the proven scientific knowledge is organized into a functional listing of principles land managers can use to help guide their decision-making. [19]

Step 4: Choose Appropriate Tools and Strategies Based on Principles

The EBIPM framework links the ecological processes driving plant community change with the ecological principles to provide the scientific knowledge about how the processes work and the practices affecting the most positive changes on the land. [21] These principles provide managers an increased understanding of ecosystem processes and the ability to predict outcomes in a variety of situations. [20] The principles can also help managers to understand how processes in need of repair may be to blame for driving successional patterns in an undesired direction toward the increased presence of invasive plants. [21] This produces a more informed base for land managers to use in decision-making. [21]

Step 5: Design and Execute a Plan Using Adaptive Management

Developing rangeland management plans can be difficult and extremely unpredictable but the EBIPM process provides managers a method to work through both of these challenges. [21] However, outcomes and the true effectiveness of management is virtually impossible to predict because of the complexity of any given rangeland ecosystem and the number of variables acting on the system. [21] To combat this, the EBIPM process includes adaptive management which empowers managers to learn by doing in the face of uncertainty. [22] Adaptive management sets treatments up using experimental design so managers can test various management options and see what works best on their land and in their situation. [22]

See also

Related Research Articles

Ecosystem Community of living organisms together with the nonliving components of their environment

An ecosystem consists of all the organisms and the physical environment with which they interact. These biotic and abiotic components are linked together through nutrient cycles and energy flows. Energy enters the system through photosynthesis and is incorporated into plant tissue. By feeding on plants and on one another, animals play an important role in the movement of matter and energy through the system. They also influence the quantity of plant and microbial biomass present. By breaking down dead organic matter, decomposers release carbon back to the atmosphere and facilitate nutrient cycling by converting nutrients stored in dead biomass back to a form that can be readily used by plants and microbes.

Landscape ecology Science of relationships between ecological processes in the environment and particular ecosystems

Landscape ecology is the science of studying and improving relationships between ecological processes in the environment and particular ecosystems. This is done within a variety of landscape scales, development spatial patterns, and organizational levels of research and policy. Concisely, landscape ecology can be described as the science of landscape diversity as the synergetic result of biodiversity and geodiversity.

<i>Bromus tectorum</i> Species of grass

Bromus tectorum, known as downy brome, drooping brome or cheatgrass, is a winter annual grass native to Europe, southwestern Asia, and northern Africa, but has become invasive in many other areas. It now is present in most of Europe, southern Russia, Japan, South Africa, Australia, New Zealand, Iceland, Greenland, North America and western Central Asia. In the eastern US B. tectorum is common along roadsides and as a crop weed, but usually does not dominate an ecosystem. It has become a dominant species in the Intermountain West and parts of Canada, and displays especially invasive behavior in the sagebrush steppe ecosystems where it has been listed as noxious weed. B. tectorum often enters the site in an area that has been disturbed, and then quickly expands into the surrounding area through its rapid growth and prolific seed production.

Bush regeneration, a form of natural area restoration, is the term used in Australia for the ecological restoration of remnant vegetation areas, such as through the minimisation of negative disturbances, both exogenous such as exotic weeds and endogenous such as erosion. It may also attempt to recreate conditions of pre-European arrival, for example by simulating endogenous disturbances such as fire. Bush regeneration attempts to protect and enhance the floral biodiversity in an area by providing conditions conducive to the recruitment and survival of native plants.

Adaptive management, also known as adaptive resource management or adaptive environmental assessment and management, is a structured, iterative process of robust decision making in the face of uncertainty, with an aim to reducing uncertainty over time via system monitoring. In this way, decision making simultaneously meets one or more resource management objectives and, either passively or actively, accrues information needed to improve future management. Adaptive management is a tool which should be used not only to change a system, but also to learn about the system. Because adaptive management is based on a learning process, it improves long-run management outcomes. The challenge in using the adaptive management approach lies in finding the correct balance between gaining knowledge to improve management in the future and achieving the best short-term outcome based on current knowledge. This approach has more recently been employed in implementing international development programs.

Applied ecology

Applied ecology is a sub-field within ecology that considers the application of the science of ecology to real-world questions. It is also described as a scientific field that focuses on the application of concepts, theories, models, or methods of fundamental ecology to environmental problems.

Ecological engineering Environmental engineering

Ecological engineering uses ecology and engineering to predict, design, construct or restore, and manage ecosystems that integrate "human society with its natural environment for the benefit of both".

Primary succession Gradual growth and change of an ecosystem on new substrate

Primary succession is the beginning step of ecological succession after an extreme disturbance, which usually occurs in an environment devoid of vegetation and other organisms. These environments are typically lacking in soil, as disturbances like lava flow or retreating glaciers shred the environment of nutrients.

Ecosystem ecology Study of living and non-living components of ecosystems and their interactions

Ecosystem ecology is the integrated study of living (biotic) and non-living (abiotic) components of ecosystems and their interactions within an ecosystem framework. This science examines how ecosystems work and relates this to their components such as chemicals, bedrock, soil, plants, and animals.

Restoration ecology Scientific study of renewing and restoring ecosystems

Restoration ecology is the scientific study supporting the practice of ecological restoration, which is the practice of renewing and restoring degraded, damaged, or destroyed ecosystems and habitats in the environment by active human interruption and action. Effective restoration requires an explicit goal or policy, preferably an unambiguous one that is articulated, accepted, and codified. Restoration goals reflect societal choices from among competing policy priorities, but extracting such goals is typically contentious and politically challenging.

Fire ecology Study of fire in ecosystems

Fire ecology is a scientific discipline concerned with natural processes involving fire in an ecosystem and the ecological effects, the interactions between fire and the abiotic and biotic components of an ecosystem, and the role as an ecosystem process. Many ecosystems, particularly prairie, savanna, chaparral and coniferous forests, have evolved with fire as an essential contributor to habitat vitality and renewal. Many plant species in fire-affected environments require fire to germinate, establish, or to reproduce. Wildfire suppression not only eliminates these species, but also the animals that depend upon them.

Disturbance (ecology) Temporary change in environmental conditions that causes a pronounced change in an ecosystem

In ecology, a disturbance is a temporary change in environmental conditions that causes a pronounced change in an ecosystem. Disturbances often act quickly and with great effect, to alter the physical structure or arrangement of biotic and abiotic elements. A disturbance can also occur over a long period of time and can impact the biodiversity within an ecosystem.

The following outline is provided as an overview of and topical guide to ecology:

Natural resource management Management of natural resources

Natural resource management (NRM) is the management of natural resources such as land, water, soil, plants and animals, with a particular focus on how management affects the quality of life for both present and future generations (stewardship).

Ecosystem-based management is an environmental management approach that recognizes the full array of interactions within an ecosystem, including humans, rather than considering single issues, species, or ecosystem services in isolation. It can be applied to studies in the terrestrial and marine environments with challenges being attributed to both. In the marine realm, they are highly challenging to quantify due to highly migratory species as well as rapidly changing environmental and anthropogenic factors that can alter the habitat rather quickly. To be able to manage fisheries efficiently and effectively it has become increasingly more pertinent to understand not only the biological aspects of the species being studied, but also the environmental variables they are experiencing. Population abundance and structure, life history traits, competition with other species, where the stock is in the local food web, tidal fluctuations, salinity patterns and anthropogenic influences are among the variables that must be taken into account to fully understand the implementation of a "ecosystem-based management" approach. Interest in ecosystem-based management in the marine realm has developed more recently, in response to increasing recognition of the declining state of fisheries and ocean ecosystems. However, due to a lack of a clear definition and the diversity involved with the environment, the implementation has been lagging.

Ecosystem management Natural resource management

Ecosystem management is an approach to natural resource management that aims to ensure the long-term sustainability and persistence of an ecosystems function and services while meeting socioeconomic, political, and cultural needs. Although indigenous communities have employed sustainable ecosystem management approaches for millennia, ecosystem management emerged formally as a concept in the 1990s from a growing appreciation of the complexity of ecosystems, as well as humans' reliance and influence on natural systems.

Island ecology is the study of island organisms and their interactions with each other and the environment. Islands account for nearly 1/6 of earth’s total land area, yet the ecology of island ecosystems is vastly different from that of mainland communities. Their isolation and high availability of empty niches lead to increased speciation. As a result, island ecosystems comprise 30% of the world’s biodiversity hotspots, 50% of marine tropical diversity, and some of the most unusual and rare species. Many species still remain unknown.

Riparian-zone restoration Ecological restoration of river banks and floodplains

Riparian-zone restoration is the ecological restoration of riparian-zonehabitats of streams, rivers, springs, lakes, floodplains, and other hydrologic ecologies. A riparian zone or riparian area is the interface between land and a river or stream. Riparian is also the proper nomenclature for one of the fifteen terrestrial biomes of the earth; the habitats of plant and animal communities along the margins and river banks are called riparian vegetation, characterized by Aquatic plants and animals that favor them. Riparian zones are significant in ecology, environmental management, and civil engineering because of their role in soil conservation, their habitat biodiversity, and the influence they have on fauna and aquatic ecosystems, including grassland, woodland, wetland or sub-surface features such as water tables. In some regions the terms riparian woodland, riparian forest, riparian buffer zone, or riparian strip are used to characterize a riparian zone.

<i>Centaurea stoebe</i> Species of flowering plant in the family Asteraceae

Centaurea stoebe, the spotted knapweed or panicled knapweed, is a species of Centaurea native to eastern Europe. It is also an invasive species in southern Canada, and northwestern Mexico, and nearly every state in the United States; it has thrived in the western United States in particular, much of which has a dry climate similar to the Mediterranean. This species and Centaurea diffusa are tumbleweeds — plants that break free of their roots and tumble in the wind, facilitating the dispersal of their seeds.

Rangeland management

Rangeland management is a professional natural science that centers around the study of rangelands and the "conservation and sustainable management [of Arid-Lands] for the benefit of current societies and future generations." Range management is defined by Holechek et al. as the "manipulation of rangeland components to obtain optimum combination of goods and services for society on a sustained basis."

References

  1. James, Jeremy J., Smith, Brenda S., Vasquez, Edward A., and Sheley, Roger L. "Principles for Ecologically Based Invasive Plant Management". Invasive Plant Science and Management 3:229-239, 2010, p. 230
  2. 1 2 3 Sheley, R., James, J., Smith, B., and Vasquez, E. "Applying Ecologically Based Invasive-Plant Management". Rangeland Ecology & Management, November 2010, 63:605-613, p. 606
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Sheley, R., James, J., Smith, B., and Vasquez, E. "Applying Ecologically Based Invasive-Plant Management". Rangeland Ecology & Management, November 2010, 63:605-613, p. 607
  4. 1 2 3 Krueger-Mangold, Jane M., Sheley, Roger L., and Svejcar, Tony J. "Toward ecologically-based invasive plant management on rangeland". Weed Science, 2006, 54:597-605, p. 597
  5. Clements, F. E. "Plant succession: an analysis of the development of vegetation". Washington, DC, USA: Carnegie Institution of Washington, Publication No. 242, 1916, p. 512
  6. 1 2 Pickett, S. T. A, Collins, S. L., and Armesto, J. J. "Models, mechanisms, and pathways of succession". Botanical Review, 1987, 53:335–371.
  7. 1 2 Picket, S. T. A., and White, P. S. "The ecology of natural disturbance and patch dynamics". Orlando, FL, USA: Academic Press, 1985, p. 472
  8. Lozon, J. D., and MacIsaac, H. J. "Directing ecological succession". New York, NY, USA: Chapman and Hall, 1990, p. 251.
  9. D’Antonio, C., and Meyerson, L. A. "Exotic plant species as problems and solutions in ecological restoration: A synthesis". Restoration Ecology 10:703-713, 2002, p. 705
  10. Davies, Kirk W., and Sheley, Roger, L. "A Conceptual Framework for Preventing the Spatial Dispersal of Invasive Plants". Weed Science 55:178-184, 2007, p. 178
  11. 1 2 James, Jeremy J., Smith, Brenda S., Vasquez, Edward A., and Sheley, Roger L. "Principles for Ecologically Based Invasive Plant Management". Invasive Plant Science and Management 3:229-239, 2010, p. 233.
  12. Velagala, R. P., Sheley, R. L., and Jacobs, J. S. "Influence of density on intermediate wheatgrass and spotted knapweed interference". Journal of Range Management 50:523-529, 1997, p. 523
  13. 1 2 Sheley, Roger L., James, Jeremy J., Bard, Erin C. "Augmentative Restoration: Repairing Damaged Ecological Processes During Restoration of Heterogeneous Environments". Invasive Plant Science and Management, 2:10-21, 2009 p. 19
  14. Pellant, Pyke, Shaver, Herrick. 2005. "Interpreting Indicators of Rangeland Health". BLM Reference 1734-6
  15. Pyke, D. A., Pellant, M., Shaver, P., and Herrick, J. E. 2002. Rangeland health attributes and indicators for qualitative assessment. Journal of Range Management 55:584-597. p. 584
  16. Sheley, Roger L., James, Jeremy J., Vasquez, Edward A., Svejcar, Tony J. "Using Rangeland Health Assessment to Inform Successional Management". Invasive Plant Science and Management 4(3):356-366, 2011, p. 356
  17. Sheley, R., James, J., Smith, B., and Vasquez, E. "Applying Ecologically Based Invasive-Plant Management". Rangeland Ecology & Management, November 2010, 63:605-613, p. 609
  18. Sheley, R., James, J., Smith, B., and Vasquez, E. "Applying Ecologically Based Invasive-Plant Management". Rangeland Ecology & Management, November 2010, 63:605-613, p. 612
  19. 1 2 Sheley, R., James, J., Smith, B., and Vasquez, E. "Applying Ecologically Based Invasive-Plant Management". Rangeland Ecology & Management, November 2010, 63:605-613, p. 610
  20. 1 2 3 James, Jeremy J., Smith, Brenda S., Vasquez, Edward A., and Sheley, Roger L. "Principles for Ecologically Based Invasive Plant Management". Invasive Plant Science and Management 3:229-239, 2010, p. 229
  21. 1 2 3 4 5 Sheley, R., James, J., Smith, B., and Vasquez, E. "Applying Ecologically Based Invasive-Plant Management". Rangeland Ecology & Management, 63:605-613, November 2010, p. 611
  22. 1 2 Reever-Morghan, K. J., Sheley, R. L., and Svejcar, T. J. "Successful Adaptive Management-The Integration of Research and Management". Rangeland Ecology and Management 59:216-219, March 2006, p. 216.

Associated EBIPM Videos